HomeMy WebLinkAbout19 - Trucks on Ridge Park RoadCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item No. 19
July 26, 2005
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Public Works Department
Richard Edmonston, P.E.
949 - 644 -3311
rdmonston@city.newport-beach.ca.us
SUBJECT: ORDINANCE RESTRICTING TRUCKS ON RIDGE PARK ROAD
RECOMMENDATION:
Introduce an Ordinance adding Section 12.32.022 to the Municipal Code to establish a
vehicle weight limit of eight thousand (8,000) pounds on Ridge Park Road between
Newport Coast Drive and Vista Ridge Road.
DISCUSSION:
Staff has worked with concerned parents of Newport Coast since before the area was
annexed to the City. These discussions have primarily focused on the traffic issues
associated with Newport Coast Elementary School. These numerous meetings have
led to the construction of the loop road for pick -up and drop -off of students on campus,
relocation of crossing guards, parking restrictions, pedestrian crossing restrictions, and
targeted law enforcement efforts.
Parents and staff at Newport Coast Elementary School have expressed considerable
concern about the number of large construction trucks driving past the School on Ridge
Park Road, especially since two trucks have gotten out of control due to driver error and
crashed near the school since the first of this year. Both crashes occurred in the
intersection of Newport Coast Drive and Ridge Park Road and were single vehicle
crashes involving trucks going westbound on Ridge Park Road.
Most, if not all, of the trucks currently using Ridge Park Road adjacent to the school are
bound for the new home sites at the top of the hill. The proposed Ordinance would
divert those trucks to Vista Ridge Road as shown on the attached vicinity map. The two
roads intersect above the school site but below the construction area. Residents living
in homes off Vista Ridge Road have expressed opposition to this alternative as they
feel they have already had to deal with extensive construction traffic for many years as
Newport Coast has been developed.
Traffic counts were taken earlier this year on both Vista Ridge Road and Ridge Park
Road. Large trucks were counted at the same time. These counts clearly show the
impact construction traffic is having on Ridge Park Road which has 6000 vehicles per
day with 280 of them being large trucks. By comparison, Vista Ridge Road has 3900
vehicles per day with 80 large trucks. So, in spite of the fact that over twice as many
homes have their access off of Vista Ridge Road (655 vs. 268), construction traffic
SUBJECT: Ordinance Restricting Trucks on Ridge Park Road
July 26, 2005
Page 2
results in both more vehicles of all sizes and over three times as many large trucks on
Ridge Park Road.
The main concern is the safety of the pedestrians at the Newport Coast Drive and
Ridge Park Road intersection as children and their parents go back and forth to
Newport Coast Elementary School several times during the school day. The presence
of the school causes the number of pedestrians at this intersection to be many times
greater than at any other location in Newport Coast.
Staff has considered a variety of options to control trucks in a manner that would
reduce the potential of an accident involving children and adults. Time restrictions were
considered and dismissed as was the possibility of having trucks go uphill on Ridge
Park Road and downhill on Vista Ridge Road. The Police Chief stated that the problem
with any restriction short of a total ban is the difficulty drivers would have understanding
and following the more complex rules. The proposed solution will leave the workers in
their cars and pickup trucks on Ridge Park Road and shift only the large construction
trucks to Vista Ridge Road. This spreads the impact of construction traffic on both
streets. Roughly 300 additional trucks will use Vista Ridge Road while an estimated
3000 plus other construction - related vehicles will remain on Ridge Park Road.
It is important to note that The Irvine Company estimates that construction of the new
homes will take roughly another two years, plus or minus, and the truck issue will
substantially go away at that time. Subsequent to the initial construction, the only
trucks will be those associated with individual property owner's projects. Staff
recommends that the weight restriction on Ridge Park Road be permanent, since the
large number of trucks will significantly diminish, but there will still be concentrations of
pedestrians at the Newport Coast Drive and Ridge Park Road intersection after the
initial home construction period.
Staff informed the Newport Coast Elementary PTA, the Newport Mesa Unified School
District Office, the Newport Coast Advisory Committee, the Newport Coast HOA
managers, the Irvine Company, and others of the Study Session discussion on June
28, 2005. This item was also discussed at the Newport Coast Advisory Committee
meeting of July 11, 2005.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW:
Categorically Exempt under Chapter 3, Article 19, Section 15301, Class 1(c) of Title 14,
California Code of Regulations. Exemption is for minor alteration of existing facilities
not expanding existing uses.
Prepared by:� Submitt by
dRithard Edmonston, P.E. / tephen G. Badum
Transportation and Development ;;Public Works Director
Services Manager
Attachments: Vicinity Map
Ordinance
INC
Sri
•., , rl -•
Kip
�•,�'�''r + {\,,� rat •.V• MI" \� y 40A.'i. �„_' . - ^' .I .. ., ,.�
�';•Y [.I `Y �Y ��r,r;�I I '�i ,�`'..\ '•fi� tY,"�`.1 t1. Y "Y. -•`. +q�4 \� w•�r'"�; "j �.0 �. r:
ly!y��ff t ,.. .: ,: -- .moo ..••....,P; �
yrt .. it mall 7 , .. �•.'_ -'.i� 1� t 'A'X�a. ....:d��.. '••. .1 • � .
'"s?'�T9 {'• �x •�,.; v..' ��'a" A. :�Ya ,,, .111♦ > >:: ■
lb. 1' i� °� � ;� •:� ' `) � ! •�/ x00' ♦♦ .�' :rk>,tw•'S•�
.:;elf ,•• "L:.T i+; \Ja:y� i•:
4�t' Twi ♦� .�,. ' �
41 AR th'1,'`-j1Q! r.s(' .�xSS/,. .'+`/ �C �.♦ '. L, '..k
ski'' ,.t !r•. - — •bv 40,� . '� =��., ., �!<<,;�` ,r .
'.t � � \ . n '. .�{'� /••�1{a".. � `Y �' t �y t '. iii.
ss _14��°..:'• }i� ... .� `i' its,•: �'p! _.:Rp�e.!•� ' -4 F�
ORDINANCE NO. 2005 -
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF NEWPORT BEACH ADDING SECTION 12.32.022 TO
THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE
ESTABLISHING A VEHICULAR WEIGHT LIMIT OF EIGHT
THOUSAND (8,000) POUNDS ON RIDGE PARK ROAD
BETWEEN NEWPORT COAST DRIVE AND VISTA RIDGE
ROAD.
The City Council of the City of Newport Beach does hereby ordain as follows:
SECTION 1: Section 12.32.022 is added to the Newport Beach Municipal Code
to read as follows:
"12.32.022 Commercial Vehicles over eight thousand (8,000) pounds prohibited.
A. When signs are erected giving notice thereof, no person shall operate any
commercial vehicle exceeding eight thousand (8,000) pounds gross weight at any time
upon any of the streets or parts of streets described in subsection (B) of this section.
The City Traffic Engineer shall erect and maintain appropriate signs on those streets
affected by this section.
B. The following streets are the streets designated by the City Council upon
which commercial vehicles exceeding eight thousand (8,000) pounds weight may not
be operated:
1. Ridge Park Road, from Newport Coast Drive to Vista Ridge Road."
SECTION 2: The Mayor shall sign and the City Clerk shall cause the same to be
published once in the official newspaper of the City, and it shall be effective thirty (30)
days after its adoption.
SECTION 3: This Ordinance was introduced at a regular meeting of the City
Council of the City of Newport Beach held on the 26th day of July, 2005, and adopted
on the day of 2005, by the following vote, to wit:
AYES, COUNCILMEMBERS
NOES, COUNCILMEMBERS
ABSENT COUNCILMEMBERS
ATTEST:
Clerk
COUNCIL A EN A
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH �, 1
CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
Study Session Item No. ss4
June 28, 2005
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Public Works Department
Richard Edmonston, P.E.
949 - 644 -3311
redmonston@city.newport-beach.ca.us
SUBJECT: TRUCK RESTRICTIONS ON RIDGE PARK ROAD
BACKGROUND
Staff has worked with concerned parents of Newport Coast since before the area was
annexed to the City. Many of these discussions have pertained to the traffic issues
associated with Newport Coast Elementary School. These efforts have led to the
construction of the loop road for pick -up and drop -off of students, revised crossing
guards, parking restrictions, targeted enforcement efforts, and participation in numerous
school meetings.
Recently there have been proposals to ban construction trucks from the segment of
Ridge Park Road from Newport Coast Drive to Vista Ridge Road. On two occasions
since the first of this year construction trucks have gotten out of control and sped past
the elementary school. This has raised considerable concern over the consequences if
a vehicle were to lose control during one of the several time periods each school day
when large numbers of children and their parents are crossing the intersection of
Newport Coast Drive and Ridge Park Road.
The great majority of this truck traffic is serving the ongoing, new residential
construction at the upper end of Ridge Park Road. This construction is anticipated to
continue for another 18 to 30 months.
DISCUSSION
There is an alternate route to the construction area via Vista Ridge Road. As shown on
the attached vicinity map, the two roads intersect above the school site but below the
construction area. Residents living in homes off Vista Ridge Road have been opposed
to this alternative when it has been suggested previously. They feel they have already
had to deal with extensive construction traffic for many years as Newport Coast has
been developed.
Traffic counts were taken earlier this year on both Vista Ridge Road and Ridge Park
Road. Large trucks were counted at the same time. These counts clearly show the
SUBJECT: Truck Restrictions on Ridge Park Road
June 28, 2005
Page 2
impact construction traffic is having on Ridge Park Road which has 6000 vehicles per
day with 280 of them being large trucks. By comparison, Vista Ridge Road has 3900
vehicles per day with 80 large trucks. So in spite of the fact that over twice as many
homes have their access off of Vista Ridge Road (655 vs 268), construction traffic
results in both more vehicles of all sizes and over three times as many large trucks on
Ridge Park Road.
Staff has considered a variety of options to control trucks in a fashion that would reduce
the potential of an accident involving numbers of school children. Time restrictions
were considered and dismissed as was the possibility of having trucks go uphill on
Ridge Park Road and downhill on Vista Ridge Road. The chief problem with any
restriction short of a total ban is the difficulty drivers would have understanding and
following the more complex rules.
Council direction is needed to finalize action. Should City Council concur that a truck
weight limit on Ridge Park Road is the appropriate way to improve safety for the school
children and the parents that accompany them to and from school, staff recommends a
weight limit of 8,000 pounds be implemented on a permanent basis.
NOTICE
Staff informed the Newport Coast Elementary PTA, the Newport Mesa Unified School
District Office, the Newport Coast Advisory Committee, the Newport Coast HOA
managers, the Irvine Company, and others of today's Study Session discussion.
Prepared by:
A -ate �,-
Richard Edmonston, P.E.
Transportation and Development
Services Manager
Submitted
St6'ph. Badum
Publi re;.
Director
�, r. t , ..\ .�.3}.::f _ i ",'•">�._'°t \ y rte` ! r,��,'��
�� '� Vii\ t .�, - -, i..' a.<n `• R ;, t.. .` �, -.
,mot- !,,�.. 1a£Ir €:.'?d!.. . c- -�� - `. ,i�y. -11`.r. •. ,� - _
tftv*�.
11�_.11�..1'�-- •_._a�'?10 tt.9.. r >''t.•t .:t� i7� ::;f i
- `fir•, �••:•� \ •v���'..�.¢,�.A� ,- ":. r:i� r) •� _
• 'i { y-i y.?.. '' ,. '��.T� *i ., ., .t. ` -r: Via.; ;' 9n«•.a "+ �; .,�. - � y. a
`��� f=':. r' {,_ `� �,, r� ,y�.� �. t`�,t��t}.�y��; ..L .'tlS -rye' 'y�:�`•�'•{ `�. .'�'1i- �•i
'fit -� ... � •'.: 1. ya3; <: �: r,;•. •. m nL �7^y .. <._}
• ,/.^Pr .'-� ... ice: i' .� .L.�. �.. ,� ^..:�'i/ \"'11••
' ''_. -, :, �. }::{,y ')4'�' °. w •' ,may, �� - •j'. ,, ., . }'3; s.�,._ �t1 -.
��� =,To- ' _ �. - '.f:` .•. �.. . • -' ='� ''�9�. •'�`��\ :;. ,:
'ate ,.. •,• ' ,` - r't` - -.�- " . "' -fi`1t• Slpt; �.
fit` 7 ! '.� i�lt. t,• r, ± .;; 's
��' \' •_ F; 3.; =t•, ate. :,�.
r " 1 !.ter '{ Ji.: , Y. . `•
/.: '�' iE ±, yid "' •F�� '-. '` i~: :r'},' ���
"RECEIVED AFTER GENDA
PRINTED;" il 1 `1
ORDINANCE NO. 2005 -
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NEWPORT BEACH ADDING SECTION 12.32.022 TO THE
NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE ESTABLISHING A
VEHICULAR WEIGHT LIMIT OF EIGHT THOUSAND (8,G00)
POUNDS ON RIDGE PARK ROAD BETlA�EEN NEWPORT
COAST DRIVE AND VISTA RIDGE ROAD
The City Council of the City of Newport Beach does hereby ordain as follows:
SECTION 1: Section 12.32.022 is added to the Newport Beach Municipal Code
to read as follows:
12.32.022 Commercial Vehicles over eight thousand (8,000) pounds prohibited.
A. When signs are erected giving notice thereof, no person shall operate any
commercial vehicle exceeding eight thousand (8,000) pounds gross weight at any time
upon any of the streets or parts of streets described in subsection (B) of this section.
The City Traffic Engineer shall erect and maintain appropriate signs on those streets
affected by this section.
B. The following streets are the streets designated by the City Council upon
which commercial vehicles exceeding eight thousand (8,000) pounds weight may not
be operated:
1. Ridge Park Road, from Newport Coast Drive to Vista Ridge Road.
C. This section shall remain in effect until September 1, 2008 and is repealed as
of that date unless a later enacted ordinance deletes or extends that date.
SECTION 2: The Mayor shall sign and the City Clerk shall cause the same to be
published once in the official newspaper of the City, and it shall be effective thirty (30)
days after its adoption.
SECTION 3: This Ordinance was introduced at a regular meeting of the City
Council of the City of Newport Beach held on the 26th day of July, 2005, and adopted
on the _ day of 2005, by the following vote, to wit:
AYES, COUNCILMEMBERS
NOES, COUNCILMEMBERS
ABSENT COUNCILMEMBERS
Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
Harkless, LaVonne
From: terreverte [terreverte @cox.net]
Sent: Tuesday, July 26, 2005 7:37 AM
To: Harkless, LaVonne
"RECEIVE AFTER AGENDA Page 1 of
PRINTED:"
-05 Al
Subject: Feed back from the Agendas, Minutes
onight you will be considering truck weight limits on Ridge Park Drive %4 have.lived offlo' Vista" Ridge for ten years. Of course, I
)bject to diverting this heavy construction traffic to Vista Ridge Rd. Please do not approve this change.
have always thought the Newport Coast Elementary School was a poor location site for a school. It has been a traffic headache
since the beginning. And the idea of a neighborhood school with children walking is a joke. I would drive my kid too, it's so
langerous walking across Newport Coast Drive.
)7/26/2005