HomeMy WebLinkAboutAM0094. rr��ty�fi�l 7��79gNING' k�TITION NO. 94
• Lsw • lY "' S V l 110. -
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH ' DATE. May 162_ .,�� 960,
APPLICATION ` F 60. t]O
Oriole
APPLICANT'S NAPE: R. M. Krieg � TiOA'tE ADD:1701 E�.Balboa PNQNE 2Z
FROPERTY ADDRESS:_53 Miramar Fir.a Balbtla, Calif
ZOAIE:- R=,I
LEGAL DESC:--TRACT 518 SECT: BLOCK,
INSTRUCTIONS ( READ CAREFULLY) : Fill out this petition carefully. This Petition must be
made by one or more owners of property affected by the proposed amendment and must be
accompanied by a map showing the location of property of the signers of the Pefiti.ong'�,
the use of such property and the use of all property adjacent thereto. The Fetitioner,-
shall also submit, any other data or information requested by the Planning Commission..
District leap No. 12 of. this Municipal Code
The Petitioner devises to amend /S�� ' w«- . Drd. Xe4 _ so as to cause this
property to fali within R-2 _ m=a_,,,_^
The reasons for the filing of this Petition are as follows -.-
STATE OF CALIFORNIA) SS
COUNTY OF ORANGE )
I, the undersigned, ceing duly sworn, depose and, say
foregoing Petition and x.11 data, information, and evi
respects to the best of ray knowledge and belief, true
The above
Subscribed and sworn to before me
on the 16tlbay of
( SEAL )
9 �O
SM, ATTACHED SBEET
pamth titioner, an�that the utmi.tt d ay,6 in all
ignatur f Pe ioner
ZONING AMENDMENT I NO. 94
HARING: July 7, 1960 ,- I DATE.
In accordance with Section the amendment as petitioned for above is hereby
GRANTID, subject to all the conditions hereinafter set forth, and shall be of no force or
effect whatsoeveruntil such conditions are mat, or until satisfactory guarantees and/or
evidence requirements are presented and accepted.
The undersigned hereby certifies t:at he has read, has full knowledge of, and agrees to
of the conditions set forth herein.
Signature of Permitee:
FOR DEPARTMENTAL USE ONLY
FINDINGS OF PIANNING COj%fifISSIO;V: The G... iSSi.on, after reviewiug evidence on file and
hearing testimony at the hearing reccumu=ed that the rezoaing ok su jec pr p -
R-1 to an R-2 District be denied for the following reasons: 1. This property was rezoned t
from an Rd2 to an R -Z District in 95 upon the request o• the properEY 0W ers. .
Density and traffic is already heavil congested in this area and additional dwallIng units
Planning Cc,meission should not be aa -r& o�e��RAI}fTID by City Council
sOn the Dg day of duly _�-- 19 6o On the day o� �q
• F' � 1
Secretary, Planning Commission City Clerk �� r
�y\
t
This property was formerly R-2 and was changed to R-1 in 1952.
There are 23 Lots involved --10 of them having duplexes on them,
2 beim vacant and the rest having single residences. The property
across the street is R-3. Therefore, the property is substantially
R-2 already. Pr�)per planning for this area as well as the best use
of the property, would best be served by changing the zoning from
R-1 to R-2. Moreover, athere is a substantial detriment to petitioner's
property value as well as to ;the =oCier remaining vacant lot by having
the same remain R-1. The difference in property values `in-.havi.ng it
R-2 and R-1 beim very substantial. Petitioner's lot' is surrounded
by duplexes and is not suitable to have a single resident erected
thereon. Since the single residences in this:block are already sur-
rounded by R-2 and R-3 type of buildings, their property would not
be devai_uated in any way whatsoever and, to repeat, petit,ioner's
property values are substantially damaged by having the same remain
aS
E � C
Resolution No.
Amendment No. 94
Aft AOL
IF W
CITY PLANNXNG COMMISSIOr3
NEWPORT BEACH, CALIFORNIA
REPORT OF: Planning Commission
BY: Planning Departzent
July 19 19 60
TO: City Council
ON: Amendment No. 94 filed by R. M. Krieg proposing to rezone Lots 24 to 46
ie.clusive, Block I, Tract 518, from an R-1 to an R-2 District.
PROCEDURE FOLLOWER BY PLANNING CV_j S1OV-'
1. Property was Posted on Jame 27, :1960
2. 160 notices were mailed to property miners within 3001 of property proposed
to be rezoned.
3. Notice of one public ari.ng was duly published in the Newport Harbor News
Press on ,lune 27, 2960.
4. Hearing was conducted on July 7, 1'9b0
FINDINGS OF PLANNING COMISSION:
The Commission, after reviewing eavidence on file and testimony at the hearing,
recommended that the rezoning of subject property from an R-1 to an R-2 District
be denied for the following reaaonst
1. This property wine rezoned fro e� an R-2 to ars R-1 District in 1951
upon the request of the propp-ty (nmers.
2. The density and traffic is 41'P: dy. heavily congested in this area
and additional dwalling unibs'`should not be permitted.
Fcr information of the Council, a Iattar from the Balboa Peninsula Point Associa-
tion protesting the rezoning was filed with the Commission. There were also four
vritt:n protests as wall as maAi, verbal protests at the meeting.
RECOMMENDATIONS OF PLANNM C IISSIO14:
The Planning ComAi.ssion recommends to the City Council that Amendment No. 94,
being a petition to rezone Lots 24 to 46 inclusive, Block I, Tract 518 from
an R-1 to an R-2 Distr;--t be denied.
RESULTS OF ROLL CALL VOTE:
AYES: Clary, Clemence, Copelia, Ficker, 1€igbie3, Marshall, Steelman
NOES: None
ABSENT: Hudson, Rudd
NOT VOTINC: None
Acting
By order of the/Chairman
Alvan C. Clemence
I hereby certify that the above is a true Appvvved by the City Council on the
and correct report of the proceedings and O day of� C). P. 19
action of the Planning CommissAon, City
of Newport Beach.
Respectfully submitted
_ —, Secretary
Newport Beach City Planning Commission City Clerk
City of Newport Beach, California
P. C. Form 1
4
—7-77T
26
27
oil
25
29
oil
AMT
:10
.............. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
31
..............
32
FtWITZ&HUR W n
-ronetuve AT LAW
7
........... t
BIND SYR& RT
RT Mm=v Cmir.
777--
"'PAINT Motto ...................
........... ---
1�
..........
.............. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
..............
7
........... t
777--
"'PAINT Motto ...................
........... ---
Qf L''t
�
J
2
an
�p S
OF nnIP61
4
�.
e 9
21+ through
respect,. ally ;ii
the zoning pa
1$.
�5".
2E7�
22
(4L
An
24
2.5
26
27
28
`.`29
30
�a
31
v
HURWITZ& MLIt4WITZ
-
A77CVUUW AT LAW
Qf L''t
�
J
an
�p S
Ti --3; -SE- T -D-E -OF G �s-, o L) R E DS
a r ne r
\2±0 E,, Ga /e e Av e
Cal -if
All inquiries will be given comideration at that tim.
plaming Director
PI-ammIMS DePt., City Hall
"Y
T .. E^ �
NEW YORK
SAN FRANCISCO
DALLAS
NEW ORLEANS
E. F. HUTTON & COMPANY
MEk9EpS .C- v0.1 $Tour. Ea GNPNCsC
623 SOUTH SPRING STREET LOS ANGELES
CHrCAGO
LOS ANGELES 14 KANSAS CITY
AT LA N-rA
MAwSON 6-=646
July 5, 1960
Planning Commission
City Hall
City of Newport Beach
California
Gentlemen:
My brother, Bruce P. Crary, and myself, are
Executors of our father's Estate which holds title to the
home at 1515 East Bay Front and the two lots behind this
property facing on Balboa Avenue,
We wish to advise you of our objection to rezoning
the lots on Miramar Drive. I have spent great deal of
time going back many years at Balboa and it concerns me
seeing the down -grading that is occuring in various
neighborhoods in the City. As things stand today, the
Peninsula. is overlypopulated during the summer months
particularly, and additional multiple dwellings will only
serve to aggravate as already bad situation. Every City
of note needs a show place residential area, and Newport
Beach needs one too. Please don't down. -grade Limo area
any more.
We are sorry to be unable to attend the hear' -ig to
register our protests in person and urge that you do not
permit this rezoning proposal.
Ver, :truly yours,
',.I L! ; ordon B Crary,
�-YTY € F General PJ
Partner
NEWPORIT EAC
GBCJr/ps
-AIL PERVON5 A C INCOTNEO rM T ANY S AT£NENT ON TNy pArT OC TNIII TeRN, am ANr Or ng gpiatgYEE';. IUL YO TkC Ra6pp N2E6 Et[lY ON —.01" pv ..r cCWS!.N, IZRta Q9t CtlgpO WATT'S k, Oce A& TL' r.V VALUE. G'T
-A?— CC11 RII,ES.IS A NCRC NATTER OF OPINION ASID OIY£tl AG SiNrw�Akp 401C4T A0 - tt+,rs'ER Or COL'RCL�i Y, ANO FQA!YNE!CN Y.O aE bab?tel RSi!EY IN Akt Yt0.r .!B TO R::'f._bE T6 TwE@ 91 Rte, ^,h AkY r -r EY% iwA`c.p-C85,
Balboa, Calif.
June 30, 1960
The Planning Commission
Newport Beach, Calif.
Gentlemen:
I wish to p3a,ce my vote against rezoning
of Mirmar Dr.•ive from 1501 to 1589 in
Balboa.
If
.....
o n ands
1588 Ocean Blvd
Balboa., Calif.
�� . U
.1
.,:.fs
A 6:. Balboa Blvd.
- &4 C-COAM'rilvd.
IM.Ocww� :3tvd-
a vas's 5,--'4 st.
lbea, Calif.
l,..Canf.
1-06 Ana1las 172 Cal$<.
9 �3_
I ":. YffiEJY�
J. Bauer
3109 Gia Md „Street.
170 � .a V�
W� .:
S. sp!7 . st
inggewood g f
Balboa,, Wig.
X62"
bbo a
Edma F. Cote
112 r 0 t.y'
19A � ; alas
go.
q..
Los
eo,��6
:'i.£WtJx d a
,.. jai LF�. h:�-.
'.&o &. ford 4a mead.,..
150 '. ,, . :.3., d.alb
, '
X355. Z. Colorado
l� n
�.
Nail J. Purcell
caorse 0.: spepheas
Gay4m 3. Crary
1-%301611 rive
113 1 1atlh°gta;
623 3. Spring t.
Balboa, C"&Uf.
t lay, a . ',
u ' . "1 �Callf.
Dean. A. Kephart
15€1 Ocean Blvd.
BalboaCalif.
Iorraina D. ewi
736 R co Ave.
Los Angeles 24, Calif.
James F.. Cita
1712 t. ftean Front
Balboa, Calif.
Austin B. slack
% 'William T-3. Eager
234 E.
Pasadeva 1, Calif.
Lo � alp:� ��, Calif.
S. jDrdam ITOO%eM
6601 Telegraph PSI.
Los Angeles 22, Calif.
2 nen P. Cary
'15,119'. Bay iFa:ant
Herbert Tatsch
163 Pap iwe.
M-Ibvrovla, Calif.
Frank W. Clocker
1514 X. Balboa �Ivd.
PIOX 616
aalbaa' Calif.
F'
Geargiana nelps
335 S. Lot Pables
paildena 5, Calif.
Stanley E. Coulter
1714 Miramar Drive
Balboa, Calif.
.Ewen D. Luke
1718 Mira r
Balboa, Cnlif.
Mary Z. read larioaa P. mllif".tt
145 . lat St. 515 Arliugtoz ,Ave.
Covina, Calif. U-Tkeley 7, Calif.
Ethel R. Fill Doris G. Potter
15@0 Hiramr 515 Arlington
Balboa, Calif. 3ark6ley 7, Calif.
Jams F. Hitc h.
xp-mmth W. cowrt
567 pair nt Drive
529 Valmont Dr.
San Bermardimo, Calif.
,tag R9Y&OAla
Harswrice F. Way
Iwxlaak
1515 PFJ . Balboa Ilvd.
107 2.t 1vd.
Balboa,Cliff
lbe Calif
?r
��
1 v tura Blvd.
L50 No.:Alwnt.Drive
SbAmzaa Oaks, Calif.
rtandals 7, 1I. .
erly IAMB, Calif.
Mary
1725.. 1
171.Plaza &LI. r
1112 V. 4T- m Front
,,�ss,,�
if.
Newport seaek, Calif.
r.
3=8611
1092
�21, Gbli�'a$�
-.>#5 V��a��{ksE.
bbq'pp fi�ee.,,,.. Cy�-
. xp Alto, Ca1b
pax
Gp'w�'�r ,. i9
P.e
�karlQ-O:x It
Im Kir mar anus ,
l7 ?t$�a sial;$tet -
161p�,,7.,.. Bal 1Va. -
W, boa g 1�f
� 4ag:.Ca.1�.fa.
lbajg" Calif..
.;Vanyarr.y�s&T
3ffi .
0 Mir r Drive..:
1706
145 tr
1621.x. BaLbai Blvd.
Balboa, Calif.
-11'boas' Calif.
Geargiana nelps
335 S. Lot Pables
paildena 5, Calif.
Stanley E. Coulter
1714 Miramar Drive
Balboa, Calif.
.Ewen D. Luke
1718 Mira r
Balboa, Cnlif.
Mary Z. read larioaa P. mllif".tt
145 . lat St. 515 Arliugtoz ,Ave.
Covina, Calif. U-Tkeley 7, Calif.
Ethel R. Fill Doris G. Potter
15@0 Hiramr 515 Arlington
Balboa, Calif. 3ark6ley 7, Calif.
Jams F. Hitc h.
xp-mmth W. cowrt
567 pair nt Drive
529 Valmont Dr.
San Bermardimo, Calif.
Marov£a, Calif.
Harswrice F. Way
`1
Ruth S. uc�
1515 PFJ . Balboa Ilvd.
107 2.t 1vd.
Balboa,Cliff
lbe Calif
?r
1
Ba 1b, Calif.
$ CalifaSan
.!
laraArr,a
R yelp
F. i
t ABdrws
1335 X. ocean Blvd.
1516 , m Blvd.
Ca.mduea .
Balboa, Calif.
Balboa Calif.
iam
1244 7. Ba'lbaA Xlvd,
um ft as Blvd.
324 S.
Wif
..:- L S P.106
'q
10�Calif,.
y
761 Oap A4i.
1,574 'so '�&Qaa-21vi.ua4ch
g
1536 r avDilve
a
mm Beatty
Siva—
We 21, moils Jr. i
2214 St&mr Ave.
1512 emew, Blvd.
Azs�el a. 64
Balboa, celif.
Howard M. bra
1530 Miramar
Willa V. "C'DOWld
Leslie Et dam
Balboa, Wig.
1536 can Blvd.
34M 215
Balboa, Calif.
x O ch,,igr. �
Halle L. WilF.izma
65d.0 6`Eiv��'. Drive
R"aCa YuMet.t d:.
d 9
7 D.
�'w•Y7i� D. �iLG�'�}iY° �
Balbcal Calif.
A540 Ovmu Rlvd.
1388 E. or-aam Blvd,
lb a, C!auz.
Yalbssa0 Calit'.
d
Alezaader Oliphant
2
Forace -. Alder
ISM Ocean Blvd.
532 N. Sa ovla
871 mudra St.
Yboa, GRIM
SaM GabTiel, Calif.
yaaa, Calif.
�Pzdmrd Frank
Cora 9. Booth
Frame"LS L. Hmmrd
Bal:mmr Calif.
VIM Nuv &a, Ca lia
_"Qdx
W
0
Albert W. Cormlius Vincent S. Dalsimer Shirley N. Nac Gregor
1551 Hirer Drive 9757 Artesia Ava. 1701 Miramar Drive
Balboa, Calif. Rellflamr, Calif. Dalboa, Calif.
Florae C. Stites
224
Glendora, Calif.
Mary, A.. -.graves
Marie V. Haatka
50+25 Ratan Circle
L*V3 Beach 7, Calif.
wewport,ftach, Calif.":A.
HeIroGe
bold
N. �d'n.� Ai m .
L51129 VA
1726 ocean ivd.
�.� ial, C&3L9.
Balbo.a".-CaII 6
Balboa, Calif.
6'564 $ -k Drive
Irl ...
'i�. �lcn
.
a1bea, ' llf.
1 17�.�Z r
.: 3 1b�Calif.lf
1721 Miramar "
.salb g Ca if. ..
114 las
@@ a A: � P $:doth
2. r-ki ll .st
a&dµ-0
.,471
&er �.. Vazdk
.
J ori� �". �
Charles Ac
22 l 3 .
1513' i
13: , call R.
vaglay.:;ftiLh
Elatr'ak it. Shepard
Sia
a 2 X. Piclv .
1711 Mirmar
alif."
Las Zez:.-,23, Calif..:'.
al g Calif.
ie
F3ori R A. sselle
Julia S. wolle2au
% J. Kriel
1700 Ocean Blvd.
1707 Miramar DrIva
128-3 W." .Palmer $!:.
Balboa, Calif.
Baltma, Calif.
GleMala 1, Calif.
Albert W. Cormlius Vincent S. Dalsimer Shirley N. Nac Gregor
1551 Hirer Drive 9757 Artesia Ava. 1701 Miramar Drive
Balboa, Calif. Rellflamr, Calif. Dalboa, Calif.
Florae C. Stites
224
Glendora, Calif.
Mary, A.. -.graves
Marie V. Haatka
50+25 Ratan Circle
L*V3 Beach 7, Calif.
rA ..: Vii ` '
. - Z& U a'�a.g�saea�
VAanvald
William A.., Miller
x.5916 L. ocean Frolm
Balboa, Calif.
Harold C. 'Peterson
014* E. Ocean 1kront
Balboa, Calif.
1540 . oc tam rxcc t
malka, Calif.
am Inivi an
1530 F. Ocean Front
lboar Calif.
425 S. Oakland Ave.
parades, Calif.
Carol K pandell
Guy L. mea
1313 Cormum St.
Faaadma, Allf.
J. we Roble. W.
P. 0. 3cz 6
&rangqsx l«
t
1564 3. mean Front
Bala Calif.
cbarlez A. Walker
l i70 3. Gowan Fro -at
Balboa, Calif.
Martin W. Yo -rest
1572 S. Ocean Pro
Balboa, Calif.
Balboa, Calif.
Zola T�
1 73 �,
Frank W. plm.ley
1569 oceam Bids.
um, Cala.:
a.5-44,*ia a, cau'' .
1559
53 OL -an Blvd.
`5alboa, Calif.
Mamie C. madford
102€3 X.rclligtu-z
Bertha Ullmn Charles A. Fowler Y r Font Ti
1520 Z. ocean 77ont 2130 Kerd1worth Ave. 1541 Gcea.a -lvd.
mlboa,, Calif. Los Angeles 39, Caii£. 3 - cal .
clarance R. stag£
Bad,Gpi a, GAN.
NAS
30wrd R. �azisla
X�1337 Z. ,m aan Blvd,
County of Orange,
of the said County, beinq duly sworn, deposes
and says: THAT. he is and at all times here
mentioned was a citizen of the United States,
over the age of eighteen years, and that ...... .
he is not a party to, nor interested in the above
entitled mattor; that he is the * _ . _.....
printer of the Newport Harbor
News Press, a newspaper of general circuiation,
printed and published in the City cf Newport
Beach, County of Orange, and which newspaper
has been adjudged a newspaper of general cir-
culation by the Superior Court of the County
of Orange. State of California, under date of
October 22, 1954, Case Number A 24$31;
that the notice, of which the annexed is a printed
COPY, has been puhlished in each regular and
entire issue of said newspaper and no+ in any
supplement thereof on the following dates,
to -wit:
all in the year 19.
'.......................
..
r ,
-.., .- ..................::....k- -............. ........ ,............... ._.............. ...............
*Printer Foreman of the Printer or Principal
Clerk of the Printer
Subscribed and Sworn to before me this ..................
i daof 1960
.....r,
11X
.. ........ .... .. .. .................................
(SEAL) Notary Public in and for said County
and State.
My Commission Expires
rrti c r;sr7t� ,1iiH... rit?*�,rav[��rr zs; issa 19 ........... .... .
'1 �4
n
L.
This space is for the County Clerk's Filing Stomp
e4ffi avit of Pu icafion o
Paste clipping
of Notice
SECURELY
In This Space
Zoning Change or Amendment
1 hearing
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEART,
Amendment # 4 Resolutia
NO'T'ICE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT THE PLAN',%-,%COMISSION OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT
TRACT 51.8
LOCATED AT 1501 to 1584 Miramar Drive inclusivea. Balboa, Calif,
NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN THAT SAID PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE HELD ON
THE 7 DAY OF JULY YEAR 1966 AT THE HOUR OF 8:W P. M.
IN THE COUNCIL CHMSBERS OF THE NEWPORT BEACH CITY HALL, AT WHICH TIME AND
PLACE ANY AND ALL PERSONS INTERESTED MAY APPEAR AND BE HEARD THEREON.
RAY Y. COPELIN, SECRETARY
NEWPORT BEACH CITY
PLANKING COMISSION
AM
A ROOF
Publication Date
Received for Pub.
Date ,Received 7.
a
i
BLVD
ET
�R l
OCC IN
ZA DEQ Rl
�A pSUR PLAZA DEL
PROPOSED -TO BE REZONED TO R2 SHOWN THUS
M Rp�" ,
a
PACIRC OCEAN