Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutIS031_ST ANDREWS PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 15037 RE�f/ 0 S Piannin E0 JANI 'Mrr 10 b NFN Clryof985�. Natural Resource Management AQF. CHI Transportation Engineering Lsa Environmental Assessment Community Planning January 11, 1985 Ms. Patricia Temple Environmental Coordinator City of Newport Beach 3300 Newport Boulevard P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, CA 92663-3884 SUBJECT: ST. ANDREWS CHURCH CHAPEL/ADMINISTRATION BUILDING INITIAL STUDY Dear Pat: In response to your request, we are pleased to provide this proposal to prepare an Initial Study for St. Andrews Church. Our scope of services will include the following: 1) a comprehensive project history, and 2) a review of the determinations in the Initial Study prepared in April of 1982. The report will focus on three issues: land use, views/aesthetics, and circulation/ parking. We anticipate that the other issues addressed in the 1982 Initial Study will not be changed by this chapel/administration building change. Wes Pringle will review the project for any changes in traffic impacts. We have assumed that no revision to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance will be needed. Services will be provided on an hourly basis consistent with the attached rate sheet and other reimbursable provisions. Our budget estimate to complete this project is $2,300, which includes $300 for Wes Pringle. We can complete the Initial Study within three weeks of authorization and receipt of a current project plan. If you have any questions, please call . I look forward to working with you on this project. Sincerely, CL/md Ca 1yn Lotell Attachment Senior Associate Drive, Suite 555 • Newport Beach, California 92660 • (714( 640-6363 ❑ 610 Newport Center e, p 0 2606 Eighth Street• Berkeley, California 94710• (415) 841-6840 Jt' Planning ' �EAartrnent�V 1� v y l OF �C CA41FBACyr ti r RATE SCHEDULE Lsa SCHEDULE OF STANDARD CONTRACT PROVISIONS FEES FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Fixed-Fee Contracts. If a fixed-fee proposal, the professional ser- vices described in t e Scope of Services section of the attached proposal shall be provided for the fixed fee noted in the Compensation and Terms sec- tion of the proposal . All other professional services are considered extra services. Extra services shall be provided on a time-and-expenses. basis at the same rates specified for hourly contracts unless other arrangements are made in advance. Hourly Contracts. If an hourly-plus-expenses proposal , the profes- sional servicesaescribed in the Scope of Services section of the attached proposal shall be provided on a time basis at current hourly rates. a Out-of-pocket expenses shall be reimbursed at cost and are not included in the hourly fee for professional services. Out-of-pocket expenses include, but are not limited to, costs of: 1) reproduction of reports and graphics furnished or prepared in connection with the work of the contract, 2) long- distance telephone and telegraph charges, 3) laboratory services, 4) automo- bile travel at 2Wmile, 5) other travel, subsistence, vehicle rental , and lodging in connection with the work of the contract, and 6) fees of special- ized consultants retained with the approval of the client. The total estimated amount of time and expenses noted in the Compensation . and Terms section of this proposal will serve as a control on the services to be provided. The specified amount will not be exceeded without prior approval of the client. FREQUENCY OF BILLING Monthly invoices shall be submitted for progress payment based on work completed to date. Out-of-pocket expenses shall be billed on the same month- ly invoice and shall be identified as a separate item. PAYMENT OF ACCOUNTS Accounts are due and payable upon receipt of invoice. A service charge of 1-1/2% of the invoice amount (18% annual rate) may be applied to all accounts not paid within 30 days of invoice date. z L TERMINATION OF SERVICES These services may be terminated upon 10 days written notice for good reason by either party. In this event, payment for all services and expenses incurred prior to the date of termination shall be due and payable upon receipt of final invoice in accordance with the provisions of the foregoing section. REVOCATION The proposal to which this Schedule of Standard Contract Provisions is attached shall be considered revoked if acceptance -is not received within 90 days of the date thereof. ARBITRATION Any controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this contract, or the breach thereof, shall be settled by arbitration in Newport Beach, Cali- fornia, in accordance with the rules of the American Arbitration Association, and judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrators may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS It is mutually understood and agreed that this agreement shall be binding upon the client and its successors and assigns and upon Larry Seeman Associ- ates, Inc. and its successors and assigns. Neither party shall assign or transfer its interest in this agreement or any part thereof without the writ- ten consent of the other party. Va HOURLY BILLING RATES JULY 98 Job Classification Hourly Ratel Principal $75.00-90.00 Transportation Planner $55.00 Associate/Project Manager $50.00-55.00 Assistant Project Manager $40.00 Principal Investigator $35.00-40.00 Environmental Analyst/Assistant Planner $35.00 Field Director (Archaeology/Paleontology) $30.00 Graphics Technician $32.00 Word Processing $28.00 Field Crew $15.00 lThe hourly rate for work involving actual expenses in court, giving deposi- tions, or similar expert testimony dill be billed at $100 per hour regardless of job classification. Preparation leading to such testimony, however, is at the normal hourly rate.. 9 RECe" Planninge D DePartrncnt 9 FE& Natural Resource Management £ N D� 0198$ Transportation Engineering Lsa �RTgr Environmental Assessment Z, IF. CH, Community Planning v N February 26, 1985 Ms. Patricia Temple Environmental Coordinator City of Newport Beach 3300 Newport Boulevard P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, CA 92663-3884 SUBJECT: ST. ANDREWS CHURCH CHAPEL/ADMINISTRATION BUILDING INITIAL STUDY Dear Pat: In response to your request, we are pleased to provide this proposal to prepare an Initial Study for St. Andrews Church. Our scope of services will include the following: 1) a comprehensive project history, and 2) a review of the determinations in the Initial Study prepared in April of 1982. The report will focus on three issues: land use, views/aesthetics, and circulation/ parking. We anticipate that the other issues addressed in the 1982 Initial Study will not be changed by this chapel/administration building change. Wes Pringle will review the project for any changes in traffic impacts. We have assumed that no revision to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance will be needed. Services will be provided on an hourly basis consistent with the attached rate sheet and other reimbursable provisions. Our budget estimate to complete this project is $3,000, which includes $300 for Wes Pringle. We can complete the Initial Study within three weeks of authorization and receipt of a current project plan. If you have any questions, please call . I look forward to working with you on this project. Sincerely, *4"'771-06W CL/mdd Carollyn Lobell Attachment Senior Associate ❑ 610 Newport Center Drive, Suite 555 • Newport Beach, California 92660 • (714) 640-6363 0 2606 Eighth Street• Berkeley, California 94710 • (415) 841.6840 RATE SCHEDULE III Lsa SCHEDULE OF STANDARD CONTRACT PROVISIONS FEES FOR PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Fixed-Fee Contracts. If a fixed-fee proposal, the professional ser- vices describe in t e Scope of Services section of the attached proposal shall be provided for the fixed fee noted in the Compensation and Terms sec tion of the proposal . All other professional services are considered extra services. Extra services shall be provided on a time-and-expenses basis at the same rates specified. for hourly contracts unless other arrangements are made in advance. Hourly Contracts. If an hourly-plus-expenses proposal, the profes- sional services escribed in the Scope of Services section of the attached proposal' shall be provided on a time basis at current hourly rates. Out-of-pocket expenses shall be reimbursed at cost and are not included in the hourly fee for professional services. Out-of-pocket expenses include, but are not limited to, costs of: 1) reproduction of. reports and graphics furnished or prepared in connection with the work of the contract, 2) long- distance telephone and telegraph charges, 3) laboratory services, 4) automo- bile travel at 2Wmile, 5) other travel, subsistence, vehicle rental , and lodging in connection with the work of the contract, and 6) fees of special- ized consultants retained with the approval of the client. The total estimated amount of time and expenses noted in the Compensation and Terms section of this proposal will serve as a control on the services to be provided. The specified amount will not be exceeded without prior approval of the client. FREQUENCY OF BILLING Monthly invoices shall be submitted for progress payment based on work completed to date. Out-of-pocket expenses shall be billed on the same month- ly invoice and shall be identified as a separate item. PAYMENT OF ACCOUNTS Accounts are due and payable upon receipt of invoice. A service charge of 1-1/2% of the invoice amount (18% annual rate) may be applied to all accounts not paid within 30 days of invoice date. I ' � • • � . III 2 Ua TERMINATION OF SERVICES These services may be terminated upon 10 days written notice for good reason by either party. In this event, payment for all services and expenses incurred prior to the date of termination shall be due and payable upon receipt of final invoice in accordance with the provisions of the foregoing section. REVOCATION The proposal to which this Schedule of Standard Contract Provisions is attached shall be considered revoked if acceptance is not received within 90 days of the date thereof. ARBITRATION Any controversy or claim arising out of or relating to this contract, or the breach thereof, shall be settled by arbitration in Newport Beach, Cali- fornia, in accordance with the rules of the American Arbitration Association, and judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrators may be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS It is mutually understood and agreed that this agreement shall be binding upon the client and its successors and assigns and upon Larry Seeman Associ- ates, Inc. and its successors and assigns. Neither party shall assign or transfer its interest in this agreement or any part thereof without the writ- ten consent of the other party. r y • . • • M Lsa HOURLY BILLING RATES JULY 98 Job Classification Hourly Ratel Principal $75.00-90.00 Transportation Planner $55.00 Associate/Project Manager $50.00-55.00 Assistant Project Manager $40.00 Principal Investigator $35.00-40.00 Environmental Analyst/Assistant Planner $35.00 Field Director (Archaeology/Paleontology) $30.00 Graphics Technician $32.00 Word Processing $28.00 Field Crew $15.00 1The hourly rate for work involving actual expenses in court, giving deposi- tions, or similar expert testimonywill be billed at $100 per hour regardless of job classification. Preparation leading to such testimony, however, is at the normal hourly rate. to ^/ \ • S co t r I Natural Resource Management ctr� Transportation Engineering LSanew�ACfC. •, Environmental Assessment �N, Community Planning February 26, 1985 Ms. Patricia Temple %� i ' t?C�Jz1/Y7t CEO Environmental Coordinator City of Newport Beach 3300 Newport Boulevard n P.O. Box 1768 ` Y2o�X Newport Beach, CA 92663-3884 / SUBJECT: ST. ANDREWS CHURCH CHAPEL/ADMINISTRATION � v1�1Gc11✓h_� BUILDING INITIAL STUDY Dear Pat: In response to your request, we are pleased to provide this proposal t0 prepare an Initial Study for St.- Andrews Church. Our scope of services will include the following: 1) a comprehensive project history, and 2) a review of the determinations in the Initial Study prepared in April of 1982. The report will focus on three issues: land use, views/aesthetics, and circulation/ parking. We anticipate that the other issues addressed in the 1982 Initial Study will :not be changed by this chapel/administration building change. Wes Pringle will review the project for any changes in traffic impacts. We have assumed that no revision to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance will .be needed. Services will be provided on an hourly basis consistent with the attached rate sheet and other reimbursable provisions. Our budget estimate to complete this project is $3,000, which includes $300 for Wes Pringle. We can complete the Initial Study within three weeks of authorization and receipt of a current project plan. If you have any questions, please call . I look forward to working with you on this project. Sincerely, CL/mdd Carollyn Lobell Attachment Senior Associate O 610 Newport Center Drive, Suite 555 • Newport Beach, California 92660 • (714) 640-6363 0 2606 Eighth Street • Berkeley, California 94710 • (415( 841-6840 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH OP g a aC ) PLANNING DEPARTMENT DATE: November 8, 1982 TO: James D. Hewicker, Director FROM: Fred Talarico, Environmental Coordinator SUBJECT: Parking for St. Andrews Presbyterian Church Pursuant to your request, attached please find a drawing of the location for additional parking on the St. Andrews Presbyterian Church site per the City Council actions on this project. No formal design study was prepared by any member of the department related to the required on-site parking spaces. The 250 on-site parking space requirement came from the environmental documentation on this project. It was determined that without the additional parking an unavoidable adverse environmental effect on the neighborhood would occur and an Environmental Impact Report would need to be prepared before the City Council could take action on this project. This impact was mitigated through this and other conditions of project approval and the City was able to accept and certify a Negative Declaration for the project. We realize that parking structures are an expensive portion of any project. It is quite possible that the applicant can, because of the allowance for compact parking spaces, provide no more structured parking than proposed on the attached plan. PLANNING DEPARTMENT DAMES D. HEWICKE , Director By Fred Tal rico, Environmental Coordinator FT:tn Attachment 0 0 _ / V1 00 = W 7 ti _`F+,•.� „tom,• `,� -ate •`' ° % _ \vf Q I ros no w unw ! �( /• � / 1 � r _,,.•^' M w++N•� r i - .-j j corn, 1 ��+ —_._\ Ji ' "•.• r /- � �• ` -r 1 •- - �e,e.cew • • io.Rioiar � .f' " 1 �� i•.+ee rl — �l.rc�wu r•.-..� ..._-.. .� i �aanl�� •r'�� .il) • 7 1s \ ' r•.i , ••w -°- , ,� '�TL` /u.6n (.l KFGs IL1dN Y laRlpi.rENIYICp , una�.ay------- ' ulalouurcwuarr. + �� \' a •e/ ^�rpc yaw h { J `1 I i •HCY! wa�T'.�•-HON 21oS,9.n J ' J19% v..rte SyTE PuAN •no m • , Ir aru.lrou . _ _ •n•m.uun. .� ' �—. .w nl•n •ur Lt••lUWAHN WAi1F.ASsrx'IAThJ•. AHCIIITEC'f�l� VS AD..•OIaATFS AtA rST.ANH1t6WYPHY.JIIYTBHIAN CIIII1t1� \ I �••• PARKING SPACE SUMMARY r eoo.a oar rr rr ,r '-� w M III 1 1 MI v%e 'iw.u• \��' ♦ i \ t \' i ^ �=. a ,'` - / �•-i• :\ �',,°' 1\ - 'V\�. 1 a° .youcncn - I • iuur';ar:i � 1 r 1 ,[wswc ratan mr °ra Sr:.rmee rl ,o lurc o..ns • r.. . .. ,. .� —1 1%ryraoro '/� _' 1° � \ `��/� �j ..» a'__ ' � '.° Snt GGa.. Caw♦cGe.) o�,ae°Y ' •—.1 � umrwurw.ucrw � \ .m,Lwa—•—_•—_-- nrccx.ro».aow ! .�� w •'I'�y .ep.Irrr( ^.af• H6b wr• __._..__--__. - _.• 4�,) 1 11___— J , "R T, far °n v wun,.reT SI`E PLAN 1° n o ur \1 h6N\YANG A.15UUhT}S„ ARCIIITECI'S �� y' • N i A55G(:IATFI AfA SI:ANIIRSW S IMl6YlIYiPJ{IAN CIIUX. o Sco \ t �' 9 , f / a• V .\ 1 to a it ,e IuK cwn 1 1 .1 • «[taunt �r wMw• : ��i' \ 1 ' 4•� • �.. \ -J , _ t�-•-_� •-_._� J�\� !. � �/ ' s�tC MM (tl IVIe4 ..•.I . • 1 ttKtPtl.rf+nwN9 , }�`I� ) K14M'M• t untlavA---�--_ I — uwtx.,auow + �•� �� •erg ^t-"•P• yeb 1 j % J .Hew warTw�.Y,oN lia.9.•• ii M.{b♦ep .3119 r�tae • p,rua.�ga SITE PLAN to -- i L EIIWANI/WANE.A.SMCIATES.. ANCIIITM-FS '��_'��(��. a Y;ASS'OCIAT'FS AIA •ST.ANUN$WS 1'NFSNI" •••.t'a'ta tut ..' �__�`. p +w«y ,••t'i..•.•.w....r.•.••.. -- Ck'NIAN IYNrIi tl j o ' co µ, Np • Tpcf ,' \ / �/ V. nu •i. � � 3 � L .';' ' � uncsacurrrww _ — \ s.8��i •SITL re•e.-. (.. /ue+) ,ctenx ♦ S � •� •.rycl ^ma's% LTV. ale _ _ __ V6 •c/ q . --s .. r>r •��1 � •CL.MJTIW TG}U.l� �Il,lb�I� .% •k' .Hew�.aaTwaTW liwS.r l' EIIWANIl WAi1F.A.iSgC1ATF3.. AUCIIITEClS , i i ASSOCIATES AIA ST.ANUNEWSI•NESUYTENIANCHUM w•••r •�•r o GO ' ) i - � _, �,_• � �>'��� `V/ J1 --- > mot/ ' Q It .o •1 •` •`^ A IN 1 ; Ile 1 V 1 ••�' \ ' �• ly 52 tot. rd.l: s p: l� _ •' _I:I� � ••/ /i./ ,✓ /�uwwcu.�•;2' y � as . d" � h:w e M1 .L• lure t T..O� w.... • I• ! X �...i . �. y unlau.c..u.wa •R 5.>z a•a+ Irxs) r!•+ lcel x ' , _�r..�_._-r_.-_- .._�_����•r��-� aT\4. •cerrouTw TcHKo C~.�7 CEItWANII WAItF.A5S.N;IATkJ.. A�N^CIIITtA7)S '• t;ASaOIaAI•tS ,A IA ,ST.ANIINEWyI'Nt7U —_ - �� "� '•'�� `_ :� ...r.a' YTCNIAN CIIUINI_ CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH PLANNING DEPARTMENT November 8, 1982 TO: Environmental Coordinator FROM: Planning Director SUBJECT: PARKING FOR ST. ANDREWS PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH Through my conversation with Councilman Maurer and Carl Irwin I have been lead to believe that the suggestion that 250 automobile parking spaces could be placed on the church site originated with this department. As we now know, the church is having a very difficult time designing a 250 car parking facility without going to structure parking, which is very expensive. Inasmuch as churches normally are in the business of catering to people's religious needs as opposed to building parking structures, this poses a real dilemma for them. I would appreciate seeing a copy of the study which you performed which apparently lead to the 250 on-site parking space requirement. D.HEWICKER Planning Director JDH/kk JULY 26, 1982 TO: ENVIRONMENTAL COORDINATOR FROM: Traffic Engineer SUBJECT: ST. ANDREWS PARKING STRUCTURE The following comments refer to the revised two level parking structure for the proposed expansion of St. Andrew's Church: 1. The proposed structure has almost 50% compact parking spaces. While this percentage is much lower -if all church spaces, including the high school , are counted I believe it must be considered as a separate entity due to its proximity to the church. This percentage is much higher than any previously approved by the City but should probably work in this instance because of the church's ability to get their members' cooperation.' 2. The ramp designs are not-detailed but they appear to exceed certain design criteria regarding maximum ramp angle and transitions. More information is needed to determine what design options exist. 3. Strong consideration should be given to widening the driveways up to a maximum of 28 feet to better facilitate two-way traffic. Ric and M. Edmonston Traffic Engineer I - CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Office of CITY ATTORNEY 1 July 2, 1982 \ 1. f 8 -��y�ti�✓s� ��;yt � To: Robert Wynn, Jim Hewicke 9 From: Assistant City Attorney Subject: St. Andrews The approval, by the Planning Commission, of the expansion plans of St. Andrews Church has been appealed, and will be considered by the Council on August 9 , 1§82. Staff has raised certain issues relative to this project that may warrant discussion prior to the July 12, 1982 Council meeting. These issues are as follows: 1. Section 20 .80.060 sets forth the procedure pursuant to which use permits are garanted. Sub-paragraph C of that section provides as follows: "Use Permits shall not become effective for 21 days after being granted, and in the event an appeal is filed or if the City Council shall exercise its right to review any such decision, the Permit shall not become effec- tive unless and until the decision granting the Use Permit is made by the City Council" . Thus, should the decision on St. Andrews result in a 3-3 vote, the church would not be entitled to a Use Permit; 2. The St. Andrews project has been necessarily conditioned on the abandonment, by the City, of an alley which transects the building site. In order to abandon the alley the City Council must adopt two resolutions . A resolution, to be effective, must be adopted by four affirmative votes. Thus, the possibility exists that the vote on the project itself, if two Councilmembers were to abstain, could be 3-2 in favor of the project, but the project could fail because of the inability of the City, to adopt resolutions necessary to abandon the alley; Wynn/Hewicker ' July 2 , 1982 • • page 2 3. In the event that it -is deemed appropriate to process the abandonment prior to the decision on the project itself, it will be necessary for the City Council to adopt a resolution of intention to abandon the alley on July 12, 1982 to allow for the 15 days notice required by Section 8320 of the Streets and Highways Code. However, the City Council has not directed staff to prepare a resolution of abandonment, and the attorney for St. Andrews, Milan Dostal, has in- dicated a preference that a vote on the project precede efforts by the City to abandon the alley. In the absence of direction from the legislative body or a petition or request of an interested person it seems somewhat presumptuous of staff to prepare the resolution of intention and place it on the agenda. The only concern of thi's office is that, should the decision on the abandonment be postponed to sometime in the future, St. Andrews may find that a considerable some of money has been spent in vain. These fears may be groundless, however, and •Jim Hewicker has suggested that St. Andrews advise the City Council that it understands the need for four affirmative votes to adopt a resolution to abandon the alley and to acknowledge that it wishes to proceed with a decision on the project prior to abandonment. obert H. Burnham bf I .NOTICE OF DETERMINATION • TO: [? Secretary for Resources FROM: 1400 Tenth Street Sacramento, CA 95814 Planning Department County Clerk City of Newport Beach -Public Services Division 3300 Newport Boulevard P.O. Box 838 Newport Beach, CA 92663 Santa Ana, CA 92702 ' SUBJECT: Filing of Notice of Determination-in compliance with Section 21108 or 21152 of the Public Resources Code. PROJECT TITLE: Master Plan of Facilities - St. Andrews Presbyterian Church use � eR2f2 PROJECT LOCATION: '600 St., Andrews Road, Newport Beach,.CA 92660 PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The project- consists of the -adoption of a use Permit, Traffic Study and Resubdivision which allows for the implementation of a Master Plan of facilities for St. Andrews PJ�esbyterian Church. Including a new santuary, education . building, steeple, on-site parking and other facilities and amenities. CONTACT PERSON: Fred Talarico, Environmental TELEPHONE NO. (714) 640-2197 Coord. STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER N/A This is to advise that the City of Newport Beach has made the following determinations regarding the above described project: 1 . The project has been ® approved by the City of Newport Beach. ❑ disapproved 2. The project ❑ will have a significant effect on the environment. ® will not 3. ❑ An Environmental Impact Report-was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CEQA. A Negative Declaration was prepared for this project pursuant to the provisions of CEQA. A copy of the Negative Declaration is litUM AVAILABLE AS INDICATED BELOW. (See Over) , DATE RECEIVED FOR FILING: FRED TALARICO, Environmental Conrdinator Date k� 4. Mitigation Measures were made a condition of approval of the project. r 5. The record of the project approval, may be examined at the Planning Department of the City of Newport Beach, P.O. Box 1768, 3300 W. Newport Blvd. , Newport Beach CA 92663-3884 (714) 640-21971 COY OF NEWPORT ACH C UNCIL MEMB RS MINUTES yG�r ?s '� y9GF 3 ROLL CALL �iS+� �� June 28, 1982 INDEX Captain Jim Gardiner of the Police Department ad- NB Police Asn dressed the Council and stated that the morale thin the department is very high, and the staff is nthusiastic about their work. As a result, thei productivity has increased, which reflects a safer mmunity. For the first five months of this yea they have lowered- their seven major offenses b 11%. He spoke in support of their proposal and ndicated their willingness to work with the Counc and staff to resolve the differ- ences. Barbara Long, 1337 G axy Drive, Vice President of Area 111 Community-Cong as, addressed the Council and stated that she repr ented a volunteer organi- zation consisting of repre ntatives from the various homeowners associati s in the City. She organizes and administers "Ne orhood Watch" programs, and feels the communit needs a strong police department. She stated the the residents want to retain the current personnel, continue to attract the "cream of the crop," an urged the Council to give consideration to the ass ciation's proposal. It was indicated the Council would also consi r the Police Employees Association's proposal in Executive Session following the meeting. K. ADDITIONAL BUSINESS: Motion x 1. Motion was made to schedule a public hearing on U/P 822(A)/ All Ayes August 9, 1982 for Use Permit No. 822 (Amended), Tfk Stdy & Traffic Study and Resubdivision No. 723, St. Andrew Resub 723 Church. of on x 2. Motion was made to extend completion date of con Balboa Pier All Ayes tract to July 15, 1982, with Douglas Cavanaugh Concsn relative to the Balboa Pier Concession, as r om- C-2326 mended bylthe City Manager. (38) The Council adjourned to an Executive Sessio at 9:50 p.m., to discuss personnel matters. The meeting reconvened at 10:30 p.m., d adjourned in memory of Carter McDonald, former me er of the Library Board of Trustees, and William Her ck, former Chief Building Inspector. Volume 36 - Page 209 o, �f A � e v 1► . . . �/ vv Our 0� ,� ,`O ,0 � O nun ®®� n n f ' KCN4ClJ.- � / Kf1 1104ND10 LOWER FLOOR PLAN cSG c54ndre'a rLrm" 1 91t-c vrian Cburck o . to Gm..IC..K..001.,O�a,11U.1,0Tf 1' t u�cw)r Y 0���� 11 • °° gall �� 1: o ao u r / ` 00 / 1 4 \ i �Q ® r000lma 0 0 x�nnoc usaloar oJOJO c oDoo❑ o.. oc°°Cc, ® st c`/Indrep* FIRST FLOOR ' ---_ "Presbyterian Church we,w.o... 0 5 10 n amwuowiu wvx+rznwc.txcKrtcrs y q • q efOIL � q O O exown euna � OD0000 \ 000000 nwgm WM10W • 000� � . 0000 11 r Cbh � j o°o�o ,. oo� o � 00 e� SECOND FLOOR PLAN ����� re x°nr arnwftCflBn QkIL " I 1� I _ carr�r�erowne.argwrn ao.. v o . E E ^O D OO �13 • � O QY M IE IGEaL Wwa % aET/FwT pl •� EaKM(T. 6�1.1LL OIAPEI - SIXTH FLOOR PLAN o a io m E E ®pa PASfa11 FIFTH FLOOR PLAN _ E E ®OO�T I�FA EgaFAFtKE _ FOURTH FLOOR PLAN EEy o ° � py .aoaEmu ° pe D ®® RIIIINE OifMZ St. c: ndreWs `Presbyterian Church 0 ..ron..o.r..a•u. N1 � eor�aruE wE G EDWIM WAfE LSaOCETE4R AEGPIERa m*o FLOOR PLAN TRANSVERSE SEC770N TWU SANCTUARY st c`lndrews cPres6yterian C6urc1L PEMIgi6j �r PA4IOfl I 18fi19TYR W• — � 1A64 ORi10E W59gp14 1 I 1 Pliif IMCY ��jp ir LO^NCafR1AN�AL SECTION THRU TOWER 7�,, a aI la m St cG/�dre'S 9resbyterian Churdl .. G�WtlME�4a0WlE&KAP6ffECI$ f'r Ct p�'�"tfi� '9 •�e(�!',F`�'..[;� t� � Sj. • �-f' ,u'�'', '• r j,, �', _' � „� - ro ..'n. b' c1 fit' , �• ,y ,j• r� �-s" -ti tr �.1 t .,t �7i lj• �'t�- ;.j.:i;;p�• :. •J,- ., • },r t•'H IF- lit - i. '.i� .'J f. 1',. 'C• .F�1c3vw-°�Y- �� =" _ piZEt`•'•� r �3 aµ f':'f ." - a{ _ lilt • r • ii.J rbt ♦� 1: � �� 'J�'��IIYT-]. .'A�e�V a'�` . ;�' _ t`\ ��. }�i�`_.� � i ��•� ♦ . `�} '. L.,.:r .P'� of•`� ,J 4t �t ,y a�a '�' �' �Y:Y d0}}'��i:. d} • -a _. SS.e+ . •yJ':�J'+r♦ J 'r i..t.. ! S ! err ` f fit. a"ti r ti s' r � • r .. yam.{y 1•��Y 5 I 4 4V, ,, ,;. , r , IFFR 1 _Y `_R -`t - .j• ,'} 1__ t'I'I�: f ; -1 ,A,i_, - -y� f. is "" -.r �g�: r, :_ � : ,yri� RF4•y - • `,S �„ _ - yi. e,� :.'". s�lCu:�s,' ..''-tr,''ir. �.v� �•',. 7 .7•b/A•`Y•. Ce�a� �: _°P'�Ly �f•Jj�� ,�•t`'.. '�.,/2. �Y� %,.�„R •iAi_.i�.s ; - :-s+ iy �r '�/ �, M-I�F�• � �. 4i.''� 'y� 1..�w�+' •t t fi' , .• � �FT1 Fi. ,cii .j;::A eta f���' �. i�'ti\`��74�'f, •�„ . .t'. R t E> +14 ra j R 1 j'it , •a. / CITY O&WPORT BEACH - PUB-� 0 DE�IMENT TO: /�Jc2c�l G _� M �Fc ��� ate ° a FROM: d' �S7 f,/.J�✓dGQ,�..) L �'0f.9 �S8 c•,' r � SUBJECT: 7/ram fie- Gs�T !'G�ISL�" GLT"ryl� ,�.c-err.-� /F 7lz'L'�� /J1�!✓sy2t�1E.G7.�' /��r�"Fe� �' nrl ' Copies to: fined _ Si ne� PUT IT IN WRITING . . . . . . WRITTEN MESSAGES SAVE TIME AND AVOID ERRORS N � � � �!! oti�v�° 2 �! REp12nn�n6nt s r�g9m���Zr � a � ' `� �1Tt gEpCH. � tJ Q � N�J4�pUF. 4 � 3,. Q � � � tp � -- v \ N THE NEWPORTENSIGN - September 8, 1982 --..-.-..r St. Andrtea,-r,..-• ews Back Oii s —�=��� ^ i;ks�...ify ' x %• '• ti.C,S l°: J xFtiy. N City Council Agenda' "The St.Andiews`rPresbyterf '85-foot to on fhe site;jFiat Qhurch,controVersy will be back south of the present sanctuary, '•' l'before:the;G"ity�G}'oyiggil,Monday ;fiaildin ib+ ;, `r et• `+ '''^ ;migh ai'IE •i ty father a regular; Church iepresentafwes said 7:3Q p..,fi.rxieeting;l s; ; , t• „ thene ,f$cilitiles were,tfeeded`•.e, ti Fy.i y•, h commrtee with.two: because'of'expansion bf the '' representatYves%eac'h from the"•-#' -church program and the inade- councfl,-tie ohuich aad•the aura ',. quacy of the buildings currently-' rounding ndf`g borhoo�l has ij4 I on the been meeinyfor the.paet month ,They had originally tried to in an effoAWt Work out,a iolu' _,geianoiher site in the ,-1;''•lam.. fion to•Ure copfroversytover.,- - Castaways area but negotiations -whether the church should be;v.,., with the Irvine'Co. broke down allowed,#o build i major expan-,._and plans,wmxe drawn up for ex- lion,of its facilities inahe''i- ,? } pension on, e'.ourxent site. , ; b residential neighborhood across' Ilesidenfs bi t ie Cliffheven 5th Street from Negort'Harboi axea,•wliere the church is ' .High'School.; located;are`adamant in$heir The item'was contm'ued fioin Y oppost#idnfo;flie expansion the first counbil,meeting in ' tY'the.chufch as pre sentlypropos'-^ August when it became evident that both the homeowners and , '; They say that the size bf the the>church had'strong points structure is not proper for a favoring their position and that residential uneigh borhaod, that ' :any decision made by the co`un-. the.#owei s too bigh'foz the area oil would leave one-or both of,-l° ,atia-t6t`addifional cars drawn ,the partjes dissatisfied. y ? s"to the Flirirgh would cause major ArY" r:^.t?r, t,v. ti.? :.,`• ; traffic problems, The church has purchased all . +:Monday night,the council,will t of the homes on the north side hear the report-of.tlie commit of Clay Street over the years' ' s tee,complete;the publidhear ; and plans to tear them downand ing,'and attempt to reach a an construct a sanctuary with •••'decision on the matter._ , A10 C/N ~ %'� .Orange Coast DAILY PILOT/Thursday,'August 26,{1982 D 0 .lf'1` ., :�F. ' ,,. Iy,'��'�u�'. "�Y-�.�:r,( thin -•,� ..i,,, �•p.'. Ad vice` fon *church_ jsite ` . a, f-1 q� r ,.,yp.y+•.,w d iw r' x,'•,w:ur py4:.. . '..0-'�Wr.�..;" Cft' ;%i�I- appears-%m.m d zrected " �q' ' , '�, S ,;i{cts ;• "4_ . .•..,ti'.;'•a{, Officials 'of St. Andrew`s ''rumungfor re-election;`Jt 'seems`""` ' Presbyterian Church .in Newport,•,patently unfair,to attempt to draw ' Beach have „been embroiled.-in a;',,the''Irvine ,Company intp.,,a dispute ,vfitFi'-'some'of,•t'heir,. 'controversy that is 'clearly-,#bt of ,neighbors' over,church"e anion•,jts own making, g � • plans,and certainly'there .is-'still � (!,VtThe-idea of a church qn, ,Ome hope,that the church and its.:,,Castaways site_is.not a neNr'�onerFi' <, neighbois may,reach some'form of `•Tlie'church atone point h d•been'-'� --F compromise. i;''= ;_lw.^F4trrha4 ' 1 ;-„ '.t;in negotiations;with the company`{' ."; .;This.was,•'cIearly the position : for such'asite•bu"t'the discussions taken by the majority of Newport ;'were't6rmiiiated:$ Beach City,Council members.;`: � Re�ocaEioni Councilman Paul Uumji 91;``"would,seem'to'be an'option to be ` {' however, seems to.be .off on a.,'•left to'tlie church"and whoever their •' 'tangent of his,own`on,this rather'kpri'vate;ptoperty,'owner iiught be.;y S`fTLSltive issue. , ; ';�.jii'1•'`;?, t;}f'n+'n 7 'Rummel-Anlyt d past, . Hummel lias suggested that „„seei}ied'to be+ferribly cohcerned ' ,the Irvine Company should make.;:over �iiomot'ifig the^.lrvine . ! a 'site on.Castaways,,Hill, mear•,i;C.Qmpany's, image �iIt isspmewhatr:g:•. Dover Drive and CoasY'IAfgliaay,?.curious that he:6 ini'coiicerneC1 ' a'vailable' to the church:EHe now. Y'1`� suggests this'would be a;way"the';i' y'i Pei haps at can tall lie put•�„ company Gould impr-'ove ,i•ts,;°downao'election time fever when r'ii; ,,tarnished `image+7{irii'he.,,ur-Newport.B.ablH,`ariy lime youi; : community. :can put the squeeze oh the Irvine.:*__ # While it must 'be`recognizdAj •Company;you will always draws a that Councilman Hummel Jsy; certain number of,admirers. ;•. `, .".- ..•y.'pF.,_, �.iF4 ,. ..#.:'1 ' - ,"k;F'n:,..f.i=h.1J t;y�' , .•Wa�� •: ,.;�� � '% '^ 5�1 . A :+4 ".tu• .:Nt�s ?'l.,uaS(z--,. .w1rd..c THE NEWPORT ENSIGN — August 25, 1982 '.r i dA1- — '.• ,. .,.., :..il:�R,�t,?r^:'�;-+Jt'i'l•YJ•.i;^'T,zc4r5�'.�., Council Opposes `� Councilman Paul Hummel's drew's had been negotiating for attempt to get the City Council a site in the Castaways area. to discuss ways to designate a Negotiations were broken off by church site in the Castaways ran the Irvine Co.',which gwns the ; into a stone wall at Monday Castaways wife: a, , :_. , ' night's Council meeting. Following continuance of the Calling the letter written last applicafion to'Sept...13 from the week by Hummel an ill-timed ef- last meeting, Hummel wrote his fort to add another area of con- letter, which suggested that the tioversy to the already troubled city may want to discuss ways'to,, St. Andrew's Presbyterian • require a church site in the », Church,application for expan• Castaways area, mentioning St." sion; the'councii 'voted 5 A with Andrew's prominently as a, one abstention_to refer the'letter, church which could use such a ' to a committee attempting to.; reach agreement amongdhe r i ' church; coinritunitybnd council .. City Attorney Michael H.. Miller told the council that it } on the project. }; .,a i•'-,"`j°'tr"'r -would'inapplopriate'to,c'i4siiier Hummel,s timlag ie.off on,, :+.,;any i formation on_lhe St 'An• this.-He has weakened the com-• drew e}application received out y ' mittei,which'is.trying to reach a • ' � „ ,: ; , aide the pulihahearing,_which doterminatlon$y Sepr,,;13, q,,r;'eP .will'reiauine Sept;; 13,;, commegt4".kzjollinan Don_' _ N : i �, ?:: •=�A committee made gip of two Strauss. .. !y:. ,. . ; f;''r;<. '•'- v •;Couhcllmitiii Phil Maurer, a'•- R; , memberd of the CityFCo"cil, member of,the•comtnitlee„add• •. Maurer and,Mgyoz_;p-tern• ad, ',The timing is very poor and Evelyn Hait, two,representatives puke us (the committee) in a very ' of the church and,_wy members; bad position""' of therCliffhaven_:cpmmunity Councilman 7ohn',box added surrounding the hurch is cur- that, "it is i'nappropirate to do rsntly:meeting in in attempt to this (receive the letter):": resolve'problems between the ;, r.The council at first discussed ,.,church and the neighbors so the putting off consideration of project can go lorward. :a*y' f Hummel's letter until after the ?,; '' The'church proposes to cos- ,` St, Andrew's Church application struct an,85-foot tower as part of was decided so there would be a new'aanctuary to be built on no hint of conflict between that"= property along Clay Street • application and a discgssion of behind the present.sanctuary church sites in the Castaways. , building. .;'a;l =^•;; T. Before submitting it's expan- Neighbors-along Clay and in sion plan for it's current site on the surrounding area oppose-the 15th Street acrose from Newport project because of what they Harbor High School, St. An. call.Ws excessive size:' L THE NEWPOAT ENSIGN - Editorial Page - 8.25.82 The Church Problem -.The protosed,expan65n of St. Aiidretivts Presbyterian Church�tas.°been coAtroveisial"since•if was first propoS ed several'montlis ago.' `;"' ' The plan to'place a large sanctuary building on the less than four'adre site has" itted neighbor against neighbor and the community against a church which has served Newport Beach with distinction for decades. When'it became evident two weeks ago'that the neighborhood did*not 'want to live with the proposed - church edifice and that the'chuich could not live with less floor space and. still offer its full program and ser- vices to the community,;the City Council appointed a committee'represeniing both sides'and`the council to'. work out a.solution to the problem. ;:.The discussions being carried out by this committee" are sensitive and should be carried on without outside -interference:- -."'y.`t •; . '"'='`•`"�f}F;i•• .''•r'h:';•_' •,.�•-,«xx "Which brings us to Councilmaii.Pau1,Huinmel's at- tempt to introduce the idea'of reserving a church site in the Castaways aiea;wliile these discussions are going ,.., on. ('ri.' '.l�< f,.:, '1} g } ;...i,•. :The idea may be good but the. timing is not. Hum="?;..1 .;eel's idea was obviously piompted by,the'St. Andrew's problem and may be a'valid consideration after the question of whethei'St. Andrew's may"build its new buildings on its current site is resolved. ' But,it is not a valid consideration now and can only^, serve to f on urther confuse an already highly polarized S1tUatlon. ',y:y:�•Fa$��ttq :: ";•, ' "� . '. The committee should continue its work without fur- ther outside complications. After a decision is made-on the current issue, the city can address alternate plans for the church;but not'before. Hi mmd *` _ Proposes ,5 �1".y. :•.C:-iv d.N �, .- JCL 3°'y.1 t?} .1`i: .t !.'•-'- 41 now•look,atthelpbssfbility''>, of locatinq"thIs new'fa ciltty of St. i4n0rew's Presbyterian Chuich- oq the Castaways site has been proposedi by-Councilman Paul THE NEWPORT ENSIGN Hummel. •..a , �zr._:,.,.n. t its la"si meeting the City` Council hid unanimously voted' August 18, 1982 -'to set up-a ci4mmittee to try tc `reach,i compromise on pro-, r t, blems caused by the proposed expansion bf the church, '••tc 'located acioss'i5th Street'from.. Newport Harbor High sSchool, ,, The committee,'made up of.,�j two members from the communi- ty;'two�Iroiq the'church and two "frori:the City Council was to .6poit?rack to the council on :direc}q {o ac:ir arl'dn fitepxoP9$.ga expae nsion i, ".ef SidirdieVi}tCliuipI,`a,'veh`. i°?tali with-hix#uneasy�eliag`tfia#':: t�e'rieeds of neiihei,pdrfy viilI. autisiifed'b'ylre clty's diredi+i five;�'Huiamel comxnented:��;;:,ls },l Reducing the'siie•df facility will diminish the,nbilitys;t f;of the ohdFcH'',to-carry`;oyt;its�y!V. yonls 'Ori the other hand; x5sc. anything lead than v eductio$to its size will serious. is 11yy'affect the.neighborhood: •z.i ",i Humtpel eaid'thafthe.;sal.: :,. d wlution`to,' epi6blem is to ' d another stte for the church,: -` Yvhere it could expand to its ai #,maximum,capacity and efficiem'' He poiated�out that tlie'',-_-.i;%. church had made an unsuc- 'r ' cessful attempt to obtain lan in tte Castaways area near Dover,;;•'' and Coast Highway. ji."It is unclear to me-whether the church's,inability to obtain• 7-the site stemmed from financial ' or planning problems,"he-said., ?,,Hummel suggested that when Y new land use plan for,the area. w(s presented by the Irvine Co. 1_the city could require a churc ' F fits qs a'condition of approval; Y.thgt-city ould;chbnge.;the eherel'plan fox'the aria to•ac; modeteth's Cb't1ic1Y;'+ ••yy,WW���;rpY_ II - :•-'Y:{"Y" '.,.i ru;^':,: -'f^r�; _' .. . . .':' . '.3'l tel:•��.'v.�rti ,,.y.i �:.rr.: •. _.� A6 N „ Orange Coast DAILY PILOT/Thursday;'August'12;-1982 1� Goodies` YS ' go"odies Y, 'lu * 1• •S1H'v .'i:. .T;,•'t 1.IP: ..)i����Y.ryY . dy} 1,':•j,Y 'tt r•..'. .T ` ' ..�� • 'J `tL 1• }f,%{�,,y i. d . ..'a.i.:hlp :,� .-L.v.'1'.'` '.r ,..�,- ' grapple ew i.' p.lr. .;1` i-i".•�•.Jr}y� �'jEEily '�Le'11�[� . 1� �4:•,Z'1,:,:'4. �°.i J`l. ..'t' .O ra S . _ } .,.i pSr t• i r,Yf lA, ,1':•'ram;>"�� e' :.L1i. N$. tt �)s,'.t 3'3•r y... .4'•.4'.�Pv. .. LS:ia.n�F:G:.7:>a 'I:F:tti�y',oi.•� F'tl�,'yl a�f 1 N.;1.... �d +�.� The dispute'ovei;how tall thef ,. d.that ISt. Andrews; located 30 sanctuary at St. Andrewttp'' , years in-tt a neighborhood, is in Presbyterian Church in Newport ',,,dire need of expanding- and Beach should,be built is one of, ifrequently,tt rns";away. '.wor those simmering'neighborhood . shippers :on.Suliday'lorBack, of spats that somehow or:another ;,'space. " ;.:' N;epolvesinto a major.cityltwue. Further; church members' The conflict :between the '„,point,out;tihat, the sanctuary church,'.located,near:;'Xewport,•,I,origihally,was''to'stand 105 feet "Harbor' High 'School, and ,but was lowered:to meet concerps, neighboring residents reached the ; fiom're§identi. City Council this week.'. . -+',`; ' ;} . 'Y::Nobody cari blame city council Y,'•, �.�, iCouncil'members, prefaced:= .members,'for being:reluctant to d�Zsion,by',aoknowledging that ; dump;'Into; tlie, midst.;of,this the, city had received'more mail "+dispute':As,�ivas pointed'out;this is and more phone calls on the; a case of,the'good.guys,versus the church controversy than-any other ;,good guys;. ':/=` :••; ' f," issue over the past two years. 4 ;; The city lawmakers, upon {'n ''.Tlie issue comes 'down to:";;`huggestiori of 'Councilman Phil whether the sanctuary, at 85 feet,;,Maurer;.'wisely:postpoed their" will be too tall and too massive. :Fclecision and asked both sides'to, Many residents of Newport work toward finding a solution.'," heights believe it will have both �';';;y This is a,' prudent approach' drawbacks. Traffic from the' :'guggested previously;here. This is expansion project is another'.';�'neighborhood,problem and'the concern. •' .church and the,residents are much x Church leaders answer that `;better- equipped than council the structure will not be offensive 'members to solve A. THE NEWPORT ENSIGN ----- August 11, 1982 ...,.y,t'3") .. ,.k t .�..";'.,:,ai .R•::Li1 `%. �...'�i �',. �.�' )�r z' ..y."t Couric�l befers Church Decision;=� � ;Y 4 t._. .-.a` , ) z• .r ik�':`�-` �: n' w' �1,i.^!. .�.. •:x�1:.�•- df:.'i ii.. a-'.i.. W: ti.;-4 a{` •:J f:� :,mot -'i'•' aw:a....r4:•wre•n.•. Committee T_ o�Attempt .Compronvse �+-, Y '•-,.)! c - "r -• /'i 'd,.v. 1 j�'l•�i�Y' ( ":4'.... Councilman Philip Maurer;`" "at the church as such. Twine Co.' ad baaked'out of a abruptly ended,an emotional t : ;'Brian-Genette,speaking for proposed se'fo the dhtitigli,,• •,t t iiblic Hearin on whether to' �i the Cliffhaven neighborhood, ': forcing them to use'.the current alydw"St. Andrews Presbyterian commented, "We don't want to site. ?:;< t , _r„ •:' '>' ' Church to-'expand with a pro- # ;atop the churcli, we just want to Residents of'the azea said the posal to set up a committee of t I keep the scale down so it fits in dhurc&was trying to put too six persons,'two from the chur='"� a Yesidential'nefghboihoo3.":,. ''': much on the property and.@aid•� `ch, two from the community and • 'Dr..John Huffman, pastor of ' that the niiiriber of parking'";.'`' •; two'from,the-City Council, to ',I,the church,loldrthe council that spaces provided was inadequate ikork out a solution to the,cos'p` ;jhechurch Wias.a;community ,.•;, and tlie.size'o the buil$ing'too tzoversy .,'�,t•xf y '' . -•`:'�-," ; ;,} ' ;• church'anc{had'giowa.to the. .•, , large:,+'; y ayi�., •,,,�`'- :x�„•:.y '• �; };'Consideration of the project" point where the expansion was , . ,The committee set up' X'the-y was delayed until the Sept.13 . +•.ziecessary. *'; council wab instructed to-lrieet,r"y e,, T",;;,':and aitempt-to'worklu- Councll'meeting.' ,,; •,• t.��,ls ,;.Tie said the'ohuich had fir•„ ,., eL$�ys..* 4- he church, located across .. originalfy'planned to move to tfoa agreeable to all a report { x- 5th_Street from Newport Harbor the Castaways area But that the x gbaak to colincilrc.-"':4 ; gh Sqhool, has proposed to Build anew sanctuary Building which includes an-85-foot tower' in'the cerit6ecif the property and. a`two-level paiking garage:f,,*,,;c; ;'fthe'church plane to fevel0f0';- tpuses along'Clay Street to allow for parking and the new sanctuary building. '!Opposition from the :1 ^`K;. '�1; nn6ighborhood was not directed , ' ::.; -i-:}-� '". fy 15^• . - "ri [, - � .. �ef ` s •2_•F-- t :_'�-''-- -,-'d einvh:js sue , elan yled t= j,�' ' '-,i•. `' ' .re '-}: »c: 5 a T` r1:. .,' ..•tiry:'. 'ts'•.+i. f 1;3. `.i_.iu,." �' .`.� ''T-'�:'_•'3,'.. t 4i._.i4:.; 'f"d•3�:.�•.>ri <`rS�"t's'f-'`-d-s--.Jj :.>.">4�...use+ r..rv-.._E'. 4-x:"�»''""} » ng-,. es n reclBa ks a•F:Co un, i� .1.. ' -J .♦ : : f..A ' '.4 =A. . 'F,-i^'• �,<' . '.. - 3'6 . r, . _;.`.' - •21.'Y -fr�a, grin-iir.;r.Ry��,:By'STEVEMARBLE, 4 - }:z_i>'a",'TlierY''o'fty wade=s Taped ,i-;, pesentattves'4f{lio`tb'fides=. a 'e�evltor?',^.µ7591eYanbtlierre'si0ent,.. Of the o.sy root Staff. ; ,'Via:,r. ,. _sanctuary-w:v tf l d.;b er,t It a ;•-meet with•two"Crouncil members:" said •the sanctuary:is:.an.office;- The;Newportrl3e' ch City ; Council,asked,to.settle a dis ute.;a�centerpiece' o>"ttie'chtirch's $9 7`ato,strive.to settle the fight and j3zbuilding'disguised as'a'steeple"` P million a on{'t $'" '''`restore peace ito' residential_;_ .Re-sidentaBarliara Jeati,. ]bet.ween. a c'huich;_and X aL a =_ ;NewporE'Height�.•, _,. .-4 ` - Whitford woFried,.that-the,;, ;- - _ .M!Igh o sides ie a,fight,isthats�-:Council_ariettibers-"said',the •` �Res'i-i1e: ti w o F ay;et"';church expansionwouid,increase'> St'. B , dsspute:has;geperated:_more+tngil,::'=:: i t. , j3 traffics and;described Sunday' been summedrtup,as the-.good;,,'and phone=calls;titan-any other' °mPlained- t e�si_7r floo'i4,,:;morniiigs irl:her.neigliborhood.as: • N guys.versus ttie;good:guys:;;,;;: `project in file city:ut'recetlt_years:.,_xsanctuary will•beitob.tall ttd tod'.%a-`•.p roc e.ss i o n:;:d f: p e-o.p 1 e= The neighborhood spat ceiifgi5 ; "Accorditiglys1t13ecounciTadfed" massive,, criticized the.projeFt z:,fperforming:>U,turns,'•S-torso{,_ on plans:;for an_85-foot big h= Mdnd`ay,nigh .with'caution;';a MOnda y ,,,>zn;::; ,4.: Z turns.and,jaywalldng ' Y.F -j ;sanctuary,at Stc._Andrews+- unastim`o,us1'y•;a,greeiiig o}.,` sHome`o'w•p`ei��Bbb� CoopeF1 t.�,IlMurth nember.Mi]an!b&t l-2 adaclPresen tto-Newport.Ha'';lopatgd=. tpone they tem?o Seats k e rj wigllg�t k ke a Chi the ga'struct acre said he Xpansio p roject has'.`f iacent to Ne rt.Hartior n M Schools., 5 h'e' c o n n=c., 1 100 beo-iit;the 20 years{aiid3- �' thatithe'churelt,needs_to expati(t', • its,facility:�Dostal�iioted:�tlie4, ST: ANDRE•WS'e pla ';f ; �xr ay.l;�d ;droppedy is tiso��1Q5='foot;;saticttiaiy.to i '. worshiP havebe ": G;+in;sDert,rSundY" l • 'eJs4itdinei?itHiaUifkfmoriacieir,nSrars'to;;i1, of •,•: turned awa •because'of lack-of seating..,He described St. 'i• eta;Q00=jnembeF3pturcl}`,said'rp Andrews as a good neighbor in'',,, Newport Heights for 30 years. ; "I would not want to pastor:a;,' I... that has in atiy way rape&+;•i • or hurt the.community," he,said, adding that the church has been :,r forced to.build upward because;.`• of its limited real estate.,^,a y;ji ORANGE COAST DAILY PILOT - The sanctuary would ificreasw% seating from roughly .700"to "ir335.Architects for the,church,in.,n August 10, 1982kan, effartto-meek parking¢ deineiids;are•§tr`. iAg`to'redch-an" f agreement for'"using parking facilities at the nearby,high'. school h,;< ,,7 ;1 , ' a`•='';RobertCurtis chait7iian of#t ,,; chu erch's building comiiiitteeX 'which3has raised more,than $6';i on for;the project, said het. believes;tlie;church has.done all is F :;it can•to-.meet, the'worries of ;; s•residents.=He' said he is,unsure :., what further negotiations can do..:, THE NEWPORT ENSIGN ---- _ 8/4/82 '•'7*s•.4rYy.wlJ .r ..41e-'nY`YY_�:.4Mx.'ct^�g+,^9 +•v,.»-,r, •rvf,:,: .,,i`,ry�n,^:,gnrarlsNvr"M,�'c 4?�^_y^R''eF�`M;F�vjT.Yyg b , 1w t[' rn ,.1.'C''r aL ....JLl¢✓jµ•S• 1 St. Andrew's • j'y _.• . �.o' '1-.i}•,.Jy5^:i.`n1i e t,r_ F.; o-'P• •�� , Y:!'.,;'..F„d� , (• Xpc1 . ir. � :4.rected T' Dr. . , o.,..�..:'r .,:�. 3i ' .n•.c' - Y i../l;yG:.r:y 6i•.='{�'%a•jl 1 ' YI•;- _ti,lil�:r, :1.'+- .N ",-ar.`i.'.'p:S:;!;>"•STJi,,., f'i' >< +4...: ",xhe issue'of whether St. An-.;1'.of parking'.aa3"height ' ;; , F,;'of from 1,500 to 3;000 persons.t d,rew's Presbyterian Church can.;; nr Petei-Gehdrorf,president of.' ; 4'Gendron criftoized the'church build a new steeple on.its.ex-•"':":•the Cliffhaven Homeowaeis'' .i' figure'of'five.slats per,parking.' 1 isiing.ohurch facility-in the Clif-, Association,said the community. placq,,commenti i that other fhaven aide will be before the",",:,,thought the;chuich was trying to, chuiches polled used a ftgufe'of, City Councll Monday bight at :'; ;build too'aeirch on'tPo ttle rb- ` 1l 6 or 1.7 persons per barr,fot`,;;F+' N. f N ���Jr P�'y 1 '.1:.,.... ti Y, Y i , ri.ii �f. `w- .`;11t•V"JC,s".,:,: j,Y.. �1+II..L.FtrL PJ, l 7:20 p.m, .' ',,:;'i• `"` their parking facilities. W '1 r $e said the heighf was" '>>,;�. The project, wliibh was ap• r�+ = X'he public hearing is:achedul- Arnved'by the Planning,Com- , ^;;unreasonable and that paikirig'.t ;,�i!o begin,af-Zh'30{r.ia:.at the, miislon last month, kvas,appeal- and traffic;piolilems pould result City ,ersat city ed to the council by Mayor Pro rirom a conceivable attendaacgT•, +'tam Evelyn Haztr'-;G:,•%F;"'�'>'. •p:� _ I >,kjpllowiug the appeaI;'Robert Curtistsbhairman;bf- re church ! i buildin'g committee,,told the'En sign that the churoh would do:t whatey',ei the councif'asks-to qet; e`p rlopdsed'$9;5 M millionj' , devefopmep Lich rthecon- JptMqH g o •81aig i circuIai .`•' aka t a in se lqj structtL�txd d��eepi, gg�1�f T Wo 'se''85 feet hig}i; sTlie pib Deed steeple would . indlude a eoil" ioora and of- itces on su"ccessiie levels. The proposal passed the Plan-' pyrtg_Commtssion by a 4-2 vote but has drawn criticism from neighbor's on kwo grounds; lack ..� ram• _�,� � 1 + _ � K �1✓�* y`• � _ f o^ ♦. yl it, r tI� t,;•3'6r,.�`�� 'ftii'i V}:ria4iw} i'hgV•„r.rr�y Z}'.J:.b f4 • .yi. 'f•'{'+{.h�lri.•r"iI .,M., ; krI , ,:.' L,"[ Vim•. �r•'•, 1 -. kr,(�kry��(. '+rk .Yn }.te :t •bra:}e"r`','�.Y11F a+)1♦ l a"t,°.y'.l•e rr 1 rq.P 3•�r�/l .,� -/ 'f'r• .r ` � f ,+1 3-'f.• •4.Y+1-a Y+a1.1'\r~V r •• �b?,'..rat. •{� ♦ • .,w�r\;,, �ya,.a ,n, .y{,i �a. : RR,,trt r.. ♦♦ ;f. ` •.7rF sit + .�v fap: v �b.�...t'.. i� L,-'" f'r''tia . to n L ra ,',4•y .er. 'l . 1 f .4,:.�•"r1.Y.kn�'♦:,fc:I•rJr'�yj'ry-^ •J' 1�� 't•'J'.' -4 ORANGE COAST DAILY PILOT ,b.. '•jj� S. � �r of�,.e-rlC Wi, k', R'}:. �.)`'1': May 28 , 1982 • - .[_ •, -.L.rY• -r,'..:-,l=•.a.. ` s' •L'+�»-'V�u i ri.'`...'�:`*v�'SRi•.. t.•P•'/ 1, f^i,•fit 7:+,: , •.r}•: ". - ,'� y : J' • •• ,r;+r,) -'Di11Y Pilot Staff Photo STEEPLE'RO{V St.`-'f'ndrew 'P's'Presbyteriah 'Church. •, officials rented this:83-foot-high crane;to show:they',are willing•to cof nproinise•in controversy with neighbois.'."- f . ,•', ra •b,t�r'�•,,�'7:'b�'�i\7;':,j1:3i'r�n r'�J;a,'••'G.t`La�♦stiJ`��'Qi� 1�.4 a�},'n%u�A .yw, «{.7+�.f'`(!$.b. h�O w.er'S s - - - ,.'. "_F, rj`:."' ..at) '*•,'�/%�7if:ar'M1?+it""'-:Y s':h,pL:y"i.5 •,.. i 1 ,.,i� .,y+� 'iq'ji 1''E,a ly..$t- ' '".ti. f�'.:i',as'i r4��.,' r ti�`:•.'• . 1. ' 114,r - ti,.,'::'P ✓u1.5e'h:it',i 'e 4 ;' .4 trtr .n....., uiy ajtjac' a;'Ji (. Officials of Str,Andrew`siITanfbegoodneightiors;rolled out Khe crane'jo demonstrate 'Presbyterian Church'in�Newport "• ;-:., ,,,'. Beach+!rented an 83-foot-high .they aie,corisideriiig loweiing drane Thursday to prove they are r,,'the steeple to,83 fleet: _p} ,' , t,,, w i l l i ri"g to lower their+; ';''Milan Dostal, a'inember of the ,expectations as well as''their -._phurch's'building committee and 1 planned 105-foot steep le. .rf�;:,",;% a;dormer• Newport mayor, The dhtuch!s plan to'erect 'a ' stressed;:that• :the::demonstration', "towering steeple as part of;a$9.7 r�:doesJl ribt;mean 'the;church has" million, expansion has brought stettled;upoli;She' 83-foot height howl§ from residents-in the ': Wit• : r "'s ,x_`' '=I' "'' nearby Cliff Haven-coir munity! 'a ,-„'It's`just bne of severAf opuonsY Residents have• Complained 'wereponsiderm' at this point'f"I that the 105-foot steeple would he noted;.'r t"+_,;,z•bq'.;, t be an eyesore. One •resident '• = Residents 'who '`observed tlie'• suggested, it will 'blot 'out!the'° bi'ane,•thodgh, said they,"eren•t . sue„ .-. iinpressed.,They said they want Church officials, saying they the church to stick with the city's - •• - , height limit of 35 feet. The -St. Andrew's expansion plaii'comes before the 'city ;- Planning•Commission''June 24. »w:s'R`M.Yw4X1•rr �y�r7." .•�it•M1�.•�e+Yl•.>u�. ORANGE COAST DAILY PILOT- - April 23, 1982 .. • . r: i' L . .�'- .:.,r:��i. is �f or�•��slior�er,,�.,to,�er.;?•. 'St. Andi;.ew'.s Presbyterian •,,'More.thari,20o,;people•showed "Church, 'which'cteated-'a stir in ' iip Thursday evening during a sNewport'Beach',s:Cliff Have�i:',.city;Planning Commission session 1dominunity=witH,plaris,foi• a' ','to protest the plans..TThe coin- .j (405;foot,tower, has-indicated_it ','mission contiriuedJhe,matter ' �ightsettle, fora�less .lo�ty trLLCttkre. yr-. cie'�: . Tr:F iw:ii i�,l:,L:s,, • ..,:l Yjski-;'r" Robert Curti's,''�hairman'for . ,,,Curtis, who said.the tower . lthe ,hurch's $10 million expan. ,would be used fot administration' J''sion platls,'said church leaders offices and-conference room's'; Ryill take,a second look,at their •i;said,the expansion is needddfb@ ' 'growth(plans,'including the.to=I,3,c'ause;the'church's membership -War. i'i )Chas swelled.'•.. ,1, i';w ,e a . �, `.t.tn-,y�'{i .1•f;. •h'i i.$xit- 'i: ']�:' -'R<ti.'., FL3"a d't .� .... r". . ..:a7:lx^.,• •iu%,,..__ ,_u...... . .........r.. ........u._e.. tiam:rri ...a ORANGE COAST DAILY PILOT - 4/15/82 Letters to the Editor Chirrch- expansion ;,�; To the Editor: .q I find;it.necessary to respond to an editorial which appeared April 8 in re- gard to,the proposed expansion of.St.. Andrew's Church. 5" First, I think'the terminology needs to' be cleamd.up.The 105-foot structure the „,church.would like,to build should not be 'referred to as a tower and definitely cannot be called a steeple. It'is, more correctly, a 105=foot structure of sub- 'stantiaf width.and significant area.(6,500, sq. ftj designed to house offices, com `,plete with ivio'e1 _ ors. ' ' ;'•k^ " Second,`the reason the'church did not complete,fis,plans for the'Castaways property last year was not in any way % -due'to;Cliff ggaven residents' opinions or. requesfsy bht,{{'athet .that the Irvine Company,wdthd`•ew,its offer of the pro,. THIR'D:;iSHO,U1D St.1?rndrew'sj• .Church move to a'more appropriate site ':,,for its expansion and•the existing prv;: perty not 'rebuin a,church,;any viable', use.oi the,prolie'rty,,could nevef• reach, e`ven. ttiedensity..of„St Aridrew's'as;it; now stands:'The,new,gwners'ivould guy xcly',b' required'40 observe the legal; }height units and$ff;str6ei parking re-, :'igtllations..It St.'AhdreVs stays and ex- parids, theylhould observe the same•' • requirements: .':,,•,;:.; .r.,,, •. "The church was founded to serve the 'needs the e heigliborhood and the' community. Over the years they have. alr44d"y,groWn W tliin'the neighborhood' as.th5?r',membersbip has grown. If they.' liave't ow outgrown the neighborhood' they should r t expect the residents-to. bend to their, iAnsion,but instead seek 'another area i JSre-their enlarged con- gregation car• w. '-We have 1 .%:the community for 26 years and • ':d our home on Snug ".Harbor Rol .•;•r 13 years during which time�.the cl .n and.residents have been good neig rors..The residents woould like., ,;to keep i,that way., .;, BARBARAyjEAl1 WHITFORD ORANGE COAST DAILY PILOT - April 8 , 1982 Keep i.t heigh,borly Plans for a 105-foot wedge- were afraid of what might take haped steeple at Newport Beach's tithe church's place. .", . ` ' t•.Andrew's Presbyterian Church 'No v'that the ci. , jr is lave caused some residential: 'staying,'the'neighbors again are eighbors to rise up in protest. upset..It wouldn't be surprising if Residents of Cliff Haven, an ;church officials'now are starting to lder community near Newport ..wonder what they have to do to arbor High School (which boasts fry to continue fulfilling its mis- ts own soaring landmark),'com- :sion in the community. a ;+sm',•. lain the steeple will be an eye- It seems reasonable to assume; ". ore. Some even suggest it'will tliat if St.Andrew's,a popular and lot out the sun during portions of growing church, needs to expand he day. I:;..,= r., :r: - •'i, to serve'the people who want to ' The steeple, desoribe sy 'carry or<-their religious activities ome as looking like a'shark fin ahrough that church, there,'neces- d by others as a'sail,"is part of, Oy will be more activity'on the he church's$10 million expansion site some of the time ` lan, which also calls foraa two- evel parking structure it =' "•. :"It seems equally likely that,. For members'of the corigre-' were the church to-leave, any vi- , ; ation at St.Andrew's, the steeple, : able:new ,use,..of such a premium rotests aren't the first they've" a ',site could be;inorg intensive than ncountered. i;. • l,,„'a t _,the present one. Either way, the '. It was only last'year:•that ..Aeighbors,ar$ faced with living eighbors expressed concern be-•' with'some, changed conaitions.{y�f4r`, ause the church was entertaining •;,,tWe hope the church and ,the bethought of relocating 6n a•,:}residents, who have keen'good' assy promontory known as The ,heighbors for„years, cad keep it astaways. Residents said they ..wthat v .....n�••rMau_ w.dv...-:••. ••:m:.ti8:tir..i..Lilai,L, axu.:y,i1.,,,yam•,' .-..,q. r+v....•�- -eY•...-.wse-gym! Area ;s,pi'i on church Te rate; the church liar iaisea a. . • "' bout;4 million through private dona)z expans i o n,: := 'tions and fund-raising activities to god toward the building fund. Curtis conceded that architects " t,.Y'.v.:,,-,r••- '• ',have to d church officials that such a . By Jeanne Wright , ,::•: . large`development "normally„ re-11 Register staff writer + ;^4 q-;: quires'-at least 10 acres of land.The- ' • •' w •" `` church now occupies about 24'i acres NEWPORT BEACH In the 32 but has purchased 10 adjacent lots toy years since St.Andrew's Presbyteri- give it 4%acres. an Church opened, the church has Mayor Pro Tom Evelyn Hart said grown to a 10-building complex with the primary concern among real--� 2,900 members. ' '' -a•"A,'•'s••. 'dents is that the "church may have. But now the-church wants to dou- outgrown its site." ..-. - ble its facilities,plans that prompted , Atone point,Curtis said the church its neighbors in the quiet Cliff Haven was considering purchasing 10 acres community to hand out petitions - of land on Dover Drive,known as the Saturday opposing the expansion. "Castaways,"from the Irvine Co.. "It is an issue that is splitting the "We felt we had a verbak option on community," Cliff Haven resident,: ' Ahe land about two years ago,"Cur-,; Linda Scheck said recently, "be- -,.tis said:But at Ieast, the"Irvine Co. cause many of the residents are f'stopped the discussions." — r.; r members of the.church and they are "Please see CHURCH/Eli' r having difficulty knowing which side of the fence they should be on." '•;r1. Scheek ,lives-about four 'blocks from the church and her children sing in the church choir._;. c;`,•'; :i ',.The church, located'on'St. An-", 'drews Road near Newport Harbor High School,plans to spend$9.1 mil- . lion on its ambitious expansion. It flues, p'ute remodel an and o ��Bt;Thq Register Stinday, Apr.,,4; 1982 ground-level' 'parking lot, and con-'&'• .:.:'..•. s •y F- . i..":^,:,;;. structtwonew.buildings." � CHURCH One would be a 36,000 square-foot'f; ; ':FROM B1';,preschool,the other a.¢0�000_square-,j .,• foot structure containing a f,400-seat,• 7.•, ,';',;, n: + a a;•w #>ut;c sanctuary, a:fellowship,hall, class- Y Curtis said the church has"hiveatigat'' other`possible rooms and offices.' " AY^ -p'�F sites.in the city, but decided,' stay,at the present •location. .. ;. ., - Neighbors reacted,gwlktly to the;'•` - • plan, focusing their dislike on the ' neNeighbors said'the church has been 'ta ry�onderful second building,a massive structure neighbor."But this,they said,goes too far. that would reach 105 feet into the air..' ="We are'not opposed to the project In terms of Its" "l.'m going to fight it until we beat rpligious and social objectives,"'said Newport Heights It," said Cliff Haven resident- resident Roland Landrigan. "We;object to such a huge. George West. The large buildings structure-being constructed in a residential area.'", 'c •1 would dwarf the adjacent homes,he ;But both sides said they still are willing to talk. .; .•' said, and would"be offensive to my Church officials have tried to "pursue a reasonable ' neighborhood.",,..' • -! ,x• ,,' dialogue".with the residents, Curtis said. "We had a St. Andrew's officials, however, professional traffic study and analysis done," and the contend that what they call the results indicated that any iucrease in traffic would be "graceful steeple-like structure" IS negligible,said Curtis. : .• •• . • - - necessary to accommodate they 'Cliff Haven Community Association President Peter ehurch's burgeoning membership.' Gendron said he would'like to have neighborhood repre. "We just can't go on the way we sentatives meet with the church's building committee are now. We need to rebuild," said before the plans go to the Planning Commission, , Robert Curtis, chairman of the At .•A public hearing on the project before the City Plan- church's building committee. hing Commission has been tentatively set for April 22, St. Andrew's has a busy schedule i 1 according to senior city planner Bill Ward. „• of meetings,worship services,adult_, To proceed with plans, the church must obtain a . and children classes and outreach conditional use permit from the city,Ward said. services,he said. "W,.z:'b .` ! -Zlroject.opponents said that if some satisfactory corn-:t -Just within the past year, since a promise is not worked outat future meetingswitheburch -aew program aimed at single per i Leaders, they will fight;the.ypeimita for.the_church',-.' eons began,; several hundred nety6 prg]ect4;`k°,.' ,;.'• .-+. = ::. ,{ ,. 1' '_ people have jolnedthe church,-said _Curtis., SEW Pp�r CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH U Z P.U. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH,CA 92663.3884 do cq<iFoaN�r PLANNING DEPARTMENT (714) 640-2197 October 15, 1982 Carl Irwin Irwin & Associates AIA 14600 Pacific Coast Highway Huntington Beach, CA 92649 SUBJECT: Final Billing: St. Andrews Church "Environmental Fees" Dear Mr. *Irwin: Pursuant to your request, City Consultants attended the City Council hearing on the St. Andrews expansion project at which time the project was approved. THe below sum is for services rendered for the period September 1-30, 1982. Environmental Document Fees Consultant Fees $ 336.70 City Fees 33.67 Total due City of Newport Beach $ 370.37 Please remit the above sum at the earlies possible date. Make the check payable to the City of Newport Beach and mail it to Planning Department c/o Fred Talarico, P.O. Box 1768, 3300 W. Newport Blvd. , Newport Beach, CA 92663-3884. Very truly yours, PLANNING DEPARTMENT JAMES D. HEWICKER, Director By Fre alarico, Environmental Coordinator FT:tn 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach FUN G A550CIATE5 AA Architecture/Plonning/Interiors ■ Huntington Beach/C>akiand TRANSMITTAL PRO1Ecr St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church Architects City of Newport Beach PRO1ECr NO. #1166 Planning Department Dare: July 21, 1982 3300 Newport Boulevard Newport Beach To: Attn: Mr. Fred Talarico Environmental Coordinator ❑ In accordance with your request Cl/ We transmit the following: by hand delivery: 3 copies of photo reductions and 2 full size prints of upper and lower level Parking Garage For your: ❑ Information ❑ Review ❑ Approval ❑ Revision ❑ Signature Signed Melinda Wood is ❑ 16400 Pacific Coast Highway, Suite 205 Huntington [leach, CA 92649 213/592-3309 714/W-3319 0 8477 Enterprise Way, Suite 110 0 Oakland,CA 94621 415/635.8669 SEW Pp�T CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH,CA 92663.3884 °+'/FORN�P PLANNING DEPARTMENT July 20 , 1982 Mr. Carl Irwin c/o Irwin and Associates AIA 14600 Pacific Coast Highway Huntington Beach , California 92649 Subject: Environmental Fees : "St. Andrews Church " Project Dear Mr . Irwin : The purpose of this letter is to confirm our conversation and your verbal authorization related to environmental fees for the ' Saint Andrews Church project. Pursuant to your request an additional parking demand analysis was performed and City con- sultants attended the last Planning Commission public hearing. Both of these items were beyond our established scope of services . Presently your account is overdrawn with the City as indicated below: Consultant Fees $1 ,044. 21 City Fees 104.42 7/19/82 TOTAL DUE CNB $1 , 148.63 In accordance with your request a final bill only will be sub- mitted upon City Council action on this project. I am unable at this time to estimate the total final bill because of the unknown amount of information that could be requested by the City Council and the number of public hearings that may be involved. I will be directing the City' s environmental and traffic consultants to attend the August 9, 1982 public hearing, but will authorize no further work by them without your authori - zation . If this arrangement is not satisfactory to you , please contact me at the earliest possible time. Very truly yours , PLANNING DEPARTMENT JAMES D . t7/ectorCKE by FRED R ' Environmental Coordinator FT/kk 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach ❑ 500 newport center drive, suite 525 newport beach, caiifornia 92660 phone (714) 640.6363 ❑ 2927 newbury street, suite c berk Lsa Berkeley, caiifornia 94703 phone (415) 841-6840 LARRY SEEMAN ASSOCIATES, INC. May 11, 1982 Mr. Fred Talarico Environmental Coordinator City of Newport Beach 3300 Newport Boulevard P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, CA 92663-3884 SUBJECT: INITIAL STUDY FOR ST. ANDREWS MASTER PLAN OF FACILITIES Dear Fred: Now that we have completed the Initial Study for the St. Andrews Church Master Plan, I feel it is appropriate to review the project budget. Our origi- nal budget allocated $8,150 to prepare the Initial Study and attend hearings. In reviewing our work performance to date, I feel LSA has performed work over and beyond what was originally anticipated on this project. In addition, we have not yet attended hearings on the project. Consequently, we will incur costs beyond the original budget allocation. The additional work and costs are described below. The principal factor which contributed to our increased work effort was changes in the project which required revisions to our report. Project sta- tistics on such things as square footages were changed and there were incon- sistencies in the statistics which could not be clarified by the architect in Huntington Beach. Additional time and effort were spent to resolve these inconsistencies. Parking space statistics were revised, with the resulting need to revise the traffic report. Also, more copies of the document were requested than we had budgeted for. We are requesting a budget augment of $837. This cost is broken down as follows: Mr. Fred Talarico May 11, 1982 Page 2 LSa Present budget overrun $157 Hearings Traffic engineer (4 hours) 300 LSA (10 hours) 380 Total $837 If you have any questions, please call me. If additional revisions to the Initial Study are required as a result of input from the public hearing process, we will need to renegotiate our scope and budget. Sincerely, LARRY SEEMAN ASSOCIATES•, INC. Carollyn Lobell Associate CL:mb • Planning Commission Meeting April 22 , 198E _ Agenda Item No. 3 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH TO : Planning Commission FROM: Planning Department SUBJECT: Church Architecture For those of you who may not have had an opportunity to read the April 19th edition of Time Magazine, I have attached a copy of an article appearing on Pages 50 and 51 regarding church architecture . The article in part refers tolthe architectural firm of C. Edward Ware & Associates in Rockville, Illinois , which is a principal architect for St. Andrews Presbyterian Church (Use Permit No . 822A - Item No . 3 on the evening agenda of April 22, 1982) . tES D. HEWICKER ning Director JDH/kk Attachment Design expression inrcigiou sarchitecture.cedersdIn the recent past,en c nct ived leaders Arid archi- as "religious lantV'Cmodem churches as "Nitrous plants" to accommodate Eureka Sand w Ark It is one cized of mexim,party counseling,banquet b school popular and widely publicised of new rooms,potty kitchens,banquet halls and Creating for Gods Glory whichsensabot130,wonandings.Tfie edardfor diverse coudledfofthelas.Ile senin which seals about A won an award far fund-, scheduled for the Iasi phase to Church architects are turning out striking nC[V buildings Archi mi from the ought outs astye teof fundemiming drives were never made it Arc,ODO viandwazsougit striking Sometimes services were held in low- During toes[of the post-World War II lake. a consists is , meetinghouse,afest or 120,The visitors.Noting its striking quad- 1 ceilinged, linoleum-floored "fellowship era have dwarfed cnnandeple bill- sanctuary small weddings ties,TheAtintegity." s,"lllacehuiid- halls." build- boards have dwarfed church steeples In tower,a parlor for small weddings and mgofgratintegrity." '� '"Che'60s were the years of Christian rwporne,religious buildings have(rani- other assemblies,a social hall,a youth Atonce famdtarand nowl,the chapel education,classrooms and playgrounds," rally vied for attention with bizarre bell center and a library with staff offices.It was built for wayfarers rather than a resi- I says Architect David K.Cooper,28,who towers,(toned A-fmmes andsrrange pa- was conccived in the Pilgrim and Portion dent congregation.No larger than a tall designed the Salem Baptist Church,Or- mbotoids But until recently,fewchurches tradition ofearly New England churches, bam,it stands at the bend of a wooded land Park,ill,and SL John the Baptist have managed toconveya religious quali- but its form is traditional only in that the trail,high in the Omrk Mountains.An al- Church in Winfield,Ill."The'70swere the ty beyond that ofa contorted steeple or a while-trimmed gmy clapboard and spire most transparent stmcture of mostly tim- yam of Christian fellowship and muld- neon JESUSSAVESstgn. convey a sense of historic continuity.The ber and glass,it seems to be one with the pie-purpose matingrooms.Now,in the All that seems to be undergoing con- architecture is closer to the modern sim- surrounding woods and rocks.The cha- Us,Useems,theemph dsisonworship" sidemble change.Many church archisem; plicity of Mies van der Rohe than the be. pers architect,E.Fay Jona of Fayette- Cooper, who works for C. Edward are now producing more exciting work toque mtricacyofSirChristopher Wim. vale,Ark.,who studied with Frank Uoyd , Ware&Associates,with headquarters in than colleagues who me straining to over- Another enchanting example of con- Wright,describes it as a kind of reversal { Rockville, III, is fairly typical of the - come the discredited, bare and square temporary architecture is also religious— of gothic cathedral architecture. The I roughly 1,500 to 2,000 church architects look of modem office towers and apart- the 22-month-old Thomcrown Chapel in trusses inside the structure form a rcpeti- practicing in the US.today.Ware em- menthouss."lf you had to pick a uve, rhythmic lallim pattern as ploys 25 architects and draftsmen and de- single piece of decent architecture e l evocative aza Bach fugue. signs about 20 churches a year,three lima that could rightfully beplled post- EAmong the most active az many as,five yam ago."Our clients are modern,"says William Houseman, - 1-churches in the US. is the small excited about the challenge ofbuilding a editor of Arcdrrecime Affnnesom. �.^-. -and simple St. Posers Lutheran church and aflmeting more people,"says "the Colonial Church of Edina, % '�;,. oChurch on Lexington Avenue in Cooper."Nowudays,congregations want r Minn.,might well be IL" ��, midtown Manhattan. St. Posers, to participate actively in the liturgy—to The Colonial Church, on the +' • ' i which opened in 1977,adorns the sing mom,to move more, to celebrate. outskirts of Minneapolis, was de- �t- ;,r baseofliughSlubbinsJr.'s 59-story They don't want space that confine them signed by Architect Richard F. Citicorp Center.Although it is not, I merelytolisteningtothe pulpit and organ. Hammel, 58, of Hammel Green strictly speaking,part of the Citi- Theywanlspacesthatgivethem nanseof Abrahamson,lnc.,a Minneapolis- r l III corpskywraper,it loowasdesigned communityandfrcedom." based firm. "Designing religious T _ C'-- by Slubbins and fits masterfully Despite the current building slump, buildings is arduous,"says Clem- into his overallarchilectural vision. I -many church architects are very busy.Ju- mel "It took six years of discm, c Stubbins'church holds in own at dith A.Miller,administrative assistant of _ lions and hard work with the con- av Ja`"" 1 gregation and its pastor,Dr.Arthur .I--,- �,- ��i,�,�.� %•••�; the foot of the somewhat bml'uh thelnlerfaith Fommoa Religion,Anand r t�,:atCii3 - 9154L Citicorp tower.Thechurch's Architectur"professional association of Runner Jr,to achieve a harmoni- The timber-and-glassThemere"ChapehawayfarnLhaven uncluttered, skylil interiors were i theologians and designers of religious in- ous understanding of the function ![ created by Vignelli Associate using dilutions,points out,"They am designing and meaning of their church.But it ;K -i _ _ !� Enatuml colon and materials Sculp- small buildings an small budgets Church 6 wonderful work,because some- aw,♦f -" 2 :tor Louise Nevelson designed the and synagogue design is no Ringers.matter thing other than dollars is valued. t jhhurcWs small but exquisite Ere] ofarchitectural theatrics,but ofemnomy You are designing for the celebra- ] �� Ot ,Beker Chapel-of the Good Shop- and liturgy." lion ofhuman life." :herd St.Petersis indeed asanctu- The church,which opened is - - ,.^;, ' m qt. fiery in a mid and hectic city. ! ongregations seldom take their arcM- 1979.is a kind of miniviliagc on a , + j,� mitt p aY All three of these churches are CtecVs first inspiration w gospel any . 22-acre site along a man-made pointing the way toward a vital new more.Building co t r^ ,� - `r+.r -,h ra t mmittees do much seat iU - '• searching about their needs To develop a u w ' A ncny,right,adorns Colardal ' "I Atthefootol CHIcorp Center I building Program,says Architect Pietro ClxrchmWvllla e,below ., xt^ + Belluschi,is oRenin a@<t"to explore our I g d'ac worshlpersamherat SLPeters I P ti with God and to search for a u <s "� ••�'S47��' k.�--'.v a +< `f b ,yF r, r, ' ^+= �: %p- ' � „i' yi" tr art understanding o[Ihe nature ofreliBian � r}'a1.<I'+If•11'='. ' fa$� 3• as an institution."Belluschi,dean emeri• 1 ••fi'a`+jt711(g +,i - i?; , tuft of the School of Architecture T:,J i ', d •� s-.I;1�vlr',-ae•nnYJ?n - and Planning at MI.T, is famous for, m;�;.`.,-. . i,j•C+'b+ir_',+>+:•,J'p37 among other things,his simple,reverent ] +�$. }4S } JJ-.r� >.ddH �$;�x+ rt > ' }'d''• y;,..+.t -' ..:,;'-qr•jrd+:s 'I 5,} churchesin Oregon. t•W'�' .tea Av'Ir,11, _ �il r f ' :n41};: :'i. t'r' •' th For Architect Percival Goodman. i#gJ�;}',,r,kk2 �nvc5'1i.; Ga, a .,,}a;i• t .9y; --- .,r, :r, ' .�•.4y� If{ r who has deigned mom than 50 reli N,'[f gious 'r"-ft,t. ,rr.t"t• a .',t .}S t .k�d : f•I}, �Y..I ,u., I t ,n;,�; t t ' 1 4 and community buildings in the US.in. eluding handsome synagogues in New I [t I'[Ip ._� ' ;., r.r, 'Cif. , York, New Jersey, Massschuulls and r •'':$ Michigan,the religious building of the N- re < lu will be"modest in five and fmgai in ^-„'_%'y ., •1,,,•,• , =:d,C �i +l �-�.Me c We seem,at long last,to be headed for e humbler a architectureou of worship, t rather than an esten—By fv. of •r �� architecture. —BY Wolf VonFe{xdt . ra CIA • ,'• ,, > TIAIE,APRIL 19,196E • NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING • Notice is hereby given that the Planning Commission of the City of Newport Beach will hold a public hearing on the application of St. Andrews Presbyterian Church for a(n) ❑ Variance Use Permit ❑ Resubdivision H Tentative Map Tract ❑ Amendment EXI Other Traffic Study on property located at 600 St. Andrews Road Request to consider a Traffic Study in conjunction with the expansion of an existing church facility located in the R-1 and R-2 District. ❑ This project has been reviewed, and it has been determined that it is categorically exempt from the requirements of the California Environmental Qualities Act. ❑ NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that a Negative Declaration has been prepared by the City of Newport Beach in connection with the application noted above. It is the present intention of the City to accept the Negative Declaration and supporting documents. The City encourages members of the general public to review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Negative Declaration and supporting documents are available for public review and inspection at the Planning Department, City of Newport Beach, 3300 West Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, 92663, (714) 640-2197. ❑ NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that an Environmental Impact Report has been prepared . in connection with the application noted above. It is the present intention of the City to accept the Environmental Impact Report and supporting documents. The City encourages members of the general public to review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Environmental Impact Report and supporting documents are available for public review and inspection at the Planning Department, City of Newport Beach, 3300 West Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, 92663 (714) 640-2197 Notice is hereby further given that said public hearing will be held on the 22nd day of April 19 62 , at the hour of 7:30 P.M. in the Council Chambers of the Newport Beach City Hall , at which time and place any and all persons interested may appear and be heard thereon. ,loan Winburn, Secretary PUBLICATION DATE: Planning Commission Received for Publication City of Newport Beach By NOTE: The expense of this notice is paid from a filing fee collected from the applicant. 0 IRWIN G ASSOCIATES ALA* fors Huntngton leach/Oakland March 25, 1982 City of Newport Beach Planning Commission 3300 Newport Blvd. , P. 0. Box 1768 Newport Beach, CA 92663-3884 To: Members of the Newport Beach Planning Commission Dear Commissioner: The purpose of this application is to modify, the conditional use permit of St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church to allow a sanctuary with an average height of'34 feet and a maximum height of 46 feet; a 1.05 foot high church steeple; and a 40 foot high cross on top of the steeple to be constructed. This new church facility is necessary to relieve existing overcrowding and to allow St. Andrew's to continue to serve the Newport Beach area at the high level that 'it has for the past 34 years. ' The church is currently offeriing three services on Sunday morning in addition to Sunday School . The services are crowded to the point that people are seated in the chapel or turned away. There is not room for children and parents to worship together as a family. The expanded sanctuary will allow the church to serve its current congrega- tion in two services without turning anyone away through many years of , continued moderate growth. Office space for approximately fifteen people has been included in the steeple to allow more parking on the church campus. It is anticipated that the oncampus parking will provide parking for normal weekday church activities. .The street parking should be significantly reduced from the present level on Sunday mornings. We appreciate your consideration on this project. Sincerely, IIN �/! • arl Irwin, A.I.A. Cl/ls O 16400 Pacific Coast Highway,Suite 205 : Huntington Beach,CA 92649 213/592-3309 714/846.3319 0 8477 Enterprise Woy,Suite 110 . Oakland,CA 94621 415/635.8669 00 gob r. AWN G ASSOCIATES AIA 0 Ardiiteaure/Ploming/Interiors y ■ Huntington Beoch/Ooklond ', .,tj2� V 2 z v IM S � tt Co NONQOCFUF. /co cU N February 26, 1982 LSA 500 Newport Center Drive, Suite 525 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Attention: Carollyn Lobell , Project Manager Re: St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church, Newport Beach Initial Study Dear Ms. Lobell : The following is information requested during the staff review of.your study: 1. The St. Andrew's site is 4.6 acres. 2. The height of the existing sanctuary is 35 feet. 3. The height of the high school tower is 93 feet or 97.65 feet per the attached sketch. 4. The maximum height of the proposed sanctuary is 46 feet; the aver- age height including the narthex is 32 feet. .Without the narthex the average height is 37 feet. The low point on Clay Street is 26 feet and the average height on Clay street is 32 feet. 5. The height of the tower is 105 feet with a cross projecting 40 ft. above to a maximum of 145 ft. The tower will be lit with a low level intensity from the narthex roof and classroom area. These sources of light will not cause a glare or reflective condition fon,.the surrounding area. The cross will be lighted on the tower (see attached sketch) . 6. The existing seating pattern on February 14, 1982 seated 544 persons in 12,900 inches of pew space or 23.72 inches per person. 7. Review Expansion Chart by C. W. Ware is attached. I believe this is all of the information requested from us during the meeting. If we have omitted anything please call , or if we can help you in any way, please let us know. Sal arl H. Irwin, A. I.A. CHI/j cc:/Fred Talarico BBrob���C�urt��i{{s ❑ 16400 Pocific CoosF HI§ftwayrSuitWe C�5 : Huntington Deoch,CA 92649 213/592 3309 714/8463319 13 8477 Enterprise Woy,Suite 110 Ooklond,CA 94621 415/635.8669 . �iy, � �` <�;��n •ram ,, pr 4 ntiio�j J i; t� VC L •� f"I,"ti�. �;=+f4 � "• Y COMPARISON OF AREAS PROJECT: St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church Newport Beach, CA DATE: February 5, 1982 Site Area includes residential lots & alley) 4.7 acres approx. 204,732 S.F. Site Coverao Exist ing chuerch buildings 33,398 S.F. Less area of buildings to be demolished ( 11 ,090 ) New construction 25,910 Total 48,218 S.F. Increase = 44.37% Building coverage represents only 23.56% of land. Building Area (all floors) .Existing 44,238 S.F. Less demolished areas ( 16,920 ) New construction 73,693 Total 101 ,011 S.F. Increase = 128.3% The total building area increase of 128 percent results in a 44.37 percent increase in land coverage. This is accomplished by underground and multiple floors. Sanctuary Area (including balcony) Existing 7,334 S.F. New 18,780 S.F. MESt. Andrew's Presbyterian Church E1100 600 ST.ANDREWS ROAD•NEWPORT BEACH,CALIFORNIA 92663(714) 631-2880 TO City of Newport Beach DATE ____ -January- Attn: Fred Talarico Environmental Coordinator SUBJECT Enclosed please find our check in the amount of $8965.00 for the billing to Carl Irvin, Irwin and Associates for initial study/traf fic study at the above address. Peggy Caudell, Bus. Adm.---- F.-MOO Boll.,Tunas 1 *= • I e CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH u s i PLANNING DEPARTMENT (714) 640-2197 December 4, 1981 Mr. Carl Irwin Irwin & Associates AIA 16400 Pacific Coast Highway - Suite 205 Huntington Beach , California 92649 Subject: Initial Study/Traffic Study St. Andrew ' s Church Project Dear Mr. Irwin: . Pursuant to our phone conversation of Friday, December 4, 1981 , enclosed please find a copy of the above subject proposal . In order to accomplish the Traffic and Circu- lation studies anticipated , it will be necessary to have your authorization to proceed early in the week of December 7th . If you desire to pro- ceed , please remit the below indicated sum: Consultant Fees $8, 150 City Fees 815 $8 ,965 We look forward to working with you on this project. Very truly yours , PLANNING DEPARTMENT JAMES D . HEWIC E D Director by FRED TALARICO Environmental Coordinator FT/kk Enclosure City Hall • 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California 92663 -3884 Mailing Address - P:O.Box 1768 ❑ 500 newport center drive, suite 525 newport beach, california 92660 phone (714) 640.6363 ❑ 2927 newbury street, suite c berk Berkeley, california 94703 Lsa phone (415) 841.6840 LARRY SEEMAN ASSOCIATES, INC. December 4, 1981 ft � (� R�CEI'49 Z Mr. Fred Talarico Win& Environmental Coordinator �� 3 City of Newport Beach 13 3300 Newport Boulevard mrvov Post Office Box 1768 -enFOCR�L EACH p/ Newport Beach, CA 92660-3884 ti SUBJECT: INITIAL STUDY FOR THE ST. ANDREW'S =°—'- MASTER PLAN OF FACILITIES Dear Fred: LSA is pleased to submit this proposal to prepare an expanded Initial Study for the proposed St. Andrew's Master Plan of Facilities. The purpose of the Initial Study will be to identify any potential impacts of the project and recommend any measures necessary to mitigate the impacts. The intent will be to fully mitigate all potential impacts either with existing City policies or with project-specific mitigation measures. If this is possible, then the City can issue a conditional Negative Declaration for this project. LSA proposes the following scope of services: SCOPE OF SERVICES Project Description. LSA will prepare a full project description to include all proposed onsite improvements and project information. The description will also include a full discussion of the local and regional set- ting for the proposed project. This discussion will present necessary infor- mation on committed and planned projects in the vicinity. Major Issues. LSA will prepare an analysis of the major issues raised by this project. Land Use. The proposed land use will be compared to the provi- sions of t e ity' s General Plan and current City zoning. Emphasis will be placed on analyzing the compatibility of the church facilities with surround- ing land uses. 2 Lsa Views and Aesthetics. LSA will analyze the, project design with emphasis on views from the surrounding neighborhood. There will be a brief analysis regarding possible views of the church from other areas of the city. Specifically, this analysis will include a discussion of building height and setbacks. Circulation and Parking. Weston Pringle and Associates (WPA) will conduct the circulation and parking study. The traffic engineer will complete the analysis required by the City's Traffic Phasing Ordinance (TPO) . WPA will also measure existing parking demand and availability during December and January. These data will be used to estimate project-related demand for parking. The study will also include analysis of the site plan for both onsite and offsite impacts. WPA will conduct two Sunday traffic and parking counts and two weekday "peak-hour" counts. Construction Impacts. LSA will analyze the potential impacts of grading an construction activities. Noise and dust impacts will be specifi- cally addressed. Minor Issues. We assume that the following issues will be minor. We will a y—naI ze eacFi one and verify that no significant impacts would occur. Water quality Air quality Noise Public services and utilities Geology and soils (supporting information to be submitted by applicant) SCHEDULE LSA can complete the draft Initial Study in four weeks. Following City review, LSA will revise and complete the Initial Study within two weeks. STAFF William R. Foley, Principal-in-Charge of the Newport Beach office, will serve as principal for this project. Annette Sanchez will serve as project manager. PROJECT BUDGET LSA will complete the Initial Study as described in this proposal on a time-and-materials basis for a fee not to exceed $8,150 ($3,000 for Weston 3 L Pringle and Associates) . This includes four meetings with the project appli- cant ) 9 p J pp I cant and the City staff; attendance by the project manager at one Environment- al Affairs Committee meeting; attendance by the principal-in-charge, project manager, and traffic engineer at one Planning Commission and one City Council hearing; and printing of 35 copies of the Initial Study. This budget assumes no substantial changes in the site plan once work on the Initial Study has commenced. Any such changes may require a revised scope of services and budget. If you have any questions, or if you need further information, please call me. Sincerely, LARR/ I Y/JSEEMAN�ASSOCIATES, INC. William R. Foley, AICP Vice President WRF:jl '.cvpolt H ron: Cni .n Llcy. _ Cal ?or•k ^/or © _ ce Schuzrz Q High Uictrict Jnyce Scljucrz 1601 16th bt. 341,r' :quiet Cov= %cw;ort death, Ca _ 60 Corc^a UC2 Isar, --a 9262E Scrfarin-^, Fasonic grdn, Assoc-- Harald A- MU1VOMSY ® D. Erookr teal%. •r O FOOox 2026 1400 raven 71oGc 164:0 Park Now art Dr. Ne.tport Scach, Cs 52663 GewporL Deach, Ca M63 Naw^.:ort Beach, Ca 92663 Lloyoc• Lc_ 1h% ® L12I!En AeCay O 3tcnl=y G. Fumfo:a u/or i'Cx E. i%ilss 34 Vi-nna Co16lndcre RI:' 2212 Continental Ave. Nlowport E3ach, Ca 92560 i:euport Bach, Ce 92660 Coste i:csa, L'a 52627 Tho-as C. C3rkctt Eduin HJlea 3ru Lloyz's Cal Bank 1439 Santiago Dr. 1COi iaven. �lcce L/or Irene Jileon Iauport E33ch, Ca «5- Neup�rt 93ach, Ca 52663 5^c St. Andrews Rd. N_u ^rt -2sach, Ca 92663 l3 Condorinimi prejcet Den H. and'�oan Nlr!gshaul Llovde C--1 5cnk 937-22-001 thru 10 E15 Tustin Ave. F:,yor n 1'.. and -- .an Nawp^rt each, Ca 92662 C J a%aW ® O _ LLcyC a l '• Cal tank Lloyds Cal c no-. ';rthur achentin &Vor Thc'cdore_='ala e./or Jilliam J. Fucik 3.20 hcren St: 1D17 1501- 35 Clay St La Canada, Ca .1o11 Turti^., Ca 92530 Lsuport Beach, Ca, 92663 19 David 'Ic-il=vy George U. Schn.,idt 1405 Clay St. 1301 Clay St. ;!euport Bsach,Ca 92663 Newport Deach, Ca 92663 Terry D. Lorentzen Eve McGann Lloyds Cal Bank Tr 1521 Doris Lane 1502 Coral Place Donna Gallant ':euport Beach, Ca 92663 Newport Beach, CA 92663 424 St. Rndrews i'lzce .:euport Ceach, CZ R 2 S ® 70knl j. MOREy N. CIRtGt� C�v i _chael D. Steiner B9i.f.1 T;R , - 335 E, 17th St. 6Si J. St. ,pt. 14J4 Arldreweaded Costa (ieca, Co 92627 L. _ ::ngela C,. 9CC0' H`;:, rt gy5c,. " qgt R1614ARh MOORS Rranhoil Per�fi Barhey � ® f aiFa+e ^ 9z� PlvaEe jPot ^_Gcn, Ca >2-352 _. _ .. - -.. G.A . N_ 01 Ca• 92rc�v3 LaUC LLoyc_ Ca ��r.• © - n S. L'_n;__y 4 a.r YiTatC Road u�07 rant: F. harnc-l!=_ /7' j_r::[: ..cad^ f:,.•_sport '_+Each, Ca C2563 1019 Clay St. .. ':'�r?. ��oCh, V, �.'tFeJ Newport Beach, CO 93= C ul: rod f Thonpron © 0ohn U. Mauer � {._g _.d Cnc=_ c 424 f•_ratc Road 41S Pirate Road 4_; crc '. '::c•r Raa_ = ' _ . .� Newport Beach Ca �20� IIEupGrt 'each, Ca �LAO.) ,J�uport Scach, Ca 92653 P � r G. C_a Nary R. 'Jilkins � i? .. =y G f:ac0= JiT:ii :J• 1��,uY _ POBox 21 2 G Harbor 3ii Ore^d Ccn=_1 � i7 �nua•fl t Salboa island, Ce 92652 Newport Beach, Ca 92663 ;acj.ar: 9m.ach, Oa 2; c { is t ® Robert J. Craig ® Carl TrcyLno .�:_� U. �ssaY�Ir s 411 Snug Har^Or Raau 419 Snug fiarbcr Rsad 251E Sierra �isu _rah, Ca C2E63 Newport 0eachj Ca 92E65 f: rt Beach, Cr atrick 'J". Canavan �:��i l.'Le?'1 _•j.L'Ty^ean ® Arthur C. Johnson � P- - 4" Snuy .arbor Road Fill Clay St. 3�i E. 15th -- ,.ru-artBeach, Ca Neupart Beach, Ca 92553, ._. rt _ r F.£fiaVa i Ra.:crt r. L''rlce 3a? Jr. 701-15th St. 519 Signal RoaC Newport Beach, Ca S2553 ;iaL a7t CG'aCt , C_ . _V: _ ® David U. uogorty � PBL 7 B. Hill J? QD J1: S;cral' Road 511 Si-nal Road 703 1;;th St. a e2E53 :e.• ort 3-ech, Ca i2c 5 Newport ':cash, Ca 929-63 �'1=1i CSC ti. iJ2lnar ® Gacroe F.�Delkers Nancy {"• van :"a.-! 7anr °15 ct. �E^ss .iaad 6'09 St. Janes Road E00 1Sth St 4 �3 CBZC{l, Ca ie[E�` NewportsNewportaach, Ca •92553 f a:.;.gr Eacah,