HomeMy WebLinkAboutX2020-1524 - Alternative Material & MethodsPr, ` CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Rr6�'
41 t COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT 6 P �U/V,
iO�yer. tS[( BUILDING DIVISION<OpM�
c�.ty", `rfCry 100 Civic Center Drive I P.O. Box 1768 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915
grlroRH,' www.newportbeachca.gov 1(949) 644-3200 ,1
mow..
CASE NO.:
2
❑ REQUEST FOR MODIFICATION TO PROVISIONS
OF TITLE 9 (FIRE CODE) OR TITLE 15 (BUILDING CODE)
OF THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee $27B)
REQUEST FOR ALTERNATE MATERIAL
OR METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee
❑ REQUEST FOR EXEMPTION FROM DISABLED
ACCESS DUE TO PHYSICAL OR LEGAL
CONSTRAINT (Fee $1,535)
(Ratification by the Board of Appeals will be required.)
For above requests, complete Sections 1, 2 8 3
below by printing in ink or typing.
JOB ADDRESS:
FOR STAFF USE ONLY Oi'lll BEAC"A
Check# //� P-Lo� - #of
upancy Classification
of Building;S ,F/ # of
sctStatusI�[Ai f'6 -AA
struction Type `✓ R
erified by
o. of Items
1
ae due'
DISTRIBUTION:
❑ Owner
XPlan Check C t 1u 0
❑ Petitioner
Lj Inspector
❑ Fire
❑ Other
SITE ADDRESS: 1419 Dolphin Terrace Petitioner Roy Reed (Engineer)
Owner George Heuser (Petitioner to be architect or engineer)
Address 1419 Dolphin Terrace Address 7727 Caminito Lifana
Newport Beach, CA Zip 92625 San Diego, CA zip 92129
Daytime Phone ( ) Daytime Phone (760 ) 586-8121
L REQUEST: Submit plans if necessary to illustrate regI. Additional sheets or data may be attached.
Corrosion protection of steel soldier piles in direct contact being achieved by use of carboline epoxy coating.
_LbUSTIFICATION/FINDINGS OF EQUIVALENCY: I
d6C.ODE SECTIONS:
See attached oroduct spec sheet. A small portion of soldier beam web/flange 1K 13 D� �7. /ad�P 20••h•� 1
Petitioner's
Position Principle Engineer
Signature CA Professional Lie. # C80503
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
DEPARTMENT ACTION: In accordance with: ❑ CBC 104.11/CFC 104.9
(Alternate materials & methods)
❑ Concurrence from Fire Code Official is required. ❑ Approved ❑ Disapproved
By:
❑ Request (DOES) (DOES NOT) lessen any fire protection requirements.
❑ Request (DOES) (DOES NOT) lessen the structural integrity
Data 6/5/2020
❑ CBC 104.10/CFC 104.8
(CBC Modification)
❑ Written Comments Attached
The Request Is -�R Granted ❑ Denied (See reverse for u
❑ Granted (Ratification required) appeal information) IIII
Conditions of Approval:
Position CHIEF BUILDING OF'riq&
APPEAL OF DIVISION ACTION TO THE BUILDING BOARD OF APPEALS (See Reverse)
(Signature, statement of owner or applicant, statement of reasons for appeal and filing fees are required.)
CASHIER RECEIPT NUMBER:6, L7 _ - Farmstmodif 11/02/2016
Generic Type Cycloaliphatic Amine Epoxy
General
Description Highly chemical resistant epoxy mastic coating
require multiple coats for hiding. Note: The low
with exceptionally versatile uses in all industrial
Steel
markets. Self -priming and suitable for application
yellow or discolor more than normal in a short period
over most existing coatings, and tightly adherent
of time.
to rust. Serves as stand-alone system for a variety
Gloss
of chemical environments and is also designed for
Galvanized Steel
various immersion conditions.
4.0 - 6.0 mils (102 - 152 microns) per coat
Features • Excellent chemical resistance
No effect on plane,
• Surface tolerant characteristics
6.0-8.0 mils (150-200 microns) over light rust and for uniform gloss over
• Conventional and low-temperature versions
Concrete or CMU
• Self -priming and primer/finish capabilities
Excessive film thickness over Inorganic zincs may increase damage
• Very good abrasion resistance
during shipping or erection.
• VOC compliant to current AIM regulations
By Volume 75%+/- 2%
• Suitable for use in USDA inspected facilities
1203 ft' at 1.0 mils (29.5 m2/1 at 25 microns)
Color
Refer to Carboline Color Guide. Certain colors may
Results
require multiple coats for hiding. Note: The low
Blasted Steel 2 cts. 890
temperature formulation will cause most colors to
yellow or discolor more than normal in a short period
rust in scribe. 1/16"
of time.
Finish
Gloss
Primer
Self -priming.
Dry Film
4.0 - 6.0 mils (102 - 152 microns) per coat
Thickness
No effect on plane,
6.0-8.0 mils (150-200 microns) over light rust and for uniform gloss over
no rust in scribe
inorganic zincs. Don't exceed 10 mils (250 microns) in a single mat.
Excessive film thickness over Inorganic zincs may increase damage
during shipping or erection.
Solids Content
By Volume 75%+/- 2%
Theoretical
1203 ft' at 1.0 mils (29.5 m2/1 at 25 microns)
Coverage Rate
301 ft' at 4.0 mils (7.4 m2/1 at 100 microns)
1000 cycles, CS17
200 ft2 at 6.0 mils (4.9 m2/1 at 150 microns)
Allow for loss in mixing and application.
VOC Values)
Thinner 2 13oz/gal=2.30 lbs/gal (276g/1)
No blistering, rusting
Thinner 2 7oz/gal=2.08lbs/gal (250g/1)
Epoxy Pr. 1 ct. 890
Thinner 33 16oz/gal=2.43lbs/gal (291 g/1)
Thinner 33 7oz/gal=2.081bs/gal (250g/1)
after 2800 hours
As Supplied 1.81lbs/gal (217 g/I)
Blasted Steel 1 ct. 890
'Use Thinner #76 up to 8 oz/gal for 890 and 16 oz/gal for 89D LT where
Scrub Resistance
non-photochemically reactive solvents are required.
after 10,000 cycles w/
These are nominal values and may vary with color.
Dry Temp.
Continuous: 300 of (149 DC)
Resistance
Non -Continuous: 350 of (177 DC)
5A
Discoloration and loss of gloss occurs above 200 F (93 C) but does not
Blasted Steel 2 CIS 890
affect performance.
Under Insulation
Continuous: 300 of (149 oC)
Resistance
ASTM E84 Flame
2 Ct 890
Discoloration and lass of gloss occurs above 200 F (93 C) but does not
and Smoke
affect performance.
Limitations
Do not apply over latex coatings. For immersion
projects use only factory made material in special
colors. Consult Technical Service for specifics.
Topcoats
Carboguard° 890
Surfaces must be clean and dry. Remove all dirt, dust,
oil and all other contaminant.
Immersion: SSPC-SP10
Non -Immersion: SSPC-SP6
1.5-3.0 mils (38-75 microns) SSPC-SP2 or SP3 are
suitable cleaning methods for mild environments.
Prime with specific Carboline primers as
recommended by your Carboline Sales
Representative. Refer to the specific primer's Product
Data Sheet for requirements.
Concrete must be cured 28 days at 75OF (240C) and
50% relative humidity or equivalent. Prepare surfaces
in accordance with ASTM D4258 Surface Cleaning of
Concrete and ASTM D4259 Abrading Concrete. Voids
in concrete may require surfacing. Mortar joints should
be cured a min of 15 days.
Drywall & Plaster Joint compound and plaster should be fully cured prior
to coating application.
Previously Painted Lightly sand or abrade to roughen surface and degloss
Surfaces the surface. Existing paint must attain a minimum
3A rating in accordance with ASTM D3359 "X -Cut"
adhesion test.
Test Method
System
Results
ASTM B 117 Salt Fog
Blasted Steel 2 cts. 890
No effect on plane,
rust in scribe. 1/16"
undercutting at scribe
after 2000 hours
ASTM B117 Salt Fog
Blasted Steel 1
No effect on plane,
ct. IOZ 1 ct 890
no rust in scribe
and no undercutting
after 4000 hours
ASTM D 4060 Abrasion
Blasted Steel 1 ct
85 mg. loss atter
Epoxy Pr. 1 ct 890
1000 cycles, CS17
wheel 1000 gm. load
ASTM D1735 Water Fog
Blasted Steel 1 ct.
No blistering, rusting
Epoxy Pr. 1 ct. 890
or delamination
after 2800 hours
ASTM D2486
Blasted Steel 1 ct. 890
93% gloss retained
Scrub Resistance
after 10,000 cycles w/
liquid scrub medium
ASTM D3359 Adhesion
Blasted Steel 1 ct 890
5A
ASTM D3363
Blasted Steel 2 CIS 890
Greater than 8H
Pencil Hardness
ASTM E84 Flame
2 Ct 890
5 Flame 5
and Smoke
Smoke Class A
Test reports and additional data available upon written request.
Mixing Power mix separately, then combine and power mix.
DO NOT MIX PARTIAL KITS.
June 2016 0986
To the best of our knowledge the technical data contained herein is true and accurate on the date of publication and is subject to change without prior notice. User must contact Carboline Company
to verify correctness before specifying or ordering. No guarantee of accuracy is given or Implied. We guarantee our products to conform to Carboline quality control. We assume no responsibility for
coverage, performance or injuries resulting from use. Liability, if any, is limited to replacement of products. NO OTHER WARRANTY OR GUARANTEE OF ANY KIND IS MADE BY CARBOLINE,
EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, STATUTORY, BY OPERATION OF LAW, OR OTHERWISE, INCLUDING MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Carboline®and CarboguardCN
are registered trademarks of Carboline Company,
Page 1 of 2
Carboguard° 890
Thinning Spray: Up to 13 oz/gal (10%) w/ #2
Brush: Up to 16 oz/gal (12%) w/ #33
Roller: Up to 16 oz/gal (12%) w/ #33
Thinner #33 can be used for spray in hot/windy
conditions. Use of thinners other than those supplied
or recommended by Carboline may adversely affect
product performance and void product warranty,
whether expressed or implied.
'See VOC values for thinning limits.
Ratio 1:1 Ratio (A to B)
Pot Life 3 Hours at 75°F (24°C)
Pat life ends when coating loses body and begins to sag. Pot life times
Will be less at higher temperatures.
Higher film thickness, insufficient ventilation or cooler temperatures will require longer cure times and
could result in solvent entrapment and premature failure. Excessive humidity or condensation on the
surface during curing can interfere with the cure, can cause discoloration and may result in a surface
haze. Any haze or blush must be removed by water washing before roweling. During high humidity
conditions, It Is recommended that the application be done while temperatures are increasing.
Maximum recoat/topcoat times are N days for epoxies and 90 days for polyurethanes 975°F
(24°C). If the maximum recast times have been exceeded, the surface must be abraded by sweep
blasting or sanding prior to the application of additional coats.
Listed below are general equipment guidelines for the application of this product. Jab site conditions Cleanup
may require modifications
to these guidelines to achieve the desired results.
Spray Application
This is a high solids coating and may require
Surface
Tempa
Dry to Recoat Dry to Recoat
& Topcoat w/
other finishe
Final Cure
General
Final Cure
Immersion
50 °F (10 °C)
12 Hours
24 Hours
3 Days
NR
60 °F If °C)
8 Hours
16 Hours
2 Days
10 Days
75 °F (24 °C)
4 Hours
8 Hours
1 Days
5 Days
90 °F (32 °C)
2 Hours
4 Hours
16 Hours
3 Days
Higher film thickness, insufficient ventilation or cooler temperatures will require longer cure times and
could result in solvent entrapment and premature failure. Excessive humidity or condensation on the
surface during curing can interfere with the cure, can cause discoloration and may result in a surface
haze. Any haze or blush must be removed by water washing before roweling. During high humidity
conditions, It Is recommended that the application be done while temperatures are increasing.
Maximum recoat/topcoat times are N days for epoxies and 90 days for polyurethanes 975°F
(24°C). If the maximum recast times have been exceeded, the surface must be abraded by sweep
blasting or sanding prior to the application of additional coats.
Listed below are general equipment guidelines for the application of this product. Jab site conditions Cleanup
may require modifications
to these guidelines to achieve the desired results.
Spray Application
This is a high solids coating and may require
(General)
adjustments in spray techniques. Wet film thickness Safety
Output PSI: 2100-2300 Filter Size: 60 mesh
is easily and quickly achieved. The following spray
"Teflon packings are recommended and available from
equipment has been found suitable and is available
the pump manufacturer.
from manufacturers such as Binks, DeVilbiss and
Multiple coats may be required to obtain desired
Graco.
Conventional
Pressure pot equipped with dual regulators, 3/8" Ventilation
Spray
I.D. minimum material hose, .070" I.D. fluid tip and
rerolling. For best results, tie-in within 10 minutes at
appropriate air cap.
Airless Spray Pump Ratio: 30:1 (min.)'
Condition I Material I Surface 1 Ambient m Humidity
Minimum50 °F (10 °C) 50 °F (10 °C) 50 °F (10 °(;) 0%
Maximum 90 °F (32 °C) 125 -F (52 °C) 110 -F (43 °C) 90 %
This product simply requires the substrate temperature to be above the dew point. Condensation
due to substrate temperatures below the dew point can cause flesh mating on prepared steel and
Interfere with proper adhesion to the substrate. Special application techniques may be required
above or below normal application condigans.
Shelf Life
Use Thinner #2 or Acetone. In case of spillage, absorb
and dispose of in accordance with local applicable
regulations.
Read and follow all caution statements on this product
data sheet and on the MSDS for this product. Wear
protective clothing, gloves and use protective cream
on face, hands and all exposed areas.
When used as a tank lining or in enclosed areas,
thorough air circulation must be used during and after
application until the coating is cured. User should test
and monitor exposure levels to insure all personnel
are below guidelines.
Part A: 36 months at 75°F (24°C)
Part B: 15 months at 75oF (24°C)
'When kept at recommended storage conditions and in original
unopened containers.
Shipping Weight 2 Gallon Kit - 29 Ibs (13 kg)
(Approximate) 10 Gallon Kit - 145 lbs (66 kg)
Storage
GPM Output: 3.0 (min.)
Temperature &
Material Hose: 3/8" I.D. (min.)
Humidity
Tip Size: .017-.021"
Flash Point
Output PSI: 2100-2300 Filter Size: 60 mesh
(Setaflash)
"Teflon packings are recommended and available from
the pump manufacturer.
Brush & Roller
Multiple coats may be required to obtain desired
(General)
appearance, recommended dry film thickness and
adequate hiding. Avoid excessive re -brushing or
rerolling. For best results, tie-in within 10 minutes at
75°F (24°C).
Brush
Use a medium bristle brush.
Roller
Use a short -nap synthetic roller cover with phenolic
core.
Condition I Material I Surface 1 Ambient m Humidity
Minimum50 °F (10 °C) 50 °F (10 °C) 50 °F (10 °(;) 0%
Maximum 90 °F (32 °C) 125 -F (52 °C) 110 -F (43 °C) 90 %
This product simply requires the substrate temperature to be above the dew point. Condensation
due to substrate temperatures below the dew point can cause flesh mating on prepared steel and
Interfere with proper adhesion to the substrate. Special application techniques may be required
above or below normal application condigans.
Shelf Life
Use Thinner #2 or Acetone. In case of spillage, absorb
and dispose of in accordance with local applicable
regulations.
Read and follow all caution statements on this product
data sheet and on the MSDS for this product. Wear
protective clothing, gloves and use protective cream
on face, hands and all exposed areas.
When used as a tank lining or in enclosed areas,
thorough air circulation must be used during and after
application until the coating is cured. User should test
and monitor exposure levels to insure all personnel
are below guidelines.
Part A: 36 months at 75°F (24°C)
Part B: 15 months at 75oF (24°C)
'When kept at recommended storage conditions and in original
unopened containers.
Shipping Weight 2 Gallon Kit - 29 Ibs (13 kg)
(Approximate) 10 Gallon Kit - 145 lbs (66 kg)
Storage
40°-110°F (4°43°C)
Temperature &
0-100% Relative Humidity
Humidity
Flash Point
89°F (32°C) for Part A
(Setaflash)
73oF (23°C) for Part B
Storage Store Indoors
This product is solvent based and not affected by excursions below
these published storage temperatures, down to 10°F, for a duration of no
mare than 14 days. Always inspect the product prior to use to make sure
It Is smooth and homogeneous when properly mixed.
June 2016 09136
To the best of our knowledge the technical data contained herein is true and accurate on the date of publication and is subject to change without prior notice. User must contact Carboline Company
to verity correctness before specifying or ordering. No guarantee of accuracy is given or implied. We guarantee our products to conform to Carboline quality control. We assume no responsibility for
coverage, performance or Injuries resulting from use. Liability, if any, is limited to replacement of products. NO OTHER WARRANTY OR GUARANTEE OF ANY KIND IS MADE BY CARBOLINE,
EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, STATUTORY, BY OPERATION OF LAW, OR OTHERWISE, INCLUDING MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Carboline®and Carboguard@
are registered trademarks of Carbaline Company.
Page 2 of 2
O
iI �$
0 q IXISTING 1 -STORY RESIDENCE
1 I GPONYCOATEDSOLDIERINAN EIlI ea C
PROPERTY UNE 1 'r - I I 6EE DEFAIL3/SH6 FO0. E%IEHISI PSE
SEE ELEVATION FOR SPACING
Po rx
9F WIDE, MIRADPAIN RED B AIN AGE /-SECTIONS MRSMERRLL
1 5 10 BOARDSTRIPS, CENTERED BEIVIEEN DR V
1El SOLIDER OEWSVfRTICALLY WRH90' FlLL VOIDS BEHIND LAGGING MATTUAL ELA C
i' \ I WIOECONTINOU5 HORIZONTAL STRIPS WOX IFdN CONCRETE
m TINeER Id6GI15(SEE EIEVATIONSI WITH 3 hE
CENTERED ABO WEEP NOLfs. $
is (MIN.) NAILS FOR IdGGING IN
ST"TON ITYP.I
1 I I PROPOSNTEVP RY WATER PRCOFNG BEARING.. 3'C. y��
PROPOSED PERMANENT SHORING l� r C
I ROH 4, SEE SNEE ENTSH2L ). SNOROIGIS¢5HEETSH2) �J I _ DURACIAY OR EQ.) ¢P
L 1 1 SEAL11
V EEE
^ /r ) } I_. I (PARA °5 G
r � (7 r ..f U as
GRADE 60 iflAxsvEUA 'esu
1 7l' �- ��7 �,y 1. Q
3. CM
oaWxcwIATEacHOLD
OLDWIa I3-TNICR snO I__ Baas Arlr D.C. IAAcx FAcf TYP.)
I L J FMES,WBP51 (FINISH
1
XS GRA OE. REACHWIG. BARSPIPE PER ARCHITECT)
l2'O.G REACH FACETYP.) SOLDIER
BONNA BET WEEN 1'Dx1P GALVANIZED
(SEEETBFAMSTO SDBDMIN NELSON SNOSB I3'O.C.
II / 'W` (SEE DETAIL 3/SH6).
h { PROPMEOIFMPOMRY NOTES: 1. IN LIEU OF SHOTCPETE, CONTRACTOR MY USE CAST IN PLACE CONCRETE
1 COSTING BWFF 7J L J P SHORING (SEE SHEEfSM) I AS REINFORCED&SPECIFIED PER THE APPROVED STRUCTURAL PLAN.
2. SEE SOWER BEAN SCHEDULE ON SHEET SHY FOR BGAI SIZE.
7 �" \ TOUCH UP EPOW PAINT AS MAY BE REQUIRED.
LO
ROPERrruNE� ( ) � 17 J� /�� IX"REPROI
3. TA
e slDEwux OL 2 SOLDIER BEAM PIAN DETAIL (SBk 1-4, 29-32)
PROPOSED POOL f C I UA m� / / I J HES H.T.S.
r O -
" a � � PRoaoscO .a
LowAR Lert� r r r � �RICMF.wav W
PEROFNEM GUARDRAIL r O
(BYOTNERS,
OU131DE
SCOPE OF WOR H, SEE 4
DETpIL4/SH61
I^ SH6 F
/ 1 -T T.O.W. ELEVATIONEPROFILE 1 6': f1YP.1 zr
7 ��.— N VARIES, SEE PROFIT£ FI W
OCE CML DWG) ry
7 TEMPORARY I I SLOPE� PRESSURE TREATED TIMBER
1
7 I IBY OTHERS, TYPICAL) LAGGING (SEE ELEVATION) _y 1 `9
•X•
1.SSACflSIURRY
SXAFi e¢MUxFlu LQaKj
PROPOSED BEPNdNEMSXI
GRIND / Jr PROPOSED TEMPORARY I F* O
I IS&'Y1933, SEE SHEET SIR, SHORING (SEE SHEET SHID PROPOSED NAT SLAB 3
i� (SEE STRUCTURAL DwcI SHfi
EPDXY COATED SOLDIER BEAM
(SEE DETAIL 3/SX6 FOR EBTENR)
4,WO PSI TPE II/V CONC0.ElE W
W/C4.45• SHUT OCCMFlLL VJ
PROPERTY t1NE� �• a
_ LVSHOTE ETE COLOR h FINISH y
SGLF: IOl II IXISi1NG1 STORYRESIDENCE t TO RCHITEITTEI1k APPaOVfD W
0 9 ! BY BE SUOUTT p'1
I
REQUEST FOR ALTERNATE MATERIAL„ _
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
•
f
O
Carboguard 890
Carboguard 890
carbolmem
nitir7
',Lun
tJ...,.
—wxw
..,.., m.�...,m...
..,m.,.
.. ..,_
..
L
.we,a
ewxgpwn pym '�a
IT
..�"'
ms.vwme�wvme
uv
,umaomanoue
pmq
yr,,,
77777
IT
�.
.m..u..I.
.....
..: -., .,...
1
mrom.a..
..m.a
..
...r..o
,, �.,.,..
..... ...
... „...... _....
III IIITI
.. 1 T ......11 0II w ...._I.I
,. x
�,a.R
..w.v, nx.IT.
,..�,.....>n....�....,.,........
.,...r• L.,u,..,,m
IT I
A1.
carbo e
-
NOTES: 1. FIELD VERIFY ALL EUS TING k PROPOS PO STRUCTURES PRIOR TO SHORING INSTALLATION.
2. SEE SOLDIER BEIM SCHEDULE ON SHT FOR VARIABLE$ "M k
PERMANENT CANTILEVERED SOLDIER BEAM (SM1-4, 29-32)
SH6 N.T.S.
A SWLL PORTION OF SOLDIER BEAMS X14 B 3932 BEAM/FWNGE SECTION W6 NOT HAVE
CONCRETE COVER BECAUSE OF THE NEED TO INSTALL LAGGING. CORROSION PROTECTION IS
PROVIDED THROUGH THE USE OF CARBOLINE EPORY PALM, AS SXOMN IN DETAILS 1 R 2/SH6.
SHORING DESIGN GROUP
qlas
7155 VIA FRANCESCO RI
SAN DIEGO, CA 92129, (760 8121
m �S0
w n p -A
oof
oaQ
c
6-5-2020
* II SHEET
��' SH -1
6I5/30U i �' l/ll/i
Ow
ROY P. REED R.C.E. 80503 fP. 3ILl@f DALE