Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutADDITIONAL HANDOUT - NB Sculpture - Phase VIII - Arts Commission Review Meeting - Public Poll ResultsNEWPORT BEACH CIVIC CENTER SCULPTURE EXHIBITION PHASE VIII PUBLIC POLL RESULTS REVIEW INTRODUCTIONS PUBLIC POLL SUMMARY: •Poll was posted on Arts Orange County’s website SparkOC.com •33 works qualified by the Arts Commission were included for consideration •Participants were allowed to vote for up to three favorite works •Poll was open on SparkOC.com from Dec. 10, 2022 through Jan. 10, 2023, and promoted by both the City of Newport Beach and Arts Orange County •Order of depicted works was automatically shuffled for every voter so that no work would enjoy any positioning advantage •Finalists as chosen by the public poll must still pass a thorough review by our installation service, confirmation of availability in the condition submitted, and a successful execution of a contract with the artist. Alternates may take the place of finalists in any event of a Finalist failing to pass these steps. •Final vote on whether to approve the presented finalists to be installed rests with the Newport Beach City Council. VOTE AUDIT SUMMARY: •Voters were required to provide a valid email address, report the ZIP code of their residence, and complete a reCAPTCHA security step to affirm that they weren't a bot. •There were 264 successfully-logged entries, registering a total of 726 votes. For comparison, 1,084 votes were received for Phase VII and 1,091 for Phase VI. •After downloading the raw logs of all votes, ArtsOC Staff deleted any entries which did not provide a Newport Beach ZIP code. •The poll also captured the IP address, time of voting, and type of device used to vote with. ArtsOC Staff used these tools to identify potential cases of double-votes -for example, if two votes from the same IP address happened within minutes, voted for the same works, and had similar enough email addresses such as NAME@gmail.com and SAMENAME@yahoo.com, one of those votes would be deleted. If the email addresses were different enough, staff deferred on the side of permitting them, since it could have been the product of multiple people voting on the same computer from the same household. •After these steps were completed, ArtsOC had a validated total of 253 Newport Beach residents casting 702 votes. SUMMARY OF PUBIC POLL VOTES (1/2): Artist Work Votes Hazel, Peter Tulip the Rockfish 63 Yordanov, Plamen Pearl Infinity 63 Burnes, James Efram 54 Hoffman, Matthew Be Kind 46 Knecht, Zan Memory of Sailing, The 31 Cartwright, Matt Kissing Bench 29 Braitman, Jackie The Goddess Sol 28 Idelchick, Ilya Newport Glider 27 Daley, Catherine Confluence #102 26 Achterberg, Luke Inchoate 24 Carraher, Maxwell One Another 24 Landis, Stephen Got Juice 23 Holz, David Seagull Has Landed, The 22 Willfors, Pontus Metal Tree 22 Tall, Cheryl White Queen, The 19 Streeter, Lynne One World 19 Whitacre, Ron Why 18 SUMMARY OF PUBIC POLL VOTES (2/2): Artist Work Votes Walker, Bilhenry Miseria Justorum 16 Slick, Rachel Compass Turtle; The Five Directions.16 Ward, Jeni Umbel Series: A Feast of Flowers 15 Vader, Patricia Balthazar the Bulldog 14 Gornushkin, Sergey Cosmic Tan 14 Tanych, David Lockdown 14 Seese, Kirk Magnify 13 Fischer, Carrie Invertadude 11 Jordan, Robert Namaste 11 Langle, Heather PALMZILLA 8 Piech, Melanie Date Dial 8 Light, Andrew Divergent (with I)6 Litman, Adrian Susnea Fish in the Sky 5 Marquez, Andy Alexander The Great 5 Moore, Norman Seasons 4 Criswell, Billy ROGUE 4 Walker, Bilhenry Miseria Justorum 16 POLL-QUALIFIED WORKS RANKED BY PUBLIC VOTE Hazel, Peter (Reno, NV) Tulip the Rockfish Size: 5 ft high, 10 ft long, 3ft wide Weight: 500’ Medium: Handmade Mosaic tile and Concrete Public Ranking: 1t (63 votes) Jury Ranking: 2t (6.25/7) Hazel, Peter. Tulip the Rockfish. Slide 1 of 2. Hazel, Peter. Tulip the Rockfish. Slide 2 of 2. Yordanov, Plamen (Chicago, IL) Pearl Infinity Size: 7 x 4 x 2 ft. Weight: 160’ Medium: Mirror-polished Stainless Steel Public Ranking: 1t (63 votes) Jury Ranking: 5t (5.88/7) Yordanov, Plamen. Pearl Infinity. Slide 1 of 2. Yordanov, Plamen. Pearl Infinity. Slide 2 of 2. Burnes, James (Santa Fe, NM) Efram Size: 85" x 96" x 36“ Weight: n/a Medium: Corten Steel, Locust Logs with a Stainless steel Armature Public Ranking: 3 (54 votes) Jury Ranking: 10t (5.38/7) Burnes, James. Efram. Slide 1 of 2. Burnes, James. Efram. Slide 2 of 2. Hoffman, Matthew (Chicago, IL) Be Kind Size: 6' Tall, 8' Wide, 3' Deep Weight: 1,000’ Medium: Recycled HDPE, HDPE, Marine Grade Plywood Public Ranking: 4 (46 votes) Jury Ranking: 24t (4.75/7) Hoffman, Matthew. Be Kind. Slide 1 of 2. Hoffman, Matthew. Be Kind. Slide 2 of 2. Knecht, Zan (Grand Rapids, MI) Memory of Sailing, The Size: 10 ft x 4 ft x 3 ft Weight: n/a Medium: Corten Steel Public Ranking: 5 (31 votes) Jury Ranking: 15t (5.25/7) Knecht, Zan. Memory of Sailing, The. Slide 1 of 2. Knecht, Zan. Memory of Sailing, The. Slide 2 of 2. Cartwright, Matt (Portland, OR) Kissing Bench Size: 60" wide x 18" deep x 36" tall Weight: 130’ Medium: Formed and polished stainless steel (304 alloy,) 2"x 1/8" flat bar strips, stainless(304) 1/2" sch40 pipe, UV resistant clear red gloss Public Ranking: 6 (29 votes) Jury Ranking: 17t (5.0/7) Cartwright, Matt. Kissing Bench. Slide 1 of 2. Cartwright, Matt. Kissing Bench. Slide 2 of 2. Braitman, Jackie (Takoma Park, MD) The Goddess Sol Size: 96 in tall x 35 in x 33 in Weight: 200’ Medium: Cut and welded corten steel Public Ranking: 7 (28 votes) Jury Ranking: 7 (5.75/7) Braitman, Jackie. The Goddess Sol. Slide 1 of 2. Braitman, Jackie. The Goddess Sol. Slide 2 of 2. Idelchick, Ilya (Solana Beach, CA) Newport Glider Size: Metal Pole 10’h Metal base 24" x 24" Monkey & Kite 6’w x 3’d x 5’h Weight: 120’ Medium: Metal, Aluminum, Metal mesh, Fiber Glass Resin, Marine Paint Public Ranking: 8 (27 votes) Jury Ranking: 10t (5.38/7) Idelchick, Ilya. Newport Glider. Slide 1 of 2. Idelchick, Ilya. Newport Glider. Slide 2 of 2. Daley, Catherine (Windsor, CA) Confluence #102 Size: 10'H x 23.5"W x 7'D Weight: 450’ Medium: Aluminum, stainless all thread, stainless washers, stainless concrete screws Public Ranking: 9 (26 votes) Jury Ranking: 4 (6.0/7) Daley, Catherine. Confluence #102. Slide 1 of 2. Daley, Catherine. Confluence #102. Slide 2 of 2. Achterberg, Luke (Onalaska, WI) Inchoate Size: 11' tall, 3' wide, 2' deep Weight: Approximately 350 pounds Medium: Automotive Acrylic Paint on Steel Public Ranking: 10t (24 votes) Jury Ranking: 8 (5.63/7) Achterberg, Luke. Inchoate. Slide 1 of 2. Achterberg, Luke. Inchoate. Slide 2 of 2. Carraher, Maxwell (Sunland, CA) One Another Size: 8' tall x 4' wide x 2 ' deep Weight: 300’ Medium: Cast bronze Public Ranking: 10t (24 votes) Jury Ranking: 15t (5.25/7) Carraher, Maxwell. One Another. Slide 1 of 2. Carraher, Maxwell. One Another. Slide 2 of 2. Landis, Stephen (Loveland, CO) Got Juice Size: 10’ tall, 5' wide, 4' deep Weight: 2,000’ Medium: Concrete, fiberglass and steel Public Ranking: 12 (23 votes) Jury Ranking: 1 (6.75/7) Landis, Stephen. Got Juice. Slide 1 of 2. Landis, Stephen. Got Juice. Slide 2 of 2. Holz, David (Salt Lake City, UT) Seagull Has Landed, The Size: 7' tall and 7' x 7' wide Weight: Under 200’ Medium: Welded 6061 Aluminum plate, painted in a white finish Public Ranking: 13t (22 votes) Jury Ranking: 2t (6.25/7) Holz, David. Seagull Has Landed, The. Slide 1 of 2. Holz, David. Seagull Has Landed, The. Slide 2 of 2. Willfors, Pontus (Inglewood, CA) Metal Tree Size: 195"L, 216"H, 190"W Weight: 500’ Medium: Aluminum Public Ranking: 13t (22 votes) Jury Ranking: 17t (5.0/7) Willfors, Pontus. Metal Tree. Slide 1 of 2. Willfors, Pontus. Metal Tree. Slide 2 of 2. Tall, Cheryl (Santa Rosa, CA) White Queen, The Size: 10' high by 8'wide and 8'deep Weight: 250’ Medium: 304 industrial grade Stainless Steel Public Ranking: 15t (19 votes) Jury Ranking: 17t (5.0/7) Tall, Cheryl. White Queen, The. Slide 1 of 2. Tall, Cheryl. White Queen, The. Slide 2 of 2. Streeter, Lynne (Oakland, CA) One World Size: 34”H x 53”W x 60”D Weight: 2,100’ Medium: Patinated bronze on a hollowed-out Verde Issorie base Public Ranking: 15t (19 votes) Jury Ranking: 60t (3.50/7) Streeter, Lynne. One World. Slide 1 of 2. Streeter, Lynne. One World. Slide 2 of 2. Whitacre, Ron (Laguna Beach, CA) Why Size: 3ft.10 in. high X 4 ft. 2 in. wide X 2 ft. 1in. deep Weight: 25 lbs. Medium: Welded Steel Public Ranking: 17 (18 votes) Jury Ranking: 27t (4.63/7) Whitacre, Ron. Why. Slide 1 of 2. Whitacre, Ron. Why. Slide 2 of 2. Walker, Bilhenry (Eau Claire, WI) Miseria Justorum Size: 15.5 feet tall x 11' wide and 10’ deep Weight: 450’ Medium: 6061-T6 aluminum plate and uses Stainless Steel bolts and acorn nuts to secure the struts together. It has been recently coated with a two-part Imron paint system to ensure long-life in the worst of environments. Public Ranking: 18t (16 votes) Jury Ranking: 9 (5.5/7) Walker, Bilhenry. Miseria Justorum. Slide 1 of 2. Walker, Bilhenry. Miseria Justorum. Slide 2 of 2. Slick, Rachel (Tucson, AZ) Compass Turtle; The Five Directions Size: 9' tall by 4' wide by 2' deep Weight: 200’ Medium: Layered corten steel, supported by a large corten steel post with a welded plate Public Ranking: 18t (16 votes) Jury Ranking: 41t (4.13/7) Slick, Rachel. Compass Turtle; The Five Directions. Slide 1 of 2. Slick, Rachel. Compass Turtle; The Five Directions. Slide 2 of 2. Ward, Jeni (Santa Cruz, CA) Umbel Series: A Feast of Flowers Size and Weight: Flower 1 (small), 2.5'w x 2.5'd x 8'h, approx 40lbs Flower 2 (small), 2.5'w x 2.5'd x 3.5'h, approx 40lbs Flower 3 (medium), 3.5'w x 3.5'd x 7'h, approx 50lbs Flower 4 (large), 5.5'w x 5.5'd x 5.5'h, approx 65lbs Medium: Ceramic, Kanthal Wire & Steel Public Ranking: 20 (15 votes) Jury Ranking: 10t (5.38/7) Ward, Jeni. Umbel Series: A Feast of Flowers. Slide 1 of 2. Ward, Jeni. Umbel Series: A Feast of Flowers. Slide 2 of 2. Vader, Patricia (Martinez, CA) Balthazar the Bulldog Size: 5’ x 3.5’ x 4’ Weight: 70’ Medium: Stainless steel and powder coated aluminum Public Ranking: 21t (14 votes) Jury Ranking: 5t (5.88/7) Vader, Patricia. Balthazar the Bulldog. Slide 1 of 2. Vader, Patricia. Balthazar the Bulldog. Slide 2 of 2. Gornushkin, Sergey (San Diego, CA) Cosmic Tan Size: 8' in length, 5' in height and 3' in width Weight: 150’ Medium: Fiberglass (cast) and finished with high grade automotive paint Public Ranking: 21t (14 votes) Jury Ranking: 10t (5.38/7) Gornushkin, Sergey. Cosmic Tan. Slide 1 of 2. Gornushkin, Sergey. Cosmic Tan. Slide 2 of 2. Tanych, David (Culver City, CA) Lockdown Size: 60”w x 36”d x 114” h Weight: 800’ Medium: Steel Public Ranking: 21t (14 votes) Jury Ranking: 23 (4.88/7) Tanych, David. Lockdown. Seese, Kirk (Lutherville, MD) Magnify Size: 8'H x 3'W x 2" D Weight: 85’ Medium: Vertical Post -2" round tubular steel painted Gloss Black with exterior enamel and a wax application overtop.. Frame -Plasma cut, 1/4" cold rolled steel, painted Gloss Black with exterior enamel and a wax application overtop. Lens -CNC cut 1/2 clear bullet proof polycarbonate with designs directly printed in using UV inks from a large format flatbed printer. Public Ranking: 24 (13 votes) Jury Ranking: 10t (5.38/7) Seese, Kirk. Magnify. Slide 1 of 2. Seese, Kirk. Magnify. Slide 2 of 2. Fischer, Carrie (Crystal Lake, IL) Invertadude Size: 11.5' Height x 3' width x 3' depth Weight: 750’ Medium: HP GFRC Concrete, Steel, tube/plate, EPS foam, concrete stain, graffiti resistant sealer Public Ranking: 25t (11 votes) Jury Ranking: 17t (5.0/7) Fischer, Carrie. Invertadude. Slide 1 of 2. Fischer, Carrie. Invertadude. Slide 2 of 2. Jordan, Robert (Minneapolis, MN) Namaste Size: Each piece = 45 in x 41 in Weight: n/a Medium: Stainless Steel forms, 16 gauge Paint: acrylic/urethane (automotive) / multi-coat finish Public Ranking: 25t (11 votes) Jury Ranking: 24t (4.75/7) Jordan, Robert. Namaste. Slide 1 of 2. Jordan, Robert. Namaste. Slide 2 of 2. Langle, Heather (Lake Arrowhead, CA) PALMZILLA Size: 9'x8'x8' Weight: 250’ Medium: Powder-coated metal Public Ranking: 27t (8 votes) Jury Ranking: 27t (4.63/7) Langle, Heather. PALMZILLA. Slide 1 of 2. Langle, Heather. PALMZILLA. Slide 2 of 2. Piech, Melanie (San Francisco, CA) Date Dial Size: 84"H x 15"W x 15"D Weight: 700’ Medium: Steel, stainless steel, HDPE Public Ranking: 27t (8 votes) Jury Ranking: 36t (4.25/7) Piech, Melanie. Date Dial. Slide 1 of 2. Piech, Melanie. Date Dial. Slide 2 of 2. Light, Andrew (Lexington, KY) Divergent (with I) Size: 14’x6’x10’ Weight: 2,000’+ Medium: Steel Public Ranking: 29 (6 votes) Jury Ranking: 24t (4.75/7) Light, Andrew. Divergent (with I). Slide 1 of 2. Light, Andrew. Divergent (with I). Slide 2 of 2. Litman, Adrian Susnea (Santa Rosa, CA) Fish in the Sky Size: 10' high by 8'wide and 8'deep Weight: 250’ Medium: 304 industrial grade Stainless Steel Public Ranking: 30t (5 votes) Jury Ranking: 17t (5.0/7) Litman, Adrian Susnea. Fish in the Sky. Slide 1 of 2. Litman, Adrian Susnea. Fish in the Sky. Slide 2 of 2. Marquez, Andy (Running Springs, CA) Alexander The Great Size: Length 61.5in. Height 34in. Depth: 44in. Weight: 475’ Medium: Galvanized Steel, Wood, Screws, Glue Public Ranking: 30t (5 votes) Jury Ranking: 41t (4.13/7) Marquez, Andy. Alexander The Great. Slide 1 of 2. Marquez, Andy. Alexander The Great. Slide 2 of 2. Moore, Norman (Alameda, CA) Seasons Size: 67" tall x 10" wide x 10" deep Weight: 200’ Medium: glass mosaic (sanded smooth to the touch) bonded to cast concrete form with thin set Cement Public Ranking: 32t (4 votes) Jury Ranking: 17t (5.0/7) Moore, Norman. Seasons. Slide 1 of 2. Moore, Norman. Seasons. Slide 2 of 2. Criswell, Billy (Lake Oswego, OR) ROGUE Size: Work: 36" tall X 28" wide X 28" wide Pedestal: 36" X 36" X 36" Weight: Work: 75’ Pedestal: 250’ Medium: Powder-coated stainless steel sculpture secured on a concrete pedestal Public Ranking: 32t (4 votes) Jury Ranking: 27t (4.63/7) Criswell, Billy. ROGUE. Slide 1 of 2. Criswell, Billy. ROGUE. Slide 2 of 2. NEXT STAGES THANK YOU!