The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About04/03/1969CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Minutes of: Adjourned Meeting of Planning Commission Date: April 3, 1969 - Time: 8:00 P.M. Dlarc• fnunril ftiamhcmc COMMISSIONERS O' � p �O Q' l 3 N 1 n ', o °� 114111 V 4:1J .l Im 1-1 I I ROLL CALL Commissioners Present Commissioners Absent x x x x x x EX-OFFICIO MEMBERS Present: Daren A. Grath, Principal Planner Thomas L. Woodruff, Asst: City Atty. Benjamin B. Nolan, City Engineer. STAFF MEMBERS Present: James E. Nuzum Helen Herrmann MINUTES The minutes of the meeting of -March 20, 1969 were approved on the motion of Commissioner Jakosky, seconded by Commissioner Dosh, and carried. * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ** FIQL MAP DONALD L. BREN COMPANY East of MacArthur Blvd south of Ford Road , TRACT 656E Por. Block 92 Irvine's Subdivision Zone P -C Applicant requests subdivision of 28.21 acres into 92 lots. Mr..Robert Bein represented the applicant. After a discussion, the Commission. recommended Motion x approval to the City Council subject to the Secon "d x following conditions:. All Ayes 1. The conditions of approval of. Tentative Tract No. 6565 to be applied. 2. The offer of dedication of MacArthur Boulevard to be rejected. 3. A separate long term agreement, without surety, similar to those used for Tracts 6623 and 6624, to be approved guaranteeing the con- • struction of MacArthur Boulevard. Page 1. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS April s, !yny 1c • y T \1:11 AMENDMENT THE IRVINE COMPANY South side of Bayside Dr., A -255 S.E. of intersection of DENIED E1 Paseo and Bayside Dr. Por. Lots 8 & 9 Tract 3232 Zone C -1 -H Applicant requests that Districting Map No. 24 be amended from a C -1 -H District to an R -1 District. Mr. Jim Taylor represented the Irvine Company and addressed the Commission regarding this amendment. Mr. George Dawes, the Harbor Coordinator, also addressed the Commission stating that the parking provided more than met the requirement for the harbor permit. Upon a.review of the evidence on file and testimony presented at the hearing the Commis- tion found and determined that under the cir- • cumstances of the particular.case, recommendin approval of this amendment would be detrimental to the health, safety, peace, morals, comfort and general welfare of persons residing or wor - ing in the neighborhood and, therefore, Motion x recommended denial. Second x Ayes- x x x x Noes x x A-255 FAMULARO, Helena 3700 Newport Boulevard (Restful Acres, Inc.) (Bay Lido Building) APPR VED Por. Lot 3 Sec. 28 T6S R10W, SBBM Zone C -1 Applicant requests that Districting Map No. 4 be amended from a C -1 District to a C -O -H District. Mr. Robert Fleming represented the applicant. After a discussion, the Commission determined that a height limit of 35 feet is a detriment to the utilization of the property and.that by changing the zone from C -1 to C -O -H the City would benefit by the requirement for on -site Motion x parking, therefore, approval was recommended. Second. x All Ayes • Page 2. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH a Anril 3. 1969 COMMISSIONERS TENTATIVE MAPS GEORGE M. HOLSTEIN & SONS Westerly of East - and IDS Mortgage Develop- bluff Dr., and TRACT 6905 CONTINUED ment Corp. southerly of Vist del Oro "Northblu Por. Blks. 51 & 52 Irvine's Subdivision f" INDEFIN- ITELY Zone R -3 -B & R- 4- B -2 -UL Applicant requests subdivision of 20.3± acres into 55 lots and 1 green area lot of a Planned Residential Development. At the request of the applicant the applica- Motion x tion was continued indefinitely to allow the Second x developer time to submit revised plans. All Ayes USE PERMITS GEORGE M. HOLSTEIN & SONS Westerly of East - and IDS Mortgage Develop- bluff Dr., and UP- 1422 -B C INUED ment Corp. southerly of Vist NDEFIN- del Oro "Northblu Por, Blks. 51 & 52 Irv.ine's'Subdivision f" ITELY Zone R -3 -B & R- 4- B -2 -UL Applicant.requests permission to construct one and two story residential units as part of a Planned Residential Development. At the request of the applicant the applica- Motion x tion was continued indefinitely to allow the Second x developer time to submit revised plans. All Ayes UP -1424 TOLL SLIDE MFG., INC. East Ocean.Front between Palm and DENIED Washington Street Lots 9 - 16 Block 8 Balboa Tract Zone C -1 Applicant requests permission to construct a recreational slide. Principal Planner Groth read into the record a petition with 19 signatures in opposition to the application. Is Mr. Hal Hagen represented the applicant and read into the record a letter from the Mayor of San Bernardino to the Mayor of Newport Beach.stating that he believed this to be a worthy project meriting consideration in the community. Page 3. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS y g Mr. Ed Earl who lives in Corona del Mar and who is in charge of the slide in San Bernardino addressed the Commission regarding the opera- tion of the slide. Mr. Everett Michael who owns three lots on Balboa Boulevard spoke in opposition. After a discussion, the Commission denied the Motion x application because in their opinion the Second x recreational slide proposed for this site does Ayes x x x x x x not constitute a desirable land use to the Noes x surrounding area nor contribute favorably to the concept and principles behind the existing and future development of the Balboa Peninsula UP -1425 PACIFIC SOUTHWEST REALTY 3451 E. Coast Hwy. COMPANY 327 Narcissus Avenue APPROVED Lot 4, Block Y, Tract 323 Zone C -1 Lots 25,27 & 29 Block 240 Corona del Mar R -1 • Applicant requests permission to use an R -1 parcel as a private off - street parking lot and to permit a bank building to encroach 10 feet into the required 10 ft. rear yard setback. Mr. Ted Roelfsema represented the applicant. Mr. William D. Richardson of 309 Narcissus Avenue addressed the Commission regarding the application and stated the only problem he could see was the escrow office proposed to be located on the alley property line and the lighting of the lot. Mrs. Patricia Bradley who owns adjacent prop- erty stated that if the parking lot were allowed, she would like to have her property rezoned to R -2 or R -3. After a discussion, the Commission approved Motion x the application subject to the following condi Second x tions: All Aye 1. Landscape plans, including wall and sprinkler details for the parking lot shall be approved by the Planning Director prior to issuance of a build- ing permit for the bank building. 2. Any lighting system in said parking Page 4. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Ah Anni1 '2 Zara COMMISSIONERS 1.i100U;1r1015 " V f t5 1 5 lot shall be subject to the approval of the Planning Director. 3. The setback from the alley shall be 5 feet. The Commission also recommended that, if at all possible, the applicant have the power pole moved 3 feet. City Engineer Nolan suggested that the applica t contact the Traffic Engineer, who has some ideas on the design of the parking lot to make it more usable and increase the parking spaces by two or three. VARIANCES PATTERSON, J. Elmer 1912 Court Avenue V -967 Lot 7 B1. 119 1st Addn. to Newport.Beach APPROVED Zone R -3 Applicant requests permission to construct a • duplex on a lot having 1875 sq.ft. of land area in an R -3 District where the ordinance requires 2400 sq.ft. Mr. Patterson was present at the meeting. The Commission, after a discussion,.approved Motion x the application subject to the following con- Second x dition: All Aye 1. Approval of this request shall not preclude compliance with any build -. ing code in effect at the time the variance is exercised. COMMUNICATIONS. The Commission considered a request from the 1. Santa Ana Tent and Awning Company that Use Permit No. 1170 be amended to permit instal- lation of one aluminum sun shade at the rear of Yards Coffee Shop at Albertson's Market, 3049 E. Coast Highway, Corona del Mar. • The Commission approved the request subject Motion x to the following condition: Second x All Aye! 1. The metal awning cannot extend beyond the present patio area. Page 5. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS v Wv 111 On motion of Commissioner Copelin, seconded by Commissioner Jakosky,.and carried, the meeting was adjourned. Ray opelin, Secretary Planning Commission 1 Page 6.