The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About05/21/1959ul`fY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMIMONERS Minutes of: Regular Meeting of the Planning Commission Date: May 21, 1959 <�.` \ . Time: 8:00 P.M. 0 '<F.cb.y\ Place: Council Chambers :f.:,�'n`.Ad 'w ------- ----------------------------------------------------- ROLL CALL ; Commissioners Present: Clemence, Copelin, Hayton, i 1 Page I I I I , 1 I , I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' t ' I ' I ' I ' I ' 1 , I , I , I , I , ,x I x; I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' 1 ' I ' I ! I ' I ' I ' I ' I , I , I , 1 , I I , 1 , I , 1 , I , , , I , i I � , I , , I , , I � , 1 , , 1 1 , , I , , I I 1 ; , i a. , , , , I , I I I I i , I , , , , i i I , � I � I � I � I 1 I i 1 , I , I , I , I , 1 , I , I , I , I , I , I , 1 , 1 , I , I ; 1 z I ' I ' I ' I I , I ' I ' I ' I Keene, Rudd, Smith ; 1 , , Commissioners Absent: Lind, Longmoor I MINUTES Minutes of the regular meeting on April 16, 1959 and i the adjourned meeting on May 7, 1959 were approved on the motion of, Commissioner Rudd, seconded by Commissioner Hayton and carried. , I et* ,kiraYin4irk•h:c #aYdeaY9c�aLYe� ink k�4ie�leteYdr TENTATIVE and FINAL MAP of TRACT No. 2758 I I , APPROVED Presented to the Commission were the tentative and final maps of Tract No. 2758, being a proposed sub - division of Lot 2, Tract 1237, Corona del Mar. I , The tentative and final maps were approved, subject Motion to the following conditions: !Second : All Ayes 1. That all utilities be installed underground. 1 • 2. That recommendations of Fire Department as set ; forth in a communication dated November 10, 195P be complied with. 3. That recommendations outlined in a communica- tion from Public Works Director dated December 4, 1958 be complied with, excepting Item 1 ; under recommendations be deleted. 4. That tree planting be in accordance with recommendations of the Parks, Beaches and i Recreation Commission as set forth in a letter dated November 19, 1958 1 " , , 5. That minimum square footage requirements, lot I depths, requirement of service road fronting i on a State Highway and alley widths be waived in accordance with Section 9256.1 of Article IX'k of the Municipal Code. 6. Vehicular access from Seaward Road to Lots 14 to 24 inclusive prohibited. i 7. No vehicular access may be permitted from Cabrillo Highway. 8. Pedestrian ingress and egress may be permitted from Cabrillo Highway. , i 1 Page I I I I , 1 I , I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' t ' I ' I ' I ' I ' 1 , I , I , I , I , ,x I x; I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' 1 ' I ' I ! I ' I ' I ' I ' I , I , I , 1 , I I , 1 , I , 1 , I , , , I , i I � , I , , I , , I � , 1 , , 1 1 , , I , , I I 1 ; , i a. , , , , I , I I I I i , I , , , , i i I , � I � I � I � I 1 I i 1 , I , I , I , I , 1 , I , I , I , I , I , I , 1 , 1 , I , I ; 1 z I ' I ' I ' I I , I ' I ' I ' I CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH CiOMMISSiOi rRs ,r, , :nn"i`,2 \a"•O+..p,•p`,S'. - ------ ------------------------------- AMENDMENT A -68 Recommended to the City Council was Planning Commis- Motion Ix, ; sion Resolution of Intention No. 636 and Amendment Second x; APPROVED No. 68 which proposes to rezone Corona del Mar State All Ayes Park Beach from an R -1 to an Unclassified District. : , r A -69 Planning Commission Amendment No. 69 regarding a proposal to clarify certain sections of the Zoning Set Over Ordinance relating to building heights was set over until the next regular meeting in June. Motion ;x i Second Acting Chairman Keene appointed Commissioners Lind, All Ayes Clemence, and Keene to serve as a Committee to draft ; findings on the subject matter which will be sub- mitted to the Planning Commission for study and approval if in order. A -70 Amendment No. 70 initiated by Marguerite Streng and certain property owners petitioning to rezone propertj IED located at 3200 E. Coast Highway and 416, 418, 420, 422, 424 and 426 Larkspur, Corona del Mar, from a C -1; and R -2 District to a C-1 -H District was resented to: P ' : the Commission. It was recommended to the City Council that said Motion Amendment be denied for the following reasons: Second x All Ayes 1. Subject property is adjacent to approxi- mately 70% R -2 property. 2. It is a poorly co- ordinated plan. 3. Does not accomplish the results of good planning. i , r , 4. Increases congestion in the area. 5. Effectuation of the proposed zoning would be "Spot Zoning." VARlANCESi V -534 MacDONALD, W. Fred & Mac Wat Corp. 1508 -10 -12 West Balboa Blvd. ; r : PROVED � Lots 5-6 -7 Block 115 Tract 234 Zone R -3 Applicant requests permission to have waived a porticIn of the square footage requirements in order to con- ; ; struct a 9 unit apartment building on three 30'x100'; lots. ; Motion ; � , : ' x' ' , Application approved, subject to the following condij Second i x; All Ayes , tions. Page 2 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS A,s'� ,F,y,Z,,R, \O�A`,O,Z`. ------ ------------------------- ------ ' 1. Required garage and off - street parking spaces must conform to the Zoning Ordinance require- ments of 9' x 20' inside measurements. 2. The alley which is at a right angle to Balboa Boulevard must be improved in accordance with specifications of the City Engineer. : , V -535 FARWELL, Lyman H. & THE IRVINE CO. Bayshore Drive & Coast Highway APPROVED Por. Block 54 Irvine's Subdivision Zone "U" Applicant requests permission to (1) construct an 8' wall and an accessory building on the north side property line. (2) Construction of an office building; within 5' of front property line. (3) Construct car-.: ports on front half of lot. � Application approved, subject to the following condi- ;Motion Ix: tions: :Second I Ix; All Ayes : 1. Development must comply with fire department : specifications as set forth in a communication • : dated May 21, 1959. 2. Height of fence along Bayshore Drive must be : a minimum of 4' and of masonry construction, i 3. The relocation of the gate approach to Bayshore6 � must be in accordance with the specifications of the City Engineer. v -536 RICHARDSON, Eileen & THE IRVINE CO. 1500 Block Ba side Drive Set Over Lot 7 Tract 3232 Zone C -1 -H until ; Applicant requests permission for (1) encroachment ; June 4 of 15' into required 20' front yard setback and (2) waiver of a portion of off - street parking spaces. Motion ,x1 Second : :x: Application set over for further consideration. All Ayes v -537 FINK, Alvin J. 705 West Bay Avenue Rear 30' of Lots 1 & 2 Block 5 East Newport Zone R -4 APPROVED : Applicant requests permission to encroach 2' into : required 10' rear yard setback and to permit a • : cantilevered roof to be constructed within 2' of rear, Motion : : ; : ;x: : property line for the purpose of an addition to an ; Second ; ; , 1x existing building. : All Ayes ; i CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS -_ ._____"__________"____'--------------------------- --------------- _____-- ___ftn' -i V -538 APPROVED V -539 APPROVED • i I , USE PERMI* i UP -517 i APPROVED i i UP -518 APPROVED 1 i • FISCHER, Paul B. & THE IRVINE CO. 1200 Bayside Drive Por. Lot 2, 3 & 4 Tract 3232 Zone C -1 -H ; Applicant requests permission to have a zero front yapd , setback and a zero side yard setback for the purpose of constructing 34 dwelling units in a C -1 -H and R -3 , District. Application approved, subject to the following r I ' Motion conditions: ; Second x; All Ayes 1. Front yard setback must be a minimum of 10' and a setback of 4' must be maintained on west' side property line. 2. Revised plans must be approved by the Fire Department. HOWARD, Charles R. 3201- 3- 5- 7 -9 -11 Bayside Drive ; N.E. 25' Lot 26 all 28 & 30 Block 238 Corona del Zone R -2 Mar Applicant requests permission to erect a 6' x 10' sign for the "Luau Apts." during construction. 1 � Motion x: Approved, with the condition that the life of the Second ; x; sign may not exceed 6 months from the date of erection. All Ayes I 1 I MacDONALD, W. Fred & MacWat Corp. 1508 -10 -12 West Balboa Blvd. I Lot 5 -6 -7 Block 115 Tract 234 Zone R -3 Applicant requests permission to construct 9 dwelling; Motion ;x units with a maximum height of 37' for the main ; Second building plus 4' for an elevator pent house. All Ayes FARWELL, Lyman H. & The IRVINE CO. Bayshore Drive &; Coast Highway I I i I ; For. Block 54 Irvine's Subdivision Zone "U" Applicant requests permission to construct 39 dwelling units and accessory buildings in an Unclassified Zone„ Application approved subject to the use and condition4 Motion x; ; of an R -3 Zone. Parkin to be in conformance with : Parking Second ; the plot plan submitted with not less than 106 spacesa All Ayes I I I Page 4 Pegs 5 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS <, n pZ ` - -- - ---- --- - --- - -- - -,-- - - - I UP -519 ; ' HERRMANN, George A. 455, 457 & 459 No. Newport Bll.. Lots 9 & 10 Block 9 Tract 27 Zone C -1 ; Motion ;xf Set Over Applicant requests permission to construct a 22 unit ; Second ; x; until 6/4 apartment building in a C -1 Zone All Ayes + ; UP -520 SCOTT, Lawrence 2110 West Ocean Front I I I I I I I I ' , Lots 3 & 4 Block 21 Newport Beach Tr. Zone C -1 Motion APPROVED ; Applicant requests permission to have an on -sale ; Second x ; beer license ; All Ayes UP -521 FISCHER, Paul B. & THE IRVINE CO. 1200 Bayside Dr. I For. Lot 2, 3 & 4 Tract 3232 Zone C -1 -H & R -3 APPROVED Applicant requests permission to construct a 34 I dwelling unit apartment building in an R -3 and C -1 -H District. Approved, subject to the condition that one covered I i Motion parking space and one uncovered parking space must second >( be provided for each dwelling unit. All Ayes OUBDIVI9JONS R -91 LIDDLE, L. E. & E. M. North of 23rd Street between: Tustin & Irvine Avenues Portion Lot 104 Tract 300 The applicants desire resubdivision of this property ; I I , so as to provide four R -1 building sites. i The map submitted with the application was denied ; Motion ac and the applicant was advised that he had 30 days ; Second I to submit a new map under Section 9252.22 of Article All Ayes ; IXk of the Municipal Code. R -92 ; HOAG, George 11 and Patricia W. North of Westcliff I I I i I I I I Dr., between Buck- APPROVED ingham Lane and Dover Drive I , Tract 1396 Zone R -3 ; Motion i ;x1 Applicants desire a resubdivision of this property Second ;x so as to provide two R -3 building sites. All Ayes; FINAL MAP�TRACT No. 3379 I I + 10PROVED ' Final map of Tract 3379, being a subdivision of a portion of Lot 298, Newport Heights, was approved Motion Ix; ' subject to the following conditions: Second ; ix� All Ayes Pegs 5 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS •c ---------- --- ---- -- ----- ----------- - - - --- -- -- - - -- ----------- ---- - - ---- - -- - - - --- 1. That recommendations specified in a communica -: tion from the Director of Public Works dated April 2, 1959 be complied with. 2. That street tree planting be in accordance with specifications of the Parks, Beaches & Recreation Department. 3. A 10' strip abutting 22nd Street must be ; dedicated to the City of Newport Beach and the; street section must be improved in accordance with specifications of the Director of Public ; Works. 4. Street lighting must be in accordance with specifications of the Director of Public Works" ADDITION" BUSINESS f� 1. i Resolution of Intention No. 638 was initiated in ordeu to rezone a portion of Lot 2, Tract 3232 from an R -3 Motion to a C -1 -H District, and a portion of Lot 4 from a Second C -1 -H to an R -3 District. All Ayes 2.! Referred to the Commission by the Mayor was a letter ; dated May 11, 1959 addressed to the Engineering ; Department, signed by John H. Parke, ' Rector St. JamP,s Church, requesting the annexation of certain property; to the City of Newport Beach. ; Motion Second Subject matter was held over for further consideratio4.All Ayes , � k:Y *�Yieieie kaF9eaYntdeint� 'eu'.ex,ttw'w�t�t � On motion of Commissioner Hayton, seconded by Commissioner Smith, and carried, the meeting was adjourned until June 4, 1959 at 8,00 P.M. Ray Y. C elin, Secretary Planning Commission. Page 6 , , , , i , i i w