Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout07/15/1954Ad MINUTES OF THE MANNING COMMISSION MEETING, THURSDAY, JULY 15, 1954 - $900 PM CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS, NEWPORT BEACH, CALIFORNIA Chairman Lengmoor called the regular meeting of the Planning Commission to order. ROLL CALL: Commissioners present: Briggs, Copelin, Lind, Longmoor, Reed, Budd, Smith, Keene, Haytou Commissioners absents none MINUTESs Minutes of the meeting on dune 15, 1954 `+ere approved upon motion of Com. Briggs, seconded by Com. Keene, and carried. VARIANCESs 9 - #150 #150 Application of the Irvine Go. for frontyard setbacks on Lots 24, 25, and 26 in Tract #1700 known as Irvine Terrace, as follows Irvine Co. Lot 24 10 feet facing Dolphin Terrace staggered setbacks Lot 25 10 feet facing Dolphin Terrace Irvine Terrace Let 26 (10 feet facing Dolphin Terrace granted (10 feet facing Serenade Terrace. The hearing was declared FINDINGS: This Variance is in accord with the previously agreed setback/ open. conditions as set forth in conditions as follows: CONDITIONS: This variance is required by agreement between the Planning Commission and the Irvine Co. upon approval of the original and tentative tract maps of Tract #1700 and 01701, and R-1 zoning amendments wherein staggered setbacks would be allowed upon the condition that a variance would be needed for each lot and the setbacks would be shown on District Map #24 and adhered to by the builder under authority of Article c*, Ordinance #650 of the City Code. Com. Hayton moved that the hearing be closed, seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried. Com. Hayton moved that the application be granted, seconded by Gem. Rudd, and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES: Copelin, Lind, Longmoor, Reed, Rudd, Keene, Hayton NOES: Briggs, Smith Application of Kelso & Sloan to re- subdivide an R-3 district parcel of ground consisting of all of Lot #925 and the southeasterly 20 feet V - #151 of Lot #924 in Tract #907 with a frontage width of 60 feet and a depth of 90 feet into two 30 foot wide lots as followss Kelso & Sloan Lot Division #1 - consisting of the southeasterly 30 feet of Lot #925 Lot #925 and Tract #907 with an area of 2700 square feet. prtn. Lot #924 Lot Division #2 - consisting of the northwesterly 10 feet of Lot #925, Tr. #907 and the southeasterly 20 feet of Lot #921`, Tract #907 with an area of 2700 equate Feet. GRANTED The hearing was declared open.' FINDINGS: Division of said R-3 district property into two building sites as proposed, would automatically limit the use of each lot to two dwelling units under Section 9103.35 (b) of the City dodo. The majority of recorded lets on Lido Isle are 30 feet wide or lase. The applicant has incorposated an Rrl district use is his application. CONDITIONS: Said building sites #1 and #2 as described herein are limited under this Variance to an R-1 district use and R..1 district requirements of Zoning Ordinance #635 of the City of Newport Beach Municipal Code. The hearing was closed upon motion of Com. Rudd, seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried. Cam. Copelin moved that the application be granted, seconded by Com. Rudd, carried by the following roll call vote., to -wit: ALL AYES and m w •, USE PERMITS Application of the Corona del Mar Business Monts Assn. for permission lication of Michael Wagner and all property owners in V - #152 Block i00. change the waterfront setback on U.P. #148 Lots 1 to 10 inblusive of said Block 638 from the existing Wagner, Michael 25 foot setback to a 20 foot setback. Said property is located G. between 38th and 39th Streets between Channel Place and the Men's Assn. channel to the north in the 3800 block. Lots 1 to 10, The hearing was declared open. Blk. #638 FINDINGSs The waterfront setback on adjacent waterfront Blocks Canal Section #539 to the west, and #637 to the east was changed by Planning GRANTED Comission Resolutions #574 and #501. The variance as applied for GRANTED herein is thus consistent with previously alleved adjacent setbacks, will not adversely affect surrounding property, and has been applied for by all of the property owners in said Block 638. The hearing was closed upon motion of uom. Briggs, seconded by Gom. Hayton, and carried. Com. Copelin moved that the application be granted, seconded by Com. Hayton, and,oarried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: ALL AYES USE PERMITS Application of the Corona del Mar Business Monts Assn. for permission Application of Vernon Edler to operate a boat sales yard at 2226 U.P. #151 West Coast Highway on a vacant lot between the Mobile Gas Station and Nautical Radio business on the north side of the highway and on Edler, Vernon property described as a 30 foot by 50 foot portion of Let A, Tr.919. Brats at present are parked on the property, and the applicant "a prtn. Lot A. notified that he cannot carry on any business until such time as a Tr. #919 Use Permit is granted and a business, license granted. (As no one was present representing the applicant, the application (held over to was set over until the meeting on August 19th on motion of Com. next meeting) Copelin, seconded by Com, Rudd, and carried.) to maintain and operate a sign for the purpose of advertising Corona del Mar. Said sign is located on Lot 3, Tract #1237, Corona Highlands U.P. #148 on East Coast Highway, between Morning Canyon Road and the easterly city limits. This application was set over from the June 17th CDM Bustness meeting since there was no representation at the meeting by the Men's Assn. Association. The hearing v4s declared open. Lot 3,Tr.1237, FINDINGSs The sign has been in its present location for a number of years. Its use for advertising a section of Newport Beach only GRANTED can be considered as .benefiting a considerable section of the local population of the City of Newport Beach and can thus be classed in a different category from the commercial •ign which the Planning Commission is desirous of eliminating from the City. The hearing was closed upon motion of Boa. Gopelin, seconded by Com. Hayton, and carried. Com. Hayton moved that the application be granted, seconded by Cam. Rudd, and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: ALL AYES Application of Vernon Edler to operate a boat sales yard at 2226 U.P. #151 West Coast Highway on a vacant lot between the Mobile Gas Station and Nautical Radio business on the north side of the highway and on Edler, Vernon property described as a 30 foot by 50 foot portion of Let A, Tr.919. Brats at present are parked on the property, and the applicant "a prtn. Lot A. notified that he cannot carry on any business until such time as a Tr. #919 Use Permit is granted and a business, license granted. (As no one was present representing the applicant, the application (held over to was set over until the meeting on August 19th on motion of Com. next meeting) Copelin, seconded by Com, Rudd, and carried.) e ' Application of Gordon Wa. Grundy and Dr. Alvin J. Terry to construct and operate a two story apartment building containing eight dwelling U.P. #152 units with nine enclosed garages on an R-3 parcel of ground consist- ing of Lots 1090 and 1091 of Tract #907 and located on the northwest Grundy,Gordon corner of Via Lido Nord and Via Antibes. & The hearing was declared open. Terry, Dr.Alvin FINDINGS: Same conditions exist under application for Use Permit #152 as were encountered in Use Permit Application $143 Lots 1090,1091 Eight dwelling units is in excess of any ratio pre- Tr. #907 cedent which might be considered as having been set by the allowance of Use Permit #107 to Mr. Harry Kelso. DENIED However, the Planning Commission does not consider any of its decisions to set a precedent. Each application must stand on its own merit. The Commission does not consider the con- struction of 8 units on said property to be the best development for the area. The hearing was closed upon motion of Con. Lihd, seconded by Goa. Hayton, and carried. Con. Hayton moved that the application be denied, seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES: Briggs, Copelin, Lind, Longmoor, Reed, Rudd, Smith, Hayton NOES: Keene ' Application of Leo B. Kirchner to allow the construction and operation of a four dwelling unit apartment building on an R-3 district parcel U.P. #153 containing 4200 square feet on Lots 14, 15, and adjacent 20 feet of Lot 16, Bloch 17, Section B. Newport Beach Tract. Application was filed late, but upon motion of Con. Keene, seconded Kirchner, LeoB. by Com. Smith, and carried, the application was considered without posting. Lots 145 15, 16 FINDINGS: A four dwelling unit building on a let area of 4200 square Blk. 17,SEc.B feet is in keeping with the allowable limit wherein 1000 square feet Npt. Beach of ground area is required for each dwelling unit under Section 9103.35(b) of the City Code. The proposed construction should not be detrimental to surrounding or adjacent property. The hearing was closed upon motion of Cem. Copelin, seconded by Gem. GRANTED Rudd, and carried. Con. Keene moved that the application be granted, seconded by Com. Smith, and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES: Briggs, Copelin, Lind, Longmoor, Rudd, Smith, Keene, Hayton NOES: Reed First hearing on the application of David I. Nielsen, MD, to amend Zoning Ord. #635, section 9103.1 from an R-1 district to a C-1 -H Amendment district on Lot 19, Tr. #1136 located at 406 Westminster Ave. #17 Adjacent lots 17 & 18 are now zoned C-1 -H. Dr. Nielson desires to ' erect a medical building on Lots 18 & 19 facing Westminster Ave. with Nielsen,David appropriate off - street parking. I. MD Com. Briggs moved that the hearing be closed, seconded by Coe. Lind, and carried. Lot 19,Tr.1136 Application was set for second hearing on August 19, 1954 upon Notion of Com. Briggs, seconded by Com. Lind, and carried. (set for 2nd hearing)' ravio Amendment #8 R.ofI. #585 Stricker Annex. First hearing on Planning Commission Resolution of Intention #585 to amend zoning on the recently annexed Stricker Annexation from a "U" District to zoning districts available in Zoning Ord. #635 that would be appropriate for land uses existing or proposed. The first hearing has been advertised and posted as being for the purpose of generd discussion with owners of property involved. The Stricker Annexation is located southerly of 15th St. between Westminster Ave. on the east and the State Highway on the west and including a trianidlar shaped parcel of ground between said Westminster Ave. on the westerly side, Old County Road on the northerly side, and Broad St. on the southerly side. The hearing was closed and set for second hearing on August 19, 1954 upon motion of Com. Lind, seconded by Com. Briggs, and carried. Letter received from the Orange County Planning Commission asking Letter from for the Newport Beach Planning Commission's recommendation on an Orange County application for excavation. There was insufficient time between Planning Comm. the City and County meetings to transmit a recommendation; therefore, the letter was ordered filed upon motion of.Com. Briggs, seconded by S m. Smith, and carried. Annual report Upon motion of Com. Lind, seconded by Com. Hayton, and carbied, 1953 -54 the annual report of the Planning Commission was approved and submitted to the City Council. , As there was na further business, the meeting was adjourned upon motion of Com. Copelin, seconded by Com. Keene, and carried. y Copelin Secretary - jm