The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About11/05/1959CITY OF NEWPOkt BEACH Minutes of Adjourned Meeting of the Planning Conimi'ssion Date: November 5; 1959 Time: 8:00 P.M: Place: Council Chambers COMMISSIONERS 0-- ------------------------------------ =------------- ==------- ----=-- --- ^------- R&L CALL commissioners Present: Cleraence, Copelin, Ficker, tWason, Lind, Marshall, Rudd, Steelman ; Commissioners Absent: Skinner ; ��rxx;r��z *,rtie *>rx�,nre;rxe,hti ' F?INAL.MAPS APPROVED ; The final map of Tract 3542 being a subdivision of a portion of Block 93; Irvine's Subdivision; located ; easterly of Mac Arthur Blvd., . and north of 5th Avenue ; in Corona del Mar was approved, subject to the follow -1 Motion ing conditions: 1 Second 1. "That recoiumendatione of the Public .Works All Ayes .i Director as specified in a memorandum to the Planning Commission dated septembeY 1, 1459 1 be ,complied with. I 2: That street tree planting tie in acitordance with specifications of the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission.; ' w ' i 3. That action be initiated to rezone this prdp'ertT • from an unclassified to an kwl -B District at the time the final map is approved: 4. That recommendations of the Fire Department 1 as specified in a memorandum to the Planning ' Department dated August 19; 1959 be complied , ! with. 5. That a turn around adjacent to the garage be provided on each lot in order to provide a , non- hazarcous approach to Harbor View Drive ; and Goldenrod Avenue. � 1 ' AMENDMENTS! A -76 i BENNETT, Jack H;, MALICK, Dell M. Northeast Coiner of; and ALBRIGHT; Kenneth C; 16th St, and Irvine; APPROVED i Ave:, Newport Beach' Por. Lots 2 and 3 Tract 1125 Zone "u" The petitioner's desire to amend District Map No. 26 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code so as to cause certain property to be rezoned from an Unclassified to an R -3 District: i Motion The Coirmiesion recommended approval . of this appllca- 1Second tim- subject to the condition that it be zoned R -3 -B: All Ages , 1 Page 1 'x I , , , i , I , , r r i r i i , , i , , i , , i , i , , , , , r , , , , , i , , , , r i , i i , i , , �1 , CITY Of NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS A -78 APPROVED VARIANCES 1 565 APPROVED V -568 APPROVED • r , STURTEVANT, Austin D. Between Irvine Ave. & ; Sussex Lane - Westcliff DA. and Mariners Dr. Por. Lot 164 Block 53 Irvine's Sub. Zone "U" The petitioner desires to amend District Map No. 27 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code so as to cause certain property to be rezoned from an Unclassified to an R -3: District. ' Motion The Commission recommended approval of this applica- Second tion subject to the condition that it be zoned R -3 -B All Ayes r i SHAVER, D. 215 and 217 Iris, CdM Lots 17 and 19 Block 35 Re -sub of CdM Zone R -1 Motion Applicant requests permission to encroach 3' into a Second required 18' front yard setback for the purpose of Ayes constructing two single family dwellings Noes i HARBOR VIEW HILLS DEVELOPMENT CO. North of 5th Ave.,& Easterly of Mac Arthur Blvd., CdM Lots 1 thru 77 inclusive Tract 2202 ; Lots 1 thru 15 inclusive Tract 3542 ; Applicant requests permission to have a 5' side yard ; setback instead of a required 61. r Approved, subject to the condition that a 5' side yar4 setback be permitted on lots 19, 21, 24, 34, 42, 47, ; 49, 50, 53 and 63 in Tract 2202 and Lot 6 in Tract 3542 with the additional requirement that a minimum ; Motion distance of 12' be maintained between buildings at ; Second all times. ; All Ayes Commissioner Steelman requested that he be excused from the rostrum and that the record show that he did', not participate in the discussion of the following application (Variance No. 569) at the study session. i i i i i Page , , , X x; x X, , x i , -r r , r , r , r , x! r , r , , x r , r , -- - - - - -; ---- - - - - -r A -77 STURTEVANT, Austin D. Between Irvine Ave. & Sussex Lane - Westcliff Dry. APPROVED and Mariners Dr., ; Por. Lot 164 Block 53 Irvine's Sub. Zone "U" The petitioner desires to amend District Map No. 27 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code so as to cause ; Motion certain property to be rezoned from an Unclassified ; Second to an R -1 District ; All Ayes A -78 APPROVED VARIANCES 1 565 APPROVED V -568 APPROVED • r , STURTEVANT, Austin D. Between Irvine Ave. & ; Sussex Lane - Westcliff DA. and Mariners Dr. Por. Lot 164 Block 53 Irvine's Sub. Zone "U" The petitioner desires to amend District Map No. 27 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code so as to cause certain property to be rezoned from an Unclassified to an R -3: District. ' Motion The Commission recommended approval of this applica- Second tion subject to the condition that it be zoned R -3 -B All Ayes r i SHAVER, D. 215 and 217 Iris, CdM Lots 17 and 19 Block 35 Re -sub of CdM Zone R -1 Motion Applicant requests permission to encroach 3' into a Second required 18' front yard setback for the purpose of Ayes constructing two single family dwellings Noes i HARBOR VIEW HILLS DEVELOPMENT CO. North of 5th Ave.,& Easterly of Mac Arthur Blvd., CdM Lots 1 thru 77 inclusive Tract 2202 ; Lots 1 thru 15 inclusive Tract 3542 ; Applicant requests permission to have a 5' side yard ; setback instead of a required 61. r Approved, subject to the condition that a 5' side yar4 setback be permitted on lots 19, 21, 24, 34, 42, 47, ; 49, 50, 53 and 63 in Tract 2202 and Lot 6 in Tract 3542 with the additional requirement that a minimum ; Motion distance of 12' be maintained between buildings at ; Second all times. ; All Ayes Commissioner Steelman requested that he be excused from the rostrum and that the record show that he did', not participate in the discussion of the following application (Variance No. 569) at the study session. i i i i i Page , , , X x; x X, , x i , -r r , r , r , r , x! r , r , , x r , r , CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS ------------------------------------------------------------------ - - - - -= V -569 HILL, Henry H. 426 San Bernardino Ave. , Lot 11 Block 14 First Add'n.to Npt. Heights. R -1 SET OVER Applicant requests permission to have an accessory UNTIL ; building in excess of 15' in height and to retain a NOV. 19 ; single family unit on the property until new dwelling i unit is completed in an R -1 District. The kitchen Motion facilities in the existing unit will be removed at the: Second time the new dwelling unit is completed. 0 All Ayes V -570 APPROVED USE PERMITS UP -560 PROVED , i UP -561 APPROVED UP -562 APPROVED UP -563 APPROVED UP -564 APPROVED • Commissioner Steelman returned to the rostrum. , PACKER, Ora J. & W.V., Jr. 2014 W. Ocean Front Lot 7 Block 20 Section A First Add'n, to Npt.Bch. C 41 Applicant requests permission to encroach 15' into a ' required front yard setback of 20' and a zero side yarn setback instead of a required 4' for the purpose of Motion constructing residential units above a commercial second building in a C -1 District. All Ayes BEESEMYER, Jay C. Southwest corner of Palisades Rd., and Mac Arthur Blvd. Por..Block 50 Irvine's Subdivision Zone "U" Applicant requests permission to construct a service station in an Unclassified District. Motion Second All Ayes TUCKER ENTERPRISES. 2427 - 16th Street ; Por. Lot 47 Newport Heights Zone "U`; Motion Applicant requests permission.to construct 15 dwelling; Second units in an Unclassified Zone.. All Ayes PACKER, Ora J.. and.W.V'., Jr.. 2014. W. Ocean Front i Lot 7 Block 20 Section A First Add'n to Npt.Bch. C;1 Applicant requests permission to construct residential Motion units above a commercial building in a C -1' Zone i Second All Ayes ALHADEFF, Harry. 317 Marine Ave. Lot 28 Block 13 Section 4 Balboa Island Tr. Zone C4 Motion Applicant requests permission to have a laundromat in Second a C -1 District.. i Ayes Noes JOHNSON, Todd';W.. 3450 Via Oporto Lots 1124, 1125 & Por.. 1123 Tract 907 Zone C -L-H ; Applicant requests permission to make an addition to ; an existing non- conforming building:. Approved, subject to the condition that the.use of the, Motion property be only for the term of the lease in effect Second' with the Lido Shops Auto Park No. 3. Inc.., which! Ayes permits use of their parking ..lot duxing the hours. ; Noes 11;00 A.M. to 3:00 A.M. of the followinS.day. Page 3: I , r i i i i , r ' , , i i i , , , , , i i r ' ; -r r ' i , i r , r , , ;x ; ;x , CITY OF NEWPORT BEACK COMMISSIONERS ---- ---- - --- -- -r-, -- - UP -565 WALKER, Robert G. 127 E. Bay Front Lot 18 Block 4 Section 5 Balboa Is. Tract Zone R -2: Motion Ix, APPROVED i Applicant requests permission to extend a room and Second Ix: , deck over an exi:.tiag non - conforming garage. All Ayes, , RESUBDIVIStTO_NS R -103 COOK, Milton M., Jr. & Jacklyn W. 2319 Laurel Plaos Tract 1188 Zone R -1 Motion I ; APPROVED ; R -104 APPROVED r *105 APPROVED Lot 5 Applicant desires a resubdivision of this property so as to provide two R -I lots. ; CIRKWOOD, Marvin E. 3729 Ocean Blvd. Por. Block A Obrona del Mar Zohe R -11 A4 icant desires a $e9ubdivision of this property so ae to provide 64o R -i tots. A{i'toved, aUbjett to the d6ndiAbN LHat a 41 side yard: se batik be estd6lished from the existing large house 64d that the rebuilding of the guest house comply withl tide City Building Code and that the subdivider provide: a bond and agreement to guarantee the completion of : the guest house according to Code. i r r PFAHLZR, Herbert W. Southwest Corner of 16th: St. and Placentia Ave. : Lot 812k First Add'n. to Newport Mesa M -1 -A: Applicant requests permission to resubdivide one parcel into three M -1 -A lots. Approved, subject to the following conditions: 1. That the application be not recorded until such time as the owner of Parcel A (United Parcel Company) sign the application. 2. That 10' on the west side of Placentia Ave. be deeded to the City of Newport Beach for street purposes. 3. That 16th Street be improved in accordance with the specifications of the Director of Public Works , 4. That a bond and agreement-be submitted to insure the completion of improvements as outlined in Item 3. Second : :x; All Ayes; ; , r , ' r Motion ix' Second All Ayes ll' r i , r r , , r : Motion 1x: Second I ;xl : All Ayes: : r , , r i r ADDITIONAL:BUSINESS 0 1. Resolution of Intention No. 641 was initiated in order! Motion to hold one public hearing on the rezoning of Tract Second I x: APPROVED 2202 from an Unclassified to an R-1 -B District. All Ayes: , Page 4 r � r ' , i , I , i i i i r i i r , 1 r � r , r , , r r , , r , r , r r , :x' r , r , , i , I i i - i i i r ' r ' r ' , x' r , , r , r , r , r , r , r , r , r i , r , �-_ - - - -- - a. , APPROVED 3. APPROVED 4. APPROVED 0 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS ------------------------------------------------------ I ---------- ------- - ----------------------- -------------- ----- ------ ----- Resolution of Intention No. 642 was initiated in ordeA ; to hold one public hearing on an amendment to the Master Plan which would delete Lancaster Street as a Motion secondary street from the Street and Highway Unit of Second the Master Plan. All Ayes ; Resolution of Intention No. 643 was initiated in orderl ; to hold one public hearing on November 19, 1959 on ,the Motion revocation of Use Permit No. 361 filed by Lido Boat Second Club, Inc., and approved by the Planning Commission All Ayes on September.19, 1957 ; Commissioner Lind, Chairman of the Building Height Committee recommended to the Commission that Section 9107.28 of the Zoning Regulations be amended to read ; as follows: I , GRADE (Ground Level) is the average of the , finished ground level at the center of all walls of a building. In case walls are parallel to and within five feet (51) of a sidewalk, the above ground level shall be measured at the sidewalk. HEIGHT OF BUILDING is the vertical distance from the '!Grade" to the highest point of the coping of a flat roof or to the deck line of a mansard roof or to the average height of the highest gable of a pitch or hip roof. i I , , I I Commissioner Lind stated that the City Council had ; adopted the 1958 Uniform Building Code and that this ; proposed amendment would conform to the definition ; of "Grade" and "Height of Buildings" as set forth in ; the Uniform Building Code. ; The Planning Commission unanimously endorsed the ; Motion a recommendations of the Land Use Committee regarding i Second the redefinition of Section 9107.28 and recommended All Ayes that this proposed amendment be forwarded to the City Council for consideration prior to a public hearing. COMMUNICATIONS ' i Approximately 60 letters received from property owners on Balboa Island protesting the construction of an Motion apartment motel on property located at 332 Marine Second Avenue were ordered filed All Ayes , I , I , On motion of Commissioner Rudd, seconded by Commissioner Steelman, and carried, the meeting was . ; adjourned. r� i Ray Y. Copelitt, Secretary , Planning Commission ; , I ' I Page 5 1 ; I , I , XI 1 ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I ' I I , I , I , I ' I , I , I , I I I i I , I I 1 I I I I XI i I I I I 1 I I I I I I I i I xI I 1 I I I I I I I I I I I I , I ' ; f i I I ' I I I I I I I i I I I , I I , I I I ' ' , I 1 I I , I I I I i I I I I I 1 � I I I I , I I , I I , 1 , 1 ' I I I I I I , I I I I I I I I , I I , I , , I I , I I I 1 , I I :I I ' I I I I I I I I ' I I , I 1 , I I I I , I I I I I I I I I I I I , I I , I I , I I I 1 I 1 , i I I I , I I , , , , , CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS n Minutes of: Regular Meeting of the Planning Commission , •, .' ', ', `, '. N \v, Date: October 15, 1959`, • Time 8:00 P.M. Place: Council Chambers ----------------------------------------- --- -------- -- --- -- ---- -- --- ---i ---- --- - -rc; Eugene Schulte, Planning Draftsman and assistant to the Planning Director called the roll and all Commissioners were absent. There being no quorum, the meeting was adjourned by Mr. Schulte until 8:00 P.M. on November 5, 1959 in the City Hall I Council Chambers. Y. Ray Y. C pelin, Secretary Planning Commission n