Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutM2014-0047 (2)STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY EDMUND G. BROWN, JR., GOVERNOR CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Coast District Office 200 Oceangate. 10th Floor Long Beach, California 90802-4416 PH (562) 590-5071 FAX (562) 590-5084 June 27, 2014 Permit No. -14-0661 NOTICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT EFFECTIVENESS Please be advised that the Administrative Permit with the above permit number which was sent to you on May 23, 2014 and was reported to the Commission on June 12, 2014 is now fully effective. Development of your project is subject to compliance with all terms and conditions specified in the Administrative Permit. Should you have any questions please contact our office. CHARLES LESTER Executive Director 11-1114v `F ?�� Liliana Roman Coastal Program Analyst CITY OF NEWPORT SERCH CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH r. �'Rclp"c oc iv VICINITY MRP HDpw MY, aLuMa z uJ u� uj z BAY NEST SETTY JETTY GAVw tk M ) V ioal- c Y'V, 0 �0'450"' square, pec, appy°z 411e.0 X' - '4e &0c, 0 ao '00 co -&c �xo 6 1e'c' a�)�) co DiscricE Of)" -'cl -001'.0 c& v + LL11N 5E- 14 SW DINGS ARE EXPRESSED IN FEET AND DENOTE ELEVRTIONS EASED ON MEAN LOWER LOW WRTER. ,fps_ q6. --Aw- Id 410( 17. ) ,4'60vvt+- I FIRM xacp- &Oc cv 341 0 - &y,rn4 DRT DOCK & PIER BUILDERS, INC. HARBOR RESOURCES DIVISION 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 (949) 644-3044 / Fax (949) 723-0589 HARBOR PERMIT/APPROVAL IN CONCEPT HARBOR PERMIT/APPROVAL IN CONCEPT BY THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH as required for permit application to the South Coast Regional Commission pursuant to California Administrative Code, Sections 13210 and 13211. General Description of Proposed Development: Remove existing 724 sq. ft. dock system and 10-12" s .concrete pile. Replace with new 622 s .ft. docks stem and 3-14" sq. concrete "T" pile. Re -locate and re -use 2 existing 12" sq. concrete pile. Address number must be stenciled on at least 1 bayward facing pile. Pier conditions must be signed by applicant prior to tinal approval. Legal Description: Harbor Permit Number: 152-341 Plan Check Number: 0552-2014 Applicant: Gregory Johnson Applicant's Mailing Address: 341 E. Bay Front, Balboa Island, CA 92662 Phone Number: 949 -631 -3121 -Swift Slip I have reviewed the plans for the foregoing development including: 1. The general site plan, including any roads and public access to the shoreline. 2. The grading plan, if any. 3. The general uses and intensity of use proposed for each part of the area covered in the application. Page 1 of 2 And find V They comply with the current adopted Newport Beach General Plan, Municipal Code, Title 17 and any applicable specific or precise plans or, ❑ That a variance of exception has been approved and final. A copy of any variance, exception, conditional use permit or other issued permit is attached together with all conditions of approval and all approved plans including approved tentative tract maps. On the basis of this finding, these plans are approved in concept and said approval has been written upon said plans, signed and dated. Should Newport Beach adopt an ordinance deleting, amending or adding to the Municipal Code or other regulations in any manner that would affect the use of the property or the design of a project located thereon, this Approval In Concept shall become null and void as of the effective date of this said ordinance. In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act or 1970, and state and local guidelines adopted thereunder, this development: i Has been determined to be ministerial or categorically exempt. ❑ Has received a final Exemption Declaration or final Negative Declaration (copy attached). ❑ Has received a Final Environmental Impact Report (copy attached). All discretionary approvals legally required of Newport Beach prior to issuance of a harbor permit and a building permit have been given and are final. The development is not subject to rejection in principal by Newport Beach unless a substantial change is proposed. This concept approval in no way excuses the applicant from complying with all applicable policies, ordinances, codes and regulations of Newport Beach. See attached Special Conditions. Lisa Walters, Harbor Resou April 9, 2014 Attachments: Worksheet for Building Permit Application Drawing Pier Conditions Page 2 of 2 Print Form Worksheet for Combo Building & Solar Permit Application Comm'I r Residential City of Newport Beach - Building Division NOTE: PLAN CHECK FEES DUE AT TIME OF S I TALa a ,Mn, -, A 8 F -Building r Grading rDrainage r Elec j— Mech r Plum cuvdcBEAK�viu I„ � Project Address (Not mailing address) F_ Flood r' Fire F_ Liq r" Lan(s�`icl r No >Vlt— AST BAY FRONT Description of Work UseI Const Type F # StoriesF_ # Units (if Res)F_ Remove existing 724 square foot dock system and (10) 12" square concrete anchor pile. ep ace with new square foot Elocksystem an square concrete I pile. Re -locate and re -use 2 existing 12" square concrete guide pile. Valuation $ New/Add SF Remodel SF �— Garage/New/Add F— Material/Labor OWNER'S NAME Last Johnson First Gregory Owner's Address Owner's E-mail Address 341 East Bay Front Jacquelyn.chung@sbcglobal.net City Newport Beach State CA Zip 92662 Telephone 1949.631.3121 APPLICANT'S NAME Last Chung First Jacquelyn Applicant's Address Applicant's E-mail Address FOR SWIFT SLIP DOCK AND PIER BUILDER'S, INC. iJacquelyn.chung@sbcglobal.net City State �— Zip F_ Telephoned ARCHITECT/DESIGNER'S NAME Last F First Lic. No. Architect/Designer's Address Architect/Designer's E-mail Address City State �— Zip �— Telephone ENGINEER'S NAME Last First Lic. No.1 Engineer's Address Engineer's E-mail Address City �— State F Zip F Telephone CONTRACTOR'S NAME/COMPANY Swift Slip Dock and Pier Builder's, Inc. Lic. No. 797052 Class Contractor's Address Contractor's E-mail Address 2027 Placentia Avenue [Jacquelyn.chung@sbcglobal.net City Costa Mesa State CA Zip 92627 Telephone 949.631.3121 SETBACKS REAR SETBACKS FRONT PERMIT NO.'� SETBACKS LEFT SETBACKS RIGHT PLAN CHECK NO.� USE ZONE DEVELOPMENT NO PLAN CHECK FEES $ CITY OF NEWPORT BERCH CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH UP PER rDSoRT w ISLAPm -- i Bim' PSC IFIL OCERIV PIER WEST VICINITY MRP 'EM ?0fQrMr. aLIFUM SOUNDINGS ARE EXPRESSED IN FEET AND DENOTE ELEVATIONS BASED ON MEAN LOWER LOW WRTER. rpI �O�h b�k- 280 5 I � r1� ��12 5 ! - -- - --- - 1 lit "u P� 140 5 �._ - Ain�ch Ido �q.-�-. {35 P _ 2-�e)ocai2�q-cove 75 r E4 � - rkpW F �jq GOhGYC � M? m I s9stez� / V4Q aSef°°td° 4yz°acvlle. Q sqv ylet, -Vol C3 lip cQ��,sttvg�24 avglra`J ctete av ksystexn / S °�e or, ate °°t oath' b►!�ki1°9d . gem jalo Ds 12 SqU scivatef ;e=,ayyt ete 13 . 5 �2 II!'� D•D avd �l h vee 62 avgrra`J 4ete't 41,vate c°vct 3010 �ace•N� dock, g e tori 12 sq sgvaV �S�;�n� � 34-� E • $�ty'(rDY+I� q se eX aid vdtev DIV 4 . atea Ise ge, ,deyr A NEWPORT I� 01BEACH DOCK & PIER BUILDERS, INC. FR-IM'S WAgo4DO 6N Joe ADDRESS DATE i •22 • ZU 2027 Placentia Avenue, Costa Mesa, California 92627 (949) 631-3121 • Fax (949) 631-3122 „� 2027 Placentia Avenue, Costa Mesa, California 92627 (949) 631-3121 Fax (949) 631-3122 I pro LDkh- 2g0 5t4_ a F_PC Cilli�12- _ itYlPi:�D,D _ �� I4n tib. a h. R6 2-��lotaJ12,4-60V JV1'P� 10, 4 r ►3 3 ,o 134 42 DOCK & PIER BUILDERS, INC. Dock and Pier Builders, Inc. Contractor's License 797052 A www.swiftsliD.docks.com 2027 Placentia Avenue - Costa Mesa, CA 92627 Telephone (949) 631-3121- Fax (949) 631-3122 #13336 01/13/2014 Gregory Johnson 341 E. Bay Front Newport Beach, CA 92662 Phone: (949) 413-1343 Email: gregjohnsoni!27/�att.net ESTIMATE Remove and replace dock, pier and gangway to match drawing dated 1/13/14. Pier 1. Three (3) new concrete "T" pile. 2. 2 x 12 framing. 3. 1 x 6 Azek PVC decking attached with stainless steel screws. 4• 3x4 posts (treated) not painted 5. Milled handrails and doubled siderails painted two (2) coats white polyurethane paint. Dock 1. Super float pontoons. 2. 4 x S framing. 3. 1 x 6 Azek PVC decking. 4. 2 x 12 facia & white rubstrip. 5. Move two (2) pre -stressed concrete guide pile w/ new pile guides. 6. Six (6)14" cleats Gangway I. 3'X 24' dimensions. 2. New hinge and axle wheel combination. 3. 2 x 12 stringers. 4. Decking and Handrails to match pier. 41. Rr ip iz x� Q o v i O C�a�ly r�V� °fit C 5 oa Sao z�Q°•�. .� CpQ apk 4 ti° ��ll Q �`� •° m C O a ° a� O v o Olz C x,.� ° h �o y p P7 pa m � Q' '1-1 m o 'A ��:��-1 �Q.0 Y o h p• y v h z�vBw v ° ���Q � kop�;Qo�°�°u,•Co z�C� °�o�m�i.� o'aC "'d ,�o�u y pa"\'� �� ��Oj J °xa �'.tiahCCh��-Q �va �u�•C\Yai �Q° V Oma .OaC '7 ora `aQgF� �° rn ` aati Sn�:F�y \e Jo OO .c 0 � p \ q o va° atn�z .G �c av y �CLZ�;myF� ° o R :�om0ax ho °y t� �,•�° �\ �� ��. 3 �4aa Dov 7b'NI�J w L3 ¢ Udo LL o o m V ��d oho J • z o Ll Q7 - ro� N pN ��Q om i L, O o¢°¢Q 0 Ll ' y o :D < V'�1 C<) ¢�0�Z —V Z�zo wI O 0]�zU `aQgF� �° rn ` aati Sn�:F�y \e Jo OO .c 0 � p \ q o va° atn�z .G �c av y �CLZ�;myF� ° o R :�om0ax ho °y t� �,•�° �\ �� ��. 3 �4aa Dov 7b'NI�J Swift Slips 2027 Placentia Avenue Costa Mesa, CA 92627 Dive Works P.O. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-9773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Subject: Preliminary Eelgrass (Zostera marina) and Caulerpa (Caulerpa taxifolia) Survey Report at 341 E Bay Front, Newport Beach, California Summary: Eelgrass patches (Zoster marina) were observed in subject area noted above. Caulerpa (Caulerpa Taxifolia) was not observed in subject area noted above. This is a Preliminary Survey report as required in accordance with the Southern California Eelgrass Mitigation Policy (SCEMP) since eelgrass is widely distributed throughout Southern California Coastal and Harbor Regions. This policy has been set in place to protect marine habitats and sea grass beds that play a role in the life cycle chain for marine life to reproduce. This survey assists development projects by contractors like you to conduct activities in conjunction with best management practices (BMPs) concerning impact and management for promoting eelgrass and controlling the spread of Caulerpa. Responsible development by contractors like you helps protect these sensitive marine ecosystems, which in turn, protect our ocean resources. Thank you. If you have any questions please feel free to contact us. Respectfully, DiveWork@gmail.com (949) 759-0773 PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 1 of 18 Dive Works P.O. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com Gregory Johnson 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, California Swift Slips Dock & Pier Builders, Inc. Costa Mesa, California Preliminary Survey Report Prepared March 19, 2014 by Surveyor's Robert Wiegand Sean Donovan PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 2 of 18 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Dive Works P.O. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com CONTENTS Introduction Location Purpose Survey Method Bounding Coordinates Description of Existing Habitats and Conditions Dive Observations of 6 The Point Dock Slip Findings Discussion Conclusion List of Figures Figure 1. Survey Site Location 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 4 4 4 5 5 5 6 7 8 9 .....................................................................10 Figure 2. Dock Slip. Existing Dock System, Dive transects and eelgrass presence ...................................................................................................................11 Figure 3. Dock Slip. Proposed Dock System and Existing Eelgrass Locations .................................................................................................12 List of Tables Tablet. Tides and Currents .......................................................................................................................13 Surveys Caulerpa Survey ...................................................................................................................14 Eelgrass Survey ...................................................................................................................16 Appendixes Appendix A ...................................................................................................................18 PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 3 of 18 Dive Works P.O. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com PRE -CONSTRUCTION SURVEY Introduction 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 This is the first survey to be conducted at 341 E Bay Front (home owner Gregory Johnson) to determine the existence or absence of eelgrass, see Figure 2. Construction has not started at time of survey. Eelgrass was present in or around dock slip in survey site area. No Caulerpa was observed in survey area. Please note, as is typical of eelgrass in Newport Harbor, conditions will vary at any time. This survey was completed within the eelgrass growing season and per the Southern California Eelgrass Mitigation Policy (SCEMP). Location The customer (Gregory Johnson) at 341 E Bay Front, Newport Beach, California (see Figure 1) is proposing to replace existing Pier Approach/Platform/Gangway/Dock Slip (dock system) and pull 10 - 12" square concrete piles and replace these with 3 - 14" T Piles of Pier Approach and Platform. Also, proposed is to move 2 - 12" square concrete piles of existing Dock Slip and relocate for a proposed dock slip with different dimensions. Dimensions for proposed dock slip are different than existing Dock Slip. Existing: Pier Approach 44'x 5', Platform 12'x 12', Gangway 20'x 3', Dock Slip 15' x 20' Total over water footprint of existing dock system is 724 square feet (220.67 square meters) Proposed: Pier Approach 26'x 5', Platform 10' x 14', Gangway 24'x 3', Dock Slip 8' x 35' Total over water footprint of existing dock system is 622 square feet (189.58 square meters) An overall reduction to the existing over water footprint is existing dock system of 724 sqft to proposed dock system of 622 sqft is a reduction of 102 square feet (31.08 square meters) from existing dock system. Proposed dock system would be composed of Douglas fir. Purpose This Preliminary Survey report address' requirements under the SCEMP to determine density and extent of eelgrass for the purpose of evaluating impacts on existing natural habitat, in particular eelgrass within the waters of the United States (U.S.), in Newport Harbor, California (Refer to Figure 1). Please note that this survey report is not a scientific research paper. This report is provided to a PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 4 of 18 private individual Newport Beach, monitor eelgrass Eelgrass Report. with limited and California which this i s Dive Works 341 E Bay Front P.O. Pox 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 Newport Beach, CA (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 resources for reporting purposes to Department of Army, City of Coastal Commission to comply with the SCEMP requirement to the first survey monitoring report called the Preliminary Survey Survey Method The survey was conducted on March 19, 2014, beginning at approximately 0930 hour. The survey day was sunny with an air temperature of 65° Fahrenheit (F). Water temperature was 60° F. Pursuant to SCEMP, Section 2 for "Boat Docks and Related Structures"', surrounding potential eelgrass habitats were measured. Eelgrass was present in survey area within 1 foot of existing dock slip. In another location eelgrass is on property line. Survey conducted observed bottom composition, slope, depths, visibility, dissolved oxygen, and water temperature. The property area was delineated as 30 feet by 95 feet (2850 square feet). Divers swam parallel to the sea wall, thus 12 transects were conducted starting out from sea wall 95 feet (Refer to Figure 2). The survey was conducted with 2 divers spaced approximately 1 foot apart. Lanes ran parallel to sea wall and the width of each lane was 7 feet wide. The divers scanned approximately 1 foot on either side, covering the entire area to ensure >75% coverage of bay floor. A 1' square (0.3 meter square) grid was used to take quadrant samplings for eelgrass found. Eelgrass was found in or around gangway/dock slip. (Refer to Figure 2). The exact location of eelgrass is estimated in Figure 2. Dive transects started at end of survey area 95 feet out from sea wall and ended at sea wall. (Refer to Figure 2). These 12 dive transects found eelgrass two places noted a Patch A and Patch B. As per the SCEMP and due to the size of the dock slip, other potential eelgrass habitats were not measured due to limited size of project (2850 square feet or 868.68 meters square). (Refer to Figure 2). Bounding Coordinates Bounding Coordinates for existing eelgrass where calculated as per requirements of SCEMP item 3 due to eelgrass existing within survey area of existing dock. These coordinates are found in Appendix A. Description of Existing / Potential Habitat and Conditions According to SCEMP, Section 2, "Boat Docks and Related Structures", factors to be considered in avoiding eelgrass habitats or potential eelgrass habitats are to be avoided to the maximum extent possible. In delineating potential habitat areas according to SCEMP, Section 3, "Mitigation" includes appropriate circulation, light, sediment, slope, salinity, temperature, dissolved oxygen, depth, 1 Boat docks, ramps, gangways and similar structures should avoid eelgrass vegetated or potential eelgrass vegetated areas to the maximum extent feasible.. SCEMP 1991. PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 5 of 18 proximity to eelgrass, history of eelgrass coverage, and etc. The data in this report is compared with the data of habitat in P.L.A. Erftemeijer and K.E. van de Wolfshaar (2006) report that describes minimum tolerated, optimum range and maximum tolerated conditions for Zostera marina eelgrass and personal experience of diving in Southern California Bays. (Refer to Dive Observations and Discussion be 10W)2. Please note that in general, abiotic parameters are generally stable year around for this site location. Eelgrass patches A & B were observed (see Figure 2) and designated according to density. Since eelgrass is not uniform throughout the survey area a total of 2 eelgrass patches were designated with their respective bounding coordinates shown in Appendix A. Dive Observations of 341 E Bay Front Dock Slip Depth: Depth ranged from -2 foot at sea wall to 10 feet at end of survey area at a length of 95 feet out from sea wall. (Refer to Figure 2). Appropriate Circulation: Circulation in this particular dock is likely similar to the circulation pattern in the main channel of Newport Harbor because of proximity of this dock to main channel. Light: Within the dock slip, visibility was 1-2 feet and some particulate matter. The origin of the particulate matter is unknown, but is likely to be the same as the condition in the nearby Newport Harbor Channel. Sediment: The survey area bottom substrate was sand and dirt (sediment). Detailed analysis is not available due to lack of financial resources of the land holder and the size of the project. Salinity: Salinity would be expected to be the same in the dock slip as in Newport Harbor. Temperature: Water temperature variation ranges from 60° to 63° F in Newport Harbor. Water temperature is likely higher due to shallow waters and minimal tidal flow near back of Newport Harbor. This survey site water temperature was 60° F Dissolved oxygen: Hypoxia, which is generally defined as dissolved oxygen levels that are less than 2 to 3 mg/L and creates dead zones. Dissolved oxygen in Newport Harbor range from 4.2 mg/L to 10.3 mg/L due to several Abiotic factors. What is important here is this range is acceptable for eelgrass habitats. At time of survey dissolved oxygen was approximately 7.5 ppm using the LaMotte Dissolved Oxygen Test Kit. The data in this report is compared to the data of habitat in Recommended Options for Maximum Water Temperature Limits and Minimum Dissolved Oxygen limits at a Compliance Point for Discharges from the South Bay Power Plant in San Diego Bay, 2 P.L.A. Erftemeijer and K.E. van de Wolfshaar. May, 2006. Ecological model of the Lagoon of Venice. Part III. Seagrass Habitat Model. 3 Richard F. Ford Ph.D. April 4, 2003. Recommended Options for Maximum Water Temperature Limits and Minimum Dissolved Oxygen limits at a Compliance Point for Discharges from the South Bay Power Plant in San Diego Bay, Necessary to Protect Beneficial Uses PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 6 of 18 Dive Works P.O. Dox 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Necessary to Protect Beneficial Uses April 4, 2003, Richard F. Ford, Ph.D. 3 Please note that in general, abiotic parameters are generally stable year around for this site location. Depth: The depth of the potential eelgrass habitat measures between -2 feet and 10 feet. (Refer to Figure 2). Proximity to eelgrass coverage: The potential eelgrass habitat is located immediately adjacent to the eelgrass habitat so eelgrass has the potential to spread. Low Tide Exposure: Optimum conditions for eelgrass habitat include less than 0 to 5 percent of the time for low tide exposure. Due to the dock's location in the north east portion of Balboa island in Newport Harbor and dock system faces a north/south orientation, the dock slip does not have any low tide exposure. Slope: Slope descent is consistent as distance increases from sea wall. The slope of survey site bottom depth starts at -2 foot at the sea wall and slopes 95 feet out from sea wall, where the depth is 10 feet. The slope of the non-eelgrass portion is from sea wall to head -walk of dock slip is 15.8% and slope of eelgrass habitat is 6.6%. The contour of bottom is a slow descent from sea wall at a slightly increasing rate but paralleling the length of the sea wall the contour of bottom and its depth is uniform inside project site. Circulation: Please note that this tide information is not exact as circulation is difficult to estimate in Newport Harbor, California because there are no gauges available in that area. However, circulation would be anticipated to be similar as in the Newport Harbor. Fauna: Observation included common species of Newport Harbor mussels on piles3. Other factors effecting eelgrass growth is visibility, dissolved oxygen, and water depth. Some areas of Newport Harbor show signs of hypoxia and no marine life exists in these areas due to water run-off from the city. A complete study of dissolved oxygen in Newport Harbor has not been conducted but having dove in Newport Harbor since 1999 and observed large areas devoid of much of the marine life exhibits the need to monitor and protect our marine life is paramount in Newport Harbor. Findings Caulerpa: No caulerpa was observed (see attached Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form). Eelgrass: Eelgrass was observed within the dock slip survey site. (Refer to attached Eelgrass Survey Reporting Form and Figures 2). This Preliminary Survey did find eelgrass existing around dock structure within survey site as was 3 US Army Corps of Engineers. Biological Report 82(11.84). Life Histories and Environmental Requirements of Coastal Fishes and Invertebrates (Pacific Southwest); California Sea Mussel and Bay Mussels. PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 7 of 18 Dive Works P.O. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA. 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 expected. Since eelgrass exists in or around dock in survey area density and length of eelgrass was measured using bounding coordinates and quadrats were recorded. The bottom is fine sand and dirt which is termed sediment and silt in this report. Discussion: First, it is important to understand that SCEMP requires a level of assessment in accordance with the level of impacts, and does not require an exhaustive research report. The observational survey report should provide a baseline for evaluation of future impacts to eelgrass. The survey should provide an assessment of the survey site such that the baseline can be used to adequately assess impacts in future surveys. Second, it is important to know the history of a dock slip. The existing dock system is described above in "LOCATION" of this survey report. The existing dock system has been present for more than 10 years. The distribution of eelgrass within bay and estuarine systems is defined by numerous variables, including light, temperature, salinity, substrate, wave exposure, currents and nutrient availability. Eelgrass forms extensive meadows in soft -bottom habitats from the low intertidal to depths of about 20 feet (6 meters), and from sheltered areas to exposed coasts. In southern California, eelgrass has been reported to occur as deep as 98 feet (30 meters). Optimum temperatures for eelgrass growth seem to lie between 50 and 68°F (10 and 20°C). However, eelgrass is known to survive with a lower tolerance level of 21 °F (-6°C) and an upper level of 104.9°F (40.5°C). Eelgrass is a euryhaline species (able to live in a wide range of salinities) that is capable of growing near stream mouths when the water is fresh at low tide, but does not grow in persistent fresh water. A salinity range of i10 to 30 parts per thousand is optimum for growth.4 In general, low circulation (<5 cm/second) to medium circulation (20 — 40 cm/second) is considered an optimum range of circulation for eelgrass to grows. Circulation may increase in the main Newport Harbor channel, which could account for lack of eelgrass in and around the dock in the survey area. The outer portion of the dock slips, although there are likely other causes for this lack of eelgrass in the potential eelgrass habitat of the dock, which cannot be fully analyzed due to limited resources of the customer. However, circulation would be expected to be suitable to support eelgrass. Reduction in light due to turbidity has been identified as a major cause of the loss of sea -grasses worldwide (Shepherd et al., 19896; Green and Short, 20031). Particulate matter in Newport Harbor 4 California Department of Fish and Game. State of Fisheries Report (2008). 5 California Department of Fish and Game. State of Fisheries Report (2008). 6 Shepherd, S.A., A.J. McComb, D.A. Bulthuis, V. Neverauskas, D.A. Steffensen and R. West, 1989. Decline of seagrasses. In: A.W.D. Larkum, A.J. McComb and S.A. Shepherd (Eds.) Seagrasses: A Treatise on the Biology of Seagrasses with Special Reeference to the Australian Region. Elsevier, North Holland, pp. 346387 7 Green, E.P. and F.T. Short, 2003. World Atlas of Seagrasses. Prepared by the UNEP World Conservation Monitoring Centre. University of California Press, Berkeley, USA, 298 pp. PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 8 of 18 Dive Works P.O. sox 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 is high, but is likely equal in all areas of the dock slip. Visibility in Newport Harbor is low due to an increased density of particulates in the sea water. Low visibility has effect on sunlight penetration into water and is a limiting factor for eelgrass existing at deeper than 12-15' depths. This measurement varies throughout Newport Harbor. Sediment is a general term, which in this case is used in describing Newport Harbor bottom make up which sediment is in this case made up of sand and dirt. No observation of clay or boulders or gravel has been noted while diving throughout Newport Harbor except around jetty entrance areas or the exception of but a handful of docks. There is bedrock that does exist and sometimes some form of obstruction whether rocks/boulders/refuse at varying depths roughly averaging 20 feet below bottom existing slowing down pile installations. This bedrock does not appear to have a visible impact on the surface of the bottom of Newport Harbor water ways. Existing dock system (341 E Bay Front) has not changed more than 10 years now. Abiotic Conditions per SCEMP that promote for eelgrass to grow in a habitat are present in good order in this survey site. Conclusion Eelgrass exists in or around existing Dock Slip at 341 E Bay Front, Newport Harbor, California. Existing and proposed docks as shown in Figures 2 and 3 show eelgrass Patch B to be approximately 1 foot from both existing and proposed dock slips. Existing dock slip has two piles at head -walk. Proposal for new dock slip is to pull these 2 existing 12" square piles and re -locate them in different locations. The Proposed dock slip would be "I" shape and head -walk pile would be opposite eelgrass Patch B and at least 10 feet from eelgrass Patch B. End of proposed dock would have a second pile re -located approximately 20 feet away from eelgrass Patch B. Eelgrass Patch A is actually 1 eelgrass Turion 4" to 6" long and would be approximately 20' feet from re -located head - walk pile. Eelgrass Patch B is approximately 4' x 3'. Density is approximately 3-6 Turions sqft. Length of eelgrass is 4"-12". At the time of this survey eelgrass exists in or around proposed dock slip. Depth ranged from -2 foot at sea wall to 10 feet just past end of dock 85 feet from sea wall respectively and survey area extended out 95 feet from sea wall. Dimensions of existing and proposed dock systems are describing above in section "LOCATION" and in Figures 2 & 3. Proposed dock system to be constructed of Douglas Fir wood. This Preliminary survey was conducted in accordance with SCEMP guidelines to determine eelgrass impacts to this project site. Best Management Practices (BMP) were employed in the construction of this new dock slip. These surveys are used to determine the continued healthy life cycles of marine habitats in our oceans and maintaining navigation channels for boaters. PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 9 of 18 -F, wo'k Finurp 1- Survev Site Location Dive Works P.O. Dox 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 10 of 18 Figure 2. Dock Slip. Existing Dock System, Dive transects and eE elgrass presence. U6Qi > to 1 ;Fee + . VAVVWDeep '/}{►�J�jrr 4' x 3' patch. P from the dock 0 3-6 turions per sq foot 4-12 inches Feet X Deep', p Date: 3/19114 Time: 0930 Air: 65 F Water: 60 F Vis: 1-2 Feet 02: 7.5 ppm rDive Transects - totall 2Transects Depth 75 Feet Deep 30.0 2 PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 11 of 18 Patch A Patch B 5 ' q p 1 turion on y Feet �„ 50 ! 4-6 inches Deep; On property p q line directly 3 across from Feet i1 dock corner Deep rDive Transects - totall 2Transects Depth 75 Feet Deep 30.0 2 PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 11 of 18 Patch A Patch B woR Dive Works P.Q. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Figure 3. Dock Slip. Proposed Dock System and Existing Eelgrass Locations Cy 1 W��L Y LIQ �� ! 4 g p0wd to 5,...�,.. 17- ° 341 F.kr�- PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 12 of 18 hm U GSE INC SEikN", Dive Works P.O. Dox 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Table 1 below depicts tide at + 3.0' ft MLLW during the survey. Additionally, tidal variations are also included. NEWPORT BAY ENTRANCE, CORONA, DEL MAR, CA Stat onld: Daily Tide Prediction in Feet ,. 5.56 5.60 Time cone_ LST;LDT Datum: IILLVI = 4,56 0 4,66 Date Day Time Hgt 7 3.56 03.15 tied 05:31 AM 0.26 L 3.66 03/19 t%'ed 11:36 .AM 4.03 H' t 2.56 03/19 Vied 05:13 PM 0.96 Lm 2.69 03+19 teed 11:36 PM 0 5.1 H " 1.59 03/20 Thu 06:18,:'M 0,33 L ,1.86 03,+'20 Thu 12:24 RM 40 3,56 H .M 9.59 9 90 :Predicted HL - Dive Time ', -- f L 0930-h( .-. f� March 19, 2014 _ � _ i S .--- -.- 03120 Thu 0 5: 42 PM 1.36 L 03/19 03/19 93/19 93/19 63/26 03/29 12an 6an 12pn 6pn 12an 6an Date/Tine €LST/LDT? PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 13 of 18 ------ ----- 03/20 03/26 03/21 12pn 6pn 12an Dive Works P.O. Box 21236 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form This form is required to be submitted for any surveys conducted for the invasive exotic algae, (Caulerpa) which is required to be conducted under federal and/or state permits and authorizations issued by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Coastal Commission, and/or Regional Water Quality Boards (Regions 8 & 9). The form has been designed to assist to identify and control any potential impacts of the authorized actions on the spread of Calupera. Surveys required to be conducted for this species are subject to modification through publication of revisions to the Calupera survey policy. It is incumbent upon the authorized permittee to ensure that survey work is following the latest protocols. For further information on these protocols, contact: Robert Hoffman, National Marine Fisheries Service, 562-980-4043, or William Paznokas, California Department of Fish & Game, 858-467-4218. This survey is valid for (60) sixty days from March to August and valid for (90) ninety days from August to October. For information regarding this survey please contact Robert Wiegand, Dive Works Diving Service at 949-759-0773. Required Information: PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 14 of 18 341 E Bay Front Site Name: Newport Beach, CA Robert Wiegand Survey Contact: (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@Gmaii.com Permit Reference: (ACOE Permit No., CCC Permit No.) Hydrographic System: Newport Harbor (bay, estuary, lagoon, or harbor) Specific Location: (UTM, Lat./Long., datum, accuracy level, attach electronic survey area map if possible) Yes, Caulerpa was found at this site and Was Caulerpa Detected: Has been contacted on date. xxxx No, Caulerpa was not found at this site Description of Permitted Work: (describe briefly the work to be Existing dock system to be replaced by a proposed dock system with conducted at the site under the different dimensions and pile replacement. permits identified above) PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 14 of 18 Dive Works P.O. Dox 21238 Long Beach, CA 98881 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form (Cont.) Description of Site: (describe the physical and biological conditions within the survey area at the time Bottom is sediment composed of fine of the survey and provide Depth range: -2'-10' sand and dirt. insight into variability, if known. Please provide units for all numerical information). Substrate type: Sediment is sand and dirt Tempe ature: 65 f Air 60 f Water Dissolved Oxygen: 7.5 ppm Salinity Newport Harbor salinity Dominant flora: Eelgrass Dominant fauna: Common Bay mussels Exotic species encountered None - Caulerpa Other site description notes: Description of Survey Effort: (please describe the surveys conducted including type of survey (SCUBA, remote video, Survey date and time Survey conducted using SCUBA etc.) and survey methods period: >75% area including bottom employed, date of work, surveyed. and survey density DATE: March 19, 2014 Refer to the above report. (estimated percentage of TIME :0930 AM the bottom actually viewed). Describe any limitations encountered during the survey efforts. Horizontal visibility in water: 1-2 feet Survey type and methods: SCUBA Survey Personnel: Robert Wie and, Sean Donovan Survey density: Survey limitations: None noted Other Information: (use this space to provide any additional information or Refer to the above report. references to attached materials such as maps, reports, etc. Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form (version 1.2, 10131104) PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 15 of 18 'SG ;s Qiy,�NG 5€'R`'ttCk� Dive Works P.O.o 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 is ! 9 759-0773 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Eelgrass Survey Reporting Form This form is required to be submitted for any surveys conducted for Eelgrass which is required to be conducted under federal and/or state permits and authorizations issued by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Coastal Commission and required for review by Marine Bureau and Planning Department. The form has been designed to assist in identifying eelgrass while ensuring that the required information is consistently documented. Surveys required to be conducted for this species are subject to modification through publication of revisions to the Eelgrass survey policy. It is incumbent upon the authorized permittee to ensure that survey work is following the latest protocols. For further information on these protocols, contact: Robert Hoffman, National Marine Fisheries Service, 562-980-4043, or William Paznokas, California Department of Fish & Game, 858-467-4218. This survey is valid for (60) sixty days from March to August and valid for (90) ninety days from August to October. For information regarding this survey please contact Robert Wiegand, Dive Works Diving Service at 949-759-0773. Re uired Information: Site Name: 341 E Bay Front Newport Harbor, CA Robert Wiegand Survey Contact: (949) 759-0773 DiveWork Gmail.com Permit Reference: (ACOE Permit No., CC Permit No.) Hydrographic System: (bay, estuary, lagoon, or Newport Harbor harbor Specific Location: (UTM, Lat./Long., datum, accuracy level, attach See Appendix A electronic survey area map if possible) UTM = Zone 11 Hemisphere N. NAD 83 XXX Eelgrass within 15' of project / disposal site Was Eelgrass Detected: Eelgrass within 15-30' of project / disposal sit No eelgrass in project / disposal site Description of Permitted Work: (describe briefly the work to be Existing dock system to be replaced by a proposed dock system with conducted at the site under the different dimensions and pile replacement. permits identified above PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 16 of 18 Of�'l7V�i SET2�''�f'G. Dive Works P.O. Dox 21238 Long Beach, GA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 Eelgrass Survey Reporting Form (Cont.) Description of Site: (describe the physical and biological conditions within the survey area at the time of Depth range: -2'-10' feet Bottom is sediment composed the survey and provide of fine sand and dirt. insight into variability, if known. Please provide units for all numerical information). Substrate type: Sediment is fine sand and dirt Temperature: 65 f Air 60 f Water Dissolved Oxygen 7.5 pprn Salinity: Newport Harbor salinity Dominant flora: Eel rass Dominant fauna: Common mussels Exoticspecies encountered none Other site description notes: Description of Survey Effort: (please describe the surveys conducted including type of survey (SCUBA, Survey date and time remote video, etc.) and period: Survey conducted using survey methods employed, SCUBA date of work, and survey DATE: March 2014 >75% area including bottom density (estimated TIME :0930 AMM surveyed. percentage of the bottom actually viewed). Describe any limitations encountered during the survey efforts. Horizontal visibility in water: 1-2feet Survey type and methods: SCUBA Survey Personnel: Robert Wiegand, Sean Donovan Survey density: None noted Survey limitations: None noted Other Information: (use this space to provide any additional information or references to attached materials such as maps, reports, etc. Eelgrass Survey Reporting Form (April 2009) PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 17 of 18 Appendix A Dive Works P.O. Box 21238 Long Beach, CA 90801 (949) 759-0773 DiveWork@gmail.com 341 E Bay Front Newport Beach, CA Preliminary Survey March 14, 2014 EELGRASS SPECIFIC LOCATIONS Square Feet Patch Latitude and Universal Transmercator Square Meters Longitude Zone 11 Hemisphere N. NAD 83 Density A 33.608531, -117.888258 Easting 417595.6 Northing 3719105.6 1 Turions - 4" to 6" long 4'x 3' square feet 33.608502, Easting 417602 0.4m x 0.3m square B -117.888189 Northing 3719102.4 3 - 6 Turions - 4" - 12" long PRELIMINARY SURVEY Page 18 of 18 9�ZFOK�� HARBOR RESOURCES DIVISION 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 (949) 644-3034 / Fax (949) 723-0589 Special Conditions April 9, 2014 C With reference to the plans currently under consideration at the above referenced address to reconfigure or modify the dock system or bulkhead, the following conditions will now be in effect: 1. The project proponent is aware of the Harbor Permit Policies (Council Policy H-1) and Title 17 of the City of Newport Beach Municipal Code. The project proponent understands that the above referenced structure(s) is under the purview of these Policies and Codes. 2. Any future work on the above mentioned structure(s) requires permits with the City of Newport Beach and any other applicable agencies. Painting and work considered to be cosmetic in nature does not require a permit. 3. The conditions set forth in this document pertain to the proposed dock system and/or bulkhead under consideration. Any future modifications or alterations to the dock system and/or bulkhead may require new conditions which may override or change these conditions. These conditions supersede all past conditions associated with this property. 4. Only marine oriented uses are allowed on the pier, pier platform, gangway and float. Patio furniture, plants etc ... are not permitted. 5. In accordance with Municipal Code 10.08.030 A. the project proponent shall obtain the proper permits for equipment and materials storage. "Except as otherwise provided in this section, no person shall use any public street, sidewalk, alley or parkway or other public property for the purpose of storing or displaying any equipment, materials or merchandise, or any other commercial purpose. B. Public streets, sidewalks, alleys, or parkways may be used for the purpose of selling, storing, or displaying any equipment, material, merchandise or for other commercial purposes in the following cases: ... For the temporary storage of construction equipment or material provided a permit is issued pursuant to Chapter 12.62 of this Code and the storage is consistent with provisions of the Uniform Building Code." 6. The project shall be implemented in conformance with the Local Coastal Program - Coastal Land Use Plan. Page 1 of 2 7. In accordance with Municipal Code 10.28.040 the following noise regulations apply: "A. Weekdays and Saturdays. No person shall, while engaged in construction, remodeling, digging, grading, demolition, painting, plastering or any other related building activity, operate any tool, equipment or machine in a manner which produces loud noise that disturbs, or could disturb, a person of normal sensitivity who works or resides in the vicinity, on any weekday except between the hours of seven a.m. and six -thirty p.m., nor on any Saturday except between the hours of eight a.m. and six p.m. B. Sundays and Holidays. No person shall, while engaged in construction, remodeling, digging, grading, demolition, painting, plastering or any other related building activity, operate any tool, equipment or machine in a manner which produces loud noise that disturbs, or could disturb, a person of normal sensitivity who works or resides in the vicinity, on any Sunday or any federal holiday." 8. Your side property lines extend in the water along their same bearing. Vessels shall not encroach upon the neighbor's property on either side. 9. Vessels may not extend beyond the end of the fingers by more than the width of its beam except as otherwise noted in the Municipal Code. 10. The maximum beam of a vessel that is permitted to side -tie to the northernmost side of the float is 14'. 11. The maximum beam of a vessel that is permitted to side -tie to the southernmost side of the float is 8 '. Lisa Walters, Harbor Resources Date Applicant Signature Print Name Date Joint Pier Applicant Signature (if applicable) Print Name Date Page 2 of 2 HARBOR PERMIT TRANSFER APPLICATION 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 949-644-3044 **Date of Applicaton: I? Permit Number: 152.,-3q I **Property Address:3 1 F.,' �:, 1 -- e **Buyer's Names: "-� i Billing Address: Telephone No.:(�y��+)( Buyer's Signatures:, **Seller's Names: Seller's Signatures:,) ryxi�'! Joint Owner Signature: L L/ **Escrow Company: f-aQ"M CSC , Phone# Y 01 . CoY Lj **Address Za) A)CWRplZTC6i 2Ne. ,,SU- r . %V•9; CA 172660 **Escrow Number: **Fax #: q�q.(��y �g3g Closing Date (Estimate)::{-/ . * *STARRED ITEMS MUST BE COMPLETE TO BEGIN THE PROCESS. Inspection Date: 5(3 t 1 (a Reinspection Date: Fee Paid: � es Qheck No: 5D -CS Application Complete: Harbor Resources Signature/Date Special Conditions: This permit is revocable by the City Council in accordance with Title 17 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code. HARBOR PERMIT TRANSFER APPLICATION 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 949-644-3044 **Date of Applicatoni: 5.1-7:12 Permit Number: **Property Address: 3y ` F L�: T77 **Buyer's Names: G `Or,,YAW- A N Billing Address: Telephone No.:rW) �-,7/,! 1 n � gj%7_"'ag_ 3Lr Buyer's Signatures: **Seller's Names; Seller's Signatures: AMD $'v i RETUM Joint Owner Signature: **Escrow Company: FgCM ESCR0lA) Phone# **Address 1 Na) RTCEA�1_I�2•.5u3T7 /� MS./ CR 1726,60 **Escrow Number: aU93'I3--MM **Fax #: N3- yl/3g38 Closing Date (Estimate): -7.jY-77&, t2 * *STARRED ITEMS MUST BE COMPLETE TO BEGIN THE PROCESS. Inspection Date: Reinspection Date: Fee Paid: Check No: Application Complete: . Harbor Resources Signature/Date Special Conditions: This permit is revocable by the City Council in accordance with Title 97 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code. SIGN AND RETUR'. May 31, 2012 Freedom Escrow Fax# 949.644.3938 Re: Pier Permit# 152-341 341 E. Bay Front Escrow #049343 -MM Dear Freedom Escrow, CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH 829 Harbor Island Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92659 949-644-3044/Fax 949-723-0589 The City of Newport Beach has inspected the above pier and found it to meet City standards. Once we receive the application signed by the buyer the pier will be transferred. Thanks for your help and if you require further assistance in this matter please call 949.644.3044. Sincerely, u�sa A&I-s Lisa Walters Harbor Resources Division 0 (o w W (D �o T (D m o 7 Cl) (D (D "O O N PO O O W C: l< CD (D 0 W O v 7 Q C- M N n O C- 0 O W O 0 m (D CD �_ C m W r cn `5 =T O (D 0 (D h v W O v Q 6 (7 O O v 0 W 5' v O Q r - v C7 cn D CD (D 0 n -n C) m C) v (D cQ o' (D T m m 0 0 m W n 2 0 0 c Z 0 0 co m 0 0 3 n D m N m O O N 1—' U1 N O OD INSPECTION FOR HaFbor Resources Department Date: 12:5) 12 1 . Inspection Requested By: --A'1:)CL_ Inspector: Pier Address:-�- Pier Transfer GFI Present Anti -Siphon / Backflow Present Other Comments Eelgrass Reinspection Yes Need None Needed Yes Need Date Time F] Eelgrass Within 15' of Project Eelgrass Within 15' - 30' of Project F1No Eelgrass in Project Area Pump Out Pier Location Yes No Operational Recommended Action Encroachmenet Address of Complaining Party Boat Description CF Number Location on Dock Comments / Observations Other Request Map Output Page 1 of 1 http://www6. city.newport-beach. ca.us/servleticom. esri. esrimap. Esrimap? S erviceName=n... 05/29/2012 r=1V== W-1010 0 1 ESCROW Phone (949) 644-3939 • 1200 Newport Center Drive, Ste. 180 • Newport Beach, CA 92660 • Fax: (949) 644-3938 www.freedomescrow.com Date: September 18, 2012 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 Dear Sirs: Escrow No. 049343 -MM Re: 341 East Bay Front, Newport Beach, CA 92662 To assist us in handling the above numbered escrow, we enclose for your review the items indicated below. Signed Pier Transfer Card We appreciate having the opportunity of working with you. If there are any items you want furnished to you, please let us know so that we may provide them to you when we receive them. If you have any questions, please call us. 'n erely, el Migliore Escrow Officer z X. 1 \� - m o r U)z om c o z S a3I v "� � �, 0 n z �S z C: 0 z O n ' o f r o a �7 D o `ncoP \1 D 1 ma rr r O z z m` 0 3 O O 0 `z �y m m O ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ 11 ❑ ❑ ❑ � N X. 1 \� - m o r n � v \ m �x cn � �, 0 A z �S z C: N "1 N p D d QX , 0\ ' m� O O V `ncoP \1 D 1 7 0 rr r O z z m` 0 3 O O 0 `z A 3 T T > w m O z m Ln A T m z X11 m m S3 i Zvi O 0 N M a MemoNEWPORT TO: FROM: SUBJECT: CITY OF BEACH DATE: COPIES TO: SIGNATURE W, O m z m m O m D n 2 n D r c z R c z n D r O 0 m I c L c r L C O X 0 D z n x m T � LD —I r m W � 4. N F - i of 4. LL IL �� o LL W w "~ w 'z z d W d INO m- O U N o O m Q J W m N z�fl 3 U w w � O U Z w LL €` Z y..,. o z w W o O w '� ❑ El El E ❑ ❑ Z a O } Q m w w U mr ,✓`, m Owe', o...,z., Z U 2 > 3 ~ g o p o O `•` LL O w `. s� *� ". Z Z b ZOZ U t s m I - M2 Z u r ms's m n o w a� 1'.i 0 Q CL ¢ LU N z LL O Ir N F - i fr w "~ w d W E.. Q � N o O J � a Z O U 1- Z w '� ❑ El El E ❑ ❑ �� o .. mr x U = > 3 ~ g z p o O `•` a u a z o w `N w va'i W d r Z