HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-02-1985 - AgendaCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
PARKS, BEACHES AND RECREATION COMMISSION
• REGULAR MEETING TO BE HELD TUESDAY, APRIL 2, 1985
CITY HALL COUNCIL CHAMBERS
7:00 P.M.
AGENDA
I. PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1. Call to Order
2. Roll Call'
3. Approval of Minutes - Meeting of March 5, 1985
4. Adoption of Agenda
II. ACTION ITEMS
5. Request to Establish a Senior Citizens Commission
(Communication and report attached.)
6. Request for Review of Policy for Swimming Area in
• West Newport (Request and Resolution attached.)
III. PUBLIC COMMENTS
IV. DISCUSSION ITEMS
7. Beach Rest1oom Study (Report to be handed out at meeting.)
8. Tree Retention Policies Review (City Council Policy I -9 attached.)
9. Recreation'Division (Report attached.)
10. Park and Street Tree Division (Report attached.)
11. OASIS
V. SPECIAL, URGENT OR LAST MINUTE ITEMS
VI. ADJOURNMENT
•
Mot'
Sec ed
Ayes
E
Item No. 3
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
n Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission
o
2 March 5, 1985
G)�n` City Council Chambers 7 o_m_
INDEX
Call to Order
Roll Call
Approval of
Minutes
Adoption of
Agenda
Ex- Officio Member Present: Ronald A. Whitley, Director
Staff Present: Tom Line, Recreation Supt.
Dottie Flohr, Secretary
I. PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Item #1
The meeting of the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission
was called to order at 7:06 P.M.
Item #2
Roll call was taken. Commissioners Cohen, de Boom, Hopkins,
Springer and Wolfe were present. Commissioners Capretz and
King were absent.
x
Item #3
x
x
x
x
Motion was made by Springer and seconded by Wolfe to approve
the minutes of the February 5, 1985 meeting. Unanimous.
Item #4
The agenda was adopted as presented with the addition of the
abutement situation on City property in the beach areas and
the request from the Mariners Library for a proposed multi-
purpose room.
II. COMMISSION COMMUNITY SERVICE AWARD PRESENTATIONS
Ron Whitley reported the Commission presents the Community
Service Awards to those individuals who have contributed
their efforts to the community in an outstanding and benefi-
cial manner. The first group of recipients were from the
Oasis Senior Center. The second group honored were the
Presidents of the Friends of the Theatre Arts Center,
followed by Fran Wynn of Corona del Mar High School and
Woody Smith of Irvine Coast Country Club.
Mr. Whitley gave a brief presentation while Chair Cohen
presented the awards,. Commissioner de Boom also pointed out
Mr. Smith's valuable service to Hoag Hospital on behalf of
the Irvine Coast Country Club.
INDEX
Call to Order
Roll Call
Approval of
Minutes
Adoption of
Agenda
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission
o
Page 2
cc� City Council Chambers 7 o.m. INDEX
III. ACTION ITEMS
Item #5 - Newport Beach Nautical Museum Request to Relocate
Newport
Beach
Temporary Building on 15th Street Propert
Nautical
Motion
x
Mr. Whitley gave a brief review of the Newport Beach Nauti-
Museum -
Seconded
x
cal Museum's request to locate temporary quarters on 15th
Request
Ayes
x
x
Street. He added that both the American Legion and the
Nay
x
Central Newport Beach Association have been notified con-
cerning the Museum's proposed plans. Staff has no objection
to the 15th Street location since the area gets a small
amount of use and there would be no impact on the Department
s
activities. The only element of concern might be in the
areas of parking and traffic congestion.
This matter is brought before the Commission for conceptual
approval. Should it pass, the City Attorney would then
proceed with an Agreement which would come back to the
•
Commission and, upon their approval, be transmitted to
Council as
a recommendation.
Following discussion concerning the sound structure of the
temporary building and how this move might affect the
Marinapark situation, Chair Cohen opened the meeting to
public testimony.
Mr. Terry Welsh, 1301 Oxford Lane, addressed the Commission
on behalf of the Museum. He stated that if the City's
temporary building could not be used, they would make other
arrangements. They are interested in the site location to
be used for an interim period until such time Marinapark
is developed on an overall basis.
Mr. Welsh answered questions and explained their publicity
plans and exactly what would be contained in the Museum,
i.e., nautical art, models, movies, etc. He added that they
would be responsible for moving costs, upkeep, utilities,
etc.
Commissioner de Boom moved the Commission approve the concep
for the Newport Beach Nautical Museum locating at 15th
Street for a period of three years. Seconded by Wolfe.
Motion passes.
•
Mr. Whitley will contact the Central Newport Beach Associa-
tion and the American Legion concerning the Commission's
decision.
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
arks, Beaches & Recreation Commission
Page 3
City Council Chambers 7 p.m. INDEX
Item #6 - Request from Friends of Oasis to Meet with the
Request
Commission
From
'Friends of
Ron Whitley reported a letter from Dick Sweet of the Friends
Oasis
of Oasis was included in the agenda ,packet concerning their
desire for closer contact with the Commission. Mr. Whitley
suggested the following be considered: (1) They meet before
the entire Commission; (2) They meet with a Commission sub-
committee; or (3) They meet as a part of the agenda on the
Study Session.
Mr. Whitley also pointed out that the Friends of Oasis are
represented at their Board meetings by a staff person,
namely, Judy O'Shaughnessy, and that the Commission
designates a Commission member, Diana Springer, as a liaison
to the Board and other meetings. In addition, there is
always an open item on the agenda for the Friends.
Chair Cohen opened the meeting to public testimony and Dick
•
Sweet, 1st Vice President of the Friends of Oasis, addressed
the Commission. Mr. Sweet said the Friends want more
communication accomplished in the easiest and.most mutually
agreeable manner. They haven't presented their plans and
proposals in the past and would like to do so in the future.
Following questions and discussion, it was determined the
Friends would attend the Study Sessions twice a year.
Commissioner de Boom also suggested the Friends appoint a
liaison person to attend the Commission meetings.
Item #7 - Request to Install Public Lockers at Newport Pier
Request to
Install
Motion
x
Ron Whitley reported that the request to install public
Public
Seconded
x
lockers at Newport Pier was deferred to this meeting from
Lockers
Ayes
x
x
the February 5 meeting. The applicant, Q.T. Industries,
Nay
x
and the manufacturer were present to answer any questions.
A draft of the License Agreement was included in the
Commission's packet for their review.
Commissioner Hopkins recommended that on Page 1, Item 1
under Exclusive Grant, should include "at the premises" on
line 10 following.... storage lockers. On Page 3, Item 11,
the last sentence should read the "Operator" rather than
the "Proprietor."
Commissioner Springer recommended the responsibilities of
the locker company be spelled out when the new restrooms are
installed: Springer also recommended a security deposit or
bond be posted. Mr. Whitley will bring both matters to the
attention of the City Attorney.
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission
o
� 2 Page 4
City Council Chambers 7 e_m_ INDEX
"k - -
In addition, Commissioner Springer recommended that on
Page 3, Item 11, it should be mentioned that the Operator
make periodic checks of the lockers and state what procedure
should be followed concerning lost keys, etc. She emphasize
the Agreement should make clear the obligation of the
Operator within a reasonable period of time.
Following discussion regarding number of lockers and cost
to the public, Chair Cohen opened the meeting to public
testimony. Mr. Don Vinding from Q.T. Industries addressed
the Commission. He said lockers were installed by him at
the Balboa 'Pier in July, 1984 and have presented no problems
Should the proposed lockers at the Newport Pier become a
problem, he would pull them out.
A representative from American Locker Company, the
manufacturer, addressed the Commission and presented the
locker unit to the Commission. He covered details such as
height, depth, composition, etc., and gave a brief back-
•
ground of his company.
Following discussion, Ron Whitley suggested the Commission
could (1) Approve-the draft with minor revisions and
transmit to Council; or (2) Transmit to the Specific Area
Committee that the City Council will be considering this
Agreement and any comments should be directed to Council;
or (3) Notify the Specific Area Committee as to the concept
and that any future development in the area should take
this into consideration.
Commissioner de Boom motioned 25 lockers be installed from
March 15 to October 31, 1985 with the provision the matter
be reviewed thereafter. Motion fails.
Following further discussion, Commissioner Hopkins moved
the Commission recommend to Council the proposed draft
agreement be approved subject to the comments received from
staff and finalized by the City Attorney and the agent of
the Applicant. Commissioner Wolfe amended the motion to
state that the Operator reapply when the new building is
constructed. Seconded by Springer. Motion passes
IV. PUBLIC COMMENTS
•
None.
Motion
Seconded
Ayes
r�
U
n
f,J
CITY OF NEWPORT 'BEACH
Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission
o
Page 5
11101< City Council Chambers 7 o.m. INDEX
V. DISCUSSION ITEMS
Item #8 - Request From Harbor View Community Association
Request From
to Utilize a Portion of Buffalo Hills Park
Harbor View
Community
x
Ron Whitley reported a letter from Robert Scott of Harbor
Association
x
View Community Association was received and.included in the
x
x
x
agenda packet'. The public property in question can be
declared surplus and sold to the homeowners association or
the homeowners association can apply for an encroachment
permit.
Following questions and a brief discussion, Springer moved
their request be denied. Seconded by Hopkins. Unanimous.
Mr. Whitley will transmit the Commission's decision to the
Association.
Item #9 - 1985 -86 Budget Progress Report
1985 -86 '
Budget
Ron Whitley thanked the Commissioners for meeting with the
City Manager on the 1985 -86 budget. He passed out the
proposed capital improvement list that is being presented
to Council.
Item #10 - Use of School Facilities
Use of
School
Ron Whitley reviewed the history of the use of school
Facilities
facilities, the joint powers agreement, and the school
district's policies and procedures. He noted that Tom Line
prepared a comprehensive background along with recommenda-
tions for the Commission to review.
Mr. Whitley explained that originally the City maintained
the school grounds in exchange for the use of their
facilities; however, since this did not prove effective,
fees are now charged for school facility usage. One
problem is that the school district gives youth oriented
groups top priority so that our adult programs are given
last consideration. In summary, money and accessibility
are the two foremost problems.
Mr. Whitley pointed out that North Ford Park will give us
an adult facility when it is completed in a couple years.
In the meantime, he suggested a concerted effort be made to
the school district to acquire the gym and athletic fields
at Lincoln School in.order to guarantee programming at this
location.
Following discussion, it was decided that staff will continu
to study the matter and bring back several obtainable
recommendations to solve the main problems.
•
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission
o
Page 6
2
City Council Chambers 7 o.m. INDEX
Item #11 - Recreation Division
Recreation
Division
Tom Line reported the spring brochure is out and mail -in'
registration starts March 8.
Item #12 - Park and Street Tree Division
Park and
Street Tree
None.
Division
Item #13 - OASIS
OASIS
None.
VI. SPECIAL, URGENT OR LAST MINUTE ITEMS
Commissioner Springer said she felt the Commission should
voice their support on the encroachment issue concerning
beach property owners. Mr. Whitley said the Public Works
Department is doing a survey on this matter and he will
keep the Commission informed on their progress.
Ron Whitley reported that the Mariners Library had requested
to fund another building so they can use the existing multi-
purpose room. Judy Clark is asking her Board to designate
two Board members to work with two Parks, Beaches and
Recreation Commissioners to re- initiate this project. It
was decided the two members from this Commission would be
Cohen and Wolfe.
VII. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business, the Parks, Beaches and
Recreation Commission adjourned at 9:55 P.M.
w
Dottie F l o hr; Secretary
E
•
Item No. 5
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
Parks, Beaches and Recreation Department
DATE: March 26, 1985
TO: Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission
FROM: Parks, Beaches and Recreation Director
SUBJECT: Senior Citizens Commission
Recommendation:
Recommend to the City Council that the establishment of a Senior Citizens
Commission not be pursued.
Discussion:
The need and objectives as identified in the attached material from Friends of
OASIS request to establish a Senior Commission can best be discussed by pointing
out the following:
1. The Friends of OASIS do most of the things identified in the
proposal.
2. The Parks, Beaches-and Recreation Commission has a liaison
member who interrelates with the Friends of OASIS.
3. As determined at our last meeting, a periodic session with
Friends of OASIS will improve communication.
4. The "Friends of OASIS" as currently operating has significant
political awareness and has as much influence as a Commission.
5. The "Friends of OASIS" .relationship as identified in Council
Policy I -17 (attached) clearly defines responsibilities and
objectives for senior program development. By creating a new
Commission the work of the "Friends of OASIS" would be altered
and diluted to a point of unproductivity and confusion.
Our interest as a Department and staff toward seniors in Newport Beach has been a
positive, constructive effort to develop facilities and programs of high quality.
We have been successful under our current method of operation and do not feel a
change in the arrangements would be beneficial.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
L'dgdr Williams, President
O.K. Englund, Ist Vice President
Dick Sweet, 2nd Vice President
Howard Jadwin, Recording Secretary
Fern Torrance, Corresponding Secretary i
Mau Hall, Treasurer
Edith Nelson, Assistant Treasurer
Garnet Burrick
llud Ueecaberg
Giusti Howard
Mcilc Hununel
Baincy Lurks
Joe Marucal
Russ Miller
Anthony Monte
Eleanor Newman
Brenda Russ
Jiur Sawyer C
Alex Schvare
Evelyn Sherwood
� Arulabclll Webb m
P.O. BOX B29
CORONA DEL MAR, CA 92625
TELEPHONE: 759 -9171
--- • - - - - -- -• -• - March 13, 1985
Newport Beach City Council
3300 Newport B1Vd.
Newport Beach, Ca. 92663
Dear Mayor Mauer and Members of the City Council:
Julia OShuughncssy, Ex- Officio C
ADVISORY BOARD
D DuuleI G. Aldrich
tblyewoman Marian Bergeson
s Blonrquist
V!
William Blurock
Dr. Allen Cottle
s
Dr. R.I. (Sul) Curren
Walter Gerken
L
Mayor Pro -Teal, Evelyn Hart
Mayer Jackie Heather
rr1
Louis lleilig
1
Edgar It. Hill
1
Chns Hopper
A. Grant Howard
C
VincentJolgensen
Peter Kremer
Lheille Kuehn
John Lusk
John Macmb
Michael Manahan
Doreen Marshall
Robert McCurdy
Supervisor Thomas F. Riley
James Roosevelt
Paul Ryckoff
Judge Calvin P. Schmidt
Florence Schumacher
Richard Smith
J. LeslieSteffensen
Dr. Jerome Tobis
Robert Wynn
City of Newport Beach OASIS CENTER
Sib and Marguerite Avenue
d del Mar. CA 92625
I
A proposal for a Senior Citizens Council or
ommission for the City of Newport Beach was sub -
itted to the Board of Directors of Friends of Oasis
n'February 25, 1985.
There was extensive discussion about the need
or a Senior Citizens Council, problems and needs
we debated, finally a motion was made that Oasis
hould send the proposal- -as— suggested•by last years
Lo Range Planning Committee to the City government.
he motion was approved by a slight margin, therefore
am submitting this cover letter requesting your
orisideration in establishing this Commission.
aF
Sincerely yours,
w
d li�r0at�i ident
ends os
OASM Qld er -4dults ; ocial, information & Services
�. PROPOSk.D;
I. That a Newport'Reach Senior Citizens Council be estab-
lished to report directly to the City Council.
iI. Need for a senior citizens council:
A. Seniors comprise nearly 25 % of the population
Of Newport Beach,
1. This percentage will increase because high
housing costs keep younger families from
making their homes in the city,
2. Thid percentage will increase as the current
8. The OASI1
SCenter�issan important asset to the city,
.but it serves only a segment of the senior population,
C. A senior council is needed to receive, review, and
make recommendations on legislation affecting seniors.
Such legislation may originate with the city,eounty,
state government.
D. The City Council,with its multitudes of city duties,
cannot be expected to keep abreast of matters con-
cerning seniors, and would be kept advised of such
matters by a senior council,
i
ITI. Duties -° - - -- -
A. Act in advisory capacity CO City Council in estab-
lishing policy on all matters pertaining to special
• concerns of senior citizens in the city.
8. Meet regularly and invite input from persons, schools
and organizations which have an interest in senior
activities and programs.
C. Review the proposed annual budget for senior centers,
including personnel.
D. Represent the interests of the entire senior.
E. Review programs and services for seniors population,
, , including
I, education,. health, housing nutrition, recreation
and transportation.
F: Promote the involvement of seniors in community affairs.
C. Encourage intergenerational activities.
ti. Perform such other duties as may be Prescribed by
the City Council.
1V- 'Suggested composition of a Newport Beach Senior Council
A. Nine members
I. Seven appointed by City Council members.
2. Two at -large representing OASIS and appointed
or elected by Friends of OASIS,
4. ResidenearofoChegCity ofaNewport Beach.
S. Regietered voters.
B. Term of office as decided,by City Council,
• C. No compensation
D. City to provide staff member (possibly supervisor of OAS.{S
I
1/2.1/80 /80
OASIS SENIOR CENTER OPERATION AND RELATIONSHIPS
In today's era of limited resources, support groups have formed to render
essential assistance, both in time and money, to worthwhile public programs
and facilities. In the context of a, philosophy which encourages people to
help themselves in their leisure pursuits, the Parks, Beaches and Recrea-
tion Department is committed to a cooperative effort to provide senior
programs and services. at the Oasis Center. The Department welcomes volun-
teer support and.intends by this policy to identify the relationship, 'roles
and control between the City of Newport Beach and Friends of Oasis..
Facility Use and Scheduling
1. The City, through the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Department, is
responsible for determining priorities of use and overall scheduling
of the.Oasis Center.
2. Senior - citizen activities shall have priority of use, in accordance
with Council Policy I -5, Use, Priorities and Fees for Facilities.
3. -The senior - citizen programs at Oasis Center are cooperative efforts of
the Parks, Beaches and•Recreation Department and-the Friends bf Oasis;
as Department programs- -and in consideration of the significant volunteer
contribution by the Friends of Oasis -- facility -use fees are not approp-
priate.
4. Scheduling of senior activities at the Oasis Center will be done by the
Recreation Supervisor, in cooperation with the Friends of Oasis President.
5. The Department maintains a master calendar for the Oasis Center; use by
other Department programs and outside groups will be handled by Department
staff as specified by Council Policy I- 5,Use, Priorities and Fees for
Facilities.
Programming and Administration
1. The Recreation Supervisor is responsible for day -to -day operation of the
Oasis Center.
2. Within the context of cooperation, programming decisions will be made
jointly by the Recreation Supervisor and the Friends of Oasis President.
3. The Recreation Supervisor and Friends of Oasis President shall be ex- officio
members of each Friends of Oasis Committee.
4. The Recreation Supervisor will be an ex- officio member of the Friends of
Oasis Executive Committee and the Board of Directors.
i
• I - C
1/21/80 80
OASIS SENIOR CENTER OPERATION AND RELATIONSHIPS - Page 2
5. Clerical assistance is provided by the City; all requests for this,
assistance will•go through the Recreation Supervisor.
6': Any improvement or physical change of the Oasis Center must have advance
approval by the Parks, ,Beaches and.Recreation Department.
Financial
1. The City'is responsible. for financing the Oasis Center operation only
to the extent of the annual City Council approved budget.
2. Equipment ;-services and financial contributions provided by the Friends
of Oasis are welcome and are in keeping with the cooperative philosophy.
3. The Recreation Supervisor will obtain input from the Friends of Oasis
Executive Committee in preparing the annual budget.
4. Friends of Oasis shall maintain accurate records of all finances. A
copy of all Friend's of Oasi's financial reports will be forwarded to the
• Parks, Beaches and Recreation Department.
5. Fund raising or activities that provide private monetary gain must comply
with Council Policy I -16, Commercial Uses In Public Parks.
Insurance
Friends of Oasis shall provide evidence of adequate insurance coverage as
.determined by the City's Insurance Administrator.
Adopted - January 21, 1980
I
C
•
Item No. ,6
March 6, 1985
Mr. Ron Whitely
Director of Parks,
Beaches & Recreation
3300 Newport Beach
Newport Beach, Ca. 92663
Subject: Request for review of policy concerning areas
designated for Swimming and Board surfing in
West Newport Beach.
Dear Mr. Whitely:
My neighbors and I request that you consider for approval
a change in or addition of another designated for "Swimming
Only" zone in West Newport Beach.
At present this zone is located between 42nd and 43rd st.
• We would like to have the "Swimming Only" area relocated
between 52nd and 54th st. or have this area designated
specifically for swimming along with the present area.
The area between 52nd and 54th st. is desireable to families
with children as the beach sand does not have a noticeable
rock or ep bble content and the shoreline is not steep. A
parent along with the Lifeguard can easily see a small child
playing in shallow surf.
This request for rezoning or addition of increased swimming
area would be affective for the summer months only, leaving
the entire winter for surf board enthusiast..Our population
increases si gni fi ca.ntl_y du-ring, t.h_e - summex months a.nd- i.t- woul -d- -- - -
appear most reasonable to increase the area for swimmers only
during this time.
Could you also contact the Marine, Lifeguard dept. for any
comments they might have on this subject.
Sincerely,
o t gQ/%d a
Dan Lazzarevich
• 5303 Seashore Drive
Newport Beach, Ca.
J
0
•
•
Page 2
We the undersigned support the request to add
another "Swimming Only" Area in West Newport Beach
as reference in letter.
NAME
i
19
ADDRESS /•
5 3fl 1 21v ,- � tom-,
DATES
�I10 {�5
31,0 /g�s
F,
RESOLUTION NO. 9451
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH DESIGNATING SURFING
AREAS AND ESTABLISHING DATES AND HOURS
WHEN SUCH SURFING AREAS MAY BE USED AND
RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 9362
WHEREAS, Sections 11.16.020, 11.16.030, and 11.16.040
of the Newport Beach Municipal Code authorize the City Council
to designate certain areas of the Pacific Ocean where surfing
shall be both permitted and prohibited, specify the dates and
hours when such surfing areas may be used for surfing, regulate
-_ the use of surfing areas by swimmers, and adopt other regulations
relating to surfing; and
WHEREAS, the City Council has adopted Resolution No.
9362 designating surfing areas and establishing certain dates
and hours when such areas may be used for surfing; and
WHEREAS, the City Council wishes to rescind Resolution
No. 9362 relating to the designation of surfing areas and
establishing dates and,.times and substitute the following
regulations,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of
the City of Newport Beach that the following surfing regulations
are hereby established:
SECTION 1. Surfing Areas Designated. The following
described areas of the Pacific Ocean are hereby designated as
surfing areas:
- - ' -(a•) County 'Surfing, Area,,- That area generally
described as the mouth of the Santa Ana River:.
(b) Surfing Area No. 1. That area between the,
westerly boundary of the City to the West Harbor Jetty,,
,s
excluding a four -block zone between 40th Street and
West Ocean front and 44th Street and West Ocean
Front. No board surfing shall be permitted during the
hours of 5:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m. from May 1 through
October 31 in the 40th Street to 44th Street zone.
(c) Surfing Area No. 2. That area adjacent to
the East Harbor Jetty in Corona del Mar, no closer than
twenty (20) feet and'no further than two hundred (200)
feet from said Jetty.
(d) Surfing Area No. 3. That area commonly
known as Little Corona Beach.
SECTION 2. Dates Surfing Permitted'. Effective June 15
.through September 10 of each year, subject to any further'limi-
tations as set forth herein, surfing shall be permitted in all
designated areas. After September 10 and before June 15 of each
year, surfing is permitted at all ocean beaches located in the
city.
SECTION 3. Hours Surfing Permitted. Surfing shall be
permitted in Areas ly. 2, and 3 between the hours of 6:00 a.m. and
12:00 noon and between 4:00 p.m. and sunset only. Surfing in
the County Surfing Area is permissible all day.
SECTION 4. Blackball Flag. The Blackball Flag consists
of a yellow field with a large black ball in the center. When j
i the Blackball Flag is flying from a lifeguard tower, regardless
of the date or time, the area is closed to surfing.
SECTION 5. Swimming in Surfing Areas. Swimming is '
permitted during surfing hours in all surfing areas except
Surfing Area No. 2 where no-swimming is allowed during surfing
hours.
® -2-
1V
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that Resolution No. 9362
is hereby rescinded.
ADOPTED this day of nci;,he•r , 1978.
r
ATTEST:
City Clerk
DDO /kb
10/11/78
_3_
�� i
z r. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
Parks, Beaches and Recreation Department
• April 8, 1985
STUDY SESSION
ITEM NO. 8
TO: Mayor and City Council
FROM: Parks, Beaches and Recreation Director
SUBJECT: Removal /Retention of Parkway Trees
Removal
Removal of street trees over the past several years has been administered in
compliance with City Council Policy I -9 (attached). These removals have been
infrequent up until the last two years. Prior to 1:983 trees removed were
requests from adjacent property owners who wished to have their tree removed.
There have been far more people upset with us,over the past ten years for not
removing their tree than those upset about removal.
Procedures established on individual requests require the General Services
Department to remove curb, gutter and sidewalk to enable our tree section staff
to inspect the tree. Their inspection determines if the tree can safely be
root pruned. If this is possible, the work is ,performed and new curb., gutter
and sidewalk is installed. On individual requests and areas prior to 1983,
all of this work was done by city crews from the General Services Department
and the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Department. Of concrete work performed
in approximately 75% of the cases, the street tree is effectively saved by root
pruning techniques. This, of course, varies significantly by tree species and
size in a given area.
Two years ago a major removal program was implemented in the *Balboa Peninsula
area. This removal program was done in cooperation with the Peninsula Point
Association, the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Department and administered by
the Public Works Department. This program was set up on a three year phasing
basis to remove the Ficus Nitida that were causing major sidewalk damage and
street drainage problems in a flat, low,lyi,ng area. For your information, it
was about this time that the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission removed
the Ficus Nitida as desirable from our street tree list. Although aware of
the natural resource and beauty the trees provided the Peninsula neighborhood,
the Association was, and is, in favor of removing the trees.
A further sidewalk replacement program was recently implemented by the General
Services Department with the aid of contract labor to assist in catching up
a backlog of problem sidewalk areas throughout the community. This program
involved the General Services determining locations, Seaview being the first
in Corona del Mar, and removing curb, gutter and sidewalk. The Parks, Beaches
• and Recreation Department inspecting for root pruning or removal and the
independent contractor replacing curb., gutter and sidewalk.
L
In all cases appropriate notification is done with adjacent property owners.
Seldom does the adjacent property owner object to removal.. Sometimes the
actual owner does not get the word due to rentals, extended vacations, etc.
is Retention
City Council Policy I -9 is intended to retain trees and makes it very difficult
to remove trees. This policy has been reviewed by the Parks, Beaches and
Recreation Commission on an annual basis. It has not been amended since 1967
because the policy provides direction on tree retention. Although there have
not been amendments the policy is thoughtfully reviewed by staff and the
Commission. The policy does provide for trees identified in the policy to
be retained at all costs by ramping, diverting of sidewalks and other tree
saving techniques.
We have initiated a fact and policy gathering task of obtaining materials from
communities identified as having stately trees and retention policies. The
requests have not been received by this date from Monterey, however hopefully
their information will be available on the 8th. Following is a review of other
community policy:
Laguna - Mr. Terry Brandt, Assistant City Manager. They do not have
a written tree policy. It is well known that they do nothing with
trees unless they are dead or cause huge problems. He indicated that
he was aware of our situation on Seaview and if i•t had been Laguna,
they would repair the sidewalk and save the tree.
Carmel - unincorporated area serviced by the City of Monterey.
Material being transmitted.
La Jolla - City of San Diego is responsible for this area. In
reviewing the material, their policies and codes are similar to
ours. Their notification of removal requires a return which is
something I would like to implement. (Material attached.)
Recommendation
Conduct an extensive review of Council Policy I -9 with those concerned
about tree retention at a public hearing of the Parks, Beaches and
Recreation Commission.
Develop a notification process whereby all residents are aware of the
possibility of tree(s) removal in their neighborhood.
3. Give consideration to funding an additional concrete crew in the General
Services Department. (See attached memo.)
Ronald A. Whitley
•
•
1
RETENTION OR REMOVAL OF PARK AND PARKWAY TREES
It shall be the responsibility of the Parks, Beaches and Recreation
Commission to develop and maintain a rather restricted list of trees
in the community which should be retained to the exclusion of all
normal problems. This list will contain landmark trees, special trees
of extreme beauty, stately trees which contribute to an entire neigh-
borhood, dedicated trees, etc. These trees will be identified, mapped
and recorded. Subsequent to this they will be given all types of
special treatment to retain them, including the use of asphalt sidewalks,
realigned curbing, etc.
Whenever it is necessary to prune tree roots in parkways or other
public areas in order to correct or prevent damage being caused by the
subject 'tree, every reasonable effort shall be made to save. the tree,
including the use of high grade asphalt sidewalk sections. It will
still be necessary to meet the City's standards relative to grades
and alignments, with the exception of those special trees discussed
in Paragraph 1 of this policy statement.
If it is necessary for a tree other than that included in Paragraph 1
to be given special treatment, each tree shall be considered individ-
ually on its own merits to determine whether the tree should be retained
or replaced. All parkway trees included in this category must be sub -
jected to and meet the following criteria:
1. Have sufficient root system to sustain life and: t
remain in a,safe condition after root pruning;
2. Have sufficient life expectancy to merit special
consideration;
3. Have adjacent property owners be desirous of retaining
tree in light of "patchy sidewalk effect" that would
be created next to their homes if asphalt sidewalk
is to be used to save the tree;
4. Not be of an undesirable species that has been removed {
from the official street tree list by the Parks, Beaches
& Recreation Commission;
5. Not have had a consistent history of damaging utilities
such as sewers, water mains, etc.;
6. Not interfere with acceptable drainage if alternate
methods of curb repair are utilized.
I -9
RETENTION OR REMOVAL OF PARK AND PARKWAY TREES -- Page 2 I -9
40
Application of the criteria on parkway trees will be conducted by
the Parks, Beaches & Recreation Department in coordination with the
Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission. In applying the criteria
other departments of the City will be consulted as necessary. 'If
there is any conflict between the application of the criteria and
established standards of the City which cannot be resolved at staff
and Commission level, final resolution will be determined by the
City Council.
When a tree is removed from the parkway for the sole benefit of the
adjacent property owner, the property owner will be responsible for
the cost of removal. Removal must still be done in accordance with
City approvals.
•
Adopted - May 9, 1966
Reaffirmed - August 30, 1966
Amended - August 14, 1967
/ Reaffirmed - November 12, 1968
Reaffirmed - March 9y 1970
• Reaffirmed - December 10, 1973
Reaffirmed - November 11, 1974
City of Newport Beach
LANDMARK Balboa Library
TREES Balboa Library
West Jetty - near Historical Marker
Dover Drive at Westcliff
400 block Poinsettia
Ocean Blvd. Corona del Mar
Westcliff & Dover
MacArthur & Carnation
In Arches Overpass
DEDICATED
Mariners
Park - Marcie Schrouder
TREES
City Hall
grounds -
Bill Covert
robusta
City Hall
grounds -
Walter Knott
15th Street - Newport Heights
City Hall
grounds -
Calif. Bicentennial
�.
Las Arenas
Park - Ed Healy
Eucalyptus
Mariners
Park - Isy
Pease
varieties
City Hall
grounds -
U.S. Bicentennial
Via Lido bridge
Eucalyptus
globulus
Freedom Tree
I -9
es
Eucalyptus globulus
Phoenix canariensis
Phoenix canariensis
Liquidamber styraciflua
Eucalyptus corynocalyx (two)
Phoenix canariensis
Eucalyptus globulus
Eucalyptus corynocalyx
Eucalyptus lehmannii
Pinus radiata
Pinus halepensis
Pinus halepensis
Pinus halepensis
Pinus radiata
Pinus radiata
Harpephyllum caffrum
NEIGHBORHOOD Parkway in Shorecliffs
Erythrina
caffra
TREES Marguerite Avenue
Phoenix canariensis
Goldenrod Avenue
Washingtonia
robusta
Dover Drive- Mariners to Irvine
Eucalyptus
globulus
15th Street - Newport Heights
Eucalyptus
viminalis
Irvine Avenue traffic island
Eucalyptus
globulus
Holiday between Irvine & Tustin
Eucalyptus
globulus
Surrounding Old Reservoir
Eucalyptus
varieties
Along Avon Avenue
Eucalyptus
globulus
Via Lido bridge
Eucalyptus
globulus
Marine Avenue - Balboa Island
Eucalyptus
rudis
��+•ted - May 9, 1966
Amended - November 9, 1976
r.
0
Y b
PARK AND
RECREATION
DEPARTMENT
236.5700
THE CITY OF
SAN DIEGO
CENTRAL DIVISION • 1970 `B "STREET SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92102
Ronald A. WHitlay
Parks /Beaches E Recreation
3300 Newport Beach Blvd.
Newport Beach, CA 92663
March 28, 1985
Dear Mr. Whitlay:
• In response to your telephone call March 28, 1985, enclosed
is the information you requested. If we can be of any further
assistance to you please feel free to call us at 236 -5744.
Sincerely,
Rbbert NiCh01�
Grounds Maintenance Manager
Tree Maintenance section
RMN:taw
•
PARK AND RECREATION DEPARTMENT
TREE MAINTENANCE SECTION
1970 "B" STREET
236 -5744
REFERENCE:
A representative of this department has inspected the planting in the City
right -of -way adjacent to your property. City forces at City expense will
remove the tree(s) or shrub(s) when time permits, for the reason checked
below:
1. Due to death or diseased condition of the tree(s) or shrub(s).
2. Due to storm or accident conditions.
3. Due to damage to or encroachment in the right -of -way facilities.
NOTE:
The Street Division of the Department of Transportation will be notified of any
• damage to sidewalk and curbing and will take such action as is necessary.
In the process of removing trees or shrubs from the public portion of the street
right -of -way every attempt will be made to protect the improvements in the park-
way (sprinkler systems, shrubs, brick, colored rock, etc.). However, if damage
does occur the necessary repairs or replacements will be made by the Property
Owner at the Property Owner's expense.
If you wish to replant the parkway with trees, you may request an application
form by calling our above number.
Sincerely,
U,1V
ert M. Nichols
Grounds Maintenance Manager
Tree Maintenance Section
Provisions for removal will be arranged upon receipt of this signed approval.
PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN:
*, -7
I have been notified concerning the removal of
Name
Address
Phone
Signature
CI ?I OF SAN DIEGO. CAL•IFORO A
COUPjCIL POLICY
• I S:Fc E_ :3ciF. ?LA ?: - CE:. RAI BU51NESS DIS TIC_'?
n
U
bALFa:-ira't� :D
CGc -t't an'� Qa
�•c,
POLICY
HUNTER
EFFECTIVE
DATE
,'q-
200 -5 1 8/4/5b i 1 :�
Mur.ici: e'_ Cede Sec.ion 52:00_4 pro,. ides that from time Lc Lin.;• o zla n
shall be prepared whic, designa Les• by 1n,eans Of a co:u leLe P01; Of %_Ly
streets , a unifcrm ,methol of S.ree. tree pla. ^. lnc:
' zoning CE: �: is
S greets f °c. a Certain °. ecimen of tree or Lrees; +shrl.'b shl -', - -,�
Showing L. ^.e . is-.c' ^.c: - ^,d the �h t ^
aca_ and -where edc.. ree or
to be planter..
Section a_ se plc.ri des that after the p_
- has been appT O ^?^ _ -
Y na;s: •
sar.,e Sha 11 be u ^L1.Lte ;C• t!:c
�0%17.cii fc: -10.4; f:i co tlCn a. ^. •OY od^ '
�/ cozio^.; by .hat bc•31• i_ a nd 'v; ,^
the uniform play. :s a•3or.Lea it shalt becom, the tree ~.
. ^.iantl.'ly p:a ^.
the S.rceCs of the City of San.Diecc, and shall be :L,ictly c
in all future street piantirg irr,prc•: =meat pro]eC.'s ar,d in the IeflC-�rl
and replacement of such trees; shrubs and plants on s:_ee-a,
the uniform plan of tree planting may, but need not. be adcp:.,d bs.
the Council at one time; but the Council may adopt the unifc_r, stY
tree planting for different porticns of the City within a reaso^.:ble
length of time after the completed plan for any particular portion
of the City has been submitted to The Council.
PURPOSE
To establish continuity and uniform ly of street tree o1=nLina it she
Central Business Dis=ricL: r
POLICY
A. Tree selection in an congested area such as
Y .he
District is difficul'L and the number of trees su.`=Zb_e for _his
type of planting is limited. :gees shall beg
r►
1. Deep - rooted but with roots that are not likely to cause und..:e
damage t0 adjacent utility lines or Structul•e3.
2. Adaptable tc c•ontrciled pruning where limitations in height
and width are _eq:ire3,
3. Adaptable to planting in restricted space where access to air
and water is limited.
• 4. Evera:-een and ncn_ fruiting. t.0 a:?oid litter of falling _e•z_.:.
�.,, and fruit.
•
•
1eq
2. Performance Bonds:
If a Performance Bond is required in accordance with Section 62.o616,
Municipal Code, the Park Division will process the same as above
except that an estimate concerning the replacement or cutting•of
sidewalk and any other applicable work required in order to install
trees will be provided by the Permit Engineer along with the plan,
and other details mentioned above in Paragraph 1 of this Section III.
The applicant will,be notified by the Park Division of the bond required,
and requested to post bond. Upon Posting of said bond, the Park
Division will then issue the applicant his permit to install trees.
(See Section VIII below for bonding procedures.)
3. Inspection by Engineering Department (when required)
In cases where the Park Division desires inspection services of the
City Engineering Department, a copy of the application will then be
sent to the Permit Section of the City 2figineering Department with a
request that inspection be provided by the City Engineering Department.
Upon completion of tree installation to the satisfaction of the City
Engineering Department (concerning sidewalk cutting, replacement,
grading, etc.), Permit Section will return copy of application to the
Park Division; and if the Park Division is satisfied on all other
aspects of the installation, bond will then be released to the depositor.
SEC. 62.0616 nOPERTY OWNERS' PERFORMANCE.BONDs
(a) No bond or surety will be required except in the following cases: .
(1) When it Is necessary to cut a sidewalk to plant a tree.
(2) When It Is necessary to relocate utilities and /or underground structures
In digging a hole for the tree.
(3) In other special cases Involving possible damage to City or private
property as determined by the Park and Recreation Director.
(b) When It Is determined by the Park and Recreation Director that a bond or
surety is required, the applicant for a street tree planting permit shall furnish a
cash deposit or a surety bond to ensure performance of the conditions of his
permit. This surety shall be in an amount which, in the opinion of the Park and
Recreation Director, is sufficient to ensure performance, but in say event, not
less than Three Hundred Dollars ($300.00), Any cash deposit shall be held by
the City Treasurer. H the Park and Recreation Director finds that the conditions
of the permit have not been met, he shall notify the property owner in writing of
such default and the time deemed necessary to correct it. If the property owner
fails to correct the default within the established time, the Park and Recreation
Director may use all or any part of the property owner's deposit to complete the
work satisfactorily. The Property owner shall be provided with an accounting for
such expenditures. The deposit, or any remaining balance, shall be refunded upon
acceptance of the work by the Park and Recreation Director. If the,property
owner has posted a surety bond, the Provisions of Section 62.0202 shall apply
'except that wherein the word's "City Engineer" are used, substitute the words
"Park and Recreation Director."
/nddnd t2 -tt -aR by Onl. A021 N.S.1
i
L
•
•
II. Individual Permits, Residential 'and Aoricultural Areas (where sidewalk
cutting is not required)
1. Property owner will make application for permit on forms provided for ,
this purpose by Park Division, Tree Section. q 7 p_ B :,•, - 2 u z�•
2. Park Division will specify species of tree to be planted. Park
Division reserves the.right to disapprove of species of trees which are
unsuitable.
3• Property owner is responsible for digging hole, planting trees including-
providing tree and soil amendments, watering and fertilizing. park
Division will: trim as necessary..
4. Park Division will issue permit when specified conditions are met.
III. Individual Permits, Commercial and Industrial, and other areas where
sidewalk cutting is required
1. Applications:
Applications for permits will to submitted as described in section II,
Paragraph Is above. Appj,icant must present to the Park and Recreation
Department, along with. the application, a plan indicating the desired '
I ocation of trees to be pl.•nted. The plan, accompanied by a coly of
the application, will then be forcaarded to the verWit Section, City
engineering Department, for advisement. Permit Section, City lzgineeri.ng•
Department, will their compile the necessary information and return to
the Park and Recreation Department so that the permit may be issued
under whatever conditions and stipulations are requested by the City
Engineering Department and the Park and Recreation Department. A bond
may be required. A performance bond will always be required when
sidewalk cutting is necessary.
oVP0g " 1. Applications will be submitted as provided in either Section II or III
(pr InEe_�; above as applicable. No permits will be granted for planting in
•
y•
if
'r
•1
i
I
f �
1 '
4
above ground containers unless:
a. The Park and Recreation Director has determined that planting of
trees in the Bound is either physically impossible or economically
unfeasible, and:
b. The proposed planting is in accordance with an approved plan.
2. Applications submitted shall be accompanied by a letter explaining in
detail why the proposed planting should pot be made in the ground.
The letter should state the appraised value per front foot of the
property- adjacent to the proposed planting.
3• If the park and Recreation. Director approves the proposed above ground
planting, the permit will be processed as described in Section III
above. Plantings will be approved only for planting in standard
containers in accordance with Drawing ?338 -64T. A bond will be required
to ensure compliance with City standards and saecifications.
Q k. Planting in above ground containers• will be approved only:'
a. In Commercial or Industrial areas;
•
b. When it is'demonstrated to the satisfaction of the City Manager that
the planting in the ground is either physically impossible or econom-
ically unfeasible; and
C. When such planting is in compliance with an approved placi.
Planting in above - ground containers will*not be'approved in .Residential
areas. If it is physically impossible to plant in the ground -in Commercial •'
Or Industrial areas, due to the'prese'nce of underground structures or
utilities or for other good and valid reasons, the,Citq may issue an '•.,•''.
encroachment permit for planting ins above- ground containers. When permits]
are granted for planting trees in above- ground containers to be located,
within a dedicated right -of -way, the following rules shall apply:* '
a. Containers to be'used shall be approved'by the City.'
b. Owner will supply container, tree, all necessary soil and planter mix
u1n Actin AtUtcr.AflUN t:UARV 1,01 Ir
.Ur31iCT: 1'ALtd TREE` 1'1 ESE MWrIOD AND 1lIxer.rMiG
ISACt :Gi:0Ut1D: In the past large numbers of palm ;trees have been planted in San Diego
• on public street rights -of -way, tite grounds of public facilities and
parks, and in private developments, 'These plantings have contributed
to Elie semi - tropical image of tite city. Currently redevelopment
acti -Aiy, old afe and disease have caused the loss of a si.gnif.icapr.
stumber of mature palms. This loss does not appear to have been
offset by new palm'plantings.
PURPOSE: Tice purpo a of this policy i.s •to gncourago a balanced landscape. wllicla
includes paten trees, to assist in the retention of 'tile City's semi-
, tropical itnage.
POLICY: It %11311 be tine policy of tite Park and Recreation Board to encourage "
the retention and planting of palms as follows:
1. Street Rights- of -l:ay: Existing palm plantings will be rctiained
•
and protected to tite extent feasible.
• ;• • -•
--- •.•It.is recognized that trees growing into power lines are
dangerous, and effective remedies must be initiated fio•corresc:r
tine hazardous condition. ' If a palm tree cannot •be trin—mod c:r
the power line re- routed at a reasonable cat: to avoid conflict:.,
the palm tree may be removed under City permft which %rill re-
quire ieplacentent With a suitable palm 1•dlcre feasible.
Due to the mail'teuance frequency required for palmm planted is
the street right -of -way, uctr plantings of palms as s "rr >vt, tr•:.:es
•
will be limited to low maintenance palm siiecies.
2. Rcblic Facilities and Parks: The planting of a balanced lrttd.-
scape which includes palms, where appropriate, will be require'-
in public facilities and parks. Tito approved design st;;;;Jard;;
for MEssion Bay Park will govern in that facility.
3. Miter agencies and the private sector are encouraged to J;1clucie
palms. in their landscaping projects where appropriate.•
RES1'ONni-
Tine responsibility for implementation of this policy is placed in t•hc
BiLITY:
itirlt and Recreation Department,
•
COvU ME I T 1110. P,7(; %G
•
FILED. JlP
OF WE OF Y.112 C11TY CLERK
• SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA
0
0
0
April 2, 1985
TO: RON WHITLEY, PARKS, BEACHES AND RECREATION DIRECTOR
FROM: General Services Director
SUBJECT: ADDITIONAL CONCRETE CREW
In response to your verbal request during our meeting this yning in your
office, the following information regarding the crew make- up-costs associ-
ated with the addition of another concrete crew to the Fiel? Maintenance
Division of the General Services Department, is hereby submitted.
We normally assign three individuals to any one particular concrete crew.
They are classified as (1) Cement Finisher, (1) Maintenance Man II, and
(1) Maintenance Man I. The Finisher is normally in charge of the other
two personnel when the Foreman is not physically present on the job.
They are equipped with one flat bed truck, 1 ton, V -8, gasoline powered,
with automatic transmission. Also, the Finisher and Maintenance Man II
are usually capable of operating a small backhoe loader for the removal
and loading of the deteriorated sidewalk. After the walk is removed,
the Finisher is capable of supervising the forming of the new sidewalk.
When the transit mix concrete is delivered, it takes at least three
people to quide the truck, steer the chute, and puddle and tamp the mix;
on a large pour, it takes more people.
The costs associated with an additional crew can be broken down thus:
LABOR:
ANNUAL SALARIES & BENEFITS
(Includes Workers' Comp., Insurance,
uniforms, shoes, etc.)
Finisher
Maintenance Man I1
Maintenance Man I
SUB TOTALS
J
SALARY
BENEFITS
$22,800
$10,540
19,700
9,600
18,560
9,320
$6i106q
$29,460
page 2
EQUIPMENT:
(One time)
1 - 1 ton, flat bed truck, V -8, automatic,
gasoline powered $ 16,380
SUMMARY:
LABOR - (Salaries, Benefits, etc.) $ 90,520
EQUIPMENT - (One time) 16,380
TOTAL $106,900
There would be considerable advantage to having additional personnel assigned
to the concrete section of the Field Maintenance Division. You may not be
aware that the present number of personnel are not only responsible for all.
the sidewalk, curb and gutter repair, but are also required to repair storm
drains, replace bulkheads,, install tide valves, install cross gutters, re-
pair concrete streets, install parking meter posts, and replace utility cuts
made by the water and sewer crews. As you can see, some days there is no
time for sidewalk repair. That is why our present back log of sidewalk re-
pair is as much as two, three, or four years old.
• Liability to the City would be reduced a great deal by reducing our response
time. Special treatment necessary for some sidewalk repairs caused by "spec-
imen" or "landmark" trees that cannot be removed, would be greatly facilitated
by having City personnel execute it instead of trying to instruct contract
personnel.
I believe the above information can answer your request. If you need any
more information, please call me anytime.
•
ge I � PA
Wade S. Beyeler
WSB /ib
14
' . Item No. 8
• RETENTION OR REMOVAL OF PARK-AND PARK14AY TREES
It shall be the responsibility of the Parks, Beaches and Recreation
Commission to develop and maintain a rather restricted list of trees
in the community which should be retained to the exclusion of all
normal problems. This list will contain landmark trees, special trees
of extreme beauty, stately trees which contribute to an entire neigh-
borhood, dedicated trees, etc. These trees will be identified, mapped
and recorded. Subsequent to this they will be given all types of
special treatment -to retain them, including the use of asphalt sidewalks,
realigned curbing, etc.
Whenever it is necessary to prune tree roots in parkways or other
public areas in order to correct or prevent damage being caused by the
subject tree, every reasonable effort shall be made to.save.the tree,
including the use of high grade asphalt sidewalk sections. It will
still be necessary to meet the City's standards relative to grades
and alignments, with the exception of those special trees discussed
in Paragraph 1 of 'this policy statement.
If it is necessary for a tree other than that included in Paragraph 1
to be given special treatment, each tree shall be considered individ-
ually on its own merits 'to determine whether the tree should be retained
• or replaced. All parkway trees included in this category must be sub-
jected to and meet the following criteria:
.A
1. Have sufficient root system to sustain life and"
remain in a safe condition after root pruning; ,
2. Have sufficient life expectancy to merit special
consideration;
3. Have adjacent property owners be desirous of retaining
tree in light of "patchy sidewalk effect" that would
be created next to their homes if asphalt sidewalk
is to be used to save the tree;
a
4. Not be of an undesirable species that has been removed
from the official street tree list by the Parks, Beaches
& Recreation Commission;
5. Not have had a consistent history of damaging utilities
such as sewers, water mains, etc.;
6. Not interfere with acceptable drainage if alternate
methods of curb repair are utilized.
I -9
•
7J
RETENTION OR REMOVAL OF PARK AND PARKWAY TREES -- Page 2 1 -9
Application of the criteria on parkway trees will be conducted by
the Parks, Beaches & Recreation Department in coordination with the
Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission. In applying the criteria
other departments of the City will be consulted as necessary. If
there is any conflict between the application of the criteria and
established standards of the City which cannot be resolved at staff
and Commission level, final resolution will be determined by the
City Council.
When a tree is removed from the parkway for the sole benefit of"the
adjacent property owner, the property owner will be respons =ble for
the cost of removal. Removal must still be done in accordance with
City approvals.
0
Adopted - May 9, 1966
Reaffirmed - August 30, 1966
Amended - August 14, 1967
Reaffirmed - November 12, 1968
• Reaffirmed - March 9, 1970
Reaffirmed - December 10, 1973
Reaffirmed - November 11, 1974
r
Item No. 9
RECREATION DIVISION
• MARCH, 1985 PROGRESS REPORT
Senior Citizens
New Board members have been elected for the Friends of OASIS. Those members are
Martha Blanchette, Lillian Lippitt and Boyd Stillings. The erection was held
March 1 and these new Board members will join the already excellent Board of
Directors for the Friends of OASIS.
The Human Services Section of the OASIS Center is going great guns with the anticipa-
tion of a full time coordinator being approved. A new Peer Counseling course began
March 6 and goes through May 16. Twenty two people are enrolled and the instruction
by Betty Ulibarri is outstanding.
The Foot Screening Clinic was held March 28 and was a huge success and the Blood
Pressure Clinic also had a good turnout.
OASIS has brought on a new Employment Specialist to help seniors with jobs. Nancy
Venuto's internship ended March 13, and OASIS was rucky enough to bring on a new
senior aid, Frank Rudolph. Frank will be at OASIS Monday through Friday from 1 - 5 PM
helping seniors with employment. Frank also is a graduate of Columbia University and
was a major in the U.S. Army where he held many good positions. Now he just wants to
help others and the City is glad he is on board.
Activity Classes
• The winter quarter has just ended and anticipation of a big spring registration for
all of the activity classes has started. One of the big and exciting spring programs
is the Annual Easter Egg Hunt. This year several improvements have been made to an
already worthwhile event. Along with a visit from the Easter Bunny for the kids,
the addition of clowns and jugglers from activity classes should make for a great
Easter program. This event is again' sponsored by the Eastbluff Village Merchants
Association.
Planning for the Annual Scenic 5K Run in Corona del Mar has begun. The race, scheduled
for June 1, will hopefully attract 1500 runners. The'race is co- sponsored with the
Corona del Mar Chamber of Commerce and the City will utilize all of their volunteers
to run the race. 30,000 fliers should be out this week.
Aquatics
Sailing and swimming registration for the
Department is hunting for new instructors
have just gone out for lifeguards and swii
summer program scheduled at school pools.
lessons, tiny tot lessons, diving and Red
to patrol all recreational swim sessions.
Tennis
spring is doing very well. Currently the
for both programs. Summer employment fliers
nming instructors for the City's large
Classes will consist of youth swimming
Cross classes. Lifeguards will be hired
•Spring tennis registration has begun and, weather permitting, this should be a great
quarter. New instructors have been hired and facilities are being improved and
cleaned in anticipation for our big summer program. Tennis is still a very successful
program in Newport Beach which is self- supporting and revenue producing.
�0
Facilities
Our recreational facilities are still
.men are still working around the clock
clean and ready for renting. Projects
at the City's facilities include:
1. Mariners facility ceiling
2. Theatre Arts Center - doors
3. Theatre Arts Center - sewage pump
4. Theatre Arts Center - electrical
5. CYC - electrical
Adult and Youth Sports
-2-
being maintained to the fullest. Maintenance
to keep the City's multi - purpose facilities
that should be completed in the near future
The adult winter basketball season ended its games March 14 and the new spring league
with 36 teams started March 18. Each team will play eleven games and trophies will
be handed out to first and second place finishers.
Summer softball registration will be accepted April t through April 19. An excellent
turnout is expected and a new division has been added for men 35 years and older.
This should become a very competitive division.
Registration for the Annual Track and Field Program is going slowly. A Pre Meet Clinic
will be held April 13 at Newport Harbor High School and Eric Tweit, the track coach,
will spearhead the clinic. April 20 will be.the Annual Track Meet which is co-
sponsored by the Newport Beach Rotary Club, and for that we are very grateful.
The bgys_hasketball
4 • - Championships. The
the tournament for
has now qualified
"Great Luck."
•
nrooram completed its season by participating in the Orange County
City's 3rd and 4th grade teams coached by Brett Williamson won
the third straight year. This team from Buffalo Hills Park
for the Southern California Tournament and the City wishes them
Tom Line
Item No. 10
PARK AND STREET TREE DIVISION
MARCH, 1985 PROGRESS REPORT
Our Park crews performed the following tasks in addition to
normal maintenance during the month of March:
Installed seats in dug outs and built retaining
walls behind bleachers at San Miguel Park.
Installed merry -go -round at Spyglass Hills Park.
Landscaped, strengthened retaining wall and
built shed at City Yard.
Replaced 4 broken windows and installed guards at
Riverside Scout House.
Reset bricks at 3200 Seaview.
Removed and disposed of chain link fence at
Recreation Department's storage area at City Hall.
Assisted tree crew on Seaview.
40 Our Street Tree Division performed the following:
Trimmed 660 trees.
is
M,
Planted 10 trees.
Removed 11 trees.
Root pruned 34 trees.
Completed 3 Work Requests.
Areas being trimmed are Westcliff and Buffalo Hills. Harbor View
Hills West and Balboa Island are completed.
r�Lwi��0o, —
0
•
•
720 Poppy Ave.
Corona del Mar, CA. 92625
March 25, 1985
Mr. Ronald Whitley
Director of Newport Beach Parke, Beaches and Recreation Dept.
3309 Newport Blvd.
Newport Beach, CA. 92663
:/
VD r Mr. Whitley:
I am writing to you as a concerned, involved
volunteer of the Friends of Oasis. It is my understanding
that the City Council is considering the formation of a
Senior Citizens Commission, as recommended by;..a previous
Friends of Oasis Long Range Planning Commission, not the
present committee.
Too many of us have kept silent too long on the
political maneuvering of a few so- called senior activists
at the center. I do not believe that the majority of the
knowledgable Oasis volunteers share their beliefs. It is
suspected that in some instances they are interested in
furthering their own retirement "careers ".
The concept of a Senior Commission sounds logical
and good. Unfortunately, the same activists who cause such
turmoil at the center are the ones who would apply for the
Commission, thus enabling them to have the official means
of furthering their own causes; it would only create more
chaos. Having more active senior representation on the
Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission would seem more
logical to me, for whatever my opinion is worth.
As a professional social worker and one who could be
most critical of the Human Services staff at Oasis, I want
to say how fortunate we are, and have been, to have such
caring professionals working there. They are excellent and
we appreciate them.
Thank you for letting me state my concerns about the
future of Oasis, an outstanding facility for which we thank
the city.
Sincerely, p
w'�--y,-,.�, hj' �r'�
Norma (Mrs. Dennis) Gilchrist