HomeMy WebLinkAbout07 - Park Bench Update - includes official city bench list•
E
u
(1)
PB &R Commission Agenda
Item No. _t _;_
January 13, 2005
TO: Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission
FROM: General Services Director
SUBJECT: Parks Bench Update
Recommendation
None, informational report only.
Discussion
Staff presented the attached report at the November 16, 2004 Parks, Beaches and Recreation
Commission meeting (Attachment A).
After review and discussion, the Commission directed staff to research additional potential bench
styles, manufacturers, and costs. The attached bench list and photo information represents 5 major
manufacturers and 38 different styles (Attachments B & Q. Additionally, the various styles are
fabricated from wood, recycled plastic, recycled concrete, metal, or a combination. Costs are also
provided, with the exception of unknown freight charges.
The official City bench list is attached to Attachment A, should the Commission choose to add or
delete bench models.
Staff awaits further direction on this issue.
Very respectfully,
David E. Niederhaus
Attachments: (A) PB & R Commission Bench Report of November 16, 2004
(B) New Bench Manufacturers List
(C) Photos of New Bench Styles
L
F �swpon'
r) Word Service
a.
TO: Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission
FROM: General Services Director
SUBJECT: Official Parks Bench List
Recommendation
None, informational report only.
Background
PB &R Commission Agenda
Item No. 1—
November 16, 2004
• In May 1996, City staff developed a list of various styles of park benches for review by the Parks,
Beaches and Recreation Commission.
After reviewing the list, the Commission appointed a Bench Committee who later met and
coordinated the selection of the attached Official Bench List after conferring with the Arts
Commission.
Discussion
Since the adoption of the attached Official Bench List by the Parks, Beaches and Recreation -
Commission, a number of other bench styles have been used in various City business districts after
lengthy selection processes. Staff has attached photos of the new bench styles used at the Balboa
Village, Corona del Mar, and Balboa Island business areas. Also attached are photos of Teak
benches used on the bayfronts of Little Balboa and Balboa Island.
Staff is prepared to address further details regarding park benches.
Very respectfully,
:.v
David E. Niederhaus
• Attachments: (A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)
Official Park Bench List with photos
Photos of Corona del Mar Benches
Photos of Balboa Village Benches
Photos of Marine Avenue Benches
Little Balboa and Balboa Island Benches
•
OFFICIAL BENCH LIST
Agenda item do. v
Bench Sub - Committee recommendation that:
The following list of park
benches be designated as
the
Official Bench List for the
City of Newport Beach.
All area,
designations would thus be
made from this list.
Design Manufacturer
Material Cost
Size
Brooks Brooks /Quick
Precast
Crete
Concrete
& recycled
plastic slats
Huntington Quick Crete
Precast $587.
84"
..';..Beach
Concrete
Columbia Timberform'
Steel & 895.
76•
Cascade Craftsmen
Purpleheart
hardwood slats
Bench #10 DUMOR
Steel & 436.
72"
Recycled 498.
96"
Plastic
Infinity Recycle
Durawood 623.
6o"
Design
(Recycled 676.
70"
plastic),
cast aluminum
.
& cast concrete
(Backless)
Newport Quick Crete
Precast 248.
72"
Concrete
(Backless)
Victoria Quick Crete
Precast 295,
96"
Concrete
Medway BiilishAmerican
Kiln -dried 650.
72"
Teak
(Balboa Island Improvement
Association bench, with
the
Association assuming all future
maintenance for the
teak
benches.)
There may be additional benches added to this list.
r 1
LJ
� r
1IIII�I,
IIIIIII 1
i
E.'
1 41
AM
�'IIIGY6 Al B1�/1CH
t
yam• 1T i..
4
. NEWPORT
"+�' `� �
'.Q'
R�
_.. �
I - ---I
Sam
; I-Ir -:-
r�BPI
AWr
1' __m
AL
la
I � r
so I'll
ot
„� ■.�
■glz■ I
a, Ilk
■
A■
r I
ri fit
• ti —
1
MR J'�ir ,l
._A
�.7r1
It�
Y
• ♦ 1111.
\ n1111�
•
--law
I �_
t
4 �
1�
r..
_ dill
NOW
N� azzi
1 �
yt
Ali ,.
,t
' i
i
gel_
` .fA I
PARK BENCH LIST
Note: Does not include Freight Charges
9
Prepared by General Services Department
December 28, 2004
Manufacturer
Design
Material
Cost*
Size
Matching Trash
•
Receptacle
DuMor
Model 93
Steel
$1,024
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 119
Steel
$1,095
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 161
Steel
$985
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 92
Steel
$810
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 95
Steel
$721
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 138
Plastic
$411
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 143
Plastic
$943
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 155
Plastic
$733
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 105
Plastic
$456
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 146
Douglas Fir
$476
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 34
Douglas Fir
$430
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 37
Douglas Fir
$771
8ft
No
DuMor
Model 56
Douglas Fir
$558
8ft
No
Keystone Ridge Designs
Reading
Steel
$1,110
8ft
Yes
Keystone Ridge Designs
Midtown
Steel
$930
8ft
Yes
Keystone Ridge Designs
Yuma
Steel
$915
81t
Yes
Keystone Ridge Designs
Lamplighter
Steel
$1,075
81t
No
Victor Stanley
Model CR10
Steel
$1,048
8ft
No
Victor Stanley
Model RBF -28
Steel
$996
8ft
No
Victor Stanley
Model FRB -6
Steel
$596
8ft
No
Victor Stanley
ModelRB -12
Steel
$748
8ft
No
Victor Stanley
Teak 8292
Teak
$1,148
8ft
No
•Victor
Stanley
Victor Stanley
Unislate UB 339
Model
Mahogany
Mahogany
$2,696
$456
8ft
8ft
Yes
Yes
Victor Stanley
Model 4
Mahogany
$388
8ft
Yes
Victor Stanley
Model C138
Recycled plastic
$1,464
8ft
Yes
Victor Stanley
Model FR7
Recycled plastic
$1,424
8ft
Yes
Columbia Cascade/Timberform Restoration
Model 2118
Alaska yellow cedar
$1,080
8ft
Yes
Columbia Cascade/Timberform Restoration
Model 2122
Alaska yellow cedar
$880
8ft
Yes
Columbia Cascaderrimberform Craftsmen
Model 2663 -6
Alaska yellow cedar
$1,310
8ft
Yes
Columbia Cascaderrimberform Arbor
Model 2201
Douglas Fir
$1,230
8ft
Yes
Columbia Cascade/Timherform Arbor
Model 2208
Douglas Fir
$1,135
8ft
Yes
Quickcrete
Victoria w/back
Precast Concrete
$903
8ft
No
Quickcrete
Victoria backless
Precast Concrete
$532
8ft
No
Quickcrete
Pasadena
Precast Concrete
$832
8ft
No
Quickcrete
Yellowstone
Precast Concrete
$1,005
8ft
No
Quickcrete
Portland
Precast Concrete
$692
8ft
No
Quickcrete
Flex
Precast Concrete
$697
8ft
No
Note: Does not include Freight Charges
9
Prepared by General Services Department
December 28, 2004
w
z
U
Z
W
m
0
E
0
t
Un
rn
o
I
9-
co
m
0
.z
F-
w
Y
U
Q
m
2
H
w
U
W
m
W
W
w
0
0
`J
•
1.
i
�ti1e,
iW
� n
N
ti
-2
•
N
W
2
U
CD
Z
00
W
60.
m
J
W
W
N
N
fn
N
C7
W
01
O
�
Q
�
m
1.
i
�ti1e,
iW
� n
N
ti
-2
•
0
i
/ 1
1
5
CD
0
m
r
r
a,
00
M
-r-- r
d
a p
r
GA
CD
LO
qgr
M
M
ti
•
U)
J
U
a
C13
0
z
a
U)
LU
Y
m
x
cn
W
U
z
W
U
H
N
CL
J
w
0
•
E
11
0
M
RIT
Ef)
cc
ti
et
Ef}
�1
Go
LC)
LO
Et}
N
m
ti
ti
Eta
N
co
U)
W
J
Y
U
Q
m
D
Z
Q
CO
LLI
Y
U
a
m
9
CO
W
2
U
Z
W
m
D
O
O
0
s.�
�
".
T
•r
- r�i
0
W.; ty
410
0
0
(D a)
,a,^)
*T
0
N
LL
m
d
O
m
0
0
_o
Z
a
O
r
v- vi
•C
1 i
t•.
'i
0
vl-
m
d
mo
O
cfl
. Ef?
U)
LU
J
Q
m
In
a
H
U)
W
cnm
2
H
LL
2
U
Z
LL
m
J
LL
LL
H
N
LU
J
Z
U)
O
U
�
m
/
�
t
U)
LU
J
Q
m
In
a
H
U)
W
cnm
2
H
LL
2
U
Z
LL
m
J
LL
LL
H
N
LU
J
Z
U)
O
U
0
Ll
N
N
to)-
M
MM
m
co
d'
N
C"
N
co
Y
m
N
H
cc
LO
qRT
V-
N
10
O
2
C0
W
2
U
W
mLU
LU
r
0
Z
Q
0
0
W
J
Z
Q
0
U
FM
U)
J
LLI
a
0
Z
Q
W
Y
U
Q
m
a- s tii ` i..•
C
cc
LO
qRT
V-
N
10
O
2
C0
W
2
U
W
mLU
LU
r
0
Z
Q
0
0
W
J
Z
Q
0
U
FM
U)
J
LLI
a
0
Z
Q
W
Y
U
Q
m
0
0
E
r
qqT
cc
v�
r
00
M
r
U
m
-a
0
N
ti
U.
H
Cl)
W
Y
U
a
w
w
m
co
w
J
U
U
W
W
J
Z
Q
H
Cl)
w
O
H
U
J
n
u
•
•
r
We-
I•
to
N
N
r
N
tU
O
!:7
to!).
00
M
co
to
N
d
O
CO
U)
J
Y
U
Q
m
0
Z
Q
H
N
W
Y
U
Q
m
2
H
W
2
U
Z
W
mLU
LU
H
O
w
H
0
0
•
Go
0
N
N
Z
.a
O
m
LC)
M
r
r
b9
W.
R
ui
uj
U
m
in
O
O
m
O
w
m
•
0
•
H
m
W
O
v
J
N
M
co
409-
c
CD
U)
m
CL
N
M
v, U)
.1•
y�j•
L J
M
O
4a
(D
0
w
3
0
.m
cc
N
r
y
d
r
64)-
U)
N
W
J
Y
U
a
m
0
z
a
U)
W
Y
U
Q
m
2
yH
W
2
U
LLI
m
uj
W
Z
0
U
W
W
U
Y
U
s
CY
0
c
co
L
0
0
N
a)
co
c
O
CL
x
x
m
iz
CO
w
J
Y
U
a
m
0
z
a
U)
W
Y
U
Q
m
w
U
z
W
m
W
H
W
w
U
z
O
U
W
LW/�/
li
U
Y
U_
Cl
0
•
•
w
w
F-
N
00
�D
Q
MO
m
`W
r
LW�/
LL
U
Y
U
.t,
d
O
N
d
m
O)
U
O
C
m
m
N
G
m
p
N
m
N
C
d
C
d
O
c
C
C
U
'-
m
m
�
>
N
—
N
O
C
C
N
C
O
O
N
U
U
=
O
m
m
m
E
m
ami
�
w
w
F-
N
00
�D
Q
MO
m
`W
r
LW�/
LL
U
Y
U
.t,
w
2
U
Z
W
m
11
n
I1
r
LO
a)
0
P
f /
i
Ln
co
a)
T-
co
m
0
r
t!3
P-i
H
CO
w
Y
Q
m
RIO
N
LU
2
V
LU
Z
m
J
W
LLI
oc
O
D
0
•
U
N
ti
6A�
R
0
•
•
N
w
2
o
Z
0o
W
m
J
W
LLI
N
CO
a)
�
°
�
V
�
�a
cm
N
ti
6A�
R
0
•
•
4
M
"Cr
a)
69
I
r
r
00
M
V-
N
0
O
l
m
t!7
M
M
ti
6F>
LO
LO
V-
I
N
N
W
J
Y
U
Q
m
D
Z
Q
W
U
m
H
U)
W
U
Z
W
m
U
H
Q
J
a
w
0
0
n
U
0
0
0
Cl)
W
d
O
m
m
ROT
ra
u
I
00
LO
LO
60}
v
N
M
O
m
T
ti
ti
F
.Y.
CD
rO
G
U)
U)
W
J
Y
U
Q
m
Z
Q
H
N
W
Y
U
Q
C13
I=-
CO
W
2
U
Z
W
m
cl
0
0
0
0
0
0
O
M
rn
r
r
r
a�
cc
CD
w
ti
O
r
Q9-
m
CL
E
w
J
LO
V-
a)
m
E
H
cn
W
Y
U
Q
m
2
H
co
W
2
U
Z
W
m
J
W
W
H
cn
cn
Z
CD
N
W
0
W
C7
W
Z
O
H
U)
w
Y
�J
11
p ok , P
CD
Vy
N
LL
m
d
-a
co
O
r
O
r
U
d
a
O
m
S
O
T-
m
d
0
O
m
O
LL
m
10
O
2
U)
W
J
Y
U
m
D
Z
a
F-
N
W
Y
a
m
m
Lu
v
z
w
m
LU
LL!
U)
W
J
Q
H
U)
w
O
U
r
L
E
0
to
c)
to
Cq
M
M
m
co
r
r
EA
N
a)
N
co
Y
ca
N
H
:7s
co
M
v
d
.a
O
2
Cl)
w
2
V
Z
W
mLLJ
LLI
H
ui
0
Z
a
0
O
W
J
Z
Q
H
N
w
0
H
V
Fa
N
Cl)
W
J
a
m
Z
a
w
Y
V
a
m
2
I—
J
0
n
U
qqt
C.0
Rit
V
co
M
r
V
d
O
N
ti
H
CO
W
Y
U
Q
m
2
H
Cl)
W
2
W
m
U
H
J
CL
w
J
U
OWC
W
J
Z
a
H
V
0
n
LJ
4
r
69
co
O
r
r
N
d
.a
O
m
co
N
N
T.
N
m
O
O
r
M
V-
6:i
O
.
M
cc
cc
N
d
10
O
m
U)
LU
J
Y
V
a
m
0
z
Q
LU
Y
U
Q
m
2
_H
N
W
2
U
z
W
m
J
W
LU
H
CO
0
LL
w
W
m
H
•
•
r'
,Y
r
0
M
N
r
00
0
N
N
O
O
m
�n
M
r
r
t-9
I
U)
LU
2
U
m
O
O
w
W
m
H
0
i
•
0
U
N
M
co
6Fi
ca
a
CD
ca
U)
as
CL
N
M
LO
t0!).
Y
L-
0
U
M
O
a)
d
0
N
3
0
d
r
cc
N
N
O
N
O
N
CO
U)
W
J
Y
U
Q
m
Z
a
cn
w
Y
U
Q
m
2
U)
W
2
U
Z
W
m
W
H
W
w
U
Z
O
U
W
F-
LU
w
U
Y
U_
Cr
\J
C,
J
•
c
ca
0
CL
N
m
cc
.a
c
O
CL
x
m
ti
rn
to
x
m
U)
U)
W
J
Y
U
a
m
0
z
a
U)
W
m
Y
U
Q
m
H
N
W
2
U
Z
W
m
W
F-
LU
w
U
z
O
U
W
H
W
w
U
Y
_U
C�
u
0
•
M.
O
D
fO
Y
N
N
O
G
d
0
E
7
c
E
R
N
W
E
O
a
►�
a
C
0/
CD
CD
a
c
O
U
n
N
C
O
U
d
tO
N
C
m
m
m
a
N
Q1
D
a_
c0
O
m
0
m
0
U
O
_c
L
U
c
d
D
N
d
N
O
E
m
d
U
tp
d
G
O1
N
s
Q
d
0
N
U
d
fD
N
a
d
U
m
i,
O
n
0
O
D'
N
d
Q
C
d
N
l9
a�
,.a
i
y
w
w
U)
m
0
Q
m
W
W
Y
U_
9
•
ri
LJ