Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout12/7/2010 - Agenda PacketItem 9 December 7, 2010 Recreation & Senior Services Department To: Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission From: Sean Levin, Recreation Superintendent Re: Status Report on Relocated China Cove Volleyball Court RECOMMENDATION For information only. Receive and file. BACKGROUND At the May 5, 2oo9 PB &R Commission Meeting, approval was given to relocate the China Cove Volleyball Court and amend the hours of prohibited use from 12 noon- 4Pm to 11am — 31m. This decision came as a result of two public hearings and multiple Ad Hoc committee meetings (Attachments A and B). The court was approved by the Coastal Commission in Spring of 2010 and installed in May of 2010. At the June 2010 PB &R Commission meeting staff discussed compiling a report on use of the court and reporting back in 6 months. DISCUSSION Park Patrol staff monitored China Cove beach activity during the period of May 3, 2010 — November 16, 2010 documenting specific activity by day (Attachment Q. Below are the statistics specific to Volleyball use: • Patrolled 84 times • Stopped volleyball use during prohibited hours on 8 /10 /10 at 12:1opm and on 9 /4 /to at 12:35pm • Witnessed authorized volleyball activity at 6:oopm on 8/16/10 • Witnessed no other volleyball activity during the review period In addition, as part of the patrols staff encountered 14 dogs off leash, stopped alcohol consumption twice and assisted with ongoing parking issues. In total approximately 60o persons were observed on the beach during the 82 patrols. Public Notice — Not applicable. Attachments: A. Request for Removal or Relocation of China Cove Volleyball Court & Minutes from February 3, 2009 PB &R Commission Meeting. B. Request to Relocate China Cove Volleyball Court & Minutes from June 2, 2009 PB &R Commission Meeting C. China Cove Beach Activity May — November, 2010. @Recreation Item 4 February3.2009 & Senior Services Department To; Parks, Beaches B Recreation Commission. From =Sean Levin, RecreatlonSuperintendent Re( Request for Removal or Relocation of China Cove Volleyball Court REcomm ENRATION Direct staff to complete an application and forward to the Coastal Commission for their approvaL to remove the China Cove volleyball court. BACKGROUND The China Cove beach is a popular destination for sunbathing, volleyball and general site seeing due to Its spectacular scenic views. The volleyball court is currently unusable due to one of its posts being broken. At the time the court became unusable, staff was approached by David Beauchamp (China Cove resident) regarding the relocation of the court. Since that time, :staff received formal applications from Harold Parker and David Beauchamp, one to remove and one to relocate respectively (Attachments A and B) .. The China Cove volleyball court has a. detailed history as outlined. below: + January 10, 1983 Resolution 83-9 shows no court at Chine{ove.. • January 5, 1988 Survey of Approved Beach Volleyball Courts conducted- August 1987 found an !illegal! Volleyball Court @ China .Cove recommended action in survey was to Post for removal. Commission recommended that City Council amend Resolution '83-9 Item 2 - -that language be added to allow -the Commission to entertain requests for courts to be. within 50' feet of 'a private property line or sidewalk. (Attachment C) • February 22, 1983 - Resolution 88 -19 adopted. by City Council. China Cove court in violation of Resolution. Item 2 amended to read: "No volleyball courts shall be installed within 50 -' of a private. property line or sidewalk in any of the five 15) volleybaN playing zones'! established herein unless authorized by the Parks, Beaches & Recreation Commission as an exception..." [Attachment D) • May 3, 1988 - PB &R: approved: retention of the court with the condition that the net be taken down when people not playing; that the hours, regulations, and location will be referred to the Oceanfront and Beach Committee for a decision which will be made in conjunction with the China Cove Association and the volleyball players using the courts. (Attachment Ei • July 5.;. 1988 - PBOR Commission approved recommendations from the Oceanfront and Beach Committee in memo .dated June 24, .1988. Commission approved recommendation to approve the China Cave court based an: 1) Use Prohibited Daily, 12 noon —4PM, June 15 September 15. 2) Use Prohibited on.Weekends and Holidays, . l2 noon- 4pm September16 June 14. 31 Drinking Prohibited. 4) Loud and Unreasonable Noise Prohibited. 5) Volleyball nets shall be removed duringnon playing times and daily at sunset. (Attachment F) DlscussION The usable sand beach at China Cove is approximately 150 feet in length from the waterline at 11 distance and approximately 92 feet across. The general dimensions of 'a sand volleyball court are with a- minimum of a 10 foot buffer on all sides to accommodate for play that protrudes outside I dimensions. Adding the buffer requires a minimum play area of 50z BO feet. In addition, spik( often travel well beyond the 10 foot bufferzone (Attachment G), Therefore, it is staff's opinion' the court is not a viabie option. The proposed relocation would reduce the usable area for the ge Cove beachgoers. The proposed relocation area would also cause the removal of vegetation require Coastal Commission approval. It is important to note that shifting of the court within would negatively impact other residents surrounding the property and beachgoers. ITEM 4 FrsRuaxy 3, 2009 PAGE 2 It is General Services and Recreation staff's opinion that the China Cove beach . is not suited for a volleyball court based on the dimensions of the beach. Any configuration of the court on the beach is within 50 feet of a private property line. The dimensions of the beach also do not lend themselves to mixing volleyball and beactigoers and creates a safety concern from spiked balls that travel outside of the court area. Staff contacted the :Coastal Commission to discuss the China Cove court. Although the Coastal Commission does riot hst China Cove as a permitted court; should the Mill Commission decide to remove, relocate or keep the existing court, the City will need to file an application with the Coastal Commission to properly document the process.. If the Commission makes the determination that the China Cove volleyball court be retained in its current . location, it is recommended that the rules established by the PB &R Commission at their July 5, 1988 meeting be posted and enforced by Park. Patrol.. Furthermore; an application would treed to be completed and forwarded to the Coastal Commission for their approval. PUSLIC NOTICE Ali residents and property owners within 500 feet of China Cove were noticed two times regarding the date of this meeting.. Aftachmentsv A. Removalof VoheybeR Court Request Application -: Harold Parker, undated B. Relodatioh of Voileyball Court Request Application � David T. Beaucharnp, undated C. survey of Approved Beach Volleyball Locations dated 8/28/87; Excerpt of 1 /5/88. PBaR Commission MlnuteS D. Resdution W4 E. Except of 5/3/88. P Bag Commission Minutes F. Excerpt of 715/88 PB &R Coinnnssion Minutes w/ China Cove Beach Volleyball Court Regulations Staff Report, D8/24E88 G. Schematic & Aedal View of Yollegbail Court. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Parks, Beaches rt Recreation Commission Regular Meeting Convened 7: 1 Opm ROLL CAL Present: Marie Marston, Chair Tim B,nvwi Bill Garrett Kathy Hamilton Phillip Lugar Greg Ruzicka Vacancy Staff: Laura Detweller, Recreation ft Senior Services Director Mark Marmon, General Services Director Sean Levin, Recreation Superintendent Teri Craig, Admin Asst Excerpt of Minutes ACTION 4. Request for Removal or Relocation of China Cove Volleyball Court. Superintendent Levin provided a PowerPoint presentation of the history of the China Cove volleyball court to the Commission. He stated that it was staffs recommendation to direct that an application for removal of the votleyball court be forwarded to the Coastal Commission for their approval. Commissioner Garrett stated that the area seemed Loo small for beach goers and volleyball, users. Commissioner Lugar noted his concern regarding parking. Commissioner Brown stated that the biggest issue is access; and as a proponent of volleyball that he felt that this location was not suited for avolleyball. court. Discussion ensued. Chair Marston opened the public discussion. Mary Ginear stated that there K illegal parking behind her house and that volleyballs constantly hit cars in her driveway. Bryan E,a,tstated that h* has played volleyball mt China Cove for over i5 years and has never heard nf anyone "ra hi getting hit 'mnvKpyhwii He stated that this court isa gem because itis protected from the wind andOotrdthat the courts mtCdM State Beach are too busy and not one oY them is50feet away from the sidewalks- ne . stated that the park ju there for everyone not just the select few that live there. Mc urged the Commission to retain the court. Dame Beauchanmp.ototedthmtheKebthn1thezm/it iu just too close to the homes and that there has been some damage in the past. He stated that the exuberance from the players can sometimes be unpleasant and believes that the court should hemoved. Commissioner Garrett asked about the use of the court Parka;: Reaches & Recreation commission Ro=rMect S February 3. zaoy- 7pm Page 3 Mr. Beauchamp stated that since 1988 it is used more and more but for the most part summer and weekends and holidays are extremetybusy.. Chris Reedy stated that he has been playing volleyball there for over 15 years and asked the Commission to remember that it is a public beach. He also noted that the players have a sense of community and leave the beach better then when they get there. He asked that the City, begin to enforce the rules from 1988.. Art Kisch stated that most players bring their families and that they seta good tone while on the beach and is sympathetic to the residents. He suggested that the court be moved 10.12 feet and promised to limit the enthusiasm. He urged the Commission to keep the :court.: .Bruce Enzley stated that for the most part that beach is not crowded and that the use of the court does not infringe their use on other beach goers. He asked the Commission to be fair and consider a .compromise of moving the court and enforcing the rules. !Sandy MacDougal reminded. the Commission that when these people bought their houses that the beach was there for the public to use but noted that this court is farther away than most courts in Newport Beach -: She also stated that there are not enough courts at CdM State Beach. James Morrison stated that it is mostly the beach goers that cause the parking problem because the volleyball players have learned the rules. He asked that the court be moved and that the rules be enforced, Harold Parker stated that safety is his big issue due to cars backing down the streets. He noted that the court takes up a Lot of the sand on a:relatively small beach. He noted that Mother's. Beach is almost gone because of the tides. He asked that the court be removed. Peter Bergen stated that most the play during the week is after5pm and that the beach is usually deserted. He believes that a compromise can be made with the homeowners and the players. Steve VrebaLovich stated that all eight of the courts at CdM State Beach are less than 50 feet from the sidewalk and in fact there is one that is only 36 feet. He noted that it would be ok to move the court 10 -20 feet as long as it stays in the same format. He stated that he is unaware of any injuries sustained at China Cove and that the Commission should remember that volleyball is now an Olympic Sport and is very popular with the young kids of today. If you are going to allow the exceptions of the 50 foot rule at CdM then the same should be given at China Cove. Russ Henderson stated that this court is very unique and that the Commission should remember that the teach is for the public and is not a private beach. The residents will still have the same type of problems: regardless of the court:. Regina Hollis stated that she would be open to moving the court and that most of the volleyball players are professional business people. Robert Gamer stated that he believes the best option is to move the court so that his house is not the target. The most part the players are very nice and that he loves the beach and enjoys it seeing it being used. He does not believe that a volleyball is going to hurt anyone. He urged that the sand at the beach at'Fernleaf be replenished. S. Giravich stated that she often sits on the beach about 10 feet away from the court and has never been struck by .a volleyball. Parlor,: Beaches. &Pe eationCmnmission Regoheld etiug February., wog —7pm Pageq Brian Ramer stated that 20 years ago the Commission approved the Court and that precedent has been set. The Commission should keep the court:.. Dave Donenberg stated that since the court has been down that he has noticed more people using the beach and that his home Life has been extremely peaceful. Joe McCarthy stated that problems will exist regardless of the fact that the volleyball court is there the real problem at that beach is dogs and being off leash. Chair Marston closed the public discussion. Commissioner Brown asked if there were other locations for the court. Superintendent Levin stated that the real . issue is that the volleyball - court: just does not fit in that specific location. Discussion ensued regarding Park Patrol, rules, vegetation and the Coastal Commission. Commissioner Brown suggested that the Recreation Committee get together with homeowners and players to discuss options. Motion by Commissioner Ruzicka -to table this item until appropriate and that Commissioner Lugar and Brown meet with a sub- committee representing residents and volleyball players to discuss other options. Motion carried by acclamation. 5. Tree Donation, Director Harmon stated that staff had received a request from Mary Kirtland to donate a tree at Old School Park. approve the the tree donation by Mary Kirtland at Old School 6. Revision of Cou oli B -17 - Parks. Facilities fa Recreation Program Donation s. Director Harmon reminded the mmission that at the October 7, 2008 that the Commission approved .changes to the wording on a donor plaque. He noted that the staff report incorporates: the change and forwards to City Co it for their review and approval. Discussion ensued regarding types of dorms at specific parks Motion by Commissioner Brown to forward the revision o. ouncil Policy B -1.7to City Council for their review and approval.. Motion carried by acclamation. COMMITTEE REPORTS - Parks - Nothing to report 9SS - Nothing to report AD- Not —Youth Sports Lfaison- .Nothing to report - Community Services Award. Award presented to Lewis Jones. Other - Marina Park - Director Detweller stated that a presentation will be made at the March meeting regarding ;. Marina. Park. I Attachmenc B I Item 4 June 2, 2009 Recreotion &Senior Services Departinent TQ. ParIiui, beachers ft Recreation Commission From: Sean Levin„ Recreation Superintendent Re: Requests to Relocate China Cove Volleyball Court RECOMMENDATION I. Con side r approval of request from Steve Vrelb a[ ovich to: a. Re loc ate volleyball court as shown In Attach me nt A; and b. Amend China Cove Volleyball Rules hours of prai-ntAted use from 12 noon -4Rm to I lam - 3am- 2. Direct staff to complete a development application to the Coastal Commission for their approval for installation of the volleyball court atChina Cove. BACKGROUND At the February 3 see Ha the to to DisamioN The Ad Hoc Committee met on February 11, March 12 and March 31 at China Cove. The result of the meatings was to relocate the court as shown in AttachmentA. PUBLIC Horric All residents and property owners of China Cove (totaling 94) were noticed regarding the date of this meeting. Attachment: A. Request forRelocation fnarn-Steve Vrebalovich B. February 3, 2009, Item 4,Commission Report, Requestfor Removal of Retacation-of China Cove Volleyball Court. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Parks,. Beaches & Recreation Commission Regular Meeting June 2, :2009 - 7pm Convened 71Opm ROLL CALL Present; Marie Marston, Chair Tom Anderson Tim Brown, Vice Chair Kathy Hamilton Phillip Lugar Greg Ruzicka Excused: Bit]. Garrett Staff: Laura Detweiler, Recreation Ft Senior Services Director Mark Hannon, General Services Director Sean Levin,: Recreation Superintendent Teri Craig, Admin Asst OLD/NEW BUSINESS 4. Request to Relocate China Cove Volleyball Court. Superintendent Levin stated that staff had received a request from volleyball player Steve Vre6olays h to relocate the volleyball court at Chine Cove. He went on to remind the Commission that at the February 3, 2009 Commission meeting a discussion was held regarding the request from homeowner Harold Parker to remove the volleyball court at China Cove and a- request from David Beauchamp to relocate the court. The Commission acted by creating an Ad Hoc Committee comprised of Commissioners Brown and Lugar to meet with volleyball representatives, staff and China Cove residents David Beauchamp and Harold Parker to see if a compromise could be reached. The Ad Hoc Committee met on February 11, March 13 and March 31 at China Cove. The result of the meetings was to relocate the court as shown. Superintendent Levin stated: that the request to the Commission is to consider approval of the reqpestfrom Steve Vrebalovich to relocate the xtleyball court; and amend the China Cove VbUeybaLl Rules hours of prohibited use from 12 noon —4pm to lfam - 3pm, Additionally direct staff to complete a development application to the Coastal Commission for their approval for installation of the- wLleyball court at China Cove. Parks, Beaches & ReweationCommiasion RegularMmting dupe2,.2q 9 -7p= Page 3 Commissioner Brown stated . that beyond the playing rules, other - issues were discussed Including lack of enforcement of the court rules Which included daily removal of the net. He stated that this had not been taking place'and that the volleyball players are now aware of and will ensure daily removal. Superintendent: Levin stated that the rules established in 1488 were not :posted nor was there anyone to enforce the rules and therefore no one was aware of them.. The Park Patrol program now exists and so the plan would be to post and enforce the rules. Commissioner Brown went onto say that issues like parking: will now be addressed as staff will request Parking Control to patrol the area more often. Conduct issues were discussed with the volleyball players: who have agreed they will address -them with other .players. He stated that the residents will be notified of the Park Patrol phone numbers and that if these rules are violated that they should call and that a record would be`kept for the Commission to review if Issues persist. Superintendent. Levin stated that if the :Commission would like a report ' back in six months after court is in place that it should become part of the motion. Commissioner Lugar asked if the request to the coastal Commission had been submitted Director Detweiler stated that <staff has spoken with the Coastal Commission. and they asked that when the Parks, Beaches 8 Recreation Commission as a body make a decision that the application be filed. She went on to say that once direction has been given the application will be forwarded and that it could take anywhere from 3 to 6 months to be processed. Commissioner Garrett asked while this decision is being made is play going on? Director Detweilerstated that currently, no court exists. Vice Chair Brown opened the Dubbc discussion Director Detweiler stated that any correspondence emails, or information from phone calls received were forwarded to the PBU Commission and copies are on the dais.. Warren James stated that he lives about 150 feet away from where the court was originally. He went on to say how often he was startled from the shouting that goes on with the court. He understands that at prior meetings the Commission was concerned because of the lack of attendance from homeowners but noted that he was here tonight along: with his neighbors:. He stated that many people that use the beach are from Irvine,. Costa Mesa and Santa Ana and were not part of the public notice and unable to express their concern about, getting hit from a. volleyball. Mr. James stated that what it boils down to is the aggressive volleyball and that these balls are 6110 of a pound and when served can travel at a speed of up to 75 mph and even faster with a spike. He stated that he would not want to be hit on the head from that. Having a volleyball court on the tiny beach where a lot of kids are is wrong and why take up 40% of a valuable resource to allocate to a group of 4 players occupying a. big part of the beach is just ludicrous. Mr. James stated that his hope is that the Commission eliminates the court and if the court remains please include a rule that the lines be removed. daily. Julia Gold stated that she received her notice of further discussion on the China Cove volleyball court and that it was not a notice of an approval of a new plan but merely a discussion. She went on to say that as a 40 year resident and over 70 years old, she is deeply involved in the environment of the Cove. She rated that the suggested relocation will totally impede free access to the beach and will constitute a barrier. She went on to say as a disabled senior resident the suggested relocation is unacceptable and it violates accessibility requirements. This beach is too small to accommodate both the volleyball court and unimpeded use of the beach and there are ample courts and parking at other locations of which there is no parking at China. Cove. Ms. Cold stated that this small public beach should not be a private club for a few and noted that she is in complete agreement with staffs original report of February 3 that the location and parking is unacceptable. She stated that the violence from the volleyball play is not safe for families.. She stated that this new location, is appalling and there is no access to the beach from the side of cove and violates the law regarding barriers for ADA. She stated again that this new location violates every environmental policy that makes Newport Beach a lovely place to live. Parka, Beaches :& Recreation Commli lon Regale[ Meeling June 2, 2009 `7Pm Pnge4 Karen James stated that she had written a letter that the Commission received Curtis Elmore stated that he frequents the beach almost.. every day and has played there since the 70's and has a son that has been playing for many years. He stated that the court has a tradition and does not understand the severity of the game that these people are talking about. He stated that there are typically 8.10 players that bring their families and friends; so about 30 people are there. He stated that last Memorial Day weekend he noted . that he had visited the beach everyday between 1:30: and 3:30pm and did a census. On Saturday, a sunny day with a: temperature of 73 degrees, good visibility and 'la' people were on the beach at the: water's. edge. He stated on Sunday there were 21 people on the beach and on Monday; there were 32. He went on to say that never once did he see anybody using: or sitting the in the area of the proposed court or the old location. He stated that there is plenty of room for everyone to use the beach and believes it is an asset to the community and should be reinstalled. Steve Vrbolavich stated that he filed the request to relocate the court and the players have tried to make . every allowance for the residents with this compromise. He stated that some of the comments. mentioned .tonight actually allow for more access to the beach and that there is no possible way that a person would not be able to go down Cove Lane and access the beach. He stated that one of the issues agreed upon was that volleyball players would no longer drive their cars down Cove Lane to drop their stuff off and that they would go around and drop it off in another location and then everyone would park their car at the top, This was One of Harold James' issues. He clarified that when the net goes up and goes down the lines would be done at the same time. He also noted that there was concern about the noise and stated that the City went down there to measure the noise level and the results were that the noise was far under the City noise ordinance levels. He urged the commission to approve the relocation of the court. Art Kish stated that he believes that everyone should be able to get along and share the resources there at they .beach- He stated that he has never witnessed a conflict or problem regarding displacing the people wanting to use the beach. He stated that be wishes he could hit a ball as hard as 75 mph and has never seen the ball }lit anyone at the beach. He :stated that there are residents that support the court. He went on to say that the volleyball players will respect the rules and urged the Commission to approve the relocation of the court,. Frank Rent stated that he lives at China Cove and noted that he is not a volleyball player but one of the reasons for moving there was the spirit of the players and it has been sad to see it so quiet since the court has been :removed, He noted that the beach is quiet and would be interesting to see a time lapse camera to see . the actual use of the beach. He urged that the court be restored. Gina Mess stated that volleyball is a great community sport and that the people that use it are families; and that they are trying to coexist with the residents. She stated that the noise or lack of bathroom facilities is not merely a volleyball issue. David Ronenberg stated that he opposes the volleyball court but should the Commission decide to restore the court he asked that the Commission reference Resolution 88 -14 that states that volleyball courts will not be within 50 feet of :a private property or sidewalk and even though the new location is 10 feet better then it was, that his house is most effected and that it would be 25 feet from his property. Dave Beecham stated that the residents would not be here tonight if since 1488 the rules had been followed and noted that he is also guilty of infractions. He stated that for 20 years there was no enforcement: and no compliance. He stated that he is skeptical of enforcement in the future. He stated that he is looking to the Commission for assurances that ,a zero tolerance be included in the rules and asked that play be cutoff at.5pm.. Commissioner Lugar asked about the problem of the lack of bathroom facilities. Mr. Beecham stated that the beach does suffer because of the lack of facilities and that it is not just volleyball: players, Steve Roniger stated that a majority of people that use the beach are residents and that they themselves are guilty of public urination and illegal parking. Parks, Beaches &Re mfion.COm®isaion Regn6rXleing June z, 2009 - 7Pm Page :5 Superintendent Levin stated that there is Park Patrol and Ihat they will be overseeing the rules. He also noted that the rules were not posted in the past. Vice Chair Brown dosed the Public discussion Vice Chair Brown stated that should the Coastal Commission approve the volleyball court that there would be a- 6month trial period and that staff would return to the PBliR Cominission for an update. Commissioner Garrett stated that he believes the beach is .too small for a volleyball court and has concerns that the Park Patrol would be able to enforce the rules.. Vice Chair Brown stated that there is enforcement available and should problems occur that they can call the Park Patrol. Motion by Commissioner Ruzicka to approve the request from Steve Vrebaiovich to relocate the China Cove volleyball court; amend the China Cove Volleyball Rules hours of prohibited use from 12 noon - 4pm to fiam 3pm; to direct staff to complete a development application to the Coastal. Commission for their approval for installation of the volleyball court at China. Cove and if approved by the Coastal Commission that staff return :6 months after the installation of the court and to provide status report. Motion carried by the following vote: Ayes: Anderson, Brown., Lugar, Ruzicka Noes; Garrett Abstain; Hamilton Absent: Marston Vice Chair Brown stated that unless there was.an objection that the Commission would consider the three Bench'. Donations together. 5. Bench Donation. Consider bench requestof. Jeanne Marcucci. at Ensign View Park 6I Bench Donation. Consider bench donation: request of: Phil Rave at Ensign View Park 7. Be=Com on. Consider bench donation request of Michael Ryan at Street.End:of Summit Street. Motion oner Ruzick a: to approve: • Bench donati of Jeanne Marcucci for Ensign View Park • Bench donation o d Rowe far Ensign View Park •. Bench donation of Mic l Ryan for the Street End of Summit Street Motion earned by acclamation. COMMITTEE REPORTS - Parks Director Detweiler stated.. that the Park ment.Committeewould meet again in the fall. RSS - Commissioner Hamilton reminded everyone a the CdM5k. AD- tic -Youth Smrts Liaison- Nothing to report - Community Services Awnrd Nothing to Report. Director Detweiler' reminded the Commission that the fu 'iiq. for additional part-time hours for Park Patrol would be discussed at the June 9r, 2009 City Council meeting. Other - Mdrfna.Park - Nothing, to report. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS • .Fire Ring Policy ADJOURNED:- :8:35pm Submitted by: Teri Craig, . Admin Assistant CHINA COVE BEACH PARK PATROL May 2010 3 Patrolled 4:50pm No activity 10 Patrolled 4:OOpm No activity 14 Patrolled 10:15am No activity 22 Patrolled 1:30pm No activity 24 Patrolled 4:30pm Dog off leash 25 Patrolled 4:20pm 3 people on beach 28 Patrolled 12:10 & 3:30pm No activity 29 Patrolled 1:OOpm 16 people 30 Patrolled 6:45pm No activity June 2010 Patrolled 2:25pm 12 people on beach 4 Patrolled 1:OOpm No activity 6 Patrolled 11:30am 14 people on beach 7 Patrolled 11:40am No activity 10 Patrolled 4:05pm No activity 11 Patrolled 12:45pm No activity 12 Patrolled 4:20pm 7 people on beach 13 Patrolled 2:OOpm 24 people on beach 18 Patrolled 11:40am No activity 19 Patrolled 1:45pm 24 people on beach 20 Patrolled 1:OOpm 21 people on beach 24 Patrolled 2:45pm 6 people on beach 25 Patrolled 1:20pm 4 people on beach 27 Patrolled 5:35pm 17 people on beach 29 Patrolled 3:30pm 2 dogs on beach / 5 people July 2010 2 Patrolled 3:30pm 14 people on beach 9 Patrolled 9:25am No activity 10 Patrolled 12:35pm 3 people on beach 11 Patrolled 2:20pm 9 people on beach 13 Patrolled 3:OOpm 10 people on beach 16 Patrolled 9:55am 3 people on beach 23 Patrolled 12:15pm 1 person on beach 25 Patrolled 10:45am No activity 30 Patrolled 2:50pm 3 people on beach August 2010 1 Patrolled 2:25pm 10 people on beach 8 Patrolled 5:40am 9 people on beach 10 Patrolled 12:25pm Stopped alcohol use /Net Violation 12 Patrolled 1:40pm 15 people on beach 13 Patrolled 4:20pm 15 people on beach 15 Patrolled 3:35pm 24 people on beach 16 Patrolled 2:45pm 8 people on beach Patrolled 6:15pm No activity 17 Patrolled 1:15pm No activity 18 Patrolled 2:25pm 12 people on beach CHINA COVE REACH PARK PATROL September 2010 3 Patrolled 4:30pm 4 Patrolled 12:40pm 6 Patrolled 3:30pm 10 Patrolled 1:30pm 11 Patrolled 11:50pm 12 Patrolled 9:15am 13 Patrolled 2:20pm 17 Patrolled 10:35am 18 Patrolled 10:50am 20 Patrolled 12:55pm 25 Patrolled 4:15pm 26 Patrolled 11:10am 28 Patrolled 11:15am October 2010 5 1 Patrolled 1:05pm 2 Patrolled 11:25am 5 Patrolled 11:05am 8 Patrolled 2:10pm 10 Patrolled 9 :15am 11 Patrolled 12:15pm 16 Patrolled 11:35am 17 Patrolled 11:25am 22 Patrolled 10:40am 23 Patrolled 3:20pm 24 Patrolled 8:10am 26 Patrolled 11:35am 29 Patrolled 10:50am 30 Patrolled 11:15am 31 Patrolled 9:50am November 2010 5 Patrolled 10:50am 6 Patrolled 14:30pm 7 Patrolled 8:30am 9 Patrolled 1:10pm 12 Patrolled 10:50am 13 Patrolled 14:15pm 14 Patrolled 10:40am 15 Patrolled 2:50pm 16 Patrolled 9:50am Dog off leash/ 10 people Net Violation — 17 people on beach Stopped alcohol use / 2 dogs off leash No activity No activity 12 people on beach Dog off leash / 1 person on beach Dog off leash No activity No activity No activity 22 people on beach No activity 2 people on beach 1 person on beach No activity 1 person on beach No activity No activity No activity 7 people on beach No activity 2 dogs off leash No activity Dog off leash Dog off leash No activity Dog off leash No activity Dog off leash No activity Dog off leash Dog off leash Dog off leash No activity No activity Dog off leash Page 2