Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutX2021-2372 - Alternative Material & MethodsCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH IP,0M" y �b ��� Ear COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ��1 7 2zZ BUILDING DIVISION 100 Civic Center Drive I P.O. Box 1768 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658 Qlr www.newportbeachca.gov 1 (949) 644-3200 d? 1" _ t Ao""r BEPG\-► DOCUMENTATION OF UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP — $W.00 FINDING OF UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP FOR PROJECTS UNDER $186,172* CBC 11B-202.4 - EXCEPTION: 8 (FILL OUT PAGES 1 & 2) ❑ FINDING OF UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP FOR PROJECTS OVER $186,172* CBC 11B-202.4 - EXCEPTION: 8 (FILL OUT PAGES 1 & 2) MUST BE ACCOMPANIED WITH RATIFICATION APPLICATION ** ❑ FINDING OF TECHNICAL INFEASIBILITY FOR PROJECTS PER CBC 11B-202.3 - EXCEPTION: 2 (FILL OUT PAGES1, 2 & 3) A. JOB ADDRESS: 2233 W. Balboa Blvd. SUITE NO. 105 B. PROPERTYOWNER: Chin Yao Peng (Tenant) Address: 2233 W. Balboa Blvd. Unit 105 City Newport Beach State: CA Zip: 92663 Phone No. (626)922-3833 C. APPLICANT: OS Design Consulting Position/Relationship: Project Consultant y Address: 88 W Live Oak Ave. Unit B City Arcadia State: CA Zip 91007 Phone No.: (213)399-8733 Email: permit-app@osdesignconsulting.com CASE NOo: H 2O22- 0 PROJECT INFORMATION: P/C. #: 20 5`l--Zo?-f Permit #: k 2®7-l. -1-112 Use: r2emw4- Stories: i Verified by: 65 Receipt #: 53Yj _ _P�, _ DISTRIBUTION: ❑ Owner ❑ Petitioner ❑ P/C Eng ❑ Inspector ❑ Other An unreasonable hardship exists where the cost of providing an accessible entrance, path of travel, sanitary facilities, public phones, drinking fountains, etc. exceeds 20% of the cost of project without these features. The actual work of the project must comply with current code and an additional amount equal to at least 20% of the cost of the project must be spent to improve required accessibility features that are not in compliance with current code. In choosing which accessible elements to provide, priority should be given to those elements that will provide the greatest access, in the following order: 1) An accessible primary entrance; 2) An accessible route to the altered area; 3) At least one accessible restroom for each sex; 4) Accessible public telephones (when provided); 5) Accessible drinking fountains (when provided); 6) When possible, additional accessible elements such as additional parking, storage and alarms. To request an unreasonable hardship, complete the attached worksheet, and prepare a site and floor plan of the existing and proposed accessibility improvements. This information must be submitted to the Building Division in duplicate, prior to processing a permit application. One copy of the approval or denial will be returned to the applicant. For projects exceeding the valuation threshold of $186,172, a hardship approval can only be obtained through a ratification application and hardship application. * The $186,172 is based on $50,000 in 1981 dollars as of January 1, 2022. ** Ratification form can be obtained at: https://www.newportbeachca.govlratificationform Forms\Hardship 06/08/2022 Address: 2233 W. Balboa Blvd P/C #: 20544-2021 1. Total Cost of Construction contemplated (not including disabled access work) $ 45,000.00 Identify the accessibility features, which will NOT be brought into compliance if the request is granted. Provide an estimate of the cost of compliance for each item. ❑ Path of travel to entrance (ramps, walks) ............................................ $ ❑ Path of travel to altered area(s)............................................................... $ ❑ Sanitary facilities restrooms ...................... $ ® Parking.................................................................................................... $ 4,485.00 ❑ Drinking fountain(s)................................................................................ $ ❑ Accessible phone(s)............................................................................... $ ❑ Accessible signage................................................................................. $ ❑ Other....................................................................................................... $ Total cost of providing compliance:..... $ Identify the accessibility features and equivalent facilities, which will be provided or brought into compliance as required by Code. Provide an estimate of the cost of each item. a. Enlarge the existing restroom to improve the accessibility $ 4,890 b. Install accessible sink and water closet $ 2,429 c. Install new grab bars $ 705.88 d. Install new accessible front entry - Double Door $ 2,267 e. Accessible sign with installation $ 100 f. Remove the existing non -compliant detectable warning, and repair the existing $ 7,225 parking surface. 4A ( cxdcl CtCger_rbL_ le, V, lv� ch (�leS1i��,, Total: $ 17,616.88 U-.' At /< 2. Technically infeasibility — if applicable complete Page 3 of this application 3. Fill out this section if the path of travel from the disabled parking spaces to the tenant space is not accessible. List projects (tenant improvements, additions, remodels, etc.) performed within previous three years where no disabled access improvement was performed in conjunction with the project. State description, date, and cost. Non -compliant (E) accessible parking _space which the length is less than the required 18' min. Non -compliant (E) Detectable warning to zero curb (required on accessible path of travel adjacent to hazardous area). _R_ eference project; PC 0841-2020, Tl "Luna Salon" 1,048 sf), the date of the Completion of_the work (12/15/2020), and the cost of the work ($ 37,204). The applicant understands that although the City may approve this request of unreasonable hardship and the proposed equivalent access, the City reserves the right to require additional access compliance upon receiving a complaint of inadequate access at this location. 4. Frank Lin 5. 08.29.2022 (Applicants Name or Authorized Representa ' e) (Date) 11 /29/2022 (Date) FOR -CITY USE -ONLY pproved ❑ Denied Z p Z Z (Chief BW ding Official) (Date) FormsWardship 06/08/2022 Address: 2233 W. Balboa Blvd P/C #: 2054-2021 TECHNICALLY INFEASIBLE. An alteration of a building or a facility that has little likelihood of being accomplished because the existing structural conditions require the removal or alteration of a load -bearing member that is an essential part of the structural frame, or because other existing physical or site constraints prohibit modification or addition of elements, spaces or features which are in full and strict compliance with the minimum requirements for new construction and which are necessary to provide accessibility. Describe why the nature of accessibility is technically infeasible: Describe how equivalent facilitation will be provided: Forms\Hardship 06/08/2022 z�-d iiOLSB•90 �� M20Z :Neor z N O v mW Zm a w D 0 O 1 a A > 0 0 0 N m D = W m no m D= z ro N T W M. WE ze3 1 m-Imt3a K m D z D -rmG) F7 cy) m D rn Z � r- cn - Z D 0 DCG) x^>>o--Im vCAT(n 0 0an:im mcocOCZ zi om rn4h G a D_ r n dMIG e ZZOZ.6Z-60 ® ZZOZ-9Z-90 ® SZOZ-m60 © mg-mm SNOISIA3H ��.$�o ear w�ersl'-uaal+rarewnawo�lxnmx �= N6n7muaNnao3maoNa H 16VO3 =1N3W3A 9dNl3 40 Anowgtl101 OOL $-u0P0llelsul swell'mV 09 $-a6euBIS'ootl 19Z'Z$ Ioo0 Ig01d elgo00 IBPAOWWOD 00V 96 OZt $ I-W1 X OOlbl $ Ieluoeuog,9£ Z9'£bL$ leluozpoq .ZO - leg qmE, 00.609 $ m-Buole wD my ,,duum VQV Aouepigo gBl4 ddO 9' 1/0' L' lecoq 1918M'OPV 00'04dl $-Pu0W ygelq ellew Pue yule elosum olwwm eCgm aOeN - Xui,S'00tl 09£' L $ io00'00V UL $ el!L 0£V $ lu!ed 099 $ IlenWO 019'i$6ul-eui-womiseH Oul-e 3e61-IL3 SISAIVNV 1N3W3AOIIdWl .0-3-ML I81SS30 v- YOV lON NVId ALI118155300Y DNIlSI%3 .O-L=.011 NVId ALIII81SS300V 0390d09d . nLN amrm°o :.wa m wz :#80r N ° Z O mw m o, Z p? O? $ D m O — a A �p N m O O m O 0 m D_ z N rn W 'i?-dk• � m D 1 Z > cy) rm- y T Z D rcn-Vz> � �> G) xN�o�m 0 A m n ' 00 D(!)(1) Z C Z Vm O) D D r 0 Mvis e 2a0ZtiL-65 �0 zzOz-z0-90 Qe MmIlY o SN0151A3b 0-A= :31] lVc)S NVId MIS 03SOdO2Jd P d 1140a3NV300 M e a' I. xenxm,mul3! 3xY'3]"�'13 i =rrsk�av 11,•e'iia'. �i3Nu lU '. O O O 33163N ri � �� l 13NIBtl0 1D31313) .I ,.. . 1. ..,.., '£433'n'I�:N]ilmaV ' AVM 3AWO (3) ccs 11Nn A:'rs,M,.ie F.O1JAW i < o �. w I1I j� h N � NMYLI e1 nNYeId %ila't3 m m 0 m � D W x T eosslr+n � 901' 11Nl1 '� .� i � �y11 ,wu��• J lirililtltl31�Zo 39 MLjw •f� - ... NTJOM I Jo 3d00S T .. I }� 1� Mawr' EVI 11NR' .. 00111Nn:.. } —' ------ 06 - NVId 311S'JNIlSIX3 3NV300 M Dr „��n»u'cuati>Nonl - 7' J J F N CD m m x jr �. eocLlNn... — N1lOM d03dOOS Im —..—_..� .. ... 1 °3omm.>r+.P .eppnl euwo3 h.n, � � I IOm loGilNn I so llNfJ Y0411YR • dd0� of V/' d o19P'i G-d ZZO CO90 �"m Ztzoz :#Sop w xz D s- O 0 1 e > CO 0 a -I M w fiDw 0 O 00 m m D1 z U1 � W rn w 5a�p� YqE6 �as •'ik ��g4�f�s�gf Fc �'Fe Ff £ie3[�1P r.mD1Z yr-�;o)G) !�m`z_`zlm— ymzr� r v v z D DCG) x^'X-1m � v3 A p1 p 0an�m z01).CG) m Jz D r n dVlviS e ZZOZ9L-fA `�S ZZOZSZ•pO z Zo-K e zmz�o eo SNOISIrea .O-.L=:%31VOS NVId 31IS ONIISIX3Q 1N0a3NV300 M sro,xm�.3 3mec.s aiYygiX:l LiYuofL Ns�V'm� •. . L LL DNR 14W LYiv'X F� ., o0.1LY�' Got 10afl .] r m � S06 1.PllNnNA �— ;t v a3rva0dsrmL131 v v v AVM 3A210 (3) n 1 ZD / I 1 y 9 �b N I m �- "OOZO 1 e6) 11N7j � 1 " Nranalilalma(1 an ii-in :1N@— ..... :. • �: ':: I N1:10M ... i dO 3d00S CL :awCW a NI" : wm31aN:: .14. i I OL 11NA EOf 1rT y01 lINN i + I� I I I — ___ ,a•ss I I Rk NMBtl Ol DNXtlY6 D1P3 m N m W x v m i r e } SAV210010ld'R SNOIS - 9 m.�ox,a.n m.�am.aawY..mmm�sn. •Hw as ww w�ea1�: ..,mr.iu�ax xvm,am•n x,a,gm�,n +iww,,,.r eoYrYwla. 4V P.,4-'Jf-Y13�6A53Y,T'1 nxYhwrcLi,nl 111..E •anxn� ,nm.�i mwuY..ax. fgNA Kq'a'AxN [av��t° 4,WW°xxYx Waltns.�wsei ZJNIN21tlM 31Htl109130 - 9 el0000 I ❑ o°o°0 0 SN0IlISNVHIWO13 4 IBWd.I..L'�I�r�,efanvexu.vm,w,wwn aw 3 •�je � a awn�M =Ytl1.m,nnNlsLn x „mu .Wuraw ww,Pmmn.v TiG ^n...—..• .... I n I I n1tl Qnn. 1� M.Y. r�iirF/5l wxx, and vXapfm _ NOIS SSEIHO3 31Il0Vl - E , Sm�iYMr, ltVHl��1M]H,�WNKn4! �„e W, .m nw+�.x+,n*��YXaxuu ms,mw°Lv, � wUN}�n,YiBN,P!>I hJ°HW Wiw a g3 ols� 3AW� M't0lev,aW N � „s Vnu°1 Ndf8bN •o avo5vm un mro�nM1SNLvaM arummw 411XG'mtx' . pµxgy38rXyy„n.�i•KI n� nN ao,�ureraaw.w,wn.+° as sww.uwi+,'Wx mmme ia�,u�un S1N3W32im3d NOIS 'OOV - Z mxr....ouanwvn�n�w �x"nmm�� � ,tl. �+IwKaew3Nwt.i3�N� HwxwiwmMnglXvfu_�B,v�,n .[.°auuMxw3lnn.sH,B i,nc f�iMofw,L YopwmXw lw.rrsxae ..nwa,•,w,runmoo..rua � 'DM1SI%33LLi01ND13H3H10330N310N114N1N3VY10030350dOtld 3Hl XVidtl00a3X1013LON ml,"L'n,>�r �x�mm I 310N WUM30 9 I F F 3mnDNSIM33noev,Le ONtl3003 tlD,nMwmHNDu03roaa.rNaN1a31v3aD L X.mn>,w a��H� � •,MMSNOa00tl1Sa0 DNI0NJHa3d0dD 33tla10d NV1NWNxoarI''dYRMY5tl031V0WN13SM3HLOSRMNn W'N 31i111 Ntl IMISI13AV LAONOIL?3MPIMUO1S%Z0GMYB LONS3 UOISSKbtl TH.X.H,r,' w3'JVN`0lMnf1,Tw�3rv]x 3.W i wanmvman.w Yn 310N Nvld 9115 3ENNOIS 318ISS300V L sgmm,rxan 0 Ip+4/OaNp an" Yf]W WY nTa biMnM, W"P.L i 311MA 4NV S2010"VH0 0361" - 9 NOUVO01 ONV1N013H N011tl IMNI VSOL-ML 0NV3l ME 080V1 LLOZ HAM AI ROO 1WHS ONV(Z30VN0)0310"IN00381WHSATIVH8- 'NOI1VO01 ONV 1H018H NOI1VlWiSNl V'£OL-8L L HIM 30NVOEOOOV N10N11VISNI 3S IIVHS SUMOYHVH0 03SIVH'3111V68 C'£OL-SL L HIM OWId WOO 3lli"S NI 031V011dn0 36 IIVHS ONV SHglOV8VHO 03SI" Z'£OL-8 L U31dVH0 OBOVI LLOZ HMM AldW00llVHR SbAl3VNVH0 03SIV3 - S310N 1N3W3i1f1Stl3W 3llIV21S QZ �e,vw,u ane o ov o� ��ierv� m w : naoamcaw r,�m,l �B100N33N,3B3]INI610 ,!1'A1NN i'XPllBY/Nr •Hre]iY.WL.0 S?S31OV'dVHO 311IV88 JO N0I11S0d NJ 03SIVH dO 1HO13H Z'fMf1 UDWOIA S'Z'£OL-8L63anold �L b