HomeMy WebLinkAboutF2020-0378 - Alternative Material & Methods (3)Q rEW PpA,T
e
u r
w
c9trcoaNvr^
F�O'a0-03Te
�GESJED By
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH '01vut'(V
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
BUILDING DIVISION N
100 Civic Center Drive I P.O. Box 1768 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915
www.newoortbeachca.gov 1 (949) 644-3200
c,
CASE NO.: 2, 11 -! )1 �OF l
❑ REQUEST FOR MODIFICATION TO PROVISIONS
OF TITLE 9 (FIRE CODE) OR TITLE 15 (BUILDING CODE)
OF THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee$291)
❑x REQUEST FOR ALTERNATE MATERIAL
OR METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee $291)
For above requests, complete Sections 1, 2 & 3
below by printing in ink or typing.
JOB ADDRESS:
SITE ADDRESS: 850 San Clemente Dr.
Owner Vivante Newport Center, LLC
Address 1 MacArthur Place, Suite 300
Santa Ana, CA Zip 92707
Daytime Phone ( 714 ) 546-5600 x220
III FOR STAFF USE ONLY 1
Plan Check # / 7-!
Occupancy ClassAifc,
Use of Building A
Project Status _
Construction Type _
Verified by
No. of Items
Fee due
DISTRIBUTION:
caner
Ian Check.
Petitioner
Inspector
Fire
❑ Other
PETITIONER:
Petitioner HKS Architects, Inc. (Eduardo Caceres)
(a.rmnner eo as .mnmce w .nym..d
Address 539 Bryant St. #100
San Francisco, CA Zip 94107
Daytime Phone ( 415 ) 544-5541
Email: ecaceres(ohksinecom
y IKEUUEST: We request to use a volume equivalency calculation for purpose of meeting building Code section 408.6 regardi q II
Please see the attached RFI #428 response reflecting the comparison of a standard
size shower with related slope and threshold reouirements in order to retain a certain
Petitioners ECACERESN, o�v� Position vVss1Hu411vs A�Mir,isw.vr vi��-rv��iv�rri
C 2565]
Signature CA Professional Lie. # Date: 11/1712021 N
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
DEPARTMENT ACTION: In accordance with: XCBC 104A l/CFC 104 9
(Alternate malenals & methods)
❑ Concurrence from Fire Code Official is required. ❑ Approved ❑ Disapproved
By: Date
34 Request (ECM (DOES NOT) lessen any fire protection requirements.
'Request tt3BEB) (DOES NOT) lessen the structural integrity
❑ CDC 104.10/CFC 104.E
OBC Modification)
❑ Written Comments Attached
The Request is: X Granted ❑Denied (See reverse for appeal information)
❑ Granted (Ratification required)
Conditions of Approval:
-'—_�) l-t tt--
SignatL � Position u-r -
Print Name! j_=hiC-7
Date Z3 Zvy-
APPEAL OF DIVISION TION TO THE BUILDING BOARD OF APPEALS (See Reverse)
(Signature, statement of own o applicant, said re ns a eal and filing fees are required.)
CASHIER RECEIPT NUMBER: Formsvnodif 07101121
Nexus Construction Services Inc Project: 17-10-0272 Vivante Newport Center
IME)QwS i MacArthur PI, Ste 850-856 San Clemente Or
Santa Ana, California 92707 Newport Beach, California 92660
CONSTRUCTION SERVICES P: 714 546 5600 P:7145465600
F: 714 546 5660
RFI #RFI428: Shower Pans Correction Notice
Status
Closed on 11/12/21
To
Joe Melia (Schnackel Engineers)
From
Caceres Eduardo (HKS Architects, Inc.) (Response
Required)
Date Initiated
Oct 18, 2021
Due Date
Location
Residential Units
Project Stage
Cost Impact
TBD
Schedule Impact
Spec Section
Cost Code
Drawing Number
A2.89
Reference
Linked Drawings
Change Reason
Building Inspection Notice
City Review
Received From
Dave Hill (ECLR Flooring, Inc.)
Copies To
Activity
Question
Official Response
Official Response
Ernesto Rebollar (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.)
1 MacArthur PI, Ste 300
Santa Ana, California 92707
Oct 22, 2021
Course of Construction
TBD
Todd Bailey (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), Brad Cameron (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), Josh Flegel (Nexus Construction
Svcs Inc.), Allen Hancock (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), Dave Hill (ECLR Flooring, Inc.), Chad Martin (Nexus Construction
Svcs Inc.), Steve Meister (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), Nadeem Mohammed (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), David Pacheco
(Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), Ernesto Rebollar (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.), Kerry Tebbe (Nexus Construction Svcs Inc.)
Question from Ernesto Rebollar Nexus Construction Svcs Inc. on Monday, Oct 18, 2021 at 02:23 PM PDT
Location: Residential Units
Issue/Question: The City of Newport Beach building inspector notified us that the shower pans are not in compliance with
CPC 408.5. Please see attached correction notice and advise.
Thank you.
Attachments
VNC - shower comection.pdf
Response from Brad Cameron Nexus Construction Svcs Inc. on Friday, Nov 12, 2021 at 09:25 AM PST
Per calculation, dimension from top of drain to top of threshold shall be 1 1/8-in minimum. Verify in field.
Response from Caceres Eduardo HKS Architects, Inc. on Friday, Nov 12, 2021 at 08:14 AM PST
See attached revised threshold detail with alternate threshold. With Volume equivalency.
Attachments
RFI-428 ASK- 21-1104 Shower Volume Equivalency.pdf
Nexus Construction Services Inc Page 1 of 1 Printed On: Nov 12, 2021 09:26 AM PST
iauueogweo yl!m pauueog
2
U
W
m
F-
m
0
a
w
z
LL
0
q
0
Q om
JL
LLI m w
❑ O �
d
ZK
zc
C) o
J u
m
5 a
cc o c
m—
O
m
N
❑ J m
W CO
z 7
W J
i a
o
J : w
U F
wo
m m Z o
N
O
m UNN U
0
z
W
U
W
a
z_
J
z
Z
7
w
m
0
a
x
w
z
w
J
m
N
y
w
U
z
w
w
K
J
Q
m
a
z
0
U
W
a
fN
z
da
om
o�
UHF
Ada
SDom
00
mew
m m
O_>>
H L Zy
w U O
Z o 0
w?�
�Qa
Il'FJ U
Q N N
Oct
(7
F z
LIJj0
J Z
zU-
<Z<
(nin0
Z m LL
-4
LL
Lu 0
i f"
r
U)aW
LL 2 LL
0 0 N
ZUZ
CD�_
�
wDQ
O�W
�U0
LL¢0
J (L >d
F- F 0
W Uf-❑
F
LLI U) LU
F
x Lu 0 W j
2
J�Uj LL
20
wawa
O�QFO
p
C
h
E N L
N
p
l i
E J C C O p
II
N O' O ro
N�
O
m
a 0 0
N
C
Q
C
c
'a E 3 Yin
ci
o
m
C L a O II
W
C
IF
C N W W O
C C
~
N
E
N J N p L
N
O N M
C
O
N N t N
Rl
II N
N"
c
E E E
E
E
(fJ
.�
o� c
7
L
d VNI V `Y > Nu
C II C
N
y
—
C y > 'V
j
m
N
N O L y C
.c 3 E
J
Oj
N c M
�.}
O+
m o u
`�.
>-o
ZN
o-n
E wa
p3F4
Nm
'�
oa oo� v o p
FIIw
IIQ
zN
O
L
a
N N C
W
y of C a--W
H
N W N O V
C
J
C
ih
W
N W O W aL+ „ p
'D
W
N
J
C
U
C N C L O
_
O (n O C
+
U
CiN
U L
W
n m 11
W
E TzO c O
3
OtiN
zmm
� inN„"
U
��
0
Ed
o
aoi
�p O O
E
h
v
EE'
r
`y
o E.yc o w
a.m of
ON
E
��
O
�
3
N
C II 2
=aQm.-m
eE
r , c cv o
w�mo�a
rW
L
0
C w i L N II
Z
d
W
E
Q_
J
O 7 6(V
zT
wv�ory3vG
v>
WONOM�
>m
m
o
E E
mNQo
>
a
VI
�'V ✓ L O n O-
m m
w
win
3aarc o<
oa
° a�
�
o o�.o_',
o0o
o
az�
�aa?a33
o"°w
mow w3
W
z
m
>n
I
J
a'
z
m
x
4
Y
W
x�
1
=i1
Q
�
d
�
S
�
zz
O
wwo
I I
O
N
LL�w
s
=
W
\�
JUJ
o"
a
LL
o
>
'zo
mo
°zw50
°m
Q
UJ
o
°mG
=
as m
m
:wa
zw-
V1
wm Nz
O
o`az
Z9z,
mom
W
°3s
musz
2
•
-
a -
d
WLLa
J
O
F
3
z5°u
f
Per
$
I
W
S
�
C
W
C
ry
!
Cd
:
Vl
'
i4
3
z-
F
z
t
O
a°
ui �
`o
IF
N
Q
G
O
s
� a
111
_ w
o w owl
�Dm
mzP
mor
m z `<
m0,
71 W S
�m a)
0<
0 Ln
m
D Wv a (j)
m m -4
D m
m N N
C = m
Cm%% z a OODZ
0 �_ r a ?DZmO
z
O C r O�,m
m
O 'J, mmX
m?0
2
--AO0OD
ui mmmz
D T�1 mDm
ry mom
Iw z S
Yl 5 0 Z
m
z OAS
O~
r
0
r
a jN
m
z
F
m m D m
0 5
m Z
Z O
O
m
-�r4p)
D
z
TKO
, rzDO
C mZ
D Amc
v-T xO
r m0c
Om
OO ZC CI zmOT
O�D
j Omm
r Opp
ODm
1, mZz
p m
evz^
O
mmm
�D
myO
N
WOE
mm
�"m
KZ
C
SNm
XO
�m
mm�
AAZ
Nm
m=
ZZO
m
o
O m
w0
m
mm
X1
=
O
zD
LSO
�D
o
m
O
iv m
= _L
1 m
ZNm;o
mxpmmc0
O�KDOZO
D
DOm'm
z�Dm
�DOm�mC
iv ^? Z
O m�
Z
D A m
m 1
r0�
A D
mrm-?
i m m
Om mT�
X
m
O
�O�A
my zD
> Ln O! 00
`
Od10
r—r 0
Z�m
m0
mS{Cow
>ZC 7�ND
v
mpm
,
r17