HomeMy WebLinkAboutXR2023-2263 - Alternative Material & MethodsXe-ZPZ,5- zz S
D��EWP°R�e CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH eECEror�eY
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT EVE VT
u ¢ BUILDING DIVISION ELOPMENT
Cq[/FORH�P 100 Civic Center Drive I P.O. Box 1768 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915 DEC
www.newportbeachca.gov 1 (949) 644-3200 D192023
CASE NO.:/ ew L— M7 1 CITY OF
REQUEST FOR MODIFICATION TO PROVISIONS
OF TITLE 9 (FIRE CODE) OR TITLE 15 (BUILDING CODE)
OF THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee $276)
REQUEST FOR ALTERNATE MATERIAL
OR METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION J306
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee-$249)
❑ REQUEST FOR EXEMPTION FROM DISABLED
ACCESS DUE TO PHYSICAL OR LEGAL
CONSTRAINT (Fee $1,535)
(Ratification by the Board of Appeals will be required.)
For above requests, complete Sections 1, 2 & 3
below by printing in ink or typing.
JOB ADDRESS:
SITE ADDRESS: 2808 Ocean Blvd
Owner Carmel Beach 2022, LLC
Address 6133 Bristol Pkwv
Culver City, CA Zip 90230
Daytime Phone ( )
t plans if necessary to illustrate re
)mpllance with 3" concrete cover
to earth will be provided by the a
NDINGS OF EQUIVALENCY -
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
Plan Check # L(Aw' 171'FS pfStones I
Occupancy Classification 1V
Use of Building S A C9 of Units
Project Status
Construction Type
Verified by
No. of Items
Fee due
DISTRIBUTION:
❑ Owner QYJ Plan Check kH
W Petitioner ❑ Inspector
❑ Fire ❑ Other
Petitioner Roy Reed (Engineer)
6Peehoner to be architect or engineer)
Address 7727 Caminito Liliana
San Diego, CA Zip 92129
sheets or data
L protection, as outlined in the attached product data sheets. This product has
Signature
Position Principle Engineer
CA Professional Lic. # C80503
CBC 1812.2; ACI 318 Table 1808.8.2
Date 12/13/2023
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
DEPARTMENT ACTION: In accordance with: -CBC 104.11/CFC 104.9 ❑ CBC 104.10/CFC 104.8
(Alternate materials 8 methods) (CBC Modification)
❑ Concurrence from Fire Code Official is required. ❑ Approved ❑ Disapproved ❑ Written Comments Attached
By:
Request (DOES DO lessen any fire protection requirements.
Request (DOE ) (DOE ) lessen the structural integrity
Date
I The Request is 2FGranted I
❑ Denied (See reverse for
❑ Granted (Ratification required) appeal information)
Print Name
of
Posltir6HIEF BUI1 DING OFFICIALDate 1Z-Z0- ZO'7--3
APPEAL OF DIVISION ACTION TO THE BUILDING BOARD OF APPEALS (See Reverse)
(Signature, statement of owner or applicant, statement of reasons for appeal and fling fees are required.)
CASHIER RECEIPT NUMBER: ECG' C z / / 9,j - z0z3 F.rmstmodif 11/0212016
Guidelines for Approval of Alternate Materials Design and Methods of Construction
Basis For Approval
For the Chief Building Official and Fire Code Official or their designated agent to approve a request for modification
or a request for alternate material or method of construction, he/she must determine that special, individual reasons
exist that make compliance with the strict letter of the Code impractical and that equivalency is provided. The
resulting condition must be in conformance with the spirit and purpose of the Code provisions involved and that
such modification does not lessen fire protection, structural integrity or occupant safety. The applicant must provide
sufficient information with this application to allow the above evaluation to be made.
Requirements for Submittals
The applicant design professional shall prepare a Written Report that describes the alternate proposal along with the
applicable data listed below:
• State specific code provisions for which alternative is requested and why request is being submitted. -
• Describe by code section those provisions for which alternative is desired.
• Compare the proposed alternative versus the code requirements in terms of structural strength, suitability,
effectiveness, fire resistance, safety and health impacts affecting the building or user of the building.
• Demonstrate that the proposed alternative is compatible with balance of code requirements.
• When applicable, specify how authoritative consensus document(s) are used to substantiate proposal.
(Reference draft [CC Building Performance Code Commentary Section 1.4.2.3 for background information).
• Provide assumptions, references, and documentation of evaluation methods utilized. This includes intended
use, input data, anticipated outputs, and limitations of computer models and other analytical tools or methods.
• Specify when and where special inspection and testing are required and the standards of acceptance for
demonstrating compliance. Show how the proposed alternate, if accepted, will be identified on the job site.
• Where land use restrictions and building setbacks are required, deed restrictions may be an appropriate
method to ensure continued compliance.
• State how and where alternate proposal is incorporated within construction plans and prepare plan
amendments as necessary. The design professional has the responsibility to coordinate all construction
documents and ensure compatibility between documents.
• The report and design documents shall be dated, signed and stamped by the design professional according to
the plan submittal procedure.
• For alternate methods of design requests, the applicant shall set performance criteria for his design.
Performance criteria shall be reviewed, amended and approved by the Building or Fire Code Official prior to
start of design.
Alternative Design ReviewNerification
The Chief Building Official or Fire Code Official has the responsibility to review design submittals for compliance to
the adopted codes and procedures. If the Building or Fire Code Official does not have the expertise on staff to
make a thorough and competent review, the Building or Fire Code Official shall select a consultant that possesses
the necessary qualifications to perform a third -party or peer review. Cost of peer review shall be paid by applicant
to the Building Division prior to commencing the review.
• Verify that all applicable information and justifications listed above as requirements for submittals is received and
verify that evaluation and design methods used by designer are appropriate to the alternative proposed.
• Verify products are being used in accordance with their listing conditions as required by recognized listing
agencies. If not available, require documentation and/or testing to demonstrate compliance with intent of code
and intended use.
• Evaluate performance of material and possible flaws that could affect performance of material in its installed
state.
• The reviewer shall document that the submittal has been reviewed and accepted as meeting the alternative
materials, design and methods of construction provisions of the code. If the Building or Fire Code Official is not
satisfied that the applicant has met the conditions, the request should be denied in writing with the applicable
reason(s).
Inspection/Field Verification
The alternate proposal as approved in the construction documents must be verified by inspection, and, where
necessary, testing as follows:
• To verify that altemate materials, systems and fabricated products comply with accepted design criteria and the
manufacturers and engineer's installation procedures, inspectors should check product labeling, certification,
quality assurance processes, and testing, as applicable.
• When appropriate, an approved third party quality assurance inspection and testing service may be required for
continuous and complex inspection and testing activities. This is intended to verify that construction complies
with the code and the approved plans.
Appeal from the determination or action of the Chief Building Official or Fire Code Official or their designated agent
may be made to the Building and Fire Board of Appeals. To appeal, the applicant must provide special individual
reasons that make compliance with the strict letter of the Code impractical. Appeals or ratifications pertaining to
State Disabled Access Standards require complete evidence to substantiate that the proposed design is equivalent
to that prescribed by that standards or that due to legal or physical constraints, compliance with the standards or
providing equivalency would create an unreasonable hardship.
Appeals must be submitted on the Appeal Form available at Permit Counter accompanied by the proper fee. You
will be notified in writing of the appeal hearing's time and date.
° �Carboguard890
product data fCarbo4liiibi
Selection & Specification Data f
Generic Type Cycloaliphatic Amine Epoxy General Surfaces must be clean and dry. Remove at dirt, tlus[,
Description Fighly chemical resistant epoxy mastic coating of and all other cortaninant.
with exceptionally versatile uses in all industrial steel
markets. GeV -priming and suitable for application
over most existing coatings, and tightly adherent
to rust. Serves as stand-alone system for a variety
of chemical environments and is also designed for Galvanized Steel
various immersion conditions.
Features • Excellent chemical resistance
• Surface tolerant characteristics
• Conventional and low -temperature versions Concrete or CMU
• Self -priming and primerifinish capabilities
• Very good abrasion resistance
• VOC compliant to current AIM regulations
• Suitable for use in USDA inspected facilities
Color
Referto Carboline Color Guide. Certain colors may
require multiple coatsfor hiding. Note: The low
temperature formulation well cause most colorsto
Yellow or discolor more than normal in a short period
of time.
Finish
Gloss
Printer
Self -priming.
Dry Film
4.0 - 6.0 mils (102 - 152 microns) per coat
Thickness
80.8D mils (160-200 miOnOW)ova light rustand br unibnn gloss ovar
inorganic zincs. front exceed to ails (25o morons) in a Angle coat.
E.,inhe flmthicknen overinorganic zees nmyincmase Barrage
during shipping or erection.
Solids Content
By Volume 75% -P 2%
Theoretical
1203 12 at 1.0 mils (29.5 Th at 25 microns)
Coverage Rate
301 ftat 4.0 mils (7.4 m2/1 at 100 rrticrons)
200 ft2 at 6.0 mils (4.9 In21I at 150 microns)
Aflowfor loss in Inking and application.
VOC Value(s)
Thinner 2 13ozigak2.30 lbsfgal (276g11)
Thinner 2 7ozlgal=2.08lbsfgal (250g11)
Thinner 33 16ozlga1=2.431bsigal (291 JD
Thinner 33 7ozlgak2.081bslgal (250gil)
As Supplied 1.011bsfgal (217 glp
"Use Thinner 876 up m 8 o ,gal forego and 16 oz/gal for ire LT where
non-phamcherricallyreadi+E solvelas are mquired.
These are nortinal values and may tierywiii color.
Dry Temp.
Continuous: 300 •F (149 •C)
Resistance
Non -Continuous: 350 •F (177 •C)
Discoloration and loss of gloss occurs above 200 F (0 C)bMt does not
armor perfomance.
Under Insulation
Continuous: 300 •F (149 •C)
Reslstan oB
oscoloration and loss of gloss occurs above 200 F (03 C)Iwt does cot
affect perfomaxe.
Limitations
Do not apply over latex coatings. For immersion
projects use only factory made material in special
colors. Consult Technical Service for specifics.
Topcoats
Immersion: SSPC-SP10
Non -immersion, SSPC-SP6
1.5-3.0 mIs (38-75 microns) SSPC_SP2 or SP3 are
sutede cleaning rretnals for Wd environments.
Prime with specific Carboline primers as
recommended by your Carboline Sales
Representative. Referto the specific primer's Product
Data Sheetfor requirements.
Concrete must be cured 28 days at 757 (24'C) and
50% relative humidity or equivalent Prepare surfaces
in accordance with ASTM D4258 Surface Cleaning of
Concrete and ASTM D4259 Abrading Concrete. Voids
in concrete may require surfacing. M ortar joints should
be cured a min of 15 days.
Drywall & Plaster Joint compound and plaster should be fully cured prior
to coating application.
Preaiousy Painted Lightly sand or abrade to roughen surface and degloss
Surfaces the surface. Existing paint must attain a Minimum
3A rating in accordance with ASTM D3359'x-Cut"
adhesion test.
Performance
Test Mtathod
System
Results
ASTM B 117 Salt Fog
Blasted Steel 2 cts. 890
NG effect on plane,
rust in scribe. iM R'
undercutting at scribe
after 2000 hours
ASTM B117 Salt Fog
Blasted Steel 1
No effect on plane,
ct. IOZ 1 ct 890
no rust in scribe
and no undercutting
after 4000 hours
ASTM D 4060 Abrasion
Blasted Steel 1 ct
85 mg. loss after
Epoxy Pc 1 ct 890
1000 cycles, CS17
wheel 1000 gm. load
ASTM D1735 Water FOE
Blasted Steel 1 ct
No blistering, costing
Epoxy Pr. 1 ct 890
or delarnmation
after 2800 hours
ASTM D2486
Blasted Steel 1 ct. 890
93% Joss retained
Scrub Resistance
after 10,000 cycles W
liquid scrub medium
ASTM D3359 Adhesion
Blasted Steqcts890
5A
ASTM D3363
Blasted Steorterthan
BHPencil
Hardness
ASTM E84 Flame
2 ct
5 Flame 5
and Smoke
Smoke Cie SA
test reports ale add¢ional data available upon Often request
Mixing & Thinning
Mixing Power mix separately, then combine and power ma.
DO NOT MD( PARTIAL IITS.
June 2016
0988
To the best ofour larowdedge the teorm ical data coma ned herein is fine and accuamte onthe date of pub le3i on and is Babied to on ange without prior notice. User nu5 coma Carbohnie Cc" any
m verify corre duress before spe cifynng or Ord edng. No guarantee ofaccuracy is grueh or implied. We guarantee our Products to confoormto Carao one quaky min,, I. We assume W respor ibility for
coverage. perlcmance or injuries resubing firm use. Liability, ifany, is limited to replacemem of products- N0 OTHER WARRANTY OR GUARANT t£ OF ANY KNNo IS AkSOE BY CAR B 0 LINE.
EX R ES 0R IM P LIE 0. STAT UTO RY, BY oP ERAT ION OF LAW, 0R OTHERWISE. NC LUOING M ER CHANTABILir Y AN D FITNESS FOR AP ARTI CU LAR PURPOSE_ CarbooneDand Carbowan10
are registered trademarks of Carboline Company.
Pagel oft
Carboguard° 890
Mixing & Thinning
Thinning Spray: Up to 13 oz/gal (10%) w/ #2
Brush: Up to 16 oz/gal (12%) w/ #33
Roller: Up to 16 oz/gal (12%) w/ #33
Thinner #33 can be used for spray in hot/windy
conditions. Use of thinners other than those supplied
or recommended by Carboline may adversely affect
product performance and void product warranty,
whether expressed or implied.
'See VOC values for thinning limits.
Ratio 1:1 Ratio (A to B)
Pot Life 3 Hours at 75'F (24°C)
Pot We ends when coating loses body and begins M sag. Pot lire limes
will be less at higher temperatures.
ApplicationGuidelines
Listed below are general equipment guidelines for Me application of Mis product. Job site conditions
may require modifications to these guidelines achieve the desired result.
Spray Application This is a high solids coating and may require
(General) adjustments in spray techniques. Wet film thickness
is easily and quickly achieved. The following spray
equipment has been found suitable and is available
from manufacturers such as Binks, DeVilbiss and
Gram.
Conventional Pressure pot equipped with dual regulators, 318"
Spray I.D. minimum material hose, .070" I.D. fluid tip and
appropriate air cap.
Airless Spray Pump Ratio: 30:1 (min.)'
GPM Output: 3.0 (min.)
Material Hose: 3/8" I.D. (min.)
Tip Size: .017"-.021 "
Output PSI: 2100-2300 Filter Size: 60 mesh
'Teflon packings are recommended and available from
the pump manufacturer.
Brush & Roller Multiple coats may be required to obtain desired
(General) appearance, recommended dry film thickness and
adequate hiding. Avoid excessive re -brushing or
rerolling. For best results, tie-in within 10 minutes at
75°F (24°C).
Brush Use a medium bristle brush.
Roller Use a short -nap synthetic roller cover with phenolic
core.
Condition
I Material
I Surface
1 Ambient
1 Humid
Minimum
50 °F (10 °C)
50 °F (10 °C)
50 °F (10 °C)
0%
Maximum
110 °F (43 °C
90%
This product simply requires the sutstrate temperature M be above Me dew poiML Condensation
due M substrate bmperatres below the dew point can cause flash mating on prepared steel and
interfere with proper adhesion M the substrate. Special application techniques may be required
a Cove or bebw normal application Conditions.
Curing Schedule
Surface
Terry;
1Dryrto RecoatDrytoRecoat
& Topcoat w/
other finishes
Final Cure
General
Final Cure
Immersion
50 °F (10 °C)
12 Hours
24 Hours
3 Days
NR
60 °F (16 °C)
8 Hours
16 Hours
2 Days
10 Days
It,°F (24 °C)
4 Hours
8 Hours
1 Days
5 Days
90'l (32 °C)
2 Hours
4 Hours
16 Hours
3 Days
Higher film thickness, insuficient ventilation or miler temperatures will require longer cure times and
mud result in aoNem eroapmen0 and premature failure_ Fxcessive humidity or condensation on the
surface during curing can inbedere with the cure, can cause discoloration and may result in a surface
haze. Any haze or brush mulsbe removed by water washing Carom recoating. During high humidity
conditions it is recommended that the application he done while temperatures are increasing.
Maximum recesti toppoat times are 30 days for epoxies and 90 days for polyurethanes at 75°F
(U4 ). If the maximum recoat times have been exceeded, Me surface must be abraded by sweep
blasting or sanding prior to Me application W additional coat.
Cleanup i Safety
Cleanup Use Thinner #2 or Acetone. In case of spillage, absorb
and dispose of in accordance with local applicable
regulations.
Safety Read and follow all caution statements on this product
data sheet and on the MSDS for this product. Wear
protective clothing, gloves and use protective cream
on face, hands and all exposed areas.
Ventilation Men used as a tank lining or in enclosed areas,
thorough air circulation must be used during and after
application until the coating is cured. User should test
and monitor exposure levels to insure all personnel
are below guidelines.
Packaging, Handling & Storage
Shelf Life Part A: 36 months at 75°F (24°C)
Part B: 15 months at 75°F (24°C)
'When kept at recommended storage com utons and in original
unopened Containers.
Shipping ylleight 2 Gallon KR - 29 Ibs (13 kg)
(Approximate) 10 Gallon Kit -145 Ibs (66 kg)
Storage
40°-110°F (4°-43°C)
Temperature &
0-100% Relative Humidity
Humidity
Flash Point
89°F (32°C) for Part A
(Setatlash)
73°F (23"C) for Part B
Storage
Store Indoors.
This product is soNerd based and not affected by excursions below
these published storage Mmperablres, dawn M 10°F, for a duabon of no
more than 14 days. Always inspect the product prior Muse M make sure
9 is smooth and homogeneous when properly mixed,
June 2016
osas
To the beatof our knowledge the technical data Combined herein is true and accurate on Me data of publicabon and is autill changewithout prior notice. User mug contact Carboline Company
M verify codecfi b ore spe,alyiN ar ordering. No guarantee of acouracy is given w implied. We guaarrtee our produdsM mnformM Carboline quaMy control. We asume no responsibility Mr
coverage, parrormance or injuries resulting from use. Liability, rf any, s timlted to mpbcerrent or product. NO OTHER WARRANTY OR GUARANTEE OF ANY IOND IS MADE BY CARBOUNE,
EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, STATUTORY, IT( OPERATION OF LAW, OR OTHERWISE, INCLUDING MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. CaibolineW and Carboguard®
are registered trademarks of Ca thilme Company_
Page 2 of 2
OLPN
�
/ T
I I \
- „ PROPOSED T.ORARY
I\ (SEE SHEET SHE FOR EL
�Z EI IC
\ TEMPORARv I 1 smPE
IBv oTHEu TVPICALI - I
BOG \
\ PPOPERiY 11NE \
TIMBER LAGGING FlLL 111 BEHIND LAGGING
(SEE ELEVATION) VaTI LEAN CONCRETE
WATER PROOLNG . p
B DRAINAGE BOARDS - a
IBY OTHER51 ��� - �-
TEMPORARY TMER BURN HOLES THROUGH SOLDIER
BLOCK OUTS PLACED AT BEAM WEBS FOR LONGITUDINAL
INTERIOR FACE OF WALL FOR DUE. (I IRA, MAx.
SOLDIER BEAM REMOVAL.
NOTES : 1. FIELD STAKE PROPERTY 1I1E5 PRpR TO SHORING INSTAWTION.
2. COORDINATE SHORING BLOCKWT WRH STRUCTURAL II
PARTIALLY ENCASED SOLDIER BEAM PLAN DETAIL - SM 3-27
C
REZUEST FOR ALTERNATE MATERIAL
A SAALL PORTION OF SOLDIER BEARS #3 21 BEAM/FLANGE SECTION DOES
NOT HAVE CONCRETE COVER BECAUSE OF THE NEED TO INSTALL
LAGGING. CORROSION PROTECTION 15 PROVIDED THROUGH THE USE OF
URBOLINE MAY PAINT, AS SHOWN IN DETAIL 2/SHA.
SHDRIII5
VATIONI r
B AOFWEB ALONG TY, 24'
1ZMIH.
IVERIEYI
P UNI SVBTERRANFAN ..,-INS WALL IDY OTXEUS
BE
WALL TON GRU BVDINAL LREINFORCFN.EI
(RUDER TO STRUCTURAL DRAWING51
CUT 4 REMOVE PROTRUDING WEB B FANGE UPON
COMPTFNON OF THE PROPOSED STRUCTURE AND/f
AS DIRECTED BV THE STRUCTURAL ENGINEER OF
RECORD. FILL ALL VOIDS WLIH AN APPROVED
VON SHRINK GROUT ACCORDING TO PROJECT
SPECIFICATIONS.
ICST ING DAORY RESIDENCE
c
LINE
A..:
EACANATION REF SHORING PILH$1
V[LL Uoli�e.
Carbogoardo 890
� vmeumn. xfl
"
mww�WVN
10.
Carboguare 890
CITY LL O.UNENPOBT BFACHI
:On1MU 1 I1 IFS, 'LIOPNILAC LI 1K1'N+
BLb" 004% 1P."OADRTRON
FS w
G ENO:
LL xW "'POI_YFP6L ORnT
IT TIT
EX�' .af: en aI A
n ww API .— r _
TO P1 OFFAL OR LINAL N.
r+vF.mu, m.rape as ^M,
w YpxtlnPxx4xbP4p ❑ ,0,
IJPAWRF]S PETIT may..
E�rl ,
Hui
�� -- - -SNAS
USSANG
cw
❑AP
TT.aw.rrn
❑n+ulwlraenm'mrrwulr.w ngerl wronnmwl
:apppmvi
nECEVTNUA.ER.. rmmma. .n. o-t
rcarMdiaPy
SHORING DESIGN GROUP T zB +on
GO
F\\1L��\ )�" (/^/ SHEET
U CNI
J 7CANINTO TRANA J,E6,zB15
SpN DIEGO, U 921E9, (7635R6 4121
Rov P. REED RCE. Bowl m. t n mzs DATE