HomeMy WebLinkAboutSS6 & 15 - JWA Noise Monitoring Stations - CorrespondenceReceived After Agenda
September 8, 2015
HARLAN AND DOTTIE HARMSEN rit m No SS6 &15
P.O. BOX 5887
September 6, 2015 Balboa Island, CA 92662
949 / 675-2100 !._ 0 # £ y
i t
To: Newport Beach City Council
City Manger's Office
100 Civic Center Drive, 2nd Floor, Bay E
Newport Beach, CA 92660
RE: SoCal Metroplex EA
September 6, 2015
It has recently come to our attention that we will soon have a reorganization of flight
departures from John Wayne Airport. Both the Newport City Council and the Board of
Supervisors indicated they have very little input on the future plans of SoCal Metroplex
EA in our area, as it is a Congressional -driven process with the FAA. Since this is a new
plan for Balboa Island, we are very disturbed that we have not been personally informed
by the Congress, FAA, Orange County Board of Supervisors, Newport Beach City
Council of this new development.
This will be a major change in our community and we should have been personally
notified of such.
As we understand the verbal and visual plan, flights will continue to fly over Balboa
Island and the FAA flight pattern indicates planes will fly over the middle of the Island,
between Ruby Avenue and Diamond. We live on Ruby Avenue and the proposed
narrowing of the flight paths also indicates that we will get MORE fly overs than we do
now. John Wayne has (as of September 2, 2015) 174 departures. They start fly avers at
7 am and finish at 10 pm. Please look at the enclosed schedule of departing flights and
the photo of the FAA fly over plans to get an idea of why we are writing this letter.
We don't just have a plane fly over once an hour. They are actually minutes apart. All
day long. It is impossible to enjoy our home and our patio to have a conversation.
We have had owned 120 Ruby Avenue since 1939. When the property was
purchased, it was not known that the Airport would grow and grow and grow and
fly over 100 plus times a day. The FAA needs to consider more than a plan for the
aircraft. They have to consider the people that are being impacted by their decisions.
We have 15 hours of jets, noise and pollution.
We have read the goals of the FAA and the one that concerns us most is the RNAV
(more narrow, repeatable tracks) not good or healthy for any neighborhood,
and it is NOT ACCEPTABLE.
The John Wayne Airport Departure Feasibility Assessment (February 28, 2013),
prepared by Naverus, Inc. for the City of Newport Beach seems like a better way to
proceed. It suggests flying over the Back Bay to the ocean. Please read this report.
It seems to satisfy the FAA efforts for:
Safety
Efficiency
Repeatability
Maximization of congeste paces.
'ncerelyG��
Dottie and Harlan Harm n
Printed
MATIONI
,,O .
E)EPARTU
9/31x015, 7:25:25 AM
Plight Partner Time
City
Atlanta
Chicago MDW
Chicago ORD
Chicago ORD
mnn5xc Pt_ Worth
-------------
Dallas Love
Denver
Los Angeles
Minneapolis
Minneapolis
Delta
I,wr •—
DL2454 VS2697 6'45 am
cnuthwest WN2658 AC5171
UA1611 EIK636992 6:45 am
US593 AA593 6:45 am
United
US Airways
American
Southwest
Southwest
t-^ . . 441 I A I M CA-
JVua.
AA1627
WN3235
WN2996
%A! N
V t.�vu
Cni �i-hihtp t N2658
W
Southwest WN3235
98 6:45 am
6:45 am
6:45 am
6:45 am
Status
Terminal
Gate
Departed
A
4
Departed
C
16
Departed
B
15
Departed
B
11
Departed
A
8
Departed
C
20
Departed
C
21
Departed
C
20
AA593
6 :45 am
Departed
6:45 am vepal Lt --U -
F r 1 F,
6:45 am vepar ACU
6:45 am Departed
C 20
New Orleans
UA1611
AC517115
SK39
6:45 am
Departed
B
Newark NJ
United
2
EI669
21
Oakland
Southwest
WN2996
-GS
6:45 am
Departed
Departed
C
B
11
Phoenix
US Airways
AA593
6 :45 am
Departed
C
21
Phoenix
Southwest
WN2996
6:45 am
Departed
C
20
San Antonio
Southwest
WN3235
6:45 am
Cancelled
B
16
San Francisco
United
UA6502
AC4267
6:45 am
16
San Francisco
Southwest
WN2658
6:45 am
Departed
C
13
Houston
United
UA321
CM2498
6:50 am
Departed
B
Miami
United
UA321
CM2498
6:50 am
Departed
B
13
Denver
United
UA1101
AC5506
6:56 am
Departed
B
9
Denver
United
UA1101
AC5506
6:56 am
Departed
B
9
Newark NJ
United
UA1923
AC2214
6;59 am
Departed
B
14
IB7139
Chicago ORD
American
AA1215
US1215
7:00 am
Departed
A
7
BA1802
San Jose
Southwest
WN2704
7:00 am
Departed
C
17
San Jose
Southwest
WN2704
7:00 am
Departed
C
17
DL7527
Seattle
Alaska
AS519
AF9640
7:00 am
Departed
A
5
AA7119
Salt Lake City
Delta
DL4742
7:05 am
Departed
A
3
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN551
7:15 am
Departed
C
18
New Orleans
Southwest
WN551
7:15 am
Departed
C
18
Dallas Ft, Worth
American
AA1342
US1342
AS1138
7:30 am
A
10
Seattle
Southwest
WN2652
7:35 am
C
21
n—,-, I I,-nid-hAniaci- \A/N1 873 7:45 am C 20
Chicago MDW
Southwest
WN3064
CM2496
7:50 am
U
ly
Kansas City
Southwest
WN3064
A(-5213
NH7367
7:50 am
C
19
Los Angeles
Southwest
WN3064
AC5213NH7367
7:50 am
C
19
Phoenix
Southwest
WN3064
AF8757
7:50 am
C
19
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA244
US244
AS1140
8:00 am
A
8
Newark NJ
American
AA244
US244
AS1140
8:00 am
A
8
Houston
United
UA589
AA6891
8:30 am
B
12
Seattle
Alaska
AS527
AF9645
8:10 am
A
6
Minneapolis
Delta
DL1343
DL7627
8:30 am
A
3
Cnr^ramcnfn
gniifhwP�-,t
WN2888
AF3063
8:15 am
C
15
San Francisco
Southwest
WN2939
CM2496
8:20 am
U
lb
San Francisco
United
UA322
A(-5213
NH7367
8:27 am Gate Change
B
11
Seattle
United
UA322
AC5213NH7367
8:27 am Gate Change
B
11
Oakland
Southwest
WN2021
AF8757
9:45 am
C
17
Atlanta
Delta
DL1918
KL6815
8:30 am
A
4
Portland
Southwest
WN2474
VS2698
9:05 am
C
18
Houston
United
UA589
CM2496
8:30 am
B
12
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA1298
KL6563
9:15 am Cancelled
A
16
Minneapolis
Delta
DL1343
VS2276
8:30 am
A
3
MiI%A►aI ILIPP
Southwest
WN2404
AF3063
9:20 am
C
19
can lncP
Southwest
WN1860
8:30 am
C
17
Tampa
United
UA589
CM2496
8:30 am
b
iz
Southwest
WN234
9:25 am
US2248
15
San Francisco
United
Chicago ORD
American
AA2248
BA8692
8:55 am Gate Change
A
7
Oakland
Southwest
WN2021
GF6715
9:45 am
C
17
Dallas Love
Southwest
WN2474
KL9457
DL7716
AA6883
9:05 am
C
18
Portland
Southwest
WN2474
AA689
9:05 am
C
18
Phoenix
US Airways
US689
081298
10:00 am
B
10
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA1298
AS1431
9:15 am Cancelled
A
16
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN1847
GF6495
10:05 am
C
18
MiI%A►aI ILIPP
Southwest
WN2404
9:20 am
C
19
Phoenix
Southwest
WN2404
9:20 am
C
19
Chicago MDW
Southwest
WN234
9:25 am
C
15
San Francisco
United
UA6349 AC4487
9:28 am
B
1B
Cabo San Lucas
Southwest
WN624
9:30 am
U
Portland
Alaska
AS587
DL7685
AA7075
g:30 am
A
5
Mexico City
Southwest
WN522
9:40 am
C
Oakland
Southwest
WN2021
9:45 am
C
17
Seattle
Alaska
AS501
KL9457
DL7716
AA6883
9:55 am 10:05 am
A
6
Newark NJ
US Airways
US689
AA689
10:00 am
B
10
Phoenix
US Airways
US689
AA689
10:00 am
B
10
Sacramento
Southwest
WN4669
10:00 am
C
16
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN1847
10:05 am
C
18
Seattle
Southwest
WN1847
10:05 am
C
18
GF6666
Chicago ORD
American
AA114
US114
BA7791
10:15 am
A
8
Salt Lake City
Delta
DL4797
10:15 am
A
3
Chicago ORD
United
UA1155
AC5550
SN8878
EI6693
10:21 am
B
12
Washington Dulles
United
UA1155
AC5550
SN8878
EI6693
10:21 am
B
12
Denver
Southwest
WN2433
10:30 am
C
19
Hartford
Southwest
WN1677
10:40 am
C
15
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN1677
10:40 am
C
15
San Jose
Southwest
WN1677
10:40 am
C
15
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA2506
AS1168
US2506
BA1811
10:55 am 11:20 am
A
7
Phoenix
Southwest
WN1717
10:55 am 11:25 am
C
16
Seattle
Southwest
WN411
11:00 am
C
17
Baltimore
Southwest
WN1553
11:10 am
C
18
Denver
Southwest
WN1553
11:10 am
C
18
San Francisco
Southwest
WN1553
11:10 am
C
18
Seattle
Alaska
AS509
AA6947
11:10 am
A
6
Chicago MDW
Southwest
WN2625
11:15 am
C
19
Newark NJ
Southwest
WN2625
11:15 am
C
19
Oakland
Southwest
WN2625
11:15 am
C
19
Boise
United
UA5187
LH9239
AC4247
11:19 am
B
1B
San Francisco
United
UA5187
LH9239
AC4247
11:19 am
B
1B
Puerto Vallarta
Southwest
WN763
11:20 am
C
Houston
United
UA749
CM2558
11:33 am
B
9
Mexico City
United
UA749
CM2558
11:33 am
B
9
San Jose
Southwest
WN2923
12:00 pm
C
15
Denver
Southwest
WN525
12:10 pm
C
16
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN525
12:10 pm
C
16
New Orleans
Southwest
WN525
12:10 pm
C
16
Tucson
Southwest
WN525
12:10 pm
C
16
Seattle
Alaska
AS513
AA6885
K L94 51
12:30 pm
A
6
Atlanta
Delta
DL2109
VS2699
AF2791
KL7575
12:35 pm
A
4
Dallas Love
Southwest
WN614
12:35 pm
C
18
Denver
Frontier
F9262
12:35 pm
C
21
Phoenix
Southwest
WN614
12:35 pm
C
18
San Antonio
Southwest
WN614
12:35 pm
C
18
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA1278
GF4358
AS1172
US1278
12:36 pm
A
8
Dallas Love
Southwest
WN515
12:40 pm
C
19
Denver
Southwest
WN2509
12:40 pm
C
17
Deaver
US Airways
US642
AA642
12:40 pm
B
10
Phoenix
US Airways
US642
AA642
12:40 pm
B
10
Guadalajara
United
UA375
CH8704
12:44 pm
B
9
Houston
United
UA375
CM2011
LH 8704
12:44 pm
B
9
Minneapolis
Delta
DL2851
KL7155
VS2275
1:00 pm
A
3
Denver
United
UA265
LH9071
AC5027
1;03 pm
B
11
Salt Lake City
Delta
DL2509
A17:910145
F9KL845245
1:38 pm
A
5
Chicago ORD
United
UA1028
SK3956
AC5628
1: 39 pm
B
12
DC National
United
UA1028
SK3956
AC5628
1: 39 pm
B
12
Oakland
Southwest
WN2131
1:40 pm
C
15
Eugene
United
UA6301
AC4589
1:49 pm
B
1B
San Francisco
United
UA6301
AC4589
1:49 pm
B
1B
Houston
United
UA542
CM2179
1:52 pm
B
9
Phoenix
Southwest
WN497
2:05 pm
C
16
Sacramento
Southwest
WN497
2:05 pm
C
16
San Antonio
Southwest
WN497
2:05 pm
C
16
Charleston
Southwest
WN2852
2:15 pm
C
17
Houston
Southwest
WN2852
2:15 pm
C
17
Portland
Southwest
WN2654
2:20 pm
C
18
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA222
AS1177
US222
2:22 pm
A
7
San Jose
Southwest
WN2187
2:30 pm
C
19
San Francisco
Southwest
WN2719
2:50 pm
C
15
Vancouver
WestJet
WS1755
2:54 pm
A
Portland
Alaska
AS583
DL9829129
L9
J..L pm
A
6
Chicago MDW
Southwest
WN193
3:15 pm
C
16
Chicago ORD
American
AA1644
BA7785
US1644
3:15 pm
A
8
Denver
Southwest
WN193
3:15 pm
C
16
El Paso
Southwest
WN301
3:15 pm
C
17
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN301
3:15 pm
C
17
Denver
United
UA809
ACS278
3:57 pm
B
12
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA1599
GF6873
BA6706
US1599
4:00 pm
A
7
Phoenix
Southwest
WN2377
4:00 pm
C
18
Portland
Southwest
WN2377
4:00 pm
C
18
San Jose
Southwest
WN2377
4:00 pm
C
18
Sacramento
Southwest
WN2435
4:15 pm
C
19
Seattle
Alaska
AS507
DL7574
AA6887
4:15 pm
A
6
Phoenix
US Airways
US441
AA441
4:30 pm
B
Oakland
Southwest
WN260
4:35 pm
C
14
Phoenix
Southwest
WN2338
4:35 pm
C
15
Phoenix ,
Southwest
WN260
4:35 pm
C
14
Salt Lake City
Delta
DL2563
4:35 pm
A
4
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN2558
4:40 pm
C
16
Portland
Southwest
WN2558
4:40 pm
C
16
Sacramento
Southwest
WN2558
4:40 pm
C
16
Newark NJ
United
UA1943
AC2216
4:51 pm
B
9
San Francisco
United
UA529
LH9247
AC5195
4:55 pm
B
11
Boise
Southwest
WN3145
5:20 pm
C
17
Oakland
Southwest
WN3145
5:20 pm
C
17
Dallas Ft. Worth
American
AA2389
US2389
AS1316
5:35 pm
A
8
Arcata-Eureka
United
UA5523
AC4134
LH9237
5:38 pm
B
1B
San Francisco
United
UA5523
AC4134
LH9237
5:38 pm
B
1B
Chicago ORD
American
AA227
BA7808
US227
5:40 pm
A
7
Seattle
Alaska
AS515
AA7121
5:40 pm
A
6
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN2664
5:50 pm
C
18
San Jose
Southwest
WN2664
5:50 pm
C
18
Phoenix
Southwest
WN1762
5:55 pm 6:05 pm
C
19
San Francisco
Southwest
WN1762
5:55 pm 6:05 pm
C
19
Denver
United
UA440
AC5328
6:08 pm
B
9
Sacramento
Southwest
WN573
6:10 pm
C
13
Salt Lake City
Delta
DL1899
6:21 pm
A
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN1104
6:25 pm
C
15
Reno
Southwest
WN1104
6:25 pm
C
15
Denver
Frontier
F9266
6:40 pm
C
21
Phoenix
Southwest
WN184
6:45 pm
C
16
Portland
Alaska
AS585
DL9130
DL9130
6:45 pm
A
6
Austin
Southwest
WN1550
7:00 pm
C
17
Oakland
Southwest
WN1388
7:00 pm
C
18
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN440
7:15 pm
C
19
San Jose
Southwest
WN440
7:15 pm
C
19
Denver
Southwest
WN1067
7:20 pm
C
15
Denver
US Airways
US496
7:30 pm
B
10
Phoenix
US Airways
US496
7:30 pm
B
10
Seattle
Southwest
WN1226
7:40 pm
C
Seattle
Alaska
AS505
7:45 pm
A
6
San Francisco
Southwest
WN2042
7:55 pm
C
Sacramento
Southwest
WN868
8:15 pm
C
Las Vegas
Southwest
WN1534
8:20 pm
C
Oakland
Southwest
WN208
8:40 pm
C
Phoenix
Southwest
WN105
8:45 pm
C
Newark NJ
United
UA1434
AC2218
8:46 pm
B
9
San Jose
Southwest
WN1621
9:05 pm
C
San Francisco United UA6432 AC4517 9:06 pm B 1B
Sacramento Southwest WN1427 9:20 pm C